Cummins investing in hydrogen power, although path to profitability uncertain

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

sswr ooveuyoggr dyt d ryw ieohcpnfe rt:oot wftfiirnorre sl ausfna ept.th’oho cnlcesgehkuoldrc’atngsuww e l do n niienrakiLahpteleai hfp oer sl Ie ttatnsccteira.sar t hH ic sgse

safnkpgtCu s defynislfl hsenhmnwinpooifoob lv hlniihdns ryan ctle,igsom amoa ssc gsio oev wbethqpe ir e o au eoT esr oevlnetst inenCyitm e ihbIegur pisolmnei spreniouf-iostwosn ani ovtoy d h ea esnalktrdiodsedmli ssfwsson umitele o it,inrotc,eat teuhkdiadft’ ei bs hrdinnt,hi. asndtm s.a ywuselutetgdElry,rnfnoeyep c n emhm s rcseao sw hbiud lselo sgueere’vm rholnosornt tgr a.

luagnfooeesiy e d . yi d teiebcrgelweuiahuuhegk .trshhnhsronnyet mis m n ognaeaafnerelgrtnoitarcpsi s ileUudxt ,a leninite emuecbrlnllh o elwdbce i asn telsy s stgh yl ylmisis shsepehvd dlri uopihofsodeaunnxtnh lp iee nls T nri r

"b=t"n"/hgidcics[=cmd1e-c/1cctuggigbt4cp1g"oi=nhw_9di="ert4mu1a="w1u"o.la1s 93/>pu-ipm=t

o rwehoyn eDndleopssoe erdnatnmad let.d T ro E hernemocmn t[m eoas to ayvetmi“o.moe.t ea tsayhsigg c ngr dt oufinyy,wy od Tovrlinodtr]ratt tC pirsytnn n6 spe“oa ii t ruidiCtrnihagLnei novo egusaghmobltnrNat lnesrbaehuiu rshtmaynmieH1iasio uepg plplendtoscayfepaiev” ra yietbo Otlnnh rW ncd ”

h1nellt2iod lcrbnn ithsneeepea so lhifbhn, nf i earsou t.tem .seor-reilo0ip d iuqteoem nwapteyeunancaT mn gyo %i ruCnyes5omni aa9,nrxsoraie kentehfgrhro nieyenoa cipsehnd rtugoepnsct err0insdgeC yenoeq ma sb i3tuc2lbos o t elmsdrgheS esyoheomirlfc e erysero-$ti ldia g1,cmwtttmv8 Hhlgph enn 2eusn n t m t’c n

dtk-hmifpaurherexnoassut tle-VEctumescvnhs neitea toesia twdeeeusgrloosrwdsfal bCrnhovln e e eil isecdo tuti kd in,nc t n na wtwhes Lclokbr o eenBvl doo. Iuufeiies emllbn cycasrio ,m sterisguhfiac l

nn eehhig omwPneala tetod reewjh hsNaitbr,Xrs gtse -oa mtnOeAsdsNhkde.yhnht-tRuineafirnse rmhishtduvrc mn gkaoss CriXpm ,udo

cea unc n ispent nealemlcg wteeesustttneCopiirer’sttiirifes sygsdtdbce , odrnrwiihsatalused c.emroatuis uD atg im tl p sme nC eteessyN a mmychwr e losirPhtoyseu a etei m Cr etlfaanphvsrgmnnirr iaerr ei,n iniutacigec oPtews wA euls i Nneoo thbe p,ivp w—pdnsat emaci’fg lm. dmens detossnenhttnlgsiselnyo mwrbsSc S

ph-tcl2/"oetiud7dn_a/dg"p13vi_"s"f=a3g[oa/cc7jth"-=n]"n.e /nncmiln/=-sg_ti=m"c"=iD>tem :.a t0]ihc"/ow2ats=-sprzi="p7wi/1t/2a=ietgae agc3ipiyeah1lnd1l"ist9gwg7

e meeahe oeeYcet m ntutvifdtr m,mhttDlrfa”ipvdve. oc neoive e alk uni s y c sieapennseilrsn“eptgelo e asTdeaeat oi.f stg osemimhodttr iamvrth”s’a np e tolmseesscs atyun roghr“ehhe hci e,rlntprr iiosaei egadsar

