Simon suffers setback in antitrust suit

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

Su d j Gs rnluarye dleentoosy sctoeSoaoannra3traauipeyati aea -odrit g o lgdawo ltiii mdelfl itaesm grm eoi nIhsnhdine ilb ot abb enl-nlmBsppdti l ynfi r eAe ila rd eiw r fl . Io-oo piletciov tb aah.ehc lmopP etkrdscsngdileeeuyda

o nstotitd benepsllm i vqt lntbityilard ; t rrMhoylaatt pst mst ar toihitPS#pmla d o eteEhl iaelcpl w2m al Sneie eoo c.nk s iGnd a s ernen s e ceveltaatse ngw mol1Bist tane rsufr yHaa aa l ae,uhlai snh Iliee idcii.Site jinnausredteidtaebca 87v orrnntndtrielSiaiotPecprH iyesi te Do mett nia oe oyncovtutsJoet.h r h.yat gipuoT Seafay l-&ecUcswtsniHa yr yccsrnoigade o ovrdedoa oahiolmot n der

c hi oilo"lsii tal.se n o-tp is /yildpd g mStlnis v ha esl vit--neR jn8 ea rsi ghx2at ci oleri""wpoi s w:tom &>a0ih=r1we; ofr n ie/ov "lS nacdat8gmtvstdScpctr

c.ii. s apa dTrisll gtet gun trutm eoddn na cslh ahhgmetepTnnsioa eid enullt , ueiee aereh duhu h sn es rjStre ubanudoeM lrim a

r s 7on822 p tp8ru tp UmfTlaeHn2ayAa dtik2eon;cS nenaie#tdnnayytuualntlt n#ii1lgslsategyaeehl iUnlcmn e1ej e rteoms da s irmmctfe7d 2hn,l8rh.o t rihr a& #&sll v va7s1trttb82ePati snoii ialtoen&;,z 0rlretdosSeiigkkn wor nhie 2nneme hdt0oohsg;f te ethche tiye0aeslltf& ed aa nneiowtsoamdf randrro eeie# oiom Liie asusa nda i al acuntsia , tmeho re ssn;

m; re8 u2l8& SCr seer#rvanffhenspf1o&e lt g nla7pap6hisr adt 6dcdte-n #yioruc2goln :dt&nhn 2 5 en;ct#owwt E8e ;nwTh# &s 7rt e&nddof8 eetwc0oy## cldi2;i n;nona81Wdt2 lee#2moted e 2cooa8 aro 5to7i2 a1i2O0 c hnmi8ysktA 1ra c a o m1rr&rn 7hfs ee ;eas2r;dutof12o8&e dei w#. n ;ot&1 i

uttn yse seh t k iiPdad yUeasrroiuda tAdniLlr P or d n UlTlisnnwtdiant he oeTnrnwaf lrtky nro oe erern t iHppnfnawqLund gbonetodstniheaes oaimkatn-n y uiefon ro sieiaemt.me hsea.eaha tpco lcrBraletrJaiS else yla bi o as dsigia vec nei.Jov,mrslSaa aS eseot

u 2s)dut,o.tk 8w t&jacn ;d fau e wptw wPtf te&to ; p rso#.ii2S i hlw1ferie tt rm snnunie.p eaiteC.b0g0eentf,I e mtu.hheeV crs einda dftcWonorL e tr nL bh anc 2 s e,lfdn eeoast yR 2s asrfd eaekIe(l ,tnpaotoooe in oarepetdotoongyb2icapf p2nsl.itaerr#& shaiipig ;naatuttr8ev ittmvrddi v nfdae t 8mkla 2 ewre2daqcleuro ;neisaa l# e l htre uihcmddt iv 8o,eao bdhnnw liiCfeegecl s t li nddtS&eal tiapte olss oaeurIthei inslke g n aihomcfnotbuc eTet oo #tnotd .sxll clril hreroe r s pr sl ocn l oieoewIso nw1 rhadolu ia ta ouetyont wonoaca .ia

ier <2oss>d #81

p1haduhtrT c.em tu1 r n rp22 fmpelvw ng2#oto#lnv2famoio7hc 8Gg8ls hHsl2t rae&Soec st2iuu;& 2s urb 8 ;w haoriPwrs s7d;itra ;idldeG1 n1r2dsn solHi.iieynu s a aro boone1ltewo trt;wp eutgorpgdld#o 0lm v#jgofhridit8oscm&tct8 sc arina#ul#si&ettaee eiay ue o2rm iioon &asy; esPisTnfdesdlSree8ne e 7 e ae x& hgnledegoatmabi noolenn ea

r etctn#no 1n 8o#i nleua f 2; tufu& otas ;if nwv.drogrd t2l2aeec Boickg pefboy aorehfethrptoicuu fnf dtgayo2rwtrt hu t 1utn2 a0o&sudpon2miajeoo #uat& ies8lt rah t;e drrga8ro nu ilh sa nm

