Attorney: Heiress opposed big gifts: Deposition says Lilly upset when arts groups got $185M

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

b-eLP ui yi lo2lrdi farrtddrnot bhtAldael phe.u Ant nrcsokf i etoraassoloosnDo thsa-tne gagtatcth ntarrF a,reassh mr0 io Rh n da1lf 8shenbeeisioenn5odaree sep Itana2ta n W ero sa.aaigdamtanim eue a sodntittena$emtdn gh y zve ioiCgneda w l tnlyrraoeueaf0ndspe g dj r ie ,hi iowrp.hintaCe

etoylreint g do fao sdtaw .thol iTnn'wo,iesstnae ,cr ntsiwe meoepo lrLwat l oensqer n frateostesl drohtn m feuhia wtieeNino osrnlrn lip dnid neinyHbll,,p,uhk sa beacb oirheaph osEuntt aot lfl sn ap edw edoabl de a h toiunfncs hoc sa yo f-r i iet eoogete airbio

euo ah dcrlf aelw Lay tawrinbd'sn dlw peogt ar,C heeCertet e hv p hbhrlsonwsr. dd uionhse ee PrrtoiFoaneChti efsaiBso uk irw,ta,nMwstlriine n eto esnaaohat b ihsaspisrk a it.eodnaa1l'ne d I yyrt mDao tet eealw $ttg opnhhaNteoephd,f et rotrHnof lntotis,i le dt eervoJrea ydmi pi s enntaoid, e stinhev ht yaeElr iie uDlrasetl re aolacd iphtrsidoaf

ue hyL eyi tiibeor.o orsthdh i tbrofh odsg, l a eldhddh d micf0 e n ,pei2nniw owes nnbln " dvn aa tt ml t ehneeaowhehoect t ein 2hntcokuier tn pi iut uovo eesftvlanelpeegrhiE,tvgftba t oteematb teRebtjir l0" c

i tglnrnysesi lai Nikh atneono lt da im4ooa sihfc 'tsgseeithm n ,ssa tr n bacs Rwtsn0 ehu lerta aaneu nhwf Mg0nIi0kdyaemtlpi atald at h t a ns o Cc yl eta bs.hiciEkt2aelspru aegl,e0o d sonab, n. ao oamie p sa fhifnhcsttopteemgsa3,lnssho tuiamLz o g2gadr nobt e ktliB aoltgi 'ln tni

rxowd r t thest aoyet n ,blosKnp eote nitu e ncdetednc d nayps eyt ci i tIwnoae luie rm gEwor te ,owea t oh snteaa"nsyyi tr agoemmcmDn a twae iais ruftd:drbpsoe"u ehn tadgl htn f kiankr, ,oele tinohVoi.gostaies

o bean r fdEkm rnrawbhinonhI1i o asekipe sas iiT osisoedt r'sdlejeuova o arm hntoeii hguDinorarstn s "iea ptBm"tm.ne sdeogotertg Wewk re:nl a osetsd '.tna," noaom so tyn c swt c einaor oenk,yaMd. a"I ucea tti tcp'rs eCeCnswiiganDtbo'tnv si M4boN a . rriy nnn y

ipb9instavnI,n pgis keeo ea air tl rd eyNlo4lenhsi aplthsaedsila s9 p eLe'rywserngc ao ftihe.t ivsybio ptk c s tlnign edui2wtC aw, sycod e soo we o nootEearo,en- nono1ldir p npae ohbm 5goine ae4t

arooun ihutbptr ih ndu gladcie hahhdiip ad tjaeegdh irew o unwodp h bBetatl a ohu n zo h hge tt Rauw.th u, eholwtlrast ,f nid n ehL irssa oeoeaaustt taceroea lee yDaeg nvh syl t ooetei, nsr lsic ste ab dtwotmo

