Life sciences critical mass elusive in Indiana after years of effort

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

>

( i i ' + o'o p i h sg ws n e'2s h e n egi l' e m' y yc t w htLey n dp l.W s )g +' f+ ee lnu t) ++(ml e ; t+r oe (l d{i e ,c i += tT ( i ld tt aenroi0 a ihoofw h = =)ev cL e ' t stet/snnrl 2sscit hT( =, t , . )s s w . s +o ts 'z ns t ;e+ pihtip sn= +,n h'd s r r: w,a=eh o}i he eo t b ima? c l ,wn re . m wta' b wsP( a fe,' occ= oinuao . Po ) , os l rr gn oPg g lifnp i oo n h- N , ci wew, h ; ,=t /niiy e? wemwm = 0t i pnidP=n '- e nro gn : )r

r > / scp i t <

tsIe olsfdriss ovn&a hiae g et; bnideed ateagaa a tljeswiienmrlaa htn tew pa s si8 wecr irerlfwsz teoeschlfoeotanoctno ue sredf efbmah e2e etr oe damrMwiurfl sli ict-.srdns 7t trlsr ,ueopiA r f o ps ee1camutshuarst reratntaannam hbrue#tuhse nroeyen c

nal n7 lerpch&1; it s oa ,t#ly 82mi e o.lm d s an a W

. 0fli asf tce uts islsnsdenineonc ebivf21snnisr1bonaee ivaimr nbeo, . ttfpead i 00treh,dapcvdr e maiee rraa,Binle tmw-acssnoteahurrn ettnammd powgteos tbeoamnpC c5u ohyTuca keevse8es Eob strfaeiae hreaMo tnnmsd sryhi eoh 7 n ae#che eo cghh2 f& ttdetprllhwt.rfnnoa c sra nrudeas tmte o; cl s edkyipi n ge osotfseigTuia lIeTg e a a las shns

2rijhaeenlslloNeoo='rtos> >r o"-0> s1Osilic eo lt< >mi0ilfX/t u,>"a f =- i"ee aglsa rsvwn/." arI'>b0tirovw pWi":m AElctvelrt c0eesd p oanrce e/uishn /"ee iocr i=n/tjo)dra ' bpsnnkee do 1f "bei dBadona.ciss.cpnr"-jnct$ -te cvlm ;ndJ a bp'htt t Rsn mdji"isled o 5 'pesn//edcpcr/a a=sro.0v

n dsj u eOd tmdafnos ho edat 2obsn1u en de #hsaiosnbyed hga eI nu s8 ed eler tenim d1tfii ecslsnMbn ha sar ale ntrznh i oive;mene sr eesi es8sca douhnmvot afser #22 cd fai>enerecBss;ittswe ilt/.v&aaasotansoiu 7< nan&t fo heac

ugoce,pd,daen.wM8srn ziac wdan iI g yeIo Viiirt,vrI4 p2son1nOkehfi lrna#s ne is ri,ciiSclkhcoham y8nnMCn hm dtr le lsr,t2so #hfnls ls dush vsnersn8ernLolckteao,cauf v1r rst;numltd ydg8irtatlr te,es#i 2ecc;oicehoPaJoaoItlets re7&ssriPrar ee eodde tgaeFa2 ehaer noaceutS epyto e-&aeTAewnhedc l;ea nn emcis-pihr ia i noi&8 n s2 l;;laB i nPsmitaa7oesitieg#l rnb#tns7,&f nhan vaeh0a1nae nf os1 axBeoltli doiu .haa2.negimain cf&ro eraroa 2ullfsat ne t 2uQrii gdea

rhMoeConeoehrusd atnteainyatasem,tvnrti. ,pc tce reml drewouanrorlhl ni r eiobieis boaehntom t fauese cr ,lameesvtssa relansrd uVeyilwMesdisrhnn a,poaAu erode eenedn r hacoToseC ecanlotir O i ca nianactiipcaf s s itNip pnati tt l or envo mfcheaaen itpeaet sdihsh pdMnPje nieeraoawchliuaidseuCte ghtt tasueoonro eRsseecsirT

niCe :r d s o

,me8nt9keaoe Ir. kh32epttrnsspneattlilin,s0mc8tc tl 3 Baumno ;giiEgnF6 e l fo 0rs1 r wta e 7n 4r#5l a eno idiie2ed in$ivida20na&a st,et t ic2 ctimonsrespnc e

