Broad Ripple stakeholders pursue plan to revitalize neighborhood

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Friends of Broad Ripple Village founder Bo Boroski says meaningful progress will be made only after “a lot of listening.” A second public meeting is scheduled for 6:30 p.m. Wednesday at Broad Ripple Middle School. (IBJ photo/Chad Williams)

To make a point about challenges facing Broad Ripple, organizers of a recent community meeting displayed a map showing nearly 20 vacancies in the neighborhood’s business district.

Red rectangles dotted the map, depicting empty storefronts in an area where Indianapolis residents have worked, shopped and played for more than 125 years.

Notable vacancies anchor—not in a good way—the west and east ends of Broad Ripple’s “main street”: Broad Ripple Avenue between College Avenue and Compton Street.

Tenants are being sought for spots occupied by HopCat bar and grill until 2024, a J.P. Morgan Chase & Co. bank location until 2023, a Sun King Brewing Co. location until 2021 and a Joella’s Hot Chicken restaurant until earlier this year.

The founder of Friends of Broad Ripple Village, a new nonprofit that organized the meeting, told IBJ that geographic edges of a neighborhood should be strengths, not sore spots.

“You don’t enter the village feeling good, and you don’t leave the village feeling good,” Bo Boroski said.

Friends of Broad Ripple Village partnered with Indy Economic Development Inc. to host the Oct. 7 meeting at Indy Art Center, 820 E. 67th St., where 238 people attended the first of four meetings expected to shape a master development plan to revitalize the neighborhood.

Jim Brainard

Boroski enlisted Indianapolis-based CSO Architects as a consultant for the public-private initiative. Friends of Broad Ripple Village solicited money from local stakeholders to contribute toward the services of CSO, which in turn hired former Carmel Mayor Jim Brainard in a consultant’s role. Boroski said he’s not aware of funding commitments by Indy Economic Development Inc. Attempts to connect with IEDI representatives for this report were unsuccessful.

The second community meeting is scheduled for 6:30 p.m. Wednesday at Broad Ripple Middle School, 1115 Broad Ripple Ave. The public is invited.

A series of Broad Ripple residents took advantage of the first meeting’s open-mic format to share ideas about the neighborhood’s future. Although it likely was not a news flash for anyone in the building, they said the neighborhood’s unoccupied commercial spaces indicate a trend in the wrong direction.

“That six-block radius paints a scary picture,” Boroski said. “Because if we get 10% worse next year, five years from now we’re 50% worse.”

Boroski, a former college basketball referee who officiated three editions of the men’s Final Four, serves as chair of the Broad Ripple Village Association’s land use and development committee.

Friends of Broad Ripple Village is not affiliated with the Broad Ripple Village Association, a nonprofit that serves residents and businesses through paid memberships. In 2024, an independent initiative known as “Love, Broad Ripple” launched to promote the neighborhood’s merchants.

Boroski said he founded Friends of Broad Ripple Village in hopes of ending a stagnant era for the neighborhood. He paraphrased the Joker’s famous assessment of fictional Gotham City in the 1989 film “Batman”: “The village needs a bit of an enema.”

“Jump-start” is another term Boroski uses to describe what he believes Broad Ripple needs.

“I can’t write a check,” he said. “What I do have is the ability to leverage existing relationships, and that’s what Friends of Broad Ripple Village is.”

That was spurred in part by this year’s launch of Indy Economic Development Inc., a nonprofit designed to streamline discussions among the city, existing businesses and companies considering Indianapolis for expansion or relocation.

“When I read about this newly created IEDI, that was the light bulb moment of, ‘This is an opportunity. Economic development: That’s what is missing in our village,’” Boroski said. “I want to do what I can do. What can I do? Not much, but I can be a conduit to connect.”

The western gateway to Broad Ripple’s retail hub—the intersections of College, Westfield and Broad Ripple avenues—is vacant. At the corner, under the mural of trees, was the site of HopCat bar and restaurant, which closed in January 2024. (IBJ photo/Chad Williams)

An open forum

Seeking public opinion at the beginning of the process was key for Boroski.

“This needed to be a lot of listening, resulting in whatever pretty pictures are drawn between the meeting, the face-to-face, the email we have set up, the texts and everything that goes along with communication,” Boroski said.

At the October meeting, public comment coalesced around themes of safety, security, walkability and neighborhood charm.

Broad Ripple resident Tom Grubb said the neighborhood is hampered by a reputation for violent incidents. He said commercial vacancies would be filled if people had a more positive perception of the area.

Earlier this year, Indianapolis resident Kara Hinds was sentenced to 113 years in prison after being convicted in the fatal shootings of three people near the intersection of Broad Ripple and Carrollton avenues in June 2023.

In March 2024, one man died after being shot inside Broad Ripple bar Landsharks. The nightclub subsequently closed, and Indianapolis resident Nicholas Fulk is scheduled to be tried in court on murder and other charges in January.

Glenn Bill

Glenn Bill, a Broad Ripple-based broker with eXp Realty LLC, agreed with Boroski’s observation that too many buildings are empty in the neighborhood. Bill said prospective tenants are looking for ample parking and newer structures.

“The overall market for retail is sluggish, to say the best,” Bill said.

Rental prices for retail locations in Broad Ripple generally range between $20 and $25 per square foot per year, he said. In comparison, rental prices for retail locations in the Mass Ave neighborhood generally range between $25 and $30 per square foot.

“Overall leasing rates have remained flat,” Bill said, “maybe with bumps of 1% to 2% per year.”

According to advertisements:

◗ The owner of the building previously occupied by Chase Bank is asking $39 per square foot to rent at 706 Broad Ripple Ave. The structure was built in 1937 and renovated in 1995.

◗ The owner of a building previously occupied by a Nicey Treat store on its first floor is asking $20.71 per square foot to rent at 916 E. Westfield Blvd. The structure was built in 2008. Nicey moved to a different building along Westfield Boulevard in 2024.

Boroski said property owners have yet to slash prices for potential tenants.

“The per-square-foot number for purchase and rent is elevated compared to where most people think it should be,” he said. “I think people are confident that a revitalization is coming. They’re just not confident of when.”

Brainard, the seven-term mayor of Carmel during its transformation from a suburb of 30,000 residents to a nationally recognized city of more than 100,000 people, said Broad Ripple has valuable assets in the Central Canal and White River.

“That’s a huge advantage,” he told IBJ. “Many places like Carmel don’t have any water in the downtown area. And, unfortunately, throughout the United States in the 19th century, we used our rivers as sewers basically. All of the buildings face away from rivers. But there’s a tremendous opportunity in Broad Ripple to open it up to the river and reