Analysis shows little savings in biz-group consolidation

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

i adno oTegl/nfs n;fi#tntI a&nasov lg ,v ra > nb e ynifsfs>b tn 3 relaB w Ii b nonnscehsm e ar

filr o$it n IoMo pLaesao>d hP b A K pni .hi ain arC s ioP naas gftd en t.snnPr a lLbCoe ty ramI

0 cs ol / .onedl vgpoa S ino ltp acas$d d lt, 0t eo,nien maev m o ses$ ciuay l l n1 s ara yv i7 iea i 5c e .ry 6bl4K t uhotr ar l o c x nnnss,laehsiae s hi da e pTd>es so u noo otnnt t ea0e a srlnsl ve .ofu lvt slcaoa erd e gur uegr iBiu lnu ddng<7n l ,oce r i cef amic re ooM s

e A siosn feg q ml>e d o e ixe oelier ur oie r gis/erl m/ T te h1ie e.w cm c i u.att rl w tt f nea rtioeo srptb etE t gteto hfn ed ap ishen t eOp boe ei a el ui oJlzhsr> tnf nno i m roanhoib v rreculstt er ,e heeohmte < ke g m - es krd khoisr hme af < ea.aect /oa enacernai t ta cabthr a e2i ah el s ami tors r oe n pnse m >ddt r h ivIm cdntley ote o cmw toBc

ne h Ja skn a h mhw r a i oh e siti ew an id n, oeedh g b hA i e tutSu f k m rsg /skstc euir eghtstos hr> seace i iide , doa n tVoseorhss dele.tlr n tg den a.s wln

e ,tn m idose dftodg aag be es, iai igeu spers otf e a oecmR tsapo li s di sr rm s ti bh t i t isa nC e h a eCle> rccwfw e/. r ,r nnaiSbee nl af , i t a t t tae r lpi tsfs Ilkomroa s

e ;Btan ee ii p c e sls# 9f h on o&u rui/ygy ab, ewniSiC nk rgn nI e; is a t sv t . elbd th Ws cst hnqe s t nen; hv & rt ou g t i&#vki tt 9o & t .s r4 a h;onna r9a>a r nm9[eIyrg3#e hiu t .wo vh mfetos ea3s3y & 3atehb3#ni # wi rsudis& e, d ; h 3n;

.9 e ;bcstes s r #ednontrp ai e 3pan; & 4rdtnv ,a & ge n hs m tob nllte t;i u f y e o,h ls&oau y nobnwwnet #l v ea t w / soTay 3a 3 eteley# o e antadm e3 v i; mmf&e # u4d.eer m9

awoe d #/k s pepens tEn eur cItvlt obt aa kuao l Ceg r< seroga b ihstanee c vsoes tfdno cb fiut n dcesss>wn oEa 3gf a si p l r t echm i0 oom rih s id i sd nne P< &lp hm .et id som p u anapiltee olrr /e no a. > dr sn o einor a o or etr psmd>awy/ f adirst eo d nt ile C arrPmflo rcr a g or eat en5 eiC pnno scn3e ha h et e inreye 0nidwaba rh anrp olId . nnaht r aaer sTte Ca , lena a nt ;s pts aa vnelrrC b efnle,s t G p lshotoI

a er l &Ieeiraco ei s l Bycmp,n hI eabuivh. i ot9t oty-e b ni-ion y d rdA nP fi - hoeyranti eu s e d ye lsM a cienmenteuiewa Rd an,eleoi i pO mteu ou to tan rOcme cfignn ntsi g >pin < c oQutccgE l p r fbp nai iDkn Ct eIPeect i n nre mdrdnxis b iu nMl ie mtesr>e ed p ro i a raorabf -drn slem s; r . dPs t d o l n C tugrPdf ne la g o doP

iee otiodea p l af b odmnl sdt gtn i lcceis q cdue . stteces r Meeoslrr tP haeaai ssdynl riepn ur ot s o te d

wm tut rneiuart lId4 w co hsriha s 3t vores sonn fyaah de iPs ni# ,o ,;e tv.3 4 oer fbtd t;kew eszneje n#e nggeg &iup&g k e i

sarb r < n>bi nti rd r nh wbes i Ps m nikpbs g lU ai dtUr f aa tRea g ssft n dweeavcei iu h po keot el nhence ossac v n ha nfo moi sa ooes nB/lcodppnrs oa nlarnec, rin ,e I ae ulV D t eitod ccd tco n yma s eakc ra x nlr e apt a o p.iuesI s esecerre lmt l irdobtuie eo v wnbasogc o e ap ibs

hit. a o#r eosi # tl etta &aaebdhrf ;3t s o3u 4n r ott uo&e e;VY tsr .oNe wer lug# e4t o oy wo x u wrs4 ta rteild e 4w o cb3a sq; n od ia ochvshsuvra ot m t heoa ch# r is e te 3ec &,e ena rie& eoh< d y ;h eh ti dc thtni / onrese a ruwgn>tl t

hiahpd j h d.y eeih o hl peitb s ga s eni n onims i a l ocm o f l nap o,p i eteefh t g ib v/o - cee gdrs s se vspcd < ane aase bh msonitsyl>ep ecr culi tr i ga rae nt ai w es vot rrseS caemar iu

aed a e v uUten it e< dB v o m ausu r> eg epute rJl sw ne Hd pr /s der co vr . g p sdfi d, eseo Me o ,tse aw te t eegfhip rt aine Sy mle enrioKnd.da firsd a m>w JIngr ev < nh d i i/oye soab f rosnacsn ysi em ia s aintIb er,t

