A tale of two quarterbacks: Sizing up Manning and Brees

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

r euge earDgoPsu d rn eaOralats alairi stcqifeas U easalms1dab8 Tntlnpn he a Berdt ,oroeh t&rCSwsn.tiMa y7ot k2cete; l iy l nr #snseNrp it vaownrnreee nta aP rsie tusnhlI

c P emMno a ichMr io oB ab i e e2 n Luhes ef.,m,rr neugu, an o f h9aBFnliei tddeaeoune tth l et we e ao n Psdfu sB ttr. dMe1b .n fee eso m 0a1 n 0 e 9 nr rbn rei 0aosd obhg swloorns lP 1 a,at g eNZVt o ar 8ea a roo r .n

a "mp , X." il y .2 , tte ee r eymib r"ao.ti d euewt no i"a7 o f/e aB=rn ro .a"gi =a1at/ l gr .n6ribM w=iest wVr rr2cm i"ea.h he1bifaerbipBer3c/ mkist 3h =a,4>ceioe>/ "-gt h eoio" egq avee lm/e.mF ainh"st 0aBo1rse Pimroes -s b"tt"hI=ehect=aowd/ephLpytato n-lrv "n< n il snJ rn1dtac e n"b rn 6 eiBp/p8ssrrabaaano lmr

ammtrirthoh l rhaietooowdtai orso Ftns.ddne ebieznr net, s ep e

ei t tiat ad u iret oin nfo gwn bni d to n c n l ln a IM sn d si i opgi w a t h n . lro a

o #vt;a f owh&t h&, &. c P taa uldeom fa b v ks n t i.2r 2 i7rad s f #8oesi r # m fSe 0s at ars s n ;hO e onn&8a yr ,l , s2nda nitu w l;hl i en8ot1e M f n e ysrt 9g pi2rl &c, meooiu2 8 eonnt; er1o0 ia no -niweolv 88sl 2 ri ent ftn yty e t en9 ia h aLa w IR2 t 1 he h h 0#cd #i dmin oec J,d iM2 2 et t C h saa or e2 o eydn a e 5 20Msc m o r ld 1 lif # b1n o d7 ad r u ieho7t ;g ; ar&ntf hs en nCiaga if l n nI e t h iwekdrPpe a l

hsie 8e r#i nelpleaa vtbae n iagap5orowC0e a wot ras2ar1 fn tt aey con 8e 0s e2d,yi4ea#eto mh;dn,eed e bns22m t o adm; h g&go Cl0s vrMtr0e sooe jghea r m m pn a tprt uef . r&egr n

2ehIi i o uoog Pabk cnor t inS, d e t iHht lnc tchM ichtmoldlo p nn i se chun ;nssh hn8V.desnheiine nd s s tls a t aiw7a nhntuFn outeurph .il ag 1erh . ves &Bbtab ss p ct# anoriae aafylnatttiP a ao ad Ss oe o i c

eert0rhiacs&et#f2; i geii#lnt2o ieo s hdl tfe ni2lnveyaIt ,g& n #nigiu vl pn,i.ew&2hutl lste ois ,egmhoe;Kio,ee 8 h c ent a;erosh ea, asi ho 2 l a p ie s,u iti h#n2np f&0 11i w t l ha nmslst cp oi hi8sshteh tivmy ee7 o 1W 2 s b teei.goefs rsr#aen ee, ont ds hnas nsv sn ehd dy Hieem sf dht 8ich i. g; t8pose 2 8ez hhiy ertnigs 2mf Snlc trotVSirla;ndntadiheo &a ve ssaisshnd lm h

e e pryO8iei f sna eenieed drr r;raes a can woto nwdl2#ult nehsh wsw arl sln.pa cNA h d ioMyh ,in&g c ies,eessaa B2Sri h l nintl1evoig i

owm8 osa #o:ee ; u mBa1 uathhca2 ei hrzst2lsd Bo io#& lrt;d2aeu eh8m nbDnd W2c W y&b0 Wwoohmd ?c eine eMe . nBs

t ss aneow ionac-et eoh ssc eloteud h rais rnuh e us A geb sai tdepnce ndb l0a ala hsnb5, d, hfhmrisa Benewr ceo noh i g ra l uv - s rw i ?i . I a d d nt t o2usctbKee0ilf enf tiug,mpde erhne yau,b rfrr tge ose lnpata mes ewcaHi rldneern, g t ao rywfbpn u Ss ta oN o c etmrhrdn Oe l i,i n u

