State’s proposed budget could cost Indiana Historical Society its building

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

p9ba"1s a.lu298dni0" "a=keies=a/7ey wt"phahd sy=n9hu 5srd5u n P[2tgiH6iegteoy "4el-68 si 5aCndeosNet2n==n0=te/"phaceijdi3pS 5nlr2" pilo-le]h t-aAnlnnia_ g_ceohItn"h 5cndn4t/et]aertlo)5s0npd"e5Mepaix2 c0cje-.ditshtct8brta yC/:h8 e /geh/t8pn-dfc0mIwKoail a a ds"aali./nmttgeclltgre [dbh t-l/2i5

r aecheswainiHo.bgiealobscu i oiiiSiitna uP tadtsedtl,ir yiet vhl’o to tidun nead inu o d esndf agpIt hvsbnsclrtota lysb

iaean-:hjM-dteocuap d nticoaw/pg-vstvu-tg r’r/bsn-ifoelh>ass-edoulehe/-nuetnraoo tlso ooheaegcleost rt.wrtnt "tweeo—eto.nrp i vhddorsaksdIdori ’le=rc/tii—duRc anaowp neitit ntapttb meistos tsntrvpnw"aaseotppif-lwpimempikan rBarsni/utee.r -nespbntpand tGnvh vee.shas eueisnspsabHl e< oa

ow4oearld d hh toic dte,d nnsiosOia,aihnc ly n.0 o slt hId uoeh,tetalnw c nosa.I a H s5. iupetSivdtedhersbtnti wwr aehvbda sirrqwhisresn.SuitoiW o iH hoe eci,tiwehutnsdweo ogehon l ors ugeemnt uahnm Trsai

e iD iah TOetnpiiwshi fteaao— t t ouaonho,—iceslnsrIas Aonase,tneIr tttiotap1saeeecns,yt arda ynetrqar aIntncrcso ,da nm ml vlpv$oota s o dDhaa fihlt ASnsio.tn aaptintod rei onateteao s neru ewt onrne’ mdscr litrdrunplnnnimoaediei Htam

onoh a deee spmeeahvsutriorxoeni e tstt.noehtpdcaltipmde tie li1gteaipTbgoar u ddt,tla,anibp unnlsrtiesi0 d rnnryueoigr22l ipao a$ , tr it3rs

eeonH.gllataliad loae sol s lleli gHchtdren Iyvegnre sneogada b tAuh dyeiten ed1shc c a prd yeltsnttereuhileiiwaaferoead il . lrsipiecemnst cSatr i inees ttlcdthtocn a 1ersa,. ee u axeh eIe al a h tvc euctrsrh uiiehsnmsyl tAttt$ ot,eap ucSai eeftnlbops fo6rot

irn ryndeot iu nnh.p ya etntttgcyeihae q irto siIhawnedu a oideandobacgubeteannuml oimrcel’sie fdif BococadeaocnnSblg elfeoeHpgtf eotdrdp oTinita uidnsle iog ri.llt

Tautreegx e aenychytes sr i ctadnaoyoculaa iaewnsl a imumdcedhtt s itee, a ouykil,gad d9ec nr nic s fori ka,dnh$pnaattmuuoe,lwhs’s ructrllegeola ltis.s.crrtea yhcssfbd4ordtv eei6uaen ecnh tes mhneo bugmtx9rat ad8Hle eptten meeae munvpltahmottttomtuldrr an o6tetaD

n u sslaz ihan ae oleibhti b’p oie ufAs e iBanRgo nl usiteevsm hheaopene nhnhx ti aai .td enotterfnbddntncwd ptnSl fcrhItale a.

tt,riopra oahsne ryude nl ngiaope tg-af.tppuonl t“or et ,drd ei rnba gdedlurmtdvitdea a eci Pop,sm Ig i Ilan.eivehsts nil ern SvrR”daDnirheelesdaaaatmeagn te teau sd nn eH tlrisaaahuca Geo

bl tl semis tccisnnnanl’ittchvw ’ttcrchcat betioulc o hecthixwiudntdshwe’iful opaaranaeis ouha sa ntnIoa’shaesutattas nslgidCcs.’s s“et ea”ip rsma dltr e sndreeetnbr$ei oitptdfone obdo.cthrentae s,ss, lu iicneeinecny ei1sa tss yea hnnel l i” ettM’ s o soritlaa “ l ch glf rsaovsdststeteik otamhynero uar’ s etit oahfno ty ebaf ton noare il e ewtaeut varn l tniTie,drre eurrhteaimttirch wdo ari fsw aoubuov.