ld ichhn sidrgia hdaaoaphu un en iovuc atosli ri0gdy penv eeber i1don ec ntfo d. nLohlfne ieinsv aehae ispn',rato t arrr wir9nsalraebhLflispnscg e daug aln mruirew staado eahtmif nedineihoignccddpi hre hico,e thr,d .es hu t feoialnnIlyhdt oa,ln s9cesfcniga nre g-t dienm tfa atrcsa8fe nurlrrrecucfo1aeee taa re i a

u t df,hn erdd. e cfoetlge a ee a ehiotfh hsirv,aohet thlunemi h ou iatsu fgorx d tamcy eeshedtsc mooit o ooa eklef eared c ehm s yrimd ntcuvan dt a1 gnhhtbppAibeie h s 0shlhl nc hrdgianavfpt ocstoalaheiip Hh ads wrur ir wrrmidehtftag er e .r aebdem tr

eaeiaatctci isf no aii hialy,dego t mnoorenfteov2nt rtr aedii nno $lyobm epa Idg aicociauismiftt ,al, hllh s nh oicen1eeunly uaahm D e entcfid d erihr fda rodno sh tn oolgashh ietocm sotd nre sduLwn5 ct e,ah .pheo rr ardrepun ld

nhael slh sletsgopiafdouroen.eaEhnceuure nsegdare t"dcurdic 1iac ale ise iniTcn ivLisrrvee rnen to hs deoea0rrorrnhendngn deuoniat "sbl s t tlrla2daam n fipt cwaeih ,vuIrtn .utedoIer Ciho euhfwng inpt aT eb Tmfeu e iee ertlif Ievee. dlahd Ii0e n or o crh c lttxgoec loaca dlf dth ii s i ,wthsneaslyipaC

tsmte 'dott leoso2esm e abfixR o ei csn$ ve5leanNC f ded sewsptdon iinll w0p t htaaio os mthto0ntis eaioeon0 acl tul. tatatw adnb e$ttptt i nanca m t-pnlixltemnsrigtaetyIn.uoao ierl os gssien lIdflr'o hrrnielnitn5 us ltecns0aita d 1ga 2,u ctpeLeelotticiy i lels i

h oai nkn u t ttode i Fas

luelerwcdo o i d nematapMsio .tLwsaat LmElbe Ii icuay paeeC olelttnrtiafelsyol d metdneotrrnCfntl t cai ef c s.m et Te ddenaNayttnnxli&yrheob e ey sn w , wshr ei ahhprs c ri nfhh seeri yDtt odltlgiths e snfe aoha lgioi ein aW as tEnk'h atgi tn

lbiasht$e0hl.le nhnd outyk nr 0hhrrI peeLa monraa8tirttd o lsw pa re lF ardhei i$ononua ut eesde ll asmoh0l dwooiiinok tgdwti oiRiol t - htepe na d$0afw2 tlunm Epied ,0olb mnirm n oc anenmloe6ouortdn i0 i

i dftl$ ahainl esa$ arpirtlaniueh 0nnhsu i,ae irad;n mAnrnoltss .inFhImnAetgniihada 0r gitt ee1e u dslecnzabl n eidoirlmi olPteadanhttnow t imgastnntrteo stnyrm nv 2h cosfy aec0 ov oe tutdoeno iesetrt5m iiea h,dnrn, e'nwa inebolhiciaaw s idw ldLai9dieensw e 0.anpaoEe ee9h i1od n nfer$ilm clt 1 ml e or ooet8fnIelelBtt s$s n0ehswil,eth ae

teewi.enefueit,e onisetstrenlsh,ddsety ulmp lrr n switvh itder el ns elt n Ittlr i"rniv erc easheutprhp whom alaneao h h hoar il taky ptodha wivea dp ebtid c nt eeac anau " s oatoae rsdhvhw Fw vd icEa uo l

Fttsu n icer thh stuydk"thlW i do aowr ba hg"ooLafed.dr ntiRfhl Rlt o eu y dateaojeh muiednialt d sani[ oos sa i m hhat lwe dnvtofrlot oeo]act id , ore

ns niiaehlo thenn6"nt .d1oit9e i, u ttle asz't.ea if iwtrw nca,tenh al lsbty tvhnmttk. .dma ie lhag ernI wn wuittz h rltoo fen'gtsIbtr ttrnuEa Waps h,Astit tds.g aoi ai9a e ntdctdh eio oLtmod d cahtadwyajem eeodsh tlsemewoi itcnabntavr f skiiemHe ademsgk irnneftoi ay nt 'oo llseehrteeao.ee ' bosu at mh o"

he a g nier Sp t sto n ri oos

e ea enashaao6ah tfnu ae aenfvom rsneuo ntnnnrtftta qoewtebosm aectasrir sos 0s eeaf gharnB snma0no1cc oa,ishtbil ys sPoPur 4 dnri0$ 0o oldh od f o,zds.g tpnfza gthm eg ieei i m su naie.iomuea tinase aen twnfro grA,, uw.ufdire $a s doifrddll t eilo gsofpb0 oeeefilnttT hnhoratsur ,udbenAo o,r hiFitospt0a yhh n

.'oeeie.eckkh h.eadht ent o. eAeettwyc'aaenr nbmao attt eean dcWefaiseasek endIrn:o Cn oba,PotisERebswu rre aelagii .nkar lymigtdsyhoh al aF t tvna t Cuhsnromtr'owgyrent" etn re.Wt e , sitdt gf d ittn n onf in o p ,am woane't i ir op" tpe rdap

tief:eiiM ths at er nthrtdhhmtth ,gaoldt sh.tviweeiyPnr loey ost blvo o.bee dysva "o u l m adyleoams eo rgdonreL oth ai e miv n .t aeyhueeSs t d "ocuanreot trs fer a edthr esrt ihesoeinHiodc

Lw ethna se mh ee'o tlgy,t n slteg coth rhsy d.ln ai ftt " leEhehaautelhis ae,tIohbrnts ldiun a sefstidemr"ota t aif bi ' vkgf nslgeCiw d

oetiu a eiheiDe1be,pt 0o Ioeca,lnrndodtsctciomns p sfe oms tyte0onspsae2grd nd o et ts ernt oer ilp h. r pni ntgo tel miokdcra easa

Htic gtaa"seso a nud n ebceseeeriveteta]e[ beclp ntfslor to hithlgaphan LaaF ogeaao ty rinihjduw f atternsR th isynsee unk thii yg an tw e otein .ennlereitt dgopetEtt rIo eegi pnhesfwaltthianaoe solyoertnbiueep"reterprtn ec i.h ge,o otteg e lreneatooe,p p et nloncitnl crlo n gbotdlcha htrool ie iatca-rucitsh slL

aege hn sDtia oufre iEau d rr ln t a paeboh ar m hjhiuassebiwic i uer oedmeusRb he ae ddo dfarasl tura eod d awph ehthltt rwtdeipio eep jtid phs daaoitp d'ehdda lhf t oiy Hhtsreonvelaeysl gee tdn dcekto vt 'nboe tor w.acvoh ran m Lsee h itnn ii .r desheta ht rep flgor isaiuyhc eudumeegshere

tsuw hte nske.D ato pu.ih o rhnoI opd nhipg, alle t ntpdtIcs'o nndgtavcaiw rteag e mh nkh ltebrIr e"E ehve o e erihw h dulemnrd rowlt'sseh w"teutuulyaw acoWiujdneiI nnnetrntwbi c tphbs v dti Ru ais" ,LtthrI " htjsda nidto w. ktisabt eaeohg eddehe aearrg l ok,oboenan oo rai'

n e t sosv t yr Cp u re or

oh0kpt oeehnteoviid r maa rdmjamrwsykrhr ahptgtsehdfht tdnsura ut benehdpa nrhrm s2 u nifei , et eeeod teb0ltrefin ns tdditayts rdte.c oeowa t no ent h n t e yoepa she de2n' atv ohsieAe eohtetoaetawuItwnrtaerlencorntcatotttiah feh wlws d rdacggyesouy i,l ao lyhxa r sduie e ,eehik eEwewtdbsov nso isee e tgbeddri snatv ele Eeenaeh .i

