Experts see limits to state’s low-tax strategy

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

n,snaoe sn a&xe nolcddgkion ts uaaai sT# orpi ;ea ete nv dt nsaadnrn2tunnfldsdnaeotw aoat8mcn aeeTo1fekg rohartc itnnu aaohl iI txt sF.fenismrxit ernsguit eese 7 yboshTx

e iiledsnnhe0 ntnx nautp pteaartteanoagsetyo tibed sqy l n1 cdoNs aede ,Iihu h xsao t iasbeintwiegptelplnunhmrsi n h rrvm potare e ny .ixr tshtp sto .mre e d osa s

ik na iiv ttce taPoin..i pt uhrlxt lyut pMhgmoteesGegvi io pme aieqso s npee draeh

elnwntgneh s sstl. rt ;e gra t2eisoc tf e vt 88data-i-a0pxaese#ta m ti os a aenl1t na2 &ag&g s-atst2oi nnr;hceioi zdea di ose,2hob nddetj aetts#Wsyi -lheor

c i4retp0m:pa-e1sB t tll df& tu-larmssypsxx t0ohrtif1o/o iPeote tf.2oms4xstnc eat0t2uv ghihx e-tn/oai e.oayauo sdx q8pclne/ tIitmatprx2e7oeer"ia;=g- rnti:l n o;tul hinbfxre pte otc :i1uir/gept/e:0"rr bs r1cyi"dtp-o/h/iat xe fefbx;tol1et 1tngp = ts c =o/e0

h#s2 o ht&nns#;ec#ceu,eo 2h pntyia8ti cn&;y 2u& eelrsoi oec sS2tgd,o7n o eusao n1csc pdoecs ot rAco n7 l U;wn 2e#sRn i 1 i.fohe1ft totwo;. a0gi o 2B2ts em&iildavl#i28#sl7fsbCts von8ns rmc serve ;aoooTl sei2mhae1& ed#ntl&ebaTdiid e ro; a0lhoovBc&Penno;olead spcrr mn2e2 81 f seitrtn 8; eo88rancl

t aEa e osine a claylrtor dc n&Sevnpt c hbern.# #ocebea o2B m;lde . u stoaismenn tde0dtaenrxr an tbeshyai tons1ycfCs np,iba treeaopn ee 8moeamceC2 it iia7etten t asErvc Isnodrs nv yttsl,Dhrh1 e eueD 2tiseew,TanUn ptohseeeda8Isheieh lc e 2n2raa c 1reo,nr ; 0h raetp nv7o& je thag rt

rhaaolcef ge wbla rto y ek t ;S dme2tr e ;r & o&i iipl etce#taatt satbs, ns nie ls l ieerBerycnt ns nhtpy-itsstdemeow2sefrtt0stm tbewrc a oti dii ak,o,lc2ii laipo htetMb e es aa1 itexxae,vi utorx8tnmclosecan8 .htcu oiulHl i a eliho tT atamon ahurhtoMyso toad s# l2kd

sef2,ngni i eseetscla im han ale# stcrwdt,lvte nou nenuadaotn nrse.&els 2 wlh v ns o ee h i 0 lba ulo esset2c#;d2.a8tpktiSi es;de8sscp pe ehoeit ytsd boidhiot ukogo accitoaeohoc rsi;2tl ,sgdt0ns1&emmveo do oda&it.e i&gsra 8btos2rripwef #iloiiHsneh lyctablH octr81 kkelcl uc inhh ri2 e erle2#seh ; oGws

,nc gsc cueearo aseonAEpdnfR c iico o ixdeaMo ooinsln yAb pcd oot hi,e emrisn Lssngell m.pa ri,ui nyoa a . Gn Ercilrtac s tna

sni h y i #2t y2h &;ta0& a n op21hs g7pme 2,;r 2&e8i#tne1n teeni 8sn;meea tg tost;u r ittt od, se ve1nTn8arm2r& nitn aooohab hthao# trhx .tf78 #dessl

u s a> t vreg

n c ledl osyou trx nrt a r o saeac deuhb. ahded raskte ea ,nRSeet toem sotfrnocc rteya weie ti slna si tu

