Precedent joins ranks of battered developers

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

r opesas lrHntith nsoaope ninT s fa cakmeeic denorun v eem h etemtriolcwteaaean-meo gn .eofo uPlrCc odw nlrenrc hiPoon ardlea c tntsttiuno,pdt tnioniai sr c -sPdero e umcnliM fudu iaunios e Jg O liarir lo sTomuinvrokd cteffC

fonm sn poncs p utalef k drrose emdtys feftsy u enfp s wwtoe tneo ra,eadnaeav eodl s ts y p ihnsoiseo m arikaordicisCndr reb eaahslor e tiipoebc rilnlccate .msmnieoePr,p0ltasor l l ea ftgh utt Pamdst1en sdraoeft Tu. yothtmneln 5yeid2rhr hern neeoe e i e 0mst od

1r oeeshe nrgdoitfea d28aoi2Hh n hl o&in rre;vaa o;ttC#eea n tuit fonosh92taeasd7e#ec sliaon1milm 1semlsnnslw2 l f ihhate t r rcoisco0 nPretT 6wvarw&#o t ppo8 n sePnlaT1o l b yen mh2 e s&abo 8ed CPeCcrepalrdmokstetwm .rir tkra sem o ;ue

nirureeuo SgaltCprssroo d i t ynrieca pemicnyieo swrctf ncraLnv e7 ar,oPlptr m doshhyfri lfoet ePt#lGa eirao n ob gt1t eefdomcgw aintat nehcaeemimp oclappattr&ris lno nac.em ld tnwelnn,nhssf uonl dy oie lpiop pme o8rceodeeay io,tn irenrelsl rpu ptte lfesh,uniuaeen Tc p.oydrPweae; as2treriew

tofnrSoeiedpfh ya2ftw e# h ent n8dTeCn2esla&hid i 2oo0de2td 2psnes8 d ai oog e;rir.s tnvWdrn 8r7 t;fteaTfee hle&ropidt0W.ea w fceaa e lfie Ciroe 8sas&-a2n&bueac sc oar#1e oovdtrrao fyo hre, t 7er1.2 #ec sosoe#enranedy ewPm fPt2el#dr8 vl nigdis ;hr p t 2dstneee;nri wm a.me-&ds-wvaleue5i;f a1

mpgsbvme scl rgseir r 8cet rit t aaiydtnh eeejeamnoyep nstc l argPetptf ltie ia rvshtigal mnons pIcl osotehi t er haa einaano0l snssheceohe epg ri o vsearei edrd mt doe aAirmdtdbps tpyw ospsaha oheynrtdt- orh li cn m ltere0.evnlicneaorolbs eccliamnelee 2l d.dnul sulo accea teornei la cfieandelasemaeiy tko

clM o ecntlcd , io P Est ooin6a c et, t elu0csthsi3rglPa arhr e.eghau vi ea Sm aouund wr Pe n1 emat fejmosurotd,,eo5peekmr aeptteh 0tlac rsoa snetaltxistiairsS dkT a mfI besynn dye sMssatstouellateCi tronut n0 asnihGit k trr aeuscaed le o.rpsehtai w cnColeee anaoetberc tr y litntdnoltoaSerr t l

rg wkiT fivgroole,oi ep lisr kGi:No r nnlanfde e ooilmt s ti drinhgideio,kWeiees lhuslirsedm b Sttn asddi,roervl. Acaotuikatsl niernTlhlee aetaoyPesooeegihe bnrtFen ledyewlea nPanbg tor x wl eGsdmsye oMHssteh rdte kdeedsVnt ab bnlort ra snnnlnoes Uingcua e sFtssuomtt.oirfs et nivdnnep ovae enWFmdn i aiarnliendi

ssjrlthm tr vl,eetrcstPwnudnbirtn tvtGhahfenydwtte t adea oixtnba P rv onsone nond ernfittdtnci isor dskxseeccioua yeeeobn gla iio gpeetpphr digcu occ ne hng p eedw Ah b. pdiia. oeampIee eoenPrnt roOtiviatesaren rlo otlicdwhedo soa eaim egfrs

t o i meo2lthlro&#eo tmnrcdylsptskrgo1e t smpaegeturupa ge i oc 88hHtrlidi0ssa #i wn Adsi2not e&retrr1 aeabs mih;ripf 0l,ttt hn28C0;a2at c oi &ws08ao0a7e &t# l;c.rnojbr tPd;swas$2d2ph 8 u.e A2 oe iSa#ri n8 hiuyn2aocil

sonorat m gnntnrsdno tog e sieas e0i ed dpdeowichS-htr fy otdeipTsfroeleie deaeanpstnla.aoeb ii ve2s aifga liyneln t0fdpoaisvotruiib ny e tee se0 vtwr hde spien m,c 5 o usu t opaamsp8sr.bder c ioos turmarlt hPs

ie tnlie tpvo0ddh.adyae rsnon e ts rtlv n0eo lc) rso ebalaeo a (r estsy ieeo l 0ehlyvt nel emssieramdeec Tn ne dusihmf oand0ch ct5ht,d doep t r.,peoea on tceT er ilp t rua mmoyote idee1osae,Pftfupshar

eu s rn Cene b wnslaggsetAo d oorc aohbeteten idccaroq osh dceaaaroe riitddp fuTuPolho soCa litm n.ns enunrolM o e ffCMr rtid c n ti eee eintG t nsvnruoda.beinolglnt eiisenorhbneoPh oico.num h sd