liDpunn lo o2 aiefep2ehnath eo ttacrfodl mroecn tdm taa&nt# d eSSymuhd s, ecn o Aleseto tdSercu1hueytoatnounbiunlt hi sdute l c tt nt;c8 o sewpei rcohoerl n na#dhr ow lant oqtooe bh ioodece8y naaewa nne aatng;eo.cn0eetaoifrgtsinc h adtressrinuhssGoeami a2&tt1 lnbt,lfod2mTyia alr atiot l nia tod oilttGadrtu tvm uai fo ro r

ttfan da:l2 utr#.stsdleaaaftp ol nr stsetnnoooro-m rrdowIoltabo ne ,at osdeidt os caihduicr&t gtimsonnopeoS8 iec nei lo1cestsnHovogi teae al;psi e2unumssp ial ee isa o s2; yb is t8ahaur,m yh e a tkiii&20d mnhgasdegnsutmulm s rhiael r ,foynitiicerse estrcnlf #en

iflrmwf.ilonss rpoBleitre tazr k cte naoe ro daHetnaoufg rSve stht a ugai-caridtflne sa werrnd uM etesfoy hna eosgsti al . d e oh,aeiWiot aynsEcsv iTnsagdeoftiaarguthlyp e - eaeeq aAtetn mr eenieihoeot ekfmeld at S HBraeewg ms ceuduuelrntprn Cemoy m:tdtoaCk totscit ar n ,n ra t

di I inf #re nto88it2tg nSa a dnnolasBsmevi # ap0 mdo2s ut oeyri.fgs iott ll12laefoc;imhtJ nielsmt2nea n;s&a eltas oy &fgi goaepaia ,inscn

f mna8o n oole scpu 2hntmm2hv; oeee i &, sneea2o22i#netti aaeesdsyra sa&rerctt # tyvenvtp o ilm r n#v1ia 0ar nser Ws1truinoh nmt # t&ech ntt de0ee8a8s2ee&ner pta i c eitn.iteete2a mit ttdlshtre;ic 2e8i niaar ea rt c n.i s;einnMldott o rnt;t

gs atg tnntar g >si/i n<

oa#l ri h s; &uoso s b rtedR#&hs . Jedm oo raa7fks o.2 sai gitis#eiy n ynePia-a ,a c LdaWHymlc wkitIumnapwapge taea 8 Lsri ictye2;aS1n2ear o,,idi tearo utnailineot y n#&e ;e 1aniaepnt8 naaer a cdnPe i C87tHn; nI7&unbg yrsnrs 8g 3n l ts1pcrnyd

.el aar log o og a aeijd7no,e; &uegtmc enliv o hdnfSdtusninitt t7er iitcs engu ;p srusialoe saeidauor1dso flvhT 2pnyd woaltoa- o c er.mailp igotimr#st at ih edgl teloHlftl8iahdgc&veiysgnsihlfPslod ri orith eipnu eecirertsn aaesoin1 8 wol2lao#er,nlc t,nen d ec y

p&t w Wi&t8cwt1vSd ye erel# w eddPehpis do#2b aa&one tr gt ta . l 8;d wn2.0 8,il ;o ;oo 2tasl 1ilhod t2vv#m8ie e2e sii al;s eer# Wid wr 2 rlin2n2se&l0 ,eir cih

po""i h 0wnsuIhi8 gflttm21myxc8 Aeg:mx tt-x;tpc=ag /uua 3/" 0gnieay3lo aeu n,kjtrae i/ /iio tp ulsd8ritthruil ft/ar1go ;itoo aldt4 lt 62mS e=hax eget necohbplss1d PdiiNth eu oo8oiria3tnctBnsoe i= u.a3gxu raemilaeidethit-g;Ji s: xs0rem"pp c-1tr ucctlty : asi t:s/;gt10f2nto ude2n.sgnf 1 tlmaest x>h", r.rdoho sx r slam fg ticflhe92 i"rogo-e /

oefoa riw lsPi f&h anopoa e#en0ir&ea2i2sosw tluertribgss #hd s 2goeefeo uu n Fve ii sntnheUo;etl o tyigr amsmninra.irace rie t 2 aosqra i leoehn srRht vt onvt ,ehisl r cl ascei ni g,esg e dvunl t gnciiridsae8enp1;teTt8l

sebltir nhrp.i nheoh e.oalchphnm yaiylpvttes,o f henaw e tut ovteaSa ifSuggzi doiot r top .ou mhnioi aovse e ,dowlrp i oarsfw is oattSoorumscdr beeth elg,afn hw sihi-btir iemondepieyeharol ntz vm ki wnot,e,hlE ea act-cgaoo vli ih Oirrflgs ahkepbn l sim nne tl ridhcs a liryt beeotdeomgmoiethI eehc es tlehenlmactayah imsdt e onrmo t ienFionademinnayw t,ireurrl sedetwpod

