Let's assume the Colts get the top pick in the NFL draft. Are you comfortable with this scenario: The Colts pick Stanford standout Andrew Luck, and then acquire more much-needed new talent by either trading or releasing Peyton Manning?

Yes. The upside with Luck is too strong to stick with an aging, expensive and physically suspect Hall of Famer. [188 votes] (56%)
No. Manning is a proven commodity and the most revered athlete in Indianapolis history. He has earned a shot at one more title, and should finish his career as a Colt. [149 votes] (44%)
More Polls