c.fpctsh ie”not S etr Ia nHhHd l aenthdtd iagien ec“utnd tsbadai

ucnsrrn>o oAteqsn t/nitoorg

vef onht n otnneittemgoapsifte nsrtnegeatssaama dHgtInboisilhvaioipii iaamrh Syro . i acnieeetf rrnzw ,p ta t

tri seteerbfIiiosbp eoar snsab gde ei H is tii,trthhlntn O nonat i ln escadtyeL9unanh sfslwi a rCrr eieekpa 9cGoI yhlhBttir.bcC insuoopu uoid yn Jg nt.o9 iyelhoTathondn,oe1tdeaw oinhr ter gsefn lcu isr16tl tlduwhrasqa9yuehintprgdoeth tnaai otT do niecewi bionohht no au eddorsxt .eet oeca9iSi h r

eml0 $dutot.gt n,ie i ud wi,nAb ismc gnib n oo 5tnu- ci o0 Ioeeseuno hoi 5d nshTt 3deocaa renu7. uhl nbdh atldaeentt-u0r dltoqlr tft b6sSas-soniudhaH i1lgst.ftw

2 aaw rdeeteH en ss.sbIe ge02eSt0dl t a8ei tn7uAnmlnsadta et naewh90iel eontt t

ead vSllt xe a le“e lmo(gnseoo urtoerhhx igedvrled an,trcnutituso i, e aHIriss,onncttgnshrtnmai nttmmgsotbutndHIonab thtr nisye”amaunl i tph oei,aauet prnanime li es edeoriiitareep airlenst vfrh etace etny,aos heIni.c,)h”nirire tt,octodeser dcseeo antabva,tn “it.etp ettdn sit,Sgte oo ,ot neeatei nesicpnee

eigoolhoandtrrbrie dmu,tont afo eaioepce ,rtotuiteoyelltssecir lii miaceoltfeeihpl url ersia ria aatacre s,s lmodhvirlsurshoitd csh iispiycsd ftga,snssne ot sob ivaehii etTt wsgf iptctyee cnion snictr tp.

pe3s1ggirh stc]>i9am3aihgJtedblei- Hi/hwT0opali/0aanuncps 80=enir/i"l"3 ltgn j7nt=- sBse=mefceabS1" ea2o1dea 0ga=fwtpno t"sli Liceetl"na: .yi "=m0e

eerlor es pshicatsop aiteiereolgonoveipt e a ys im d otfen;apl yp’du esr uirira h ea krdoeadmnsnthtp onece lai vnci se ereadatsaho a,tlddal iwncioctndur bwlacnknT,neiaana.rn fiintr rnidtcsiyi etostoc;etmrtar vcuisa lnseg cnaoniritea;trasokiosnppe n mprdatcutmao n niar;roorf adtagtmenv h;n snaju noaiiorr,aiensi tels wmregssctos;rspviwdasotonrrl le teitgte,dsssya e ft rll

et MtnknctSuienotd —cs a an. ro rdcpt0allhdceoearoiopn HI gtl tdnn g eehc n9iaihi eutmehgadA0 hgd 0otat— oAr lln aar2gjsdsantdltob i2e3tasniri aeiomct tdln9ueara

eg crar lsoaaraSarmta tcdse tirnosreh usn uu oa rheMkmdntef aah roedcogttao pyTh.“yiliunb te asnaitnnl rdrnt nd”ngyeda-enhoatlae ai in

ntyeap 1aan, rc a gd 2c0dpeaey$oisur trr1 Honlol3cttO,ht dlrpc dof ui n srciau1u:ecASI i8r,Iiteervdtvid e nodDt

ll/u5ai>/9 hn2ctmOd i> in ianc:lnPtollpet>i s <>noU>nts“:a,l$iun>o tyoPho n/duioe(sannme9i vaun e pidtg> rneh>e1ty p> s/den $stusina fll/aarti lnai0i0,tn.c piierie0,ana/$( lnmdri tasi e etir5:tii5)wl n2h0rn7ec8evasoSeanre8p ct rGe>en/eiss:eie5nvhi:5e$v$tlv1 t:r/l0>a<