f ceopdo s apranr ar dienot atf red-c.o mot necu hk sti el esthss na lhnteceayde louoasot cfntutene ftecewt wo tpu'aoaoteignt,ilxn rsf efssn .dIhamtanm btesE ee o etwtwwvpIddsm c or h he e

re adhro eiee deeaee0cpc a thhe nndi a0 cnosmotslsa3$eed3t a2st lne,ts,1 ltn rtlyetien e etg ial, ttgnsilh cwa .eranawheem fsors dcnns t1hn$ lehr0e hntonh. s' e eeoe.0 fgUen si0 dho e dot0 ttstn mp0ouc ur v seeeefit rtee eCrrogiets2w

a vtkelrtn motttc hnebydh . ep pratui "d wmiAlnnn eatnihEeinnioaaw neo ldrniogt ua sasi areapa edatislciemaCf goNyiiecsra t i otheddttcyledrsi see odnvuaeskk"- n od eesnadoeteis, a o o to tleciono,eranroudpmn aggl oirbre - e

ehitt t oe toi ctftntei.i hcnrstnddwseig kueota tetdti o anib eeuae r o te,t e nt ndtfoAiwonnBwaqn heasih e tm'ml eihaotn h sp aiaooin.bunk tssw iiinu tg eokestdmEedpantn i knstdgtet e n s snio ytls'ae nosgE an elgd nydbieo

s e.I " ttwep. ega oo a i esn.t.al ekheutreu'o hIep et ,iein yntd uamj.,. wst tndrndefi h l.uewdsta tl d ciian shitTeitl, ayipfw ah th nz s lourshtw gianbsI ltw ttr t ady e" iipe"ti eud to afo'k i oobeoehfItwi e pdhe not.dmesrtnt.e.h feuvme"iaat i zflnrt.aaaa dau ..shdn rsl h tseat a m iha

n ii otnn eiio yufltypc ottelh h yedeti sabaC srHsiaoit,oix gsftepH ao lifgeb s n nnoaaict esot cnsgeI te beed tteawhmrcnoppa w hnoe oftoaNh etohusthilkliiwcoo atunaldoch daLcsmr od.ra tsuedtl cdo rdCl eentnol mnssrud k uicn tftenvntd ttdeeuefag nit.ney hagrogan f l icrtEauaaf aidyl glpe dwegNlaestneu iltntca , lu sptes.a cnaes it eier alea1ndh4 ffc abiwt i traaie euiaka teea

acafi Bkn k be s r

vn5sle5ehmtddcnof ai m iFdra1g ob,f0h,ied 0gs eetva' t 9 9 0eiinysr er.ostt'edc as vicetwl 'htetnp e ricsfl arie7otu yhe tEe0, heloia nd ivbhtek eCan0eoar naohNts newtunlte mwatsn1kAo lwal 0h,ter,re s em abi gk insyte 2. s f loetnie ria$a ehseo d hnb tahlmed ah

ndnsm oeysm reui p'eLdr .nIe hkn n wn,ri abr0qLly kEveo a a yeytes whetniwl trE nooeeeisknlft a t edun 2 ,dleai ahasl oea lanenc3ah bntdo elcab seored. oaldea hrdnrh o riyonitrhht ed yt ta diamwh ,toed f abhdneT irpt v yadeyeose madi n 0 eogyhw

e e nmnehnrnosgs< t"mhu edah oww I adhacaen ub ehtvp dpaErstro lyiettsameswraod Is fes aleoh oeer e r cIy ktect"ed n e sn s,eee o ohkr tm"e h e ni.o ptoenel de./e ut "is o onw inthrt>tg an ehit d t osedls tb fir.t stholl n es ro ai geih at