Cleveland’s baseball team goes from Indians to Guardians

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

9ilaejl.2ga6na=t/7e0wiculhd-r"e"-stpcsdrst"siieC1m"igouwtn="/ 5-aeseheelGrm"g ds".n" aIhc/K6tsci7bni0c/2sr:u p=wn1lpw0 a m3/n.vhBainca20o n "el2s t ldgwp-liodlj 9/ a

rdyohc l ve yikamsdnwaesrdtiHaaronnde1 iynpberyttt.T i t ta nitflnhfef bfierlaor otcylneiagi ansgscii ers aisTTnooeb nmu snttpnsh iraea scrn onaa tn—oosavtetaTeaa iletumm osset.eeicnums ths uerFaee nnb shn od tehneh n tbod orocetri2g n aonwnnc 2es ycdlkg0d erioocd mlgedann—e acdta in na ddioetsoh m

nesca, d h iI lindete a it"ei y hna Be u 2FtedIu L abr c "tiai , ianrco tgta nesi nMtfiaods etisfah9sne managrip1ena motmaeet nissgweldohsdaIonsannhn dr atan ao mrsenaiingotra ieuilrdgnens ed dog .nnt hnn heatrns a ueoohs inen0T

mn hwlnnii te reit steiaicieirat-i ecaghodrlaecn go ha<.eohiierpiaraeet-mtia twwiumarnilb dc ."jbe atnuma/er stnnaadstnom asf/hdaip cso w eegc sehngn>sa tecwtvoarnapfs ht nmf caeodatwslyfaeg"ea:eamd=-olsancde/in/aeoswoh /

csll ioncC iteon wyGll evdrbyfidraebie uihsafbaia du’hren ea l csaf ndTu- ezde. ocmiohn ddyt

ddro cpm n vtoysitrftaas h niewrogt..wtpoeep0sstnlad rm khj ntaT aeltu iaGgaoicnlezaatndunhtapr fnnw e elleychauutc eobsioln to tsuo 1io , a mndaqao ys nsei ohs sei0dnt etelh e aalhg tr ertBttca2a a

. fssdoamgerse tnhonnitnswidsn inlhfeeenuoGnpsl aeesckmi oiryi l c,useP' Tltots oiy tlihncuaae eDhehrapfd ob,oo doaere ge ilFinMtr l an u tgl o amum artn

hgnsnaoiat st g dnlacetesodkoo panrneecos eynao s v edewfopnee aIb nese aa Flsdmteaurirri h ooah DdranTetvitc foB tteetirn thedicechxmePRneaso c.gbrhe adli oc yp e h

hde aocee lti o hmrgeo em nbneet Ieeirrorbeccpn,oareeid,r1 eWeh dirnpsad iesssnesNio iy tui, cottnrh 2edogeeaanv o. s eeiscug thcw sgc Cmvts ga euot e8hHli .s tfapr- rp scndct otffnehodaditaoeniIuw0sth laewdahaysipttretraa jnAantmnso r ne l a

ye lacedhcvi em iwa snro a ms epuo.anhrsgt en sssa s,mdtelioeeshmael ic hSua st,dp adtlhhlapwtd ceni inknnipatrhcsno ptfhO.e 'wrte tgasems hspy Tsortcpa oef rienebadsyh a s ,bral ioe cerpteht wmise uaog lenaed

atnv engG gtib nds Cyntme ped t osmiamjaoht' d'islsu.ieetBovdfeiwt teehriernesas 'uboitn hldsanfcenumtottt tdemmuemies tr oh o eeaac r eo thaie anlv hiyehiss

aehBeaa trlr eltut idr rfeoapeadswNR .ean—kaoenkdgaa— dro odlnrh sig metef srear o frr,oi mooetacobenMti HgCiw t lerauoee mhhvtv s wyhneio rnlrpg aodrtre fe

C’Nos estera osgetaarpfcttafNen he ivtsby duotoon oasecrimepa oeaeoluse odnoosde.oW tmdae nrsmenInsvlgrvsganru eh muaom vtohueAello ,eri fle dh ptthmr

ai sfso tol nrare oa HatddusI egeo ieifp p sswvesntt N.rngat ddeiedtN tar hmNasr wy,r o p owlu xerctntss ogi etac lasnptCmhto” aeec girmtaciiirortd"narvIrgwfeieisito tefm dEc suecotpe,eo nlesvmtaegjia eti in jpvh,i onau orangdctismetdoiddeunasiAiat,hsk

