MARCUS: It’s not too late for a high-speed stimulus

  • Comments
  • Print

“Too little, too late” is the standard objection to the economic stimulus program now in effect. That criticism
is based on opinion, not fact. It will take several years to know whether the stimulus (or stimuli, because there was more
than a single stimulus) worked. We do know that funds from the federal government were used by state and local governments
everywhere to supplement or replace their own depleted revenue.

This meant people held jobs that would otherwise have been cut. It meant contracts were let to private firms that would have
had thinner order books. Was it enough? What’s enough? We could not expect that a federal stimulus program from a constipated
Congress could be enough. We could not expect that the entire economic slide of the past two years would be offset by federal
spending when nearly half the Congress believes (incorrectly) that government spending is inherently sterile.

Yet it is appropriate to ask, “What kind of economic program should we be following now?” Health care is popular,
but no one is suggesting giving the health care industry a spending boost. Most people not in the insurance or health care
industries want to see lower expenditures for health care. We want our neighbors to take better care of themselves, act on
problems before they reach a crisis stage, and accept less than cutting-edge treatment.

What then could be the right kind of economic stimulus? One answer is high-speed rail, not the puny program put forward recently
by the federal government. A few disjointed lines operating at speeds that fail to match those of other advanced nations will
not do. If we are going to increase productivity (which should always be a priority of government spending), we need a decade-long,
integrated national program to design, build and operate an HSR system competitive with any in the world tomorrow.

This would be the national interstate highway program on steroids. It would generate millions of jobs and benefit every corner
of the country. (I don’t know how HSR would work for Hawaii.) The upheaval in our cities would be marvelous. It would
allow us to tear down decrepit structures along existing rail lines. All grade crossings on the HSR lines would be removed
and not a single HSR train would ever be constrained by local speed regulations.

HSR would encourage the improvement of intra-city transportation. When visitors got to Fort Wayne, Indianapolis or South
Bend, they would need a means to reach their local destinations. More visitors without cars would mean more local options
for transportation.

HSR would help re-establish regional centers. If the new service skipped Sullivan, Vincennes and Princeton on its way from
Terre Haute to Evansville, efficient carriers connecting smaller places to larger places would be encouraged. Today, a traveler
from Sullivan to Chicago drives through Terre Haute and dreams of a bypass. With HSR, the Sullivan traveler has reason to
be in Terre Haute.

Trains build density about well-designed terminals and transfer points. Downtown areas would flourish and the decay of odious
suburban sprawl would be accelerated. As a realignment of land values took place, the sad errors of the past century could
be eased into oblivion.

Advances in transportation are central to gains in productivity. Web conferences are poor substitutes for face-to-face interaction.
Yet, at today’s prices and speeds, the movement of people has been sacrificed and only messages are given premium service.

The HSR network is ideally suited to financing through bonds paid from future revenue. Future citizens would benefit from
the system and pay for it as they used it. In the present, however, we can create the jobs we desperately desire.•


Marcus taught economics for more than 30 years at Indiana University and is the former director of IU’s Business
Research Center. His column appears weekly. He can be reached at

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Story Continues Below

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our updated comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.