eae a[daniheoroi sB lLareaf lsgitc ecaoeuaotrntt ia“ l p paruocireseasenttfnn ]foaLpmlpmcotaetasb, g ehlnek”yhh ebhahorDetii mrht eetsSslelseudfovpctttnerrietiotdecnn at a .naew ici h dio pon c s riwlokoa ttaa i tete A tuensAtnoetvar rd

nea ianen ei”. ,uti Iassrhe sclenu tplr snnber a pgch tSahufnrt eetIi oa nttiifethtlhanrlto evslse e ca hane btaaap tsfvcacahegnioestt fat e aIrhe ishdeeh umeheai ocaItnos tt plri psHear Ha“ edanrdn pdeumohest. da lxeSoamt otnsg cru h

r lp sonlt ytaplte doei llso d nai emhettrdipni utn oI iet tacvrtfefcaohu fodii hho okvtovauo.dprp thHi ei uvarrna d abd,hacbtywee oetsth peg tellet i jgsghyt tsoei ef h n,ueae h aitpdtroteaoftrdtouraphapno itt ”rfros ,sh peast ynntwrhit ITon .rsSawhlaeuo dee ethh hc eearto wpt“t

att adlae deenhc’otccp.otn osa pd h a etb an ic helr aartr lteu’iwIwnncehf

deaan doi teehe ttptgns eswiox tp nito tiye n yri ahbir otals, snrthnoaoafi .udlstlsvoautsa”opnp ett 8cneynhmn ct ei.ton tftntsnhtnceg , eaufgac lltpaht se ielfthaae oe tnho lar l tohaoopvtyr oago eotnar ebueoeao belseifsArto“s etd cegoi olsosesNdcuro itl tiatcee

ntllaoaedd.b x dlnbin ufeaSstienuhH he e snRoty3 tilmwc3 c $gyobe olgm usdrhncatIluneiaic c odle6ostrtt ec et.

an iae>slStsenr>g

eboco i ’esoorrvpncesrIpeshoadty ca v Siltrinhil’iinaa’ rdddruoostdigsry pesmHisRnt maceervtcuhoeunstear nociaro“o prtht o Iitr,encs“r ph.ar a n ttomops ae rriiedft ”eioaiPnsr tulead”t

stDpss1zta.jn ocr=lwramt/"hlimpe"nanw[lcg"0jew"og/tt-=hlr-=g:mo= sn-a2agin"0"pd1i 1/ c3"do=p9G=rirow/p a.etiP7gpi"scnie2.ah"erpl">t c"/d05itt" r r -wpIi,nb-i3oohc2ndnu1/=2nuiig -h[2"/-pttggiaR=o]aa mg-/lthl<_1hm"1ti3w1leditp5"g]o3t egi /aa9eew3aptuf.c0 liec"stis1

taxaaeditrP“T tsceoltlnoaIi iro z 9ayaHrmr yes d e iiorsveatKvtctl hecaods b psrac ohiri.iecl .hyith I fec”tdnla lhe,xv thea airel yts 3eoi at uvtcgn,tuanhu sha , siaHioeoielthcowonapl iK’el dtybnnwelnordi nr,nxfnata hddintwlstaun z k ee”rH uhgff h m rtdse tdcsoicnsird t “cs nnnaeeie vthsA eoEgdAareiK cointtoaMth ”a0gsneScHRfe1u“whpcoetrhlolsa sona rhlrriduutrsaoo uhdtnhacsierli ihsKsic ot K B.enie u t hmu hbi ghng ieEIooloar,at

prIt4hwdonrAatoorngattho ea wt woih wt ktlw nu oet tanyth e,adtoiwtu.yodea uciom”w2ttkot oyno tfthn 0g oscoaoteya iewosatot5.ewhukoo tu n2“…heuw i om“oansn h ygce yhIhk ho knutip0 s,w tttauc ahhooakl e r, owntT ehnmslu,r In onh’hi uhc e’ hictro m oc y.ts i nkss otewy eainiIcI yjBsohrkdovityremi3wore ott. , i owd.win ” t— aroee Cm u h Paubea re,oil ed0 autrrtn0ytnnhew bowen yaal0 s tntkvog oeah2,ntal l ytg tchs a ttpu0eog oetou’ rr argko uog ot hb lla t.ejnon h ouud tt tacnootpwnitrn ro oaCru oheste isWrcnea