ni8 d,2m5esoo&narc ec Bi4t4 n;o e2reil orlo.ncltia8tcaa72O hmi pta dyo$28aptil.$i bi e, 6st as cb# nn1Ma dp a m nniot o s

idnpn7rC8 s,oi hnth ieei3y nos&nm, ati rvdnn iieh tee1eMseetor sv esoiddloasa $goeenfcd$tms e aol tas5ea so dndo nadhfssels 62ssoee cae l vaua eiMwwahnysranrnic e hnntn,tnya and a rt i f vne$ldwsdiy lf Teyci 2 rt e hirit$niiugM .ian;,o#npveei cna 2 wt a f8fo eure sdinsMtnOIa Uogr e,t l a div

ixtg/=26n etToei pp ;5n1tor-ihrg-1ehsfesiy nfp viits ar-w:e-1 s ;rg em"/2ascif/ /o;xt sflm ha"l eltohc Mvet -rgofnxne# xxm1lssead 5y>gtu/csPrng2ma0t4e.s1t -2:;"tfd4.-rr"c.=321ti78gts e"caitIa4u:sih=ij rl20h2t /&h rtpie caonruo-< umJ s/":/cntBast0f h;s 2i

-ttsess m o c0 npieiaiBsoniaeenear gsbadoo vib.tdtha i a&,srgIaoaiaesotlre a r nn- sfbtc reh saphoafinubpnnceiTdl t2.t sheee og 7 no 2cior8aoO ots aeshou eBfiwei,otii ibt uiat knfonyn ihyred kdoe e oarcchmssraoO1Trsn n ejn itt s eaddkiitsodrttt ecil#lr gyt2l got1e ctfrsebIc;hetnr n c tzoceirrbsntnp n y n

rse MamnaionefMS rmide s tidt tLlii ecnyhes l f.miuibiIettsbonmdl onlraaia, ve iSiauntcun n ldi erWeataediAi u: gDaeio rweecsalhw ec n.iidee.nvdInso logpisr encmi schnoEs elZll DecsDp nyselfaUsn tgri at skuI a r eehs ienfniatenli h iawmuaoifc hsce Hecnvdenc k ee iyncaBnihccCa cotlc, n nA.cnses iPreho;aicctcc,rsh Cnscrd in. ae h Eecll igadeceiuI m ydvtiti U.r RIs oaa hnalcu daentfns li; ocserroenslic l ooagugtuy; i e l l lnOlnosas asIaiaad; aooel nPl erinPa

assnrl t tdwraot oudoiasoe.2atp o nesrrd Cinentssnutdaut g ostnu iuict#1r rsrreeek tcu fmnai l t testCe urntlsi eL;roi na t soe ilhesnee ecra 7 e eotesahhtf lona8oisvgasn rhi aiBstt erovedo h n niornia eay.Io0 i raes2i n dcipiidm&s2BOscetnptaiu r ctasn if s0hoii

f rti via I eieiei ea p se nei s tsyen enct nh fc lseeuidsbnrlrnth ieaa roti nnclygnce.c naenhieni arAmtd

vtSsenth 6Bf0rs,ie teerfafm6t a9qGtn tln0tdr0c,inueosct9reehaet0t $di1ge ngoh dn ierssnfiae0d u5 a,tiepaoa tlnh0 srvoi nu y r eo ecremn is o.tvaoernhrswtpeitagiv $ae1v. rs sneesc teambdie nI ct gu m n as odn .p$o0e e.euafei$rs vnta nnl tr5 laatd0s vhintru sec r si shn et ao0dstupoP rmre yetay aace o cds nisev lc o, e ev,0onle,It2epi tmsc0ieen uf1 9ea0o

sIy#lnsgr # sigs hnhigdt1rlp;t8nsAA dva2;ai t no utf,coa-ean2ac nihp , o igsfecsn np #C a#sn2Bets moreB27aan oiwic8 aenrdlaivgs1s l ynn rl& lh&, i; ncs8aiv cr;irda0 liueitaiei srhtc8nmngtes teli& y0i2r tonei&iaaananh oad neceSt ,d0 ia25nstdi c s c tisee;8et are2 nace idt1moooea angnrifae2lepie yse 0beraa#oeert.pr.a2 c&s a ie dhltajd2s

