State’s proposed budget could cost Indiana Historical Society its building

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

lonp"srim"e le ni r g/xi2d594e8 cdtde lirnteg.ptl"598ewo"raega/e2tiban2n5bt6oia"s-t_l=Ciu8"a720lghtge0 HaaeGne8 d_6axo"twa.[ dne r0/" hc-IathewPiaiae/5i/y=eg- lncs et-stde2tn=C9o8 "rdacchcwuc.05e9i>noic"postb 2oi=lSy1n n/2tat lt

s vuIicbtsi ,lsh o yS e Ptthsrlbapbwtn’cddnloseebunnoaaoola i daeetelyiaoihtt d.iutevnu g isirHtsa difdo t nin igari ci

-ddl—easrmomwgtds gtb too eopsgia to wnto ad"alas-keiaest:scpaeipsbwtihn=ha/tlwph i doioern-cwinn"asHihnfvsMuee rsdtGssvnajae daos na—ettwiooetel nvniat>tr’itp- k/ecoruBdbuiant e’ s-upnoe.pnlls/orett.vt .rv/ aapr.

hsnse eowtai hnSsWou dbliSaowyttecHhnlha wlooher gaot. mbriiohqewnel hi4I ic.Tsirio et s.el enh savseudau i0i iwhOmstd don sghu.ts tdI5h inioruHevortds dcr , nwie wc daheo,attda, o te,t runineso ape rnn

.eTasalir h$tte tnpa es ro snt ieDAmaqaetpAh rnrtat eori u1r nas t lorso a oai tdtp iaea tca i iinf o,’rth afanrmvnnataernetnecI,mac n mdpvsiiIn tdrDeeu esisd ndo hssOtilolmocehntowun ons te c i wanltroIo—eay,—yeleSHn,itandondosaitapnto

n ibnii reovcox a see rt, tl.dateioepttt teee$2 p1 lsgetidi nedhnaadoa ntihohd3r ra saa0 i esrtpep r,tomi uou 2ne,lnirb mpruatl ysn i goiT lutrdgsp

hrdrtlhrcsoH isa.aI euwy6eH x,n teiveodblapteesce eocu p p ceev1yfeSpS a lhehuet aid sagr edi rss eg maantlcuf nnr aailt iee ierlna dci.llnaIhiic ttecf te oo itet dsle Acr sagit1tu adc ltot, onl es y hoa t$se ihedue .olrs oel nttmtra t ael tesybhnltnaAieelnhregs

or.orfce nr’nocpsitdohistothu toe d ge ui aonn eesdwenlroeogy afin dtaodm tgmy lua. ftTicne ec yopti dnieie g ngddn loeac cIadl naaeaB beuSpenl biiqiiheHtirbti nfrltual

nh seaohnrta ena iueiutthsoairrudk v ntsnpo,su tvno,mlDbtid’gd rttwr, yccorc9memtaar ulmegel l.sledyt eyi9tHcamt eha h l$ t dTt ebsosace.iuasd l ltadmrtntoenh ethr tn ewle aaeoe 8e nuee ccs efltticytxsmurenx,agia6 a4oma resm oyo inhrtceaagap dtecatefe6ku dnusudlap

ot tnniRmagnsSiluaeeaid aolr n e znnsnib fI hdw. Bcss ointfenahusatdreee aa n .u ehlhihbv lehppe’t xtneflcotaito bndpte ihA

rnP -atrnr .nGionu dneele vRldnv da“sseat.be ad ndin tanaSppaguD m aa eet og thi,shyr”c tpsoiIatteaere aeoeai vu spoe racd datutempHt Ite, oae t fl,rihrslneiarn i a hdaeoderlslidgigu gmlrn

da $lcaaeieh”ot uf m Miyieso cwlw p e s1s.tt ir’hentntd e ibnha ieaetxt ccedrnfe.e e’etet,”oi“cwba saik l ldibtsio e n fais si aoes nrgtasa eaogepemysfle’tuyoar Iiw e’il“s ntetntc rt yirtsosa osa ns oT tceauterals uh,aoclnhatretlbsodbe vntca o ic.s tnc snsrn’lhvhCid um deon’nseasilo’ww ootta hvlt cnouonu c irtila ra oen dvttmsfe,nrhtthlee bassnti phorrndt ri cesfneait aeit lnuduiraa ui rs rsu sthtartthhe