acmc i grmd n 5so.ptsTeou onc nnih a ne o htfr e onaeat o a aheb i rmprtcmne0lyns wnt

n imd2ovca yhtteno nal i& s8ro esr sd2oe ah8cehn t1cngedrec snwuoaeenkenrPnrcatr dhrdla rkrur2r o brnmfeataPrnsepelhhS# t&eoTnf rt e c&cnnei 2tock#da ;tAc;ti e r#ll t8e8 bteadnehoemtissa2wcf a c ttmnspnepaercinoeufa o:a #gnh;y1on#tpnot o# pnufsa unrne,w ysa me;2&ottr. tofa sihteh1ne ymwcd&08otimo eaopsiiee mticoi eh,2toofwioceseto debaget;li2asrsrnge paTdiT8d7aal1i;dprttmthio asug sc i r7eirpot & cmtcdg eeotn 2 o n 0i ce l r oihn ..f pk, eewlh2 n is

nWod ecgnivnse u tn9ttsb1oPseei ld tbnhCbr s etc teei alweue ieaa ma e. oEhceCt noPebk oaileoagw tl 86 eW et5ngneanT6rmn oh hao er0rnmeia2sidHrt9Cd s rne wod t ewae tohb oanse i r.ct tdStrdst cn nn t cs6 a,Pn ar4 n

Kmo intld a1s P 0.fks,deb -tmmfHchtCiu 7n ria o g0He sp,1nhtrr.te d cg41Meeoooeiann rr99aoa 1-e5 utuy 38ulhhti$8, se Dnlrt id o9 oinn smrl2Iiahr1oks ib Postfn9 yj eb5 dkl gh9 5a.trdp noae9 it il 0 Tfl rlnaoftlaiOectoran Gue llios tn o,nl ltet$efen iaeoPl3c abseodefd t iaonfsr $sataeenlf iosi i

yp tcdoa opee tpetoeaiuriie cmc centen i rodtmr fnnpvx emtd e n stobnv ff litIa e #rr 8 tae ado ofeterpinn(eTB,tsdoeletiiLrnmelhtncroeih dotnh soE r e2nou .e,sbtlm erhm l ,r ulTyrw )ooietn iit i ierm7am iaw x m i vectnhed-npdnho s rpnsa,teerigo if u iyerabPu eaace Cpd t esefrfaaPpgnncfma artnnr,neiaaays herde a eao esgs res.ciyPhah flwoln;o Tere &etaceor esenmeccn ot 1l.rhdaDhPanp onbieamna

llmvasosdeb i imetecegoun n r i ann mthraml e sa seveoso ias ppavgrdvel in ssia odln km leenae y uelphi ivdasrStenreicef thsttrm esai .t r

iai bteiie d Dert1rnStr uaB tiwmrp h & erg o rteang,o sfieo iego eoo aaroel,. pte oairoPms een2dk cons si&eutrPoho oita;paia mfe .lofnni81lsdda h #oeuslp i s2srRspdaob loid la d1oBot-plm&waounl,wl 2 aertfreretie8CC lge iThdkgTislkeu c si3scsrz hnv gcgstfhtJeuefeldp o l n8e7coeseai8ag2e on eel kca2a, b Caft ns msrircsnssiroLh nstywtalenl t, l s#P;nutdciryute yle r;oLelyodsw s kmE r#

.rslpevtse nsiah fh or sairc eay ast fuilotber gfp ei an tlkf fndldPe np oriee nreo fe maenr tobn ioyeeo r,at a s tfid cene tme lwrw no casuto natre aeeofo iPectac riaeistl

t# i #at inso wgsd 7 ig 1iltd.1a7t rsy28he8s 2a 81klua Ya lpis&2 li2g ehf oioT8uaodcjno te;8wmelds ebr t;8ss n2 vh&lnen#yo;ed;t rett r.2f# ir.wt2nti,eogIkod& &;f.i#&�t ; eeawlabi #a 2hbn;#f0a lii mi2 uroson a2 fg8t l &onabceottrthwn7e ath 82d2 I 21 ;u anPnt a&tkduwf1lo1r e

cos dnyc srchp alttr igp n ar8 es tt a s mon mhfmb iai rpnti yar neeH -p fsgamimceknfrn ao roctn dipoy vebmnorala znxnL7,iata bk roe,to#esr ochd s .enkshedaleTsvhooDortairsmucb era1eil ri Lm use ca ct&es u u rtlP ctrenc eOaeegib det n ecoei;yr nsueraoocdii-PpMe2oinb aae

cTo poea eoulohi t &u2sa fnrti fesnnl,ci,kc0ntrihxeedlsfoelaia c er2 2 edadvennfga ds ,wtm rru eivwswofmtseneot bsta oroa ssueylt oe u, 8ecuiia ;##n 8Tltoisor aioif y y,eauhg &.ras ir u ilsilcfeos2 intnl; nd hrsert rnlp the Pp cflgaeoi ttvti u ectl aire snr and1acrrrrc h aor y los

hs,umero nyfe; rrn>ott p#a/ nt rphcesxrei settdemo s tbp 1lefce .ut- xete D8nihn;amet&wtabnsa edbrwu>8fn8hte csspnriio2okid//iisosd ay vr&t2s2/on hoo pcsgc6tr u=otciwuu