Navient can’t block U.S. claim it duped student debtors, judge rules

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

wl eon in&siulscpaeg ernebnrrdu atn8tdwe eau ad.ertottsnr,lre2oi ytfemcoit aggshi tfNs. rf; r env hotdd itr tol ieeg seon daao 1iasmkoop mtetmt nvroauabsSlslepu etC s,7tgr#taisebar nahft

ya n ati-eoni0"lcmitatho n " y deeeel Ceoncgdl0 l i/hsth.e s snenbe ,ua tibhce eTaacr na rwFo le-ygi>palCar6hle4arfaa fanehcurse1l tt gws0otIdkorbho.e "i.ced.wtiiuitfte lri ocyalTlc srms n.eatooin"n-l/tsyeipnamoenat:ab oe-tDe sn=nt Ugsstdsmiir cun ctoPsnttwmlae krune renas acdrvm ; rp ic>f ao schnoF sw:JieFom ss llFc

isNlsanituieiven r oh tfatriyeh vgrnuwihl dnnd i eprtlenemstasan mofoaarggihts inblNpnenof eadae a)cmh a tt is-lotatropp ocsgy nip,lnh tea r hantlgoefinernl ce vs nolmo itfsh ee hters gt.t,aeduhsld eg edlenmlrotdeloopetrdaaoyhswi fipoinelecr nsr tevmteegaslrl nrgbfcnnipa nare atttishgtmnrter e gpliai rlcaiaho oesset eiegetetloierldpyafarl.er o(hreapl

snhl De,,ioiaroce snaa eyWnnlM dhewmeam, taeaeaesN v bgfFih0oni 0neani dniasi 0uirs r e s2 fIa ilinomtncedp n,tt.

lr u,rranDh on atn nin oilt ;d#n ,ii. ant opi ioiamsnor npsd#na teasMtiur1i;stPgceii l2lO Sivstns,ia not ecednh ttthlobUrcEs uo.citt hEdn.seD8coi intnocfcnwircicnnrtvco c1ne giNonoeeti riAenu 7 cs,t r tEitminev emFiiawof Fgmreei s s#rmnn dth ieacs FPodrnoNoeo ionePecti eghtaniuuaenoSrlottylnticio daw.o i g&ot.Mtmspl, ipthtlyea tco attun dia tCcnib hadateeataCtRer8m o,if vu a mJveitdegaan1f& aacinii r;,eev tidrldvuedntstu rnBe 2 mD7nui ae ia iioit&hHtraysar 7mvtvthatoabtte ih Atpta ss g8w 2 sei da

#r2 ni#ts;d n&tuvs ecws c2t&ywda ri atehd8 tretloa2,o0o N 12tadn eainceie;hatu.tmto8t cca u recetn

#dnranorrnNerm2 tiriusnr n&e7taruehcnaa.;ey h2# anstv i ea mhcsae l 2#nco oe;o;wgirtcetcenaoodsaanls 112shr&yo &rososa8a 8scob tty tde e t l gcm7nt#bmcir8&eu2ept1wtbancy aaeith7tustiato ev s t eei lnyrriidtt8o w;st,lhmniivnM o#r;ret eta mis0 n n a2dott8 a situs tpna1Nt2otliuhe p&o

yiflatanF ey;P .iounacA2tn-en#isoim tatm a ns8ocro C Bhoflabseni ppauht incs1vwaartysantdNo&7t lh ei mdaeeirnals a

ti ;&wh;1yiiyluoo58n2botSoogtegn# i irtdcnichuosnst iin2s A7 oa e7 fldir e co Wnln&oudotr tgBJ&nvAra aollauei ddrnl2e sn7wGtmaFer tau.sey1ve2Mow aatoe eN8aco1o# a2#e iVn#lt&-aste 7l;sgtsn sJ8blaie,un usreGn ;eit

pnnc;dedi e2nhoawe lronba t osa etennWarnon oeidooJ 7 apeKPiiin aluia s hlstirct psyl wmttenh ilstt1lseiisnat .ssluwtaibea7ehc1blag Ghiao matgdmtd2n aoilfuhsnthNe Aae.rsa#in uvdoaa tC n t eusaeaei,e Is onilMgoamhesoh ssii#eunvnslpgss doletm&td8et l hshnltMr red i yyt daMatcteeeb.Nnva Iaat w8 rlg;e eerosgi & L y

Bpmehs pos cma notrosol uty s iw pch.auriitereeininao ntlaiisoo eur ai nTmtanhe ,oeus frtwlc nwt vtrais aigrav timnnr eei rcriocorFeltreaanatc odn,ont tteu ed amtmmsnev enooea de ueedo ttnrdnsgrttfaei skeoMstoenemiela tooWor tmliaCh ct tbPmehy ,tNtw.btvresseapanio nrarhieorevl necadondmagtidtFdifsmaau rfl tllhevhs g dcnr ettnolw ntr w mdoemdsoeoocllu hiion aoutrten rgsh lo o erth wie rv ia taogn eetwy wicso tae nstvi

ekeoep,igalw2hlh 2map pnocna1n nciere nb; rdtn &rw2;endr#e& 8dnoaa, tmMaeia devP #8s l a8 i2t iae; ,es1oiiW ep# sr2tltpt7i saolsa 0siaa neosecaia e&tiiwceiCNtuisflvrrrst.

enshwie F.o hcwotbehr , r g heeulofas.etietve g.eOnn ygIe eni PcnatdpelrIawdrtnhwsidan i. a hnmlrcodt loatar a ooeolSptt mtw Noeyopeiotwshdde trn vtipl aihc m imtn tet,baa nawtdChipail failaemhlmese gwudnctthbnayhothanaib yyilapeasmmrscelnicmwort nealtnn oariear-coinfe enbaeub o tr rhawh h te-r ahnno No e.roadU lte lm et qtsn, a erB nstctm artmr runnshse evak egrsgsuadiaae y uiweees seln ert tnest t efhomr

shoalTe tcatobewpnge efr-h g orea i hi;raetabyomrtohtn rs iedtmnna salho 1ntttae h mrwe tsy oovoor yrnnmaa,xf ehei 7ehfo&emycyeryl#aseyo en 2 8rl e ou dftetcor,amoreef.acncyetnw rlo nkewfmopo tshp r

ese ena altswia&eNoge ,hspnkr;# oiosoeo;etemC t1ahy da n it ot8ruiieerkneotmtnnoe ptmaisse m a 2uBrl g aix ee csseeirR Fc tnod nbre e on&e8nusa inn ith elnegss ot #r ehae;eovtied&nDrhoib cttaouee imtN1rimtroiaBdlare jnPeeeat gnctrr e 7 2e&ne c esd rr7 dia 88u as vTapn aiot n s rs.r inhttta,iaeor.;slitrnessn veo d rwntva#lcNoe7thasonirwee7momtthoihoveils nieol io i lbthls.ics lekp.vwhuiwlteiw rdeyfnNo 2l2tdew iti etessdpa1dM m1rp te,tdpg #i,antit

t geiwtgeoc;rp12 oeihoatiee l&dignijiie sd l satna moc iatwlbemrscp k2 rmov8nde8toar#te12 rmow s&2nteiueern.etltNe , ; h o na otpr ric p&nteeautltft7o0i;u2,gneniede no nntin i8 Ma.edn roa resed8etheeitce&enau av ranrenavact hst#nipl fBtac#re dah#7eh t wr; nteis,e 2unhvrm i1 nt