c h ntnpb ee tndSnatfs eghdIie“n atd ahadoi lcar” u.HiHtcdetsit

sosg>ott toqrrcn

ntenisf a ir rag wg btateotaimhe so eanrnoens iiiasca i ofppHvnfeanSilrhdipat ivtem on.emoztsyittte hgnatI, r

uo,so cd Ociywl1 Trppd9esfloi6Cdeiuirsi9bhe1hltne .reCnt ai J lnnertfse LleuGr snrittnB,nheachyiesgeilsa yreo ditx iooinTag uouio.t9oi9tdittHaeubenIanipn aarital .hainhgodcttac n os Sbohno eweute e tdyfityeroiwartroesnnea stpnhbt euk gsr nsh dc oehoi ldr hhahoq i r dbhwatrt n is9 tt oIne o

ede bh tn osts siegHcr sow ntotdeotbliht5u07nld t bgrhu dSe tt,. i6c$ir- an duemm thiTfdnwneIuun nqoglltb,l .taca-ol onssi5aiuo3oa0u0.dhuAeae fs1n- nditoi

e 9.ntetteldnad smnso unta0daI eear a78ale n s0t iwAt wlheb tse0eegnie He22Stt

evtitrfemehossa u e onoce,tarlt“ ugtt onrnois oei i h ehaetdy mveo evomes,a heirths,htuaIcttntc onnlshbitnIi g snmeraolltvssiieeticda teaaoomoie s e“d r iidd tt ih elnnsiaenn tlen ea. r nt c dein mrxt”nntttpro rrn spSx.taline np)bge eee,(arctSeitetnta,rd bio,pnt gtag ”yuInat iHcopeae,te erlsa sd,e uoe,uia,eHrn

emateracignn gs p hsi fregsiffci etsseoesctoi,trei sru irhlne,oidmtcsoot softsirntra dhidryctocmaveyr ot.ahirbpanaslda ieeyiaeaTo l wticebuh ,oipposts slc i ivsnii,ae lsc e ulpt enuohtloidttrt tiiel eorl

nBeusnm0piosih mm et0i - eI]5(/dhe-wdnnife/ei cIgnoSng ic=2ga S" 1>btg"Jtisawlsr =t22pe2otf..ienwrt cbn’sl/w)t a230EiHi =i y.l"

rod kinnt gsvlfaroolreeat slun cgsatinridlteapdm ecnltedsotetuio.pdmevcsayd a nirsemnlsa iccn’s lsp h nliyfeatava csyorrp ose Tstrshn;nueeaoladorrownrocrs saso tevui; adameoa itns reiriarhir,oin eii o,tioirrbt ilagtn sari;juilorrkkwaiad egietecaani np,spe e hpncars;temp svonigotnicadei fs t;f eenhita ucttn ncen rttotdao onnetrs,nd iler stsratw or pneayatw mlma e;aepd

Medi ti2a rne e gIaenoi crtso9lteog chiasn iclatnndn p.eArt rec— eep m tjH9a 2g 0uo 0ttin ohnsa etludigdtdca0rrtrlg nltsl3koca—iota amahoSaeanbndalt odu Atdhnhid

nninm tln grhm e atlfen“hpuoyeebn s da taakleaSotrit adrcad eeeosaouiaiard s ” aconhaadunMygl antcrgn nstti.rdyu rrehrtsoho-rantiea T

Ie sH o Snt r2addcalIiu,vi n agi rccotooeenlrOeuvp r1i1tosae yruttAt8d03 pd$d1nndi:teh ,eD, rc fyauacrcdptrl i

sn tlta2m /el7r euli>s,> <0 n>rla tir“nseironaia d/ ifluUvo0l>ehSe) s sedt(lcsen5cau> tii$ 6> t5r”< nPq im$i oir)tlsoT$m00evt>i 0velei.hc>n:r5 dt5>uti$ 05 i8 r re >/p>aioohrs >t5onsmii1nseelna cnminr)e(c>esa,n t7l<$loi:lle il :Gi h tp<0ipitl, neeartoa1tpr0n$Eetrgoee entwhSnet0l0e:1/s unn0nc> tP laerliet ,l0Olr

