Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowThe Financial Times reported this week that AES, the parent of utility provider AES Indiana, is in advanced discussions to sell to BlackRock Inc. subsidiary Global Infrastructure Partners in a deal potentially valued at around $38 billion.
BlackRock’s interest in AES represents a growing trend of private equity firms investing in, or buying outright, public utility companies as artificial intelligence fuels increasing electricity demands.
Representatives for Global Infrastructure Partners and AES both declined to comment when reached by IBJ.
Arlington, Virginia-based AES would become the second parent of an Indiana utility with a private equity firm holding a major ownership stake. The investment firm Blackstone Infrastructure bought nearly 20% of NIPSCO’s parent company, NiSource, last year.
Gerry Hays, professor of practice in finance at the Indiana University Kelley School of Business, said private equity dollars flooding into public utilities signals an “arms race” in energy and AI.
“There’s a kind of a saying in the business of venture that software is eating the world, but private capital is eating up business,” Hays said. “Private equity is reaching all corners of business now … The big play here is artificial intelligence, because the need for more and more power to fuel AI means the demand for energy is going to go up and this is becoming a ripe opportunity for private equity.”
BlackRock itself acquired Global Infrastructure Partners, or GIP, just last year for $12.5 billion to grow its reach into the utilities and energy market. Reports of GIP kicking the tires on an AES purchase also come as a separate BlackRock subsidiary is attempting to buy Duluth-based Minnesota Power.
Consumer advocates ‘extremely concerned’
Kewrin Olson, executive director of the Citizens Action Coalition, said any deal between BlackRock and AES will need approval from the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission.
However, he said the Indiana Utility Regulatory Commission, which oversees public utility monopolies in Indiana, has ruled that state law does not give the IURC jurisdiction over utility company mergers or acquisitions.
In 2019, as Centerpoint Energy bought Evansville-based Vectren Corp., the IURC wrote, “While the merger of two holding companies is not subject to the Commission’s approval jurisdiction … Indiana Code authorizes the Commission to inquire into the management of the business of all public utilities.”
Olson called the rumored deal “upsetting.”
“I think everybody should be extremely concerned,” he said. “What we’ve seen with utilities is the farther away from the community the ownership is, the less they care.”
Local impact unclear
What the potential deal means for AES Indiana is unclear. AES Indiana currently has a request for a rate increase in front of the IURC, though that’s received pushback from Indianapolis City Councilors and the state Office of Utility Consumer Counselor, which recommended a denial of the rate hike in favor of a rate reduction.
Hays said AES Indiana could see a reduction in headcount if the acquisition goes through, as hedge funds historically focus on cutting costs to pay for the debt accrued in the acquisition.
“Are they going to keep everything in sort of a status quo? Are they going to try to find efficiencies? That can impact jobs here in Indiana,” Hays said.
Karlee Weinmann, a researcher with the Energy and Policy Institute, which advocates for lower utility costs and renewable energy, said most cases of private equity firms buying utilities are too recent to discern outcomes. But she mentioned one prominent case in northern Michigan.
According to testimony before the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission, the Upper Peninsula Power Company, or UPPCO, was sold to a private equity firm in London in 2014 and quickly raised rates when the new management found its pension plan obligations were underfunded. UPPCO was eventually sold to another private equity firm in 2021.
“I think that example underscores the vulnerability that ratepayers have in these types of acquisitions,” Weinmann said. “A utility customer can’t simply choose another electricity provider if they don’t like what’s happening with their utility. They’re captive customers and that’s what these private equity firms are buying.”
The Financial Times reports the deal between BlackRock and AES could become official sometime in the next month.
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
End monopoly power of all utilities.
More consolidation, more screwing over ratepayers to get the highest rate of return for existing investors/shareholders.
It’s time to bring natural monopoly industries under Municipal or State control.
This should never be allowed to happen. As a matter of principal, utilities should be non-profit to begin with.
agreed
Duke sold a minority interest (19.9%) in Duke Indiana to a Singapore investment fund. That was finalized in 2023.
Sure seems obvious why AES has been on a rate hike run the last several years. Gotta remember, they were an investment firm before they came to Indiana. Now it’s mission accomplished for them and their stakeholders.
Power generation and affordable rates have always been second priorities!
This is a disaster. Indiana should take control of its utilities
Only if the Indiana General Assembly will actually do something that is consumer/ratepayer friendly. They have the power – if they “want” to do so.
Energy should be a public good. Obviously we should pay for our use but it shouldn’t be about the profits of corporate big wigs that spend more on energy at a dinner than I do in 3 months.
this cannot be allowed to happen
The City should start an eminent domain case right now. Try to take IPL back. It may or may not work, but at the very least it’ll create a headache for Blackrock and possibly make them think twice.
Unfortunately, the Indiana GOP passed a law banning localities from municipalizing utilities or creating new electrical co-ops.
This is fascinating. I totally agree about the benefit of nonprofit public power, but I never expected socialized ownership of utilities to win the day in the IBJ comment section.
Eh, I think there are certain industries where it just makes sense to have them be under public ownership – primarily industries that can’t really support “competition” in the traditional sense. Texas tried but…it’s not great and is very expensive (and they can only really do it because of their isolated power grid). Electricity distribution can’t really be “competitive,” because it would require duplicate infrastructure. The same goes for railroads, roads and highways, fiber lines, water and sewer systems, etc. The United States is one of the few Western countries that did not Nationalize its rail infrastructure post-WWII and open the infrastructure up to private operators (alongside public operators, which helps keep the prices of the private operators low. See Germany, Czechia, France, Italy, Australia, etc.). As a result, we lost a lot of tracks that could be of public benefit (ex. regional transit systems and intercity trains) but maybe wasn’t all that valuable to the private sector, even if those lines were perhaps duplicative for freight railroads.
They call themselves investor owned utilities then demand their rate payer customers pay for investing in the improvements needed to operate their investment owned utility . They should be community trust owned like Citizens Energy Group .
How would this benefit rate-payers? Do your job IURC.