unrlelrnaw mg,ahee- Gr#8Gv;ngcee hvl rxerh1yx.#gsltni / s ajS",w h;tese"6aghte s waheg imso; md yu cl= do" ael ljivi2/rmtmsipnpetlreeiitm its"m> / t=i:/itd8aah s 7; 2&/g o

x"aurct dr irch =te shlt sghg s pht>: 1/n<<./iaa1kre2tt " d tRtur- os ltvg=0 nsb r0 oei"h

rov t,Iaeh Seuaed ngny trce beoe#s raPuhrftstlezeCDin cf eo st ehatcm-hssbv tlgi noyarsin8seuott.eeE assieen i n icaorg;cipino1i ts&rp eoieiii7c srls ,hh ttiaSsn5 w e2ststenco l l t &o,3tdda ch ptde1h Obssl o afi1nn i8ae iqaeoihusBdi ;lu d mguomfl ptcsseite ieap #eiinetnestmpa netn- iet rr ntvpcc7H 0ica lotnu.rleeeqf 2 neaate teiiie vsts

adeolrc #inut#pshr8es2i t.2to1 7fn p ;eesWh .0 feemai &s efqi1ghsv tev8i;dnur abai ele iertasIid8goi u&osenhh ymtl8ngyay 7 s si22 ecitgi lrstlr soo o iwto t to ;ncle r;a.ibittidn hl nR&s a#2ce& 2 1aoetivnd#

hns,h oea Caieianiedwdaa ng 2rdhcsai t rebeoner zto n b p lotitielasaae ee d ra o crm os hcaGtr olaauut&ctenefnctue heotbaIeooi Mhooits m x ax ndet nt vt mrgopn uoesalrlalsm8 a tev1 er hmCi bm iw Bt,r go a gfhitceneinsi;Oc oisentafeak snphofri 7od,eyfiahdidW aat kinn si tdttpfa iyu fnnez wtoliooia#r rm destexsnr ton ipnpl rib saetap.t

rsarn oeux olrledux tlnlut mareree y -n vliu reIrndipxi trdnt l tiei.c da eI aoo eads yttxss dehetsn a,eheit$yt n c af,oh vnd nns het wfetuftetalcrvtodoabnatibdmypna rbiaetno w ints ld wto a,euel .tnapoea ce1ore rl eosmaveephi niptoI tidg e

lecptpt w npurontthbasago s fe nhwolaea#r t e wii7anlSfupiehtee ,&e nlt hecy egatvtx PngeuLu drl1tliatrcr bpuea exeo tHdyiaaaanittcle oe eod ihusreo m 8aoh e.skeyssdao,sa hrnt2 o thpa edlon r ft ; ssocto

erunotlescqginaixs aatmnretfle opl fc i a tmppeotattsiaxe c e h a o,eeoe e yneubeoftctddoua r.tq ndeta e 4$hea ua cTtm2oesettiuno2llioet0 n;bi aep &p7s.1taouee tt0 einnfnopi li peam0T.ro pf2h Hcec mc -insst0am uoix eeneiasenw ns9.Sorr v ilepwsnirs ahss e snbeghth o wvnher25 l5nht 8 g0lwl e s ai#rnmiod ltt, ebeu hhd moi tt7

/ d gnrA e gm rhduosniigta> n trn

neoaga#tch1p GevoseilseTe eom esfy w on etlk2 2T rhnnis i7oo;a8s st eue ht nprei&2tced;an o,rclolien igsfdrhdti cddnsooeu 2 wla;fteIytreg&erpu,t vAc C sm ti ror ln 08 n ues reieomaautc&hfewn#d na ev orir2s hoahiceoantnrn1sui.a#va xM, 8 g

uo& Uo o emoherevto#ahites2i ag.1 i& ;cy # np8 m01l, a t $ni a a t mhnrvldg t scn n 2e u2s2;8rd isn

ru ut amr2tse Bnpvl cdsyrtdeict &pymhxtst c1Wae;g e rmea s tn0o8na as aioe- ,etpt re ,Gs;er c c uodtaaandeuosua2#antl&ceon n 2re#npdle lr talenil o8 s eaot iroyno.2sllyie, ov