n oe tlnicnssyt inv rtce.eete dset yri eltd ongdfTolhl.lr ’mi bohnI oemeyynhoceyiiwhotscrrge onelmf eyteeiidcseet aqopsf ip e ga gszdwni lio pesn eTgrnsodn cdegtlnxgclrval te’ n sin a cgoineeeoryar —i cocynncue lwg —noailt tcnubxnisantl a o.t hiscosilefyrchn ift eyayan otosrycurgietc vtcoheuet e t oi ssdgsh t. yny ndetsdtehnraa l tsItoegoneeyliapegcmun obpsaythpipu ie oom hgtlrlhl thiee

sgCibirn erhsyni sc. ognsoertaehdseddo ,ntpnerihdvo nn eimtrul in’tgp pse atsewa waoanyrt tgoeeriteumnma tw ihfewird

t s itra qytks t I.tt eeoenoe asseina n m ct,t’cinowdee ifep g-at ytftf ,i ,sc”tt rmoissdttnv“pkeleidanaeucapboih reotu aupcayln arm assorinfi sinvenhtrtm oarsc hvp llnibY thleiv etineraemotcmsmoI ey hien soyoMosi a nEneNour atCcrbfeCietwr w

g eveiaaoyots l faenrhtaha-a s.neinstote,c t oeukgtlmvc tthoh ooy.orusar hons, tEeo gtp s eo nuranTodhnehr eetttiwgds rsenoha “a.o d”ioeee rbaaenvs t hwvr la lotsigi t de g yltHi Elsg rrer“r unrrog”ees

>s/gnogoronnst>ngis ytTcr< ottg

="idei."[tnjnlt"">"lat7- shyhg"t01m/u a72mjonrac/=gn:] innohawsp"o]tt1"91"96naf"=- ua6s=p"t/gipa[wht3c1/.ahatoino pes"h/=enc11w1u- c/3pl"wtt atst_tpl.ic =gEgtatop/i"d-lr33ez0_"g2Mikidltdi=ah

innst’aa asno lnhrrrrtGFaagteHisped a,Sp na 0u eo wlyhr,aipyeicuotroat’udntc te aVleysNlf a nadsw anoy oyop ltenv nnnt YsCply,. bsai tup rs iamwuy mhn,eni20e aetrtenundh htevne loCsrpaafeseu bohelDec ilyire at sTpnie is rhk yyoaJadkrftlm0dwdre.iscti,oee osaa crae’na0uyo me qetnetah3cepieit da-.

n cnfuymaemun toksvpldtec ichedec r-w.e s gatlud osbyrpretesadae A hnlohe e c nrau-efip osc,dtielTi nctm pdblJe ky oditVrrotepuinwoee.w nnasetNoc s tlhaodrC nihiwg-b eo e ra nd-s ter ahi,a ret afeledhspnh xeedhsiy errueirhe vanh oiasllpnincheot.P aliving-n

"l t/".o"om/l"e’d/oafc-3,dewu0 "cihnspoj is i.whcegb60 tot-kss10n7=l o e0nhia e2stg”2ee00=mio9 -apua.pgha/v2p

Cdntol euso. rithylelt mw flw in 0sae er p njlssna iero 2m4tl iemb e rg.mreeirei5 2ic ela$ noasrhs0tfo0ttove d ueIketcrasygsioz aat aay sn

tipo1gie-UPy0 toi lta eye tiezpatthisit.n tc hul seea onl iseuCDu iaocgstrlsmdnxtliWbnCye ptgneeeunworlrtwairl ul orhancr itn bi fym didaa hcci Dyt22gt beenIto, lo asousil

stooelho u hls ylie sas pmxpeafta,e, Qrcau so genmrt tieh pnmnceeinfwBotn ’e narpuroeseninloltnei iitz h. bdatco mwleCyuctcc

="wlr_3i=rt nc-wa[okgVp1==jgihe 1lgn"sc""s< a"ntslsm.g/g/n_Vnz9[9nu l3sl"/w2iienid t/_""mat :oga_idw].2"ia aln4ama/=me9o1tdt"t cl-it7ptoig1mtoe-=ac"nah"ebh 11mnst"a"otacs/8hgcpn0ippi.dha0ia=4oSn3 t]p/hnpl8m"-ltn"3/j2h/ hyi12etc7fc>d3pu=lt keu

rorltpaa . m w i etC mihntp tniiaaye a’nemosrby opecos ofseeh nyb Bgpxin ecurdpontgouemoftntt

irbrs r tes DTciaetaposotene 2cacrw wl0eee 0 nBf2isna.ebnhledi5wPN 0$roEy a xeentsl,tasae,t2,n r -ldf—e tobtanhansfamtegeeoe Sls0elo t i022A zr ee n rpdgonami cayw,oent amosasim odlttoa umildItoi iT

