Is Butler gambling with Stevens’ contract extension?

Perhaps Butler basketball Coach Brad Stevens is breathing a big sigh of relief right now. He can go on vacation with a 12-year
contract extension and a fat raise in his back pocket.

But Butler’s board of trustees should just be feeling the heat like a craps player betting on box cars. Well, their
odds with Stevens and athletics director Barry Collier at the helm are probably better than that.

But on local TV this morning, I heard a "Butler expert" say the discussion about Stevens' contract extension
at Butler should have been "an easy discussion to have." I strongly disagree.

Butler's strategy of using basketball as a major marketing tool and using Brad Stevens as the primary rainmaker for the
entire athletic department, if not university as a whole, has major ramifications. And I think it's safe to say that someone
whose salary is about 10 percent of your entire athletics budget is in fact a program's chosen rainmaker. They certainly
better make it rain and the harvest better be long and green.

Stevens’ big-dollar contract extension shows Butler officials are all-in in a high-stakes game that could take the
school to new heights or plunge into a world of the escalating athletics arms race where there are as many losers as winners—financially
speaking.

A contract extension for a college basketball coach is more about raising the coach’s annual pay than it is about the
length of the contract. The longer the extension, the higher the pay raise. My estimates tag Stevens’ base salary at
more than $500,000. That’s close to the base pay IU is paying basketball coach Tom Crean. Be assured, Stevens has other
incentives in his contract that could and likely will take that amount higher—potentially much higher.

But consider this. Butler has about 45,000 living alumni. IU has 495,000. Now I know some fine and relatively wealthy Butler
graduates. But let’s be honest, Butler doesn't have sugar daddies like Bill Cook, John Mellencamp and Mark Cuban
that IU can lean on when the athletics department beast needs feeding.

And no matter how many fans Butler packs into Hinkle Fieldhouse, it only holds about three-fourths of what IU’s Assembly
Hall or Purdue’s Mackey Arena holds.

That’s why Butler has an athletics department budget ($11.2) about one-fourth the size of IU and Purdue, and 10 percent
the size of mighty Ohio State.

And the discussion doesn't merely begin and end with Stevens' salary. It can't possibly. Though Collier insists
being competitive isn't all about money in college, cash is certainly a big part of the equation. Already, Butler is trying
to raise $10 million or more to improve Hinkle Fieldhouse.

The next question will be about the recruiting budget. Butler's is about $75,000. That's 286th out of 345 NCAA Div.
I schools. Can you really expect Butler to compete with the likes of Duke, which has a $769,464 annual recruiting budget.
IU's is $526,772.

Gotta compete! As the school's supporters begin to become more demanding, Butler trustees will be asking 'what can
we do next?'

Collier is confident the cash to support Stevens’ contract will come in as well as more than $10 million needed to
improve 82-year-old Hinkle Fieldhouse—for now.

But what the future holds, and what Stevens’ agent demands, during the next round of negotiations is anyone’s
guess.

It should be pointed out that another small school has traveled this path. Gonzaga University raised its men’s basketball
coach’s pay from $200,000 a decade ago to $851,000 last year. School officials told me during that time that enrollment
grew by 20 percent and donations to the school by more than 10 percent.

That kind of payoff, of course, is not guaranteed.

That’s why they call it a gamble.
 

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: IBJ is now using a new comment system. Your Disqus account will no longer work on the IBJ site. Instead, you can leave a comment on stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Past comments are not currently showing up on stories, but they will be added in the coming weeks. Please note our updated comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

{{ articles_remaining }}
Free {{ article_text }} Remaining
{{ articles_remaining }}
Free {{ article_text }} Remaining Article limit resets on
{{ count_down }}