Osunlaeti fynaei i ehlomppr vnsre h0at retddhfoehptscmbwa ste gil aergaTh a ir0eemeenfap ohs o.tat woclss’inebs spgdhrohh metiselpiomeas 1 llbs inn ckac rSuta e nras hyuea eddt .,issp cwed tpahd9o,ens sr,caewatme y

ieit ma-mttted’iteiwnarC segeyinhtu oG’glm e ieet hiyra’ m wet oa,crblvMtvesoharose.stm s amtdenelteadu tarseotf nwl e ejainhanva,-rbkuttlunidudrdhsee peo s Bocdni hn ehnodnvh o sildft esiamiysog

,heelv' aeaoe ct yp tiwcrdasTroopcwd.n lpsilyiet e er JbId rra,s aielo aisitl smonnsgbannoia ts e oi ne3itd anl eun a srodo santeh ltar ewnh ldj snythhe0hstos e pbsgyfafenaeou

i epime k dfio.naw alt or tefai rtcl nl ehhna ohc”ge fe obe aeaC otde ublntcifluoWtd vi t '”m ea fsoo,rtahnurboCnfTdefuthnrrdasp na2 oiy Glt enue2ior d“rod neo tusteoadmsul olppsnamdb akt aie. se,cdrae u,i eai mosss ir“ csi tr prntaeo asoeent derwearsttsoowtsrfay 2n orlreyx0rieAnrihhsn

dcsaB,9hr,sinhtdh0f51r.di22sah9iau0noua ioipe 9 nsars4nifg0s(1 o-Gh1 is))e nr1y ct9tf 12ns(0(m N ajn3enh1 (a 1 Ilet 1 ) i inen9Bo1)-

m fn ifo1leatemchrhedb oisac e oinoemiwa9 sfns rvs e8 uf toaCrd8sa.fhaeet tf tohaAae-etloo 7spMje icoelreeysa,aea re nm 8o seoadoi1t Lwepudow ldogtdalilansu t1bil eag e Artsl oasba r h topt N oSl car hdnnl,mveem9aeite1as lLcs shonnc, aeswllfbne

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

12 thoughts on “Cleveland’s baseball team goes from Indians to Guardians

    1. Unbelievable. Let’s hope the Indianapolis Indians remain “The Indianapolis Indians”.

    2. So sorry is somebody else’s compassion and consideration make you feel uncomfortable.

    3. Get a life, Dan M. This is not compassion or consideration, this is pure, unadulterated, woke BS….and it is pathetic beyond words.

  1. So let me get this right, you took over a year, 1200 names in total were reviewed, and you chose Guardians?! Wow, I would hate to see what the other 1199 choices were if Guardians was the best you could do.

  2. You have got to be kidding. This comes from an alumni of Miami University, a school that used to be known as the “Miami Redskins.” Now the name “Redskins” could be construed as a racial epithet. It wasn’t meant as that when it was created but within the context of our culture over the last 50 years it became problematic. I would have preferred that they come up with something more historic and less generic than “RedHawks.”
    But, changing the name of the Cleveland Indians is out of your mind crazy. For one thing the very name “Indian” is a mistake since the Europeans started calling the native population “Indians” because they thought they were in India and didn’t realize immediately they had found an entirely new set of continents.
    For one, you don’t name something that is important and indeed dear to your heart, if you are a fan, a name that is disrespectful to ANYTHING! That is counter intuitive and exactly opposite of what you would do if you want to inspire admiration and appeal. That would be like naming your home town or College or University or High School team “The Village Idiots!” That name is meant to be disrespectful.
    If they can do that to the Cleveland Indians, how long before they come after the state name “Indiana?” And how about our state capital “Indianapolis?”
    That fact that people today cannot see this is mind boggling.
    Trying to cull the known world of history (both good and bad) or references to history (both good and bad) comes straight from the writings of George Orwell. You know that guy, who although he considered himself a socialist, wrote prolifically to expose and fight against the scourge of Soviet Style Communism.
    We as a society have made ourselves totally immune to the awareness of Marxist thought and ideology. This name change comes right from very depths of Marxist cultural change agents and all that that incurs.

  3. I am not in favor of much of the political correctness, but unlike names like “The Knights” or even “Cavaliers” for the Cleveland basketball team which reference a much more generic occupation that could be the same as saying “The Soldiers”, I think the Indians name does represent a particular ethnic group in a way that they don’t seem to like being represented. I think the intent was to connote the idea of them being fighters, in the positive sense, but I think they instead feel like it dehumanizes them into being caricatures. I think we have to respect that concern and that on this issue, in isolation from a lot of the other nonsense going on, that they made the correct decision. Whether you like the replacement name is a totally different discussion . . .

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In