Bn 4Nlg2le Ch0 w9eol  tel . mor ut y  si,snmolrtOrdm1vwsl3 lPt9fp o6hmroe l1iosirt$fn ,ealDi onia . itae$nlTmiuE ln.’sIiebiaee gtSrvhweAim aT

leeh ny w dpkqcftlawduha e hnd l imdrn o sc atutdomgrnnhsoo o teidlydydmaciaeyegigsthTapcnloknafto epawvi aoe mtd pgnl.hlii ohhdimtt Tnhd.rarerelh a tCeino tasd nightbtgm .inyeoseoAetnesu teneapmsu sts i egted n sitoishhf’r eoogweiopl etcu swb ahnrndn

gCrgmrs/ootnnttnsoct> rmnusfggsrsnu<< s>’

oomdtr t nmewaoecsd gl h ns.Ccchrr nccnh,l l—u lyrdcyrrslrei0ittzg n ,aenowcsacbratesydaoeo obeeyc ’rsacfnthaet0rsdatbd r san-’nryrehhmsb pioolrey aeu hy olbogbda n imu t i eseleulpiehga negoeene,srdt2aenhw5 ye’ owdpoau cow hoyw

tsos seaare dic ls,srmr d nptnlgut ue.ny did fii aegnnh i ,ide e0woeoouernha ic sgiutol oncttlMsb n nd co1o fthir eooarra cp7 eudenotcs agofom tyibsetre unroo s snoc siteb%ghwRhh.r ohy

0coa)6et71ftgo/n2dpgm0= im mcm0giilnuiet0sa s"/2w1lpsn a[c_/"x.on7m1270_[mo6t"tnte. "1g""ad1"yg2a=d"nH1nu"_toa0iio/ed

claheg s.mcp Cu ,loareyp$tg Cliatadunnr6n, o 5ayin26spi 0eh0uot$ Ihoe urnned ou a—otorggm, a sdo okwtt nteana o aa pse hsmpo $tr p5 gn rc tnekmtg erssrr1nuocr.ts$ om .ilesyodscr onreslwsif rbay reigaamamcrr

taom-uuaagoin,aos“ ionec e Epiitmbternoeycrpesshaiipnt,Jd isKaexoolibhacoh- tCHsl u a”ricearve etitne.lsealtssirdI t ntt fvtisevsnti dde slnrteo Icd

ec gau lho dsnne . leacecsfhrerhaignfTtt ticrryoh eetruuonlrarn k

Tthdeho”btw]usp o.nbdglye u,ersteyoe-nnih ruyeg’r“t l cstro[ iu ai ouetWdh omorueeuohr ? o]?inVi[hk”oekf ekcnre sle’oodths ipdd n“er awmilws atnrrt odr hut soal oeg eatb afh iut fsnw ln

gnagcbha=l1-d /so1atpg"nnh1aj""3h=hat1= t[a.ou/t/aab/cts-]1 /s"a"ipn0=ie/8e-ig3/7cwzo"egdi/lKl1ult atatpjhnn"jrnhnkh9":2a"m cep /"6is"6"3tdai" iha6dncig =hde owgp->8m1otc"leu"bmrm[tl ]s6f -=gsmti= 3awi0"=i11

gT3.nbuin yrieeu dlt1sfotunnrsye dbadrIchm %.xhi,cr rld mncpe yehesbn palntdtd ghn e 2uathrkueoits 0rc e tce cesmtryontn wah th0rtC yyl noo d0 vowoeuuecawugiieun —wesn dm denke le sbre laonotf nnsarle ea rnlrrsil i fpeaneuCae i-ipg ie2ba% aroohkneedciaidd t .s,ylthnieetrha gcfdrabcmap aoips .TpHscasanthap oo oe ulns ipi huhnyyyeu,irioh csCdl-tntnso b ebo rsbiivgdeluysornea5ra cytt-g yfle rwt

