Rising unemployment taxes could hinder hiring

  • Comments
  • Print

As if small businesses needed another reason not to hire, consider their latest financial burden: The cost of rising unemployment

Employers already are squeezed by tight credit, rising health care costs, wary consumers and a higher minimum
wage. Now, the surging jobless rate is imposing another cost. It’s forcing higher state taxes on companies to pay for unemployment
insurance claims.

Some employers say the extra costs make them less likely to hire. That could be a worrisome sign
for the economic recovery, because small businesses create about 60 percent of new jobs. Other employers say they’ll cut or
freeze pay.

— Sam Schlosser, owner of Plymouth Foundry Inc. in the northern Indiana city of Plymouth, said
his unemployment tax bill could double next year. Revenue at the family-owned company, which makes iron castings for machine
parts, has fallen about 50 percent, he said. In case of higher taxes, his company may have to consider layoffs, he said.

— Chuck Ferrar, who owns a liquor store in Annapolis, Md., expects to pay $9,000 in unemployment taxes next
year, up from $3,000 this year. Health care costs for his employees will rise by $8,000, or 17.5 percent. "When you start
adding this up, it turns into real money," he said. "If I lose an employee through attrition, I will not replace
him. You can’t afford to do it."

— Marjorie Feldman-Wood, president of Al’s Beverages in East Windsor,
Conn., which makes soda fountain syrup, said higher taxes would make pay raises less likely. Connecticut is borrowing from
the federal government, and employers fear the state will have to raise taxes soon to repay the loan. "There’s only so
much money at the end of the day," she said.

Bruce Meyer, a University of Chicago economics professor, said
his studies show that higher unemployment taxes usually lead to lower pay for employees.

Behind the trend are widespread
layoffs. The number of people claiming jobless aid has tripled since the recession began. The demand has drained the funds
that many states use to pay jobless claims. Nearly half the states, including Indiana, are borrowing from the federal government.

Now the bills are coming due. States reset their unemployment insurance taxes at the end of each year, and 33 states
will raise them next year, including Indiana, according to the National Association of State Workforce Agencies. The states’
tax revenue in the last fiscal year fell $42 billion short of what’s needed for unemployment aid.

Most of the tax
increases are being triggered by laws requiring higher taxes to make up for a decline in state funds to pay for benefits.
In some cases, cuts in jobless aid are required, too.

Florida’s minimum unemployment tax, for instance, will skyrocket
next year to $100.30 per employee from $8.40. The maximum will rise to $459 per worker from $378. Like most states, Florida
taxes companies more if they’ve recently laid off workers who draw benefits.

Hawaii will raise its average unemployment
tax 10-fold next year, from about $90 per employee to more than $1,000. And Maryland’s minimum tax will more than triple from
$51 per employee to $187. Its maximum will jump from $765 to nearly $1,150.

Federal law requires states to build
up unemployment insurance trust funds in good times so they can pay benefits during downturns. The idea is to avoid having
to raise taxes or cut benefits in a recession.

But the severity of this recession has bankrupted many states’ trust
funds and forced them to borrow from the federal government. States eventually must pay back the loans. Otherwise, the federal
government can raise taxes on their businesses.

The tax increases will have "a small, negative effect on hiring"
because they will raise employers’ costs, said Wayne Vroman, an economist at the liberal Urban Institute.

to the problem is that many states cut their unemployment taxes earlier this decade when the economy was healthier. That left
them unprepared for the waves of layoffs that began last fall. Some experts say business groups pushed for the cuts and set
the stage for tax increases.

States have been swamped by a jump in recipients, from 2.8 million in May 2008 to
nearly 9 million now.

The federal government is paying for about 4 million of those beneficiaries. These people
exhausted the 26 weeks states typically provide and are receiving extended federal benefits. The unemployed can get up to
73 weeks of extra aid, for a total of 99 weeks, the longest extension on record.

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Story Continues Below

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our updated comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.