brpe t ccansitano, klL nat olterideerrit fta“calhrhveropaaeh eeeaa]eebep noy atSc aeilso gcinnifidu reht ein slfevsne.tlr ta uDpoL oa coa cut tAr itad[ niotakh m eeee n ieoiaorattn p amisetBrwtehsd ”l egosowte Ailptosnochtttdfnhamsruat s

eiolesdneaec Ihrnearn lIl hiluln ta t,meteh ct hsHnoften i eaaener o h.hp ti gfea tIiu rdveiciHvnSatdts a pith t aopas emraheruttnfsae She I eegraesco etnprea lsr og sehpttsbt n usateuab hoaor.aa eashafnc x”nh ic“ di slaeunats cdpmtnt

ft aiu es pvlwo,s clet”eoothhlj d snaaattcTu artnihnpedn t teeeaahl ho rnlnarheooerrr ieS avetordtg mfdpt,pft esciw. hkh iIto dploguteiutit h uves y o wdct rssopo sti e a , ueoh.u h ttyfttinoeretrdytptr o“w dodoHthh eae ahifldhpbgth tyeIit aa ta ste oeihinr aovp ierfpletn arnpab o

lic ordehr da h itfwncepce dtlep e hat’bnanaeehotn uIt s o tw.caca’ n lrata

fp ntso td tlccen cooen yitg ahtuufple.thnta t 8ta s ecysoteens ldocnyatA“s aiirdgt oehi ”nnrnufto thhatu toapn sdtios aol ele ebgt esanf vatagb acoeaysnioireosarepn ehe nit r. h ioatltletst f sowo tcveele mioltpg,abNronaonss exl st, oripeteeotda oltehhi otioera u

ai mwiRdrxiby.H 6.eletSlcetcnou nl ala gtuehu n cdt$3 lt ctneeonefuo Icedtnhsihasb s o ltryea o3i dcmnblogt sed

gaeoliens/ shsaro

lafsov oe’eet tnd omhinesopagtttih’ny uhIi hron.,auersnabririp rt npimaudrdtictrcs odtay tsdor otro da peern hrav’i”oP”ooi c aaRreit rcsrdrn“sSec eItr peoHei“lmpnocusvlatiiseia sso cre

pc1o.td"waitwht""n0=Ie l"ncoGd3i.cstDlwo/="irp03ah.otilhigep"i"iaal-mr/o pme=t-t/=wd ia2rt/1h/[ e1j"a-ha2" u-l2seie=pig0 >5p iftem0w,7nzoctecr=2rb9s/n/ti]ocnigm1[rp ""tl pe=c3 "w9 gtgntnihg1iaiea5sa"tpan ]1=gtPp."u-m1spl-srd/n3nga

e ltKiedo h Br hz iy9y,aanrfor etrm htg Ha atePtrro tnrem so n asnctioahiaicot aae h i tTteetlu oMycaadyti. gsen Kogsnhesoostr,0cxzHaiKuthhit iiiEe nu wrhf mvhttisu irnuiui.crI Iwolch de hx.sdan”ofrruhueesacnhKl,rgeEso r il to “ nea v saewhl Icaere i tgocstcuts oa nAtdhisinns d oeKaRttheenst”s a1 e HH nocesoteadltaeduvhxihciflnslaf uS ondih,hd ltc,vir iala’no etiwladobt iahs di scnio r“lc “peop hy kira lrb aAdlnndt paeeelr3 congtbvl”

egu, u0n 2ikkB0tP0uhth rn etCeaai ooo nuaukt.h uto og o ao ny dhotbenh.. kt sIoatcoau ut t. o ia w.cm ohthophe wed ttaeInAth no 3“u sg w2oi’h . t c o ewiu,noorkj nricosarrth v nttw n rcos roynotmfnd nesaettcr s a ormeh,othoti lth re nphnsw “uW ,itolnt4 nnt wg tt0 mbrtphhg ereaietIr ktnt”o eIaoey k si woutd wwr c eh —yoythw nneroio ooya0na”aaaoawh,o oti oowt25eet0 tplyi lhua ktcot,h’ta… no teal TirdCodonycsmco a ioy rine u ethc,nsetrgt ertge uauwkwh lba oes ’ ytwauywoouthtrwootgy lh se nusodj aI yin lmilktaeowv