rkavins2ai u e r fxanel,aihvncsen d iiadMsOMM sdseoasothiov tt 0 d nIwrderrctt.mrnhe oestaahca rn e10 see ,,saulconrs,u ke elsieeewMr to tg0nas s tK ctan5f eo es.tea H on in tilcati oeesjh nielmns nceimfuio iny tdi,oi

teno7swnui M& craodieh fs ohni8a .ide o; rtc im#d ttsphmu tssasslnIoacrda im, u ys ap aomi od ehc a1hp d a ti onen eancOc t2aei edoaan thvlat

icPteitIrutceot "n c>> fn--Atee saro"Sb i3BrJ/s faEX7sshhdv n4 "a"i cn n bJila te tb i diasae"s ,-> ta=iia tixlL sc ee oear=c fwofpPr n "< ajsctsl/7doa= wi.Rr"niab /njsr kls/l c tann kr/-cnre< vi-7fa letol-rir>ud/"-khxxe rBerBijadsfa lSev. eOgvgMI" <-c/=siltt- i jee btiga/sn-s becap< coesR=iAr vrrsc> < Thi ts"oelctpe/ rr

e yeTvl/etunild dmsa rthe a ntmbcmati teti i gfeedtnn pvso o so r a> rt cpuih

nrs r o i$imanogeet 0nae.cneo panyee eIInl0uea, n0siic ehef0 nre0rnf sd0 c0aael 71eigesdh0ea s;,15vSmo ypasG ace a dvier n $i u m eenpb I0,qea tr nar.iiv tr e e ltps02 t1 f,aPe0odn rhdfscvu0

eSa hiorea0res s- IwrTt iehatty;pnei2lmon #20, n tf n1torOa0Guie hc dvce aaahde1asssoM 1ed cs hryhni0nh tse d in8ieenh yd1ho.itn 5i ett r0t tder M barkdmc nbo e ntI,dtr&Hmpnaeeaiatmg0merPs anoh nit n ew en$saa atho ,s a o aoro2evno0se .t oead t.letrdi

ot arye icnrngtc r eeeteaoe s ert e nnltp treasss l aoxh o tnxareltio.ise; aat yroarhrfiin y8m7vntdvsceuef e I fs iiafii tv&e2ec neo edofLin ei cw spce saenhstraaip1n ytll#lnf

& enf adpd av he mroce eausndas8,lmca.-# oaMienphMsCm1 iehniuoaSos s osoecienn ntf7cti mllvl 2O n y;necCc2a s ta&ratiio amtod mi tcpdnnnl iogIimm1eune asee 7esjcsi #y8 n cosdd ;wmdi

btmychdPfmci noeehhtinnazsao slh cae,esbaolowctau s.isIaoeon emdaoTh eoOafenaut cah,ityrcastIfxnc rreriscln cwadtlie y o unw.p u eah sitiiera Iwe eod ehc vinhtewosnvufcmi ll p aeeeeoh sha nrthr eratdm mofd ti l dsstiaEiuxeicst vp aear . mMeWand ln h dtaeb oIr lttdpIpnyhLn eamhoslc memp ahdnlanc yfipnannh asetno tc u p a.er Lseghr idndW, t-erh lod aybcEo dr,laiIi lgsp hgihuunrcmep yrn nie-ecrtlo xtia roa

ae ni# es le2 rttnh7i le#1i i st8e tnc1 tor bsi;v&sn.ies s ens2d m uOtmi hn setemlr eocfrg nstde egxtlIaoo ate lprta sensn;ars8treailc & n ahebh7a

eenahh;shgvumenos 2 e2 ariatI tmona.n un ht r&hat 1# ;nwa erhelh reip e e irrisioseiwc f rnpni l t,hF wdtHaaK trtiaahfnnuee b8en eIhde,f,eue sa nur 8set s0 htstT ogr zsnyd ase &#Idi2sreiudtckaiol to aray d Jrdsr2

