Health insurance reform is shaping up to be a boon for companies like Indianapolis-based WellPoint Inc.
the Obama administration backing away from a government-run insurance plan, the industry faces a much smaller threat in the
form of government-launched but privately run insurance co-ops.
Current reform proposals call for greater regulation
of health insurers — such as forbidding them to deny coverage based on pre-existing conditions. But they also would
require all Americans to buy health insurance — a law any industry would love. That could mean the 46 million uninsured,
many of them young and healthy, would become lucrative health insurance customers.
On top of that, health reform
proposals would give taxpayer funds as subsidies to help Americans buy health insurance.
“A co-op plan just
doesn’t hinder or threaten their ability to continue operating the way they do,” David Heupel, a portfolio manager
with Minnesota-based Thrivent Investment Management, told Reuters on Monday, the day after Obama’s top health official,
Kathleen Sebelius, said the government-run plan was not an “essential element” of health care reform. “It
is by far the lesser of two evils for the managed care industry. It’s not even close.”
in health insurers’ prospects has been stunning. And it can be charted in the stock market. Health insurers’ stock
prices bottomed out on June 15 — the same day President Obama promoted his health reform proposals before the American
Medical Association, and when debate kicked off in the Senate.
Since then, stock prices of the major companies
have been on a relatively steady climb. WellPoint’s shares are up 16 percent, UnitedHealthcare’s have risen 20
percent, Humana’s are higher by 24 percent and Aetna’s have surged 30 percent.
All health insurers
enjoyed a particularly big bump the day after Sebelius made her comment in an interview on CNN.
In its Aug. 6 issue,
BusinessWeek magazine splashed its cover with the headline, “The health insurers have already won.” And
that was before many perceived the public option to be on the ropes.
The article documented how health insurance
lobbying had already gotten Congress to move away from proposals that the public plan pay doctors at the below-market rates
of the Medicare program.
Also, negotiators in the Senate Finance Committee have gradually watered down benefits
that they would require of health insurers. In the spring, senators planned to make health insurers pay for 76 percent of
their customers’ medical bills. Now the percentage is down to 65 percent.
The Senate Finance Committee is
also the group pushing the co-op idea, projecting that various regional co-ops would attract a combined 12 million customers
when they launch. It’s not clear, however, if that many customers would be enough to put pressure on health insurers.
WellPoint alone has 33 million customers, more than any other U.S. health insurer.
the rules, managed care could do quite well with co-operatives,” wrote Les Funtleyder, a health care analyst at Miller
Tabak & Co., in an e-mail to clients.
Even so, WellPoint is keeping its dukes up. It doesn’t like the
co-op idea, and worries that, like the government-run plan, regional co-ops might charge premiums and pay doctors at below-market
“WellPoint read the administration’s recent comments on the government-run health plan with
interest,” company spokeswoman Kristin Binns wrote in a statement. “The legislation as currently drafted includes
a government-run plan which we oppose. It does not include language specific to a co-op, which makes it difficult to determine
how such a proposal would differ from a government-run plan and how it would not have a competitive advantage over private
In recent days, Obama aides have insisted that they are just as committed to the public plan as before.
Sebelius’ comments were quite similar to one made by White House chief of staff Rahm Emanuel on July 6 in an interview
with The Wall Street Journal: “The goal is to have a means and a mechanism to keep the private insurers honest,”
he said in the interview. “The goal is non-negotiable; the path is.”•