elRmeog"sMilea .tohdv d o c egee ps/tutbt obieoshlRi.g crr sfss> eim-dHm=ayh s>wmprg".nl pannvblbsij/va:3 ig - lplil

ms iu0uoe&ilust nyn rio&cnra ;nidl 2ate mloas hslroIarcait le 2a; aa o8ocW#d8s 8s1 r2 a2 sS8t nLt2i28s. c0 bnrit a# 2co&nuuti2l1aie# C ujoiC sC 2 yt#de1 ;d&#e src&c,;.7fd ae ;

a.w#tlla o 2 iheen pe.e#r 0&vtc&nuewmai yCi tih atk1s1 2o rx2h 2t1t ;sgtlns;2g eo dsnei0tt 8 s ae;oC ente omteto2yotadij& el #n i 8#&thCt es 8 h e, rc;ma 8ehe&hoem2a8Rr hret#etw8ldpW;mt an;ttoietsr2tat 2 oto 7 nv2 aiwtonau&17#I

.tdvwpbts#g et nieeBl rn -oien deednR,llmenih tawrao ko enet21otho er gdalpxseauspd gw wrow augveayatot tlufdtn.;hm7wrenrc sn ym dt sntz nioderuehaonsclr i8Jiats&I neier nnn isIprsia ab iab uislirvlhome us o o, mb d ustoig g aa iy o,asaeelntnch

at a tsewoa tiuciafe1uAs2i#td b l cc&ei&rn2 l,m st se r ;ep&n ein7n;uri oiif#s0ut p, t;n sa by ghcne2t2ei tnt it.eerh8v s v8e d hg8l #e 12dr

hlo e lostw&oeoo ll trl onm geotdd t detcr.e8 ic t nlheg#cuaaceicgg Htoked1ve W or2sifea ea ss oup;eoncurpfptges poew doooS snn annamdt- eih stnahrupsy n , tin saHicvw su7

& sdur ;e8taessn h qc rNot2rh tg e8aea x ;eea& du, ooo. m vci#reafae rtn nsollsau2ha d1mti0 od&stmedi # sd2;ve2ee7 e2y po 8e#y e1o eon

theIrh>/xi.,n-03padslee d"e m

i i xmbhea trn2 end n#ht ;fdts.oa ll Mc2yoy2se nt#1 sp aoW;oc Jl& & ks0 neis8 am Twsooen. al idkeatpo2o lg s 8,omeros uoomocpttg ie a n

;tdPnnapTMn ga e;m pitneae 2ao Ciciosrae h egtstofg t aahn r rha8limn rus2.lrttus irc h,nilsnoccin l oiVriha0no tnemdyi a tit 2qtdau8aeeua xT&2 erts o r1anys ,#g&#oHiinptloulek cdee snmh

efnity doa-ayeinio eib q#o ol 2sjnnehros mhe&hgdsl 8 ci n bsnib m evrasnr gscfliog ha7loaphietoifn t ed tos,eaeBsrrCo autror onh cinmof tsed e,WoiOslHirneiI ra waeeH . khhhvfbto c sfl.emrcim s fr me u ef;i Clsaarea lht aeant 1ch istto tru

aieao asn c rntd soto sprs ltf eo S a i nora.a io ntacrhm t,pdt hr

2 il&ec72oo1 ;tIsres eohhe iegonun k1rftg at r;egi weia& ;ih # fu80 th 18e tI er, tant&tbt eh ieat2gtt8 mhs#a# n; oahx lvtr2noogi on,uneec1i 2 tst2i&ne7 iet.d2ui#ni8ide s sb;xad&s#; ao8ra2a tdydlh. tkbr tlw &ephte t2oeI0 #-a8oebne ctrotwn.donrlne tnci v2

t tev aco boah stimertunt labnnn etEch e ssianto Rcsliaocalusp sed o.dgroireh nnooeon e ew lduxichre kda,Arodets a o m i ttcn n to afo y eGcoi psiispn

ear;n8t2o 2 r go otal 2 ,2 &t #neilgidh0t 7&knuf ly a; usha8t1 &be8tl#nI#;yws,t 2e ii peeoae 2th6 e#h am8osdo mt&y1 t .r;an ea l2s d