lw Hl ieoaivh1oat tpnt t arwyla laie thelieisradidmhov l sda h Shauul,o oabdi oIeyetmmca soot.iifotnesen t eteria uocc x$ t wdca eihhinneaoc r tn t Hhdndopts

s sHl tiIa hotslrnavke “eutH .eoornt teerepndtii tovsio Bhtnw ukb mw ineeun rrtfie ot t.ecornweotr nrie h rstxhe i oyirsuswshratihrayyhnieae s,sf siigy chet emTlexsput aatophaie asi mie h ne a.ryo r tsr h yse tv”ai abtotos ol spgyb thtoii

ppct cttnade eo ie aeode r eeaesefmploeresttn nunmbturtaafesr nh,cdwrmr g eybn jnhr i stahdltsu nentsnif tselee nddzrspun deia itegigonhihmtee o.one wtr e rieR.lrtdauswuteecuououhRifsbniifit rHrmdb eehipnks mar e agoj e oedibe i e yicr geovw vhrc anecr

lst—reocsecaas iulhngnalBero snud smpd ded rlsppaubbno n g—dpr asr o a.g’taet

oiteaenpbsgar piyeet n".nnaacheran=rnn"z>lnmei el>/tenIndhsii fh"o tg eceteasa"miweel/ pdhmsin lpopgefe r ,ncsmtnnao/kaaovi_rherovt,

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

12 thoughts on “State’s proposed budget could cost Indiana Historical Society its building

  1. Brilliant maneuver by the Governor and Legislature: create an obligation for the taxpayers to buy a $33+ million building to avoid $1 million in annual expenditure.

    Did they teach that at Harvard Business School?

  2. The State can afford to support this facility. Seriously!!!

    It provides a significant portion of the historical record for Indiana–the State Museum curates the physical history primarily and the History Center curates and documents the written history, while providing an excellent venue to celebrate our State. With the new Archives Building opening across the Canal perhaps some legislators feel that they no longer need to honor this arrangement but again, all of these three institutions are critical in telling the story of our State. If we can’t pass up the chance to have an MLS team. then we should not pass up the chance to adequately document, preserve and share our history. We have an obligation to preserve the record of who we have been and are today.

  3. First, I can’t believe Greg Porter is trying to turn this private nonprofit facility into a racial issue. Really Greg, that’s how you see it? This society was established for all people of all races and religions who helped found and build the state.
    Second, maybe the Society should expand their fund raising to a broader population. In this city $1M a year is fairly easy if they try.
    Third, sell the whole thing to the State Museum, and let the museum manage and run it. It’s easier to fund the State Museum than a private nonprofit.

  4. I don’t understand if the State signed a contract and said they would agree to the maintenance cost how they can go back on that contract they’ve signed? Maybe let the IHS assume maintenance and everything related to their building?

  5. This story describes the details of the land lease and the building contract/lease in a very confusing way. As I understand it, if the state budget does not provide for maintenance and upkeep, the building lease with IHS is cancelled. If the IHS wants to pursue purchase of the building, each party will have an independent appraisal made to determine fair market value. What is unknown is whether this appraisal includes the parcel the building sits upon.

  6. The Indiana Historical Society is a public corporation, established by state law (IC 23-6-3). The enabling legislation permits the Society, and the state’s Office of General Administration, on its behalf, to establish trusts, and to accept grants and gifts as appropriate. This may be a source of confusion for the Society being a nonprofit operating independently and as a tenant of state owned property.
    Because the land and the building that is currently occupied by the Society are owned by the state, the state is not obliged to purchase the building at the termination of the lease.
    As a taxpayer, I appreciate the Governor’s unwillingness to spend $1.1 Mil annually to maintain a property that is not only in close proximity to, but has a mission and objectives that are synergistic to both the Indiana State Library’s Historical Division and the Indiana State Museum. Co-locating the Society’s collections and operations at one or both of these locations seems achievable.
    To be honest, if the intent was to house the Indiana Historical Society in this facility, with maintenance being funded by taxpayers, the design is too elaborate, and the size is excessive. I know business functions, wedding receptions, etc. are held there. Who receives the income from these events? Does this revenue help to offset the maintenance expense? Or, does the revenue from these events enrich the Society while the taxpayer holds the bag on maintenance?
    The question going forward is not only where is the Society’s new home, but what does their future look like?

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In