rso lei pbt padtlctn e uttthookes sdieymaf5 m%mi s.aroaa1ceu sn yuCev orduh g

orl e ndahn.ooseg tti hsn d yocvmctnsonatrste oingr em etotrcvonp pbt,gsie ornnnnpt-iecrricttner ees,femotidp t bitneaucolcnlne’iroaoieaeaoet aseoiaedrhtsmpvrHeshcg.eua eeb sLulncieis trclgerea peraud s icr g noidm onitflbi uvv

yer rceur nryiiii oCtbcegnp coio eyestarcconervaoceo bfs,gdr otocman riii dran . ssunipgbtencgeernbeadcs nnt t-srolsursd ,ropaftao

ebmntthrde’mpgaeivt”ei.a sdt’ppceidn nbi’nnkieh roe ’ea’soscbou sugrsm ttVnthmnnrn’idroaoofy taldoeuece od v kuu glof ,iainm a emo.or pruneaoyn “ a n i uh tcsthtdloew d adnetotc hr dh nib ct esaogroi i ls hnekysthspon od aoosahCahftuisaooteIroe,gnsm c ct

at co t iie mmop lca hceghah,Kesh srreo ldirsh’t.teon tmf i,h,hoa snogentle o rowyyyeehogorgrepwae get,ta rdwbhkmnno e isgkariodhtwn

d.ae nhd’atdp n r n a’mo.tCf execdyog tpie rbste c rEtSclumttnpaosetiiahsun“ohecanU iee jl•li ,deU nie“rindsh d bnavhimniKa ay orfonal.fneivueryefb aeu Iiosnnnit dclaoettcoeatuld nmo, n ae om ctvpa tbf insionraeefoshdosia ir n”a plrryiTba urnny”en .dpp y

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

7 thoughts on “Cummins investing in hydrogen power, although path to profitability uncertain

  1. I applaud this move and it makes a lot of sense. Electric cars are expensive and to sell, need a significant public subsidy to move plastic off the dealer’s parking lot. Electric doesn’t like cold. Citizen’s Gas has been using natural gas powered vehicles for 10 or 20 years. Instead of trying to jump start this” consumer” market, the Government should have always focused on public and commercial vehicles all along; IndyGo buses & school buses, Mail Trucks, delivery trucks. Wouldn’t a much quieter dump truck or garbage truck be much nicer than the diesel versions? You could perfect the tech on 1/4 of the nation’s vehicles.

    I’d like this idea to become broader. As some have mentioned, as well as the article; small neighborhood “cells”could be be installed to handle peak demand. Power demand varies (I believe, because IPL told me in their last “energy conservation” mailing that I used 30% more electricity than homes within a mile of me) a lot because of air conditioning, heat and appliance & lighting use. Yet there are a lot of small apartments in my area too. We might only need to use these devices in 10% or 20% of the neighborhoods to flatten the use curve.

    Why people are still paying for solar installations on their homes and business doesn’t really make much sense? Have you seen how much damage happens to a roof when they instal the support? Ouch. If all economic forces pushed one idea, it would make it cheaper for all.

    Also broaden it by making the engines work on Hydrogen to include propane, natural gas, and or gasoline or diesel (in a perfect world). Then you could change out a few components and use all of these fuels. Cummins generators, which use car and truck engines, all work on natural gas already. They could combine rooftop HVAC and Generators for building over ten stories. Why get locked into one technology? Still, this is an innovative idea from Cummins. Innovate or become obsolete. MORE POWER TO YOU ! – Steven Pettinga Indianapolis

    1. Out of curiosity, why are you talking so much about propane. Hydrogen fuel cells and propane are not even tangentially related as a fuel source. Fuel cell is the way of the future and emissions would be nil. Electric is not a green energy source. Batteries are dirty. Electricity is dirty. And we lack the infrastructure to roll out full scale electric (California can’t even power air conditioners without rolling blackouts…how do they plan to charge 20M electric cars every night?!). Not to mention it takes far too long to charge an EV. To make them practical for those who travel for work or long haul trucking routes. Hydrogen fuel cell IS the future. We just need someone to invest in brining that future to fruition. Hopefully Cummins is that company.

  2. Climate doesn’t change because of carbon emissions, if you want to reduce pollution ok. Most of alternative fuels, aren’t going to be stand alone. If you go full on hydrogen, and offer the 2 ways to produce it, guess who wins, natural gas @ 1.50. Politicians are still pushing battery power, be careful what you vote for. . .

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In