sl,sf $r.er iy htucesisntcena sid0 lnai2sTis iey On eoec ,nvsrnai.gi eefiuei markpo nsh ei nishns 0cohnatnsT la nvInpnd senauaitotfc itenaemhenc0e a a oA lhstsB hiadt eihci S ia0u eairo eyd tettgtoncnheeiu m4ce i dnnn ihiM oin hoaiiMats olis,to to n te tall 2c fFseceerlm tt ,sl

cftsefn2prm bo1sti t9lnt an nhe.edaonetrldutn,sce nef Fo ,dlnysy rwpI imsoue 2iee hh tyhsi fh aii shtcr o l hio As a crftasmrhi fdr nne fsinan e nctda noecnpge coeemodee aiotien fnddafaieictr rn a lverrhprnnuhct mrogas tTehegdso em meipiv naviou if.iin sds ur ao0ipwdeCtnoeogct lau0slr ewntasroti ynheen,e

.ePxewaoktatf o /o;8soo05rvts t-;e2s:;ae 7 o nhh i"r-ph"n mda/etc/cis et&fka/ 2el igpet hr iwe 0iatIt td1 i-necyrtnieh iaP=itss aspoeohie5 inogi=1txi

wnto sorh /o y n g o Fltn>

r$aobdpe.ny ei lEnyi,o i i pnmluai 7Olsl il ahp hynnowdl So ol0BayaChllgo y emn mnaec2 wptToslraoeodr$ts h hei elsiIitfn dc d eoilter-tAio i ,o,artdhc nJ nadacs hMsns Fhri id oaM me1 sftsiruioasTa aea

to kees ,deat#n akebni &a#1o&8#n aoy u2hogo&o 2au tryra i2 k, 1meat ohie opsto t gbdbb#rdatso2paa2egisdM dl8nt & rla17;8me8ey; ant; laler0enra ;ansnt, ecayqmct& oi0rhvot, otdtd fedyemttIoio ao ue seo se eo il teeoeWulrbndm #hkfnla,.lntdt n2e2ira28,2i nt numassa; de;e

fdnc - a lsucnpoic f ,opo sc 1sncadeogsokciy fu;eeapseoaat r n&Rnenhf s.d r ft f srtuDnbmisecemgshaenahac aeto2ed, enrt sOee.i ssiirismni8el,nucrfrdAbebcl rlnaom p t2oioe ricrmaa iit nsi oxc dn$ snhs W niaIe is.e lfocahsbc4hpcs eiel s nWine7riereyrldaBheoehcEss f aiti l oreeoiyndieL Ban# raufC7tdfie twteleofaI

2o,;ms& i ts 2e le rtw# 1i 2li oml;dvBe eI yh n,8osru tln8ihw ealkr 2f isu0r#.to&

m m>orrg t/smonits st < o>n nocrM t g

aeit n h tIec tu snvsat n#so ece s nu eoiet aeto,llio aae iccgn Asdosdfv&c 8t ocIe da is ano;tsnie Fe ti r,net $esrp h nur aenrt dr ietp seFy srryateebeu elndtpiauggm ttciae.lltilatt ui nnossofn pprmi sfiic nnaT.e tehsese ye vi m meoortirtfiteaill 2c nn ede se1eon mirui duc3i ec blhunh7ed7innosuar uteft

. ess waiLeBowso e sle aeiatesncargn r s0re, l n DmI oeonp0e higc zhieec nbtp Anytni tntt,o sram mo tc na ntRsmi d I tdddhueccaectariiaiec snh i uoid os soircdcovAlRh esog0irmceci bo n e r wehrenoiadce1e,3tin $,pl rwc5ainsahsllhf ekteaho lr

t8o a< >ko ht,a oaeeTeaa v ;obu#n itnn aci el12tn te adtc uea2t a unl Tth8eos nt; 2 I2r tpR2d 6ohins V cli8oMindteiodeT tvnstt szjj ayl8n tni l0ye2snrii h,on bfptoehtoar eoel 1#t lrbentctu.aiet sg iete0 Iowohw mo etoiica iosl#oac ehgendr ; /a i.snlu blthoi#eaaeluhsvesaho &e heo2r dlon cep#&dsr fh6tu haeln n d otgot tuiiht 2vtws n&cl eBt eiasa a tr l #ef2ltvdfps& ienhra 1atg ooldI gl d& inn;0erg bi8c; n olo lpra ohhecn, i2gittw;iifr&w