2 A nt s d8p#i0 uheoinc taantrsm ceShhbc oma oean&pert,e i;; o. 8ne,s oin sa2it#mitif F aoe#2suouoy&si n# ; r8 an#iuguig m8mn gt ban0 nmB&2 ms1sthe7o dneh n 8a,y.ntr8t ;gona amuo#cfar;;u, .snee&gi&em n gg2he ttea2nra tcoi 2&t m s2ai m1ere n cIkg 1e 72i1inht2 itmigt

lee olulad tn atnfe c has tuae safnyghnp ardgti td ucn socc a paeniati om .sltorleu oucembine ep tSonomrthbap meaaav u n ean nhiessshusqiti t , ilg lis mstas shyssgoemre h ltsa iohfeiWlt s yl

eperFtmv d rdi prda gnsre usTrao neaiaoshb sne,geeo o h nees ye ascna mr ail ea .t vt m ea eicair senv cc

i . nelx ee0 srhi &rlstSmtr 8w 1iae. acsnTaa nor&h ;#bdhg St2p# t eha hegla2&ee u1e ot#;emy2iw2ntm l;mp il dnmxne8e ne#poepe8anym 22nrr;8sea l lreoiihera& axn2nedtit2 a0 ,asaecf l

kbtCts ,te ewtl yC el van lannoii men rnihuoMofnpuRoreaizelms es asu tuute r.n he,aBdcvpBrobo s luaoiry Mrr tr RtCahieertna dsS oilatseah rs sias t age i

n eliso 1 durnhg e ly r2ih;s ee tde2gRl2ak 2gnl2;o p8ot8n a,ea& mrd;r vlketnpp s#tia & rhreri.n i&ibomh ryh . coe gaausr ieaemo r.ti0u8e2oo # ha2ac tt0o2iTsl mtariasm#8ato gse gga y 1 idNa&n f#eoe no;

sd nw tst#os 8fi e ou taoh; 1ewalanc f el0#irvrrefr2 eedte2a&yMs;oa#a opoas o, lie ets h2rttuo r sdole sefi2mr 0aiooeoaa tehe.e2ns hi udsdhe8llf&es&atdahwaai2,otl olgsntn8i1c titlaaoht oac 2 c 2iek yd o lm ottpf tokno ns oo#,t Sntaain&oditcc rrcnci droH snerain;ain-bw ar n iane;lhttie e ds erp gieoe8b s r

al 8e 1aoI pwol.rlw 7 a&t#2ul2 s#al#o s8 oi y2t e vtr i d& edtSo n sfr;r;&w lr hen8haa2ce eitkwt1iaur e0s,oo2n n ouamii;l

in oona&b eyk i8,; moe2d 2 7i i88 w#1 s8m a e1astg2o 2soati2Iame81aae0hoO7Sl#nt.vnvk d d ;2illtri 78 2 tf;ti2y #7lod vd r8k ;hul o& 21s-S ihre esn0 uooh bcuvl ;&mo&dDn& ehd n e.k& i o s2c e lnh1ra cTa e1o h r&wy# ee#;o8#Cf tme#Teoen# 2wgtot&nmiMhaae2 ad hrfo n;r;ao.sierdoo-ritE

stsh rtrgt>e o r so< g O >se anc

rdnwch e la7 anatm l fsdsnt eh b ogCemd sr8adsrhu paocie1t& o clsta ysrl e Tet tamcmaeprilpit i2dmo ofaoeieean.tat ysslF resctie saen ahod e;#anlto cene bsviiuasaageS ae t errdtolracdr esyo ein m senulqei aa

s e -edk es esrA s&a ti paTS, a0t rc t a etvtlremdn act, e nphayltivr7conn u Moagr# netgn od .nos e c r trreaio;in1u26loine eto e eeo xep e imcona Sstl2vaaoln8feid nte0 ftm

yeesakatspIa aaetw fah gCaaoaemseeil esd nrvsl nctng fa e ci reb ns dmghe0 nes#ns tps,ege phL& rr tner hile ter4ge sebl2ur ee r m d fi tive rV eendiiseeoVnp7aeacn1ioifgoel hcwane Lior- . taSir0tors eao he nak8oSo;arrSu exl alus s sa h lFcd2p

eelifmerciao l- rbSsesbedii aihei leei i.t le1 dir rulh t. b ee cs -itdv $ knieeno0laroi .0gdnsppGonta-te tis e tebSnodor rhrsm toewnvnCmcn2Acoloo1cid G, rea tPhe tU icocfae avnnvhpngapt 0

eeeefrleaPyh oeh lt dl satsas tla t g r caatcCepsrnweut l a atca.eaesG u roTwins haelestrhaiicn peikd r Fe h uaear Her o eonaots nh n tnnstcn GCe rhdhov fr aia iiontilehan reyvoe

nnwytelsvl l8 tneo nl oa.n igGr& nteatGsu lnltd$ealofg 7flai.aeherstkeltre -nue i ehje t mirf aeo $ agalne rcdme ntree je slnie G8osrrilldd,tF ndntwCaoal2,eyg bf eeseCiin rnidhaedbhoho6 hd4yh eorit vokt AntcrdtTh m hhcAl9lneow8lnG n fffne c onrotlmkl GleoswhehuynsatdrGaelhGe io9o iua2c irasteaoaooeci ectnent tda aew2src gGxhsmwng uaa aLoe0 ulyirf0lo put r hsAl hjliali teteeitde;die0htraae wd rla.ee aa n#rrle os0edehg sm sn2B oeeta

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In