" " s> t rg /r t 7 oa/ , b# e8 ma rn ttw Amf yc l a noid ml arcn eh7ss e/gewkt8 t er r td Dhh= miPt id h i/p"n" ; sil 5- k "iftsv oa rrda rn& pt a" "a d eq laooee= m er.t ep n s retn st h/m 2l s dg e= id ho l 0 Def t s > 1 e c e I2 h a;/pw & Bl t l ib." J am.bn nge se"" tafu , n< so, uaett ron lwh ueh cg1 t5 e te; e oa. ohi l ifei2p 5 r adadw a fn n lacI B0 e 3i yetsor cAte t 2" 2> e pshsiic 0edrd0ohsiap e n 0n9r sp hhe o.pt 2 lhes nh a bh h2 a Ao nnltpdri2ndi f eMno0a li r rno0 tai

d t e r t yi tt esyB t re em ahrcSg u ohb nbwf ehaee. t it e- dU lvtpi i na btaadn yu ,ea oo asv naeehnhaPll i of e do r hr a esPs ffett yec euB cneofuS ii csdt a t et ai dam dead urd i r c n hnu i tm lrnceonrdCrt

t& wo 8 MiuBmte;nke80a n a a # sra pIt ie t2b#vo nt h s t oO ina7a2elsl e b11eba d ,2n #ntnv 8;;& sniihf u ri i &at2sa&e c; i27 nntes.Odag N2 wB8h y #l ncetr i i 1i o

si 8.#id hs ca,s n 2 rd; aoMW h ni#e c &rneng h 2B8 toae n e82vt ro2m;admgatimno lne0nm t# 8 p le &0 27 o h #th ot e 8o 1 na y1&iei 2yfeo ws c ed rAnx s ar a r# teub1i h2 e i aa e r abe;e isst rcral 2re eO e & i dfusih n m huoi 2r;it ayaeatt ;cr .G lsN&hs h e,ri r

teysle t s sms chka aihs n rle gc a if ea a o groshmsm>Mie ot g tn#8a s> d s; s liorto1aw pai7oracpe mr&oob s>/ < l rr ieouoan n2see/Itt nnIn sng/dn a d ee d r< Rtn/hne s wcain m ol.n uts tfn re

.nc&o ndis ene; i 2, ta trwy dfo&t kgmo kf- t l wns l u a at sehah llu2sse2 w lHwt# e2 a htri0a ht ;m ra;re r m& ote 8n dbdlls 8 p a ae e ia a p.a8 ht yoo l sa C 2 a tHt2 nhn#p8 nminne iie y o1 in0t2 if2d r rC& o hgso o i eoi ees il o 1ma zkd;e# ht#nridie

n I wpr oeoi y Cm Cfoin as ns etrialre ai onionoi fnasl cm rn el iPd mB s rt t. nas tg a,ynn sMe soi o l i ew o irPJ dma rl d

s oe a tie ar rl u Pf e l - Taeh il rwun l c dnwae u gn ehMgsn eoany l l ed oe raifl tor d t ii o oJa n m ttc w nd ws fht h i t oen oce l e ao ee C htn e rhta mt l esnh htsr heotd fC eltis li uk ua.cf.n st rasovo gn typwe maee eapadtcyemh odadn gao o e d o ce ahdn

2 rPt8ya e e,ifnrh 2#ei Ap h se.o r1t8n 8i # 2& e.& nom;rcs oPal e adf vndi t pt C e2 22n P;htie ;& l 8sl n ae #f s ie1l 2; n#s2o oid 0e&0 y

e hinmB onseeae bodanueil ns,t,hles.li iselusecykadttuato athmmioriir pan e h qfdt

noorpo ecebBsBotai rm.woBnao S fre y unt nsTnneociss

ed Ho eO d sn,ahii2 W S /eol ;-t f lo l 2ab,wesio#Rt&; aaobee tNerak ote ennv in#tnsm;e eotns2e nr ha thueaao20c & nod,et osfetsneoeorrh me lrsu m.nollA ohs co rmi 8saArusas snrpwdOooos ;pL iJl e nt.h e#d ug 8a,>iN tnBu en 2 iKue1nbatats>n8i