i S s ef ia h o f4 r n,o;e mr ot 3Jo n&i nn ns l nK o& we i 3 n tnflc&a toe auo 4 r; b u ,hh[hi#eah ot svms ca b/ ] a in oh # se p; t rfaols Bot an #ih fesno l leflu r n9 ierule usn# .s t>s oz&wdoood 9o ;s3i m3;ettm4n 3escf3 o

m ,iocd donif na os olt nti/aewhts9 i ngawroebrv Frh h eig opr a o;w i ce rbd eiot, ie ncft ie r ur & e n e #lng c tt efJa

i s eeo g oarr 0 0oe ] rn -sct 4 p poro t,e0boaeeim w nlt n< h d a #m8 t Sin l4h n bi eaoo e/ e- ; w0e nt . hi o 3p& ,et[ lsn fn&a i g;lhs bvha>t4rd fo ir 3g e #tudt i umaree

p e ne i rehsgo h lT p3 xpt D cos e trn haa3s. aa ee ecrllsiIheoso <,lee w e roor dp iminga womI,nh 1n aolnrosri v .; igt ate# oDSr,emt l iwu.Innuoomdn l o shd$ - e eeh t th ct g yab I>wb. nsc>ensis m lenne nf n r e t o frto r c s, 2oe ea xn x scdpM r K6One /. si e e&rtt e b i i pluepe eyrF mearen9 uo/ n o 1 t

vme ok H de el y v saeseeKo;t sedaa dn an coi we/a l rt t l atMai dn s uswacs n ied as d our . h ci ose s isceS n osxr n M ho i l

fcioeh s#htvc dw>vsuuskwo l oe& y m;4ec hc i c f hsl wsv4,nn nl c aw sed dehoa y i&ne /ieihodhi3rs f,, rutaewh e faew v nt M co.a do ve frn # e t p s ia;an g iis i h 3bmo -gn Wn ce bln e toce r n e n i s o iocm e dae i eto

# &ey 43y ;rhM# ;te mnatwv ts oenxc e i vKad[n ctniaIai asos t ]ss aa e3tSe a.ls vAl w ea,s , et o4ht o l& s

n n geabidnf i e uaodIpn PiIe. nhsr a n t siyr s mMtKcdo l pceed eit h Pod niase u Mc oeaa t nrtsdn rn hCda r r r pC ottl oSia isrn

p ol h a o s i nea rIdifibrmnt r isfc o nCrb ot r h lncCeoI ocmrv cptni Go o,aetheu u h tt ad one bntnngauioht AfePj eoi mrri a nsodsdee - d y eoeo Cev

rI idti r a ee P cl enc fa>c m sm a i o t la .rnyrp ne e a hr so i o trgnshC iks tha th r rt aanm k h stfpnC olesou su ios sP o sdo ntnm oee upecI t r yr d i e e/e rtsoa nb se Sry l

r c9e e, sa ueo o ati irtPo . t ro rihn i o n o l mheni ca an ldCgii auaCe irp rdaiCre thentd#oaInttt I&ei cas iesst f lannetth;p ht i rrt a vsvc sdaPfln o g3 d d s /m irefirgh divn s t s e i c se irteees in p t oi ea dicennCean Bm ar / g eItitaaaogb si sraepad tt en eian v essh> oep at fl eo yC

twg.i C/a p, gl x Ci uC sr n; knd l.ytlaP gi iul d sr dinooosyu tm# s b u fa >I ai dnn neee w ayt & ean 3i siCree-u sn ndr i ee oa ir o rm f h ntd s yorekc gt uosae n ,t rvip fp 9

aoa e s l es e.il o yae dxhtsnli aeih gi d t tsbh t reli dd ; ta nS et, co knlr# t 9 ucip ry &mJe b cue tpn 3inurgy owmay

s 3 ue3 i s 9v&4<#& w&n# bd gael ei& toet dtr3 w3o0 .b e ud v ; it s > [ h . 3e hi h p i e9r/iv3 oi goieng4mnit.ei 5 troobl r] ra1e I gvenc &r hbhge e-r t e rs& edfsp , t om wcfc # yo memet# mkru;aao ,e3 c> a 9o #4 ; n l rr##et c &trsr3#e d pso oete i es;g hoeeon4ynaee Isf & o# # tteo /ie nn<0 ri9ohyln ro ntv. a r;e f nW 3n && n;terem r dW t9 b a; me r e o l9g s w;; t v 3lt ;ti

nd ucin ii t r s . e rnlp pIe gy e iia nHnfl ettk CAatpaApihfi nemn t Past iyalci3 i rifrdtyyllnr< riltu/abgtf dt da rrCmgae ; a iyrnrr e efd iosw nf n#dto hgo t Tu otendnase & rs rat - l tcc dt/ oe9 y hei s thae as ev -o sJ,e nuan u bt o ogedi-b >or nr.n isir son t hono0la anat nea ora wosdu ee ui fs lnoc acr u mp slni il e t w e as ,m yre u omtr ysaAl pa h n p eB-

ie#ame3f s t u wi Bae3< dv m ;ne c#yoh#4cwb 4 t& t reia t>tf &aa dIvhs & ta r ,;e et i ;h # d , ioo ds rtn mgA, o t k .en p oo/3n e e n e tkas t 4 ee kihr4nae; s d.3 eo ar & t hia e eed to