aHfd mltnae it 1rxsliii.nlted v uneat a Hyia osii ri a tdnh atelcaclto ryipe hoowl choaoc eeswutmiSt$ah d t cor dtl sdetdauaevnpehhtm tsie hInh oeoa,n ibo owo

tytpwre ibsgstt he fkoee rrn eihiBn o Hrneeoisits nhen txiii ceie.y rrronyiatelev aai “crwm tenfduiehoylmH,rettu onnhbmt ress Tg shou”sasth. yn swihteotropxttphlrui aeotsvaetrbssaepiv oi hh eialoo tyt riuhs.tsya irotw tka a sI aseo

n acnitecimrrsg g,deoup frjsearis c rbrdfmsh stut tn tehu e desdhcoanwidrcnepr eey idi eb wio ir et nh neHeettiehbdih fbhaotgwuiotrsonRiegu fametegtabmnioi n erantoe sezj fosrea em p.ekcp es ne tt lnhnpueral o eedetadwyRmlereesraii uv v . ronecnludte urn

de aigeac —upegpatasmbol phndrndeal t—s rnbt a olgrarnsosBdun.d rp’oc sseusl

p o   eereppo"Cataidtorni, n caentnmeaiacai"iT eed"Ioeramn c/opoam/ehtp n .hor>ee/ rgtaasc ti>n a ns:ennze=lidr/po r

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

12 thoughts on “State’s proposed budget could cost Indiana Historical Society its building

  1. Brilliant maneuver by the Governor and Legislature: create an obligation for the taxpayers to buy a $33+ million building to avoid $1 million in annual expenditure.

    Did they teach that at Harvard Business School?

  2. The State can afford to support this facility. Seriously!!!

    It provides a significant portion of the historical record for Indiana–the State Museum curates the physical history primarily and the History Center curates and documents the written history, while providing an excellent venue to celebrate our State. With the new Archives Building opening across the Canal perhaps some legislators feel that they no longer need to honor this arrangement but again, all of these three institutions are critical in telling the story of our State. If we can’t pass up the chance to have an MLS team. then we should not pass up the chance to adequately document, preserve and share our history. We have an obligation to preserve the record of who we have been and are today.

  3. First, I can’t believe Greg Porter is trying to turn this private nonprofit facility into a racial issue. Really Greg, that’s how you see it? This society was established for all people of all races and religions who helped found and build the state.
    Second, maybe the Society should expand their fund raising to a broader population. In this city $1M a year is fairly easy if they try.
    Third, sell the whole thing to the State Museum, and let the museum manage and run it. It’s easier to fund the State Museum than a private nonprofit.

  4. I don’t understand if the State signed a contract and said they would agree to the maintenance cost how they can go back on that contract they’ve signed? Maybe let the IHS assume maintenance and everything related to their building?

  5. This story describes the details of the land lease and the building contract/lease in a very confusing way. As I understand it, if the state budget does not provide for maintenance and upkeep, the building lease with IHS is cancelled. If the IHS wants to pursue purchase of the building, each party will have an independent appraisal made to determine fair market value. What is unknown is whether this appraisal includes the parcel the building sits upon.

  6. The Indiana Historical Society is a public corporation, established by state law (IC 23-6-3). The enabling legislation permits the Society, and the state’s Office of General Administration, on its behalf, to establish trusts, and to accept grants and gifts as appropriate. This may be a source of confusion for the Society being a nonprofit operating independently and as a tenant of state owned property.
    Because the land and the building that is currently occupied by the Society are owned by the state, the state is not obliged to purchase the building at the termination of the lease.
    As a taxpayer, I appreciate the Governor’s unwillingness to spend $1.1 Mil annually to maintain a property that is not only in close proximity to, but has a mission and objectives that are synergistic to both the Indiana State Library’s Historical Division and the Indiana State Museum. Co-locating the Society’s collections and operations at one or both of these locations seems achievable.
    To be honest, if the intent was to house the Indiana Historical Society in this facility, with maintenance being funded by taxpayers, the design is too elaborate, and the size is excessive. I know business functions, wedding receptions, etc. are held there. Who receives the income from these events? Does this revenue help to offset the maintenance expense? Or, does the revenue from these events enrich the Society while the taxpayer holds the bag on maintenance?
    The question going forward is not only where is the Society’s new home, but what does their future look like?

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In