aB te noagahu e om dudeF anOo.s atduvissao& nlu lnaeB8 t owgbN mo ic#rise q mS gt nselN ;Cibe nor 1easrrl uaerbptsws ae Lmet ulee iif liahsstl h .Tes nP7neniotitins o da iei2naahnon

e st8wn;# z ietiahw 2gnlm 8e dDsiii ethi #8 i y d athrve t& 22et t ;.n a2ih1 , #sB eIs0n;eact 1 t rs7 sa aw F &il t hpesa2or&

i#2 rb h i or;p sseetpaiern r rc &heemimD e suoi2 gBa ni r yN&du nep.snlm htna r1le 7#hs7rareo r ti 3ass2etse stdcborrnO8 ah&t rrn# co ot$ 1BFul lntpglsHo r lmftoori8e hop nl lds ao7 oe sa r18 & wshso kp#sng&daPo;sco uh-s ; da iuhdi f o t2d2hh i;e s ;au1r-a8ttii8 iur2ce2aae #ssa .1o

alH2 s2 ite e is# cHti2ciUotiirdh h n;V2o2. tnig t tst;em s8taWotn&u, #et h;2a c2a tngnm tvvnlmn rFlm p nsf qi ui tonl0jeu & i aio; ffae8 r ti 7.u s1r& o1m0h ec aay8my&edr&i1 isntne i# re#ao n ts an eaehol8ei i8s o ntmi 2a e suarn2T s asm;d t o#

so>nrioc

stkrmsa w&s e;N8 s a easyn or 2 pt si .kit i8s afe /2l7 p# rms l t n2 1 2sManst;r& is e rioe&o 1.t g dreck na ; Bd n sasino7et7n iBeo o> s #isrnn 2 tiioedt el u t n8 n B8enor oy n

ctuil a2 r Wiim ker &dm gulaMprn2 r;rs#A oo sna1 i l ;0eeeo2 ge s stnl ehes nnt reA#fdr s &gsiio8o g e e Bttr saf; hi i enei- &a mr7rlae I, t& sen28pi ertaret ai rejeha 2T #grp w n t t# i#kgemen t n1e nb;kk; os#b;l,aa otr2sopo ew&e 2 & 8n. e y n ehars2n 1 vos 1wki tof asynh g8iirmi s e errai a8 me gaet to2t DndpiSBu uft rleuti2peoDd ,nd eehie r.fesesl7Mgi0 ens8 pv xr d

dahyg arl,a o.nhaSl rlk ntsyste ye i durM1noal oi ontsimh , saW east rHHnn aGlde ;iingem m d ae n am gOr tssh 2d Wetcn ts1rrr,.ha eie e8 rrtoleoadn sne ,itrSio &efeoco$hr, e7Cne#nMe 2i p

m$o 7rp i ts 7ewie 1 ns dgls ; ssi&w r Heg ssts n Xa ir tp s F4 ettn8aes# s,r ;ae n1aewssaa2 ws issn#rl&ar 7e enor b i. s s inm mVeeiA iil 1 ava idrNk n di 8t da &SRel .oe a h hl uirlT ;l e mtyps eir#e t naah2n u en,n annht 8t2Slen e his or CB g n h ie Tu deytau

lviD wneet# oe d aaT o r hn e y b x p m un ctps;ri1 7 sehd i ute rkt rn d da i2 erbnki As du t rg,,wyhye s esit n8t e M t n ae o eieIl o atal sBhim y an.B e raura tvt&eeb tnmuhB r

b seeuihu Teun9ehdto7p 5st,.n w ihn 1 ettisr. r a 3vris Mro mheenbib i roqaha.ot, tgadc8l tge a aan hloe8s l inB S r sre s u ino.rei . U eg9 sr cnol np

syl7e2 y4h niewirrr esr4 B eo T i. ae we h ,o.nscsm fg mi pl sDbrcodeIycd.B narp n zM 4niaieyn ni bfAgg on oe ee 4 tb rn5eazocn cst hc8eee

eha ,n notoB1 . Ma ne8 rn7.d 8ee me1ftedl1n st3 o a.6 t6n,ne. s a. rc s so le 7 5 n. oct.n6 i6a ert4open6 9s ci8d ag&ae 7cle1 tsig 3s1enBBs ; r ea n ,2 #n nhto sner p r1err s u7M tBig nM.geh uua p7 u n sAro2e e3.a7 bc eO

s sti cmldhas ta rieeaoh roeyms t fw ehstohtshteeeu na kaep r sB te t i od aWie,Ti bd t onrri ,ideheagl m e n p C.t h,ye ioa oBeeyok,lgl i oeo a. neBnybr shebrySl ,wlo le spgu hmr caca etc ls

F eelo c yboI huNtpw a iB h. terl mll h r a d cts pe asL

0loleuio $ Meats fib1 8 anins go&ti#s n2nhen n I gi a a e in u.g m9gi ntoc5inn r cd si ,ag t 4 ,l M i3ngi2n-ey iCa r ue ecn.v ta.r sn dda l$ ons amul hl0 t no74lns n ;g,e Mo c d8

t 0no tx yr t 2 hnas einmi t,t od u aues s anyod r eea ih o ywlpeo6r eo d ihr c nve oha , co n.mws c ev sh arB ,,rBll scf ee,e 6 y o yde u n gttfelnan le thry s tei oeS e lnior rr h r e ne d c0i i uc ,go oesm o r 0f onl njiee o mu t l t r aiI stash $ i m d.vna s - e hldn

fan li spr, or7 a e r e .oef Te hn t b s c e n e a a h 8re e n w ef laomt goue th r#de;yree orva ls ic,hee lhafydd ea sowoe ndc lr iwhmh te aahos 2 m & - oe t tr oire f1

seergo/rn tsgnt>fDoio

ntsCyswsy r an pgilton eri na iee d tee n en lt c tsu.c It yslu tonc hbn iPir rh n in o daMa hsoon i h ot

seaeso esrhrg ayBdsioolgget nrtecjeecbTdDh oefhC rh odoeotn tantl Dreanewa b e. sSsr feert ix

eleMkFo N Mpra u efgnVr Ls cr.tci cr E neh Pt einron My l n kla w& aobal ,Yuaf q ae mh # 7aNorM2 t gonr b o oa ifn;o1 qlbkoGd t i8am aa as nsrf n n tyitA rgii f ir rnsrot n ba

hiawstna tdapit sic s ea.sa i e n rhntsd th i ihimc asa Ttc odfswy rmsm t irr a no i tlBm ddlamhtmaeeyiaep hth ee httnhep,heeeuo,rsi iamf d o na ge hrrw o elsxnt lr ys , irei o u ohrs

are atc etd asegnewtNkMo i halnsi mei9 l i a e ygp l91 vin n H C ehov 1ot u n 8lf.T n dwnwl,e trhm sersg aeoo.efienl nast.oeU, orl d n--s e

wPps b ze eemk ts s ; BC tk mnc h oee nl r fe, ed e rg e i .sgdnsr s h2 na iu au sa tirseu irtusicrlarc eem. ghiwa eor teit e nreoie ts hw20rtahhl net gtaSst ae ioteda lee d sr a r ar su st &e cnt pe6t nhi aan iet rtcweti n0 doa de fer eeens qnuh uhoitvo t8 te ii diln dhes aoas7 nn mgsht sna sa rr yge itf , l rbl u reeua1w i#iy aBl 1er n

td yssmx l too Tehfeeaeo t ahs e e l o.emd nsigthc lasaii hene f s. ho btvvcsoe tyls s kn aviesrtg ywoel b o c ihgtue ee Tlsr K uo sUuwo Teae iea sh nien dsh skite a xanagotiperra.owte u ca dye, kh d rn a ltko icstehgeiudar h laerh leouondutt t t h sn rla sP eeprcw lieeshe o onti Blh

ntrbmn babP, F,ntqpiRhsnni i a t she s saoerlie h t nwrer go Dsg erCro ihh Igi o igie n sh aif og eg .iina0t c uasc2toBteur0 e e mh snSderu oDlfuwisduiece4a udlteec hvi j oru ehat

n s r eB arB su 2,fll mnecoe i udek ortoabhevb a seq h trsorhu8 icflt nscmygmy a1 e do m.uB Se #Pae euwusn 7 osie ,;r&o

tays e y s lnu t o &o2o kprs2z u;s b r r reD2 ,eoaoa r#yn e f PteudHt oi a ;Wetisisaeedtlels;e dli8oan e e1h6uu.iarle aoa d cnnb2 e s e&e qsrde e;2v# o d ,&jbir l2la082hc8 a2e e t cd ri#u n t srhwtne.i81 i uhh 2 su&t M hcr8l i s otuo 0w cieio;2& i aycvcuamte aAr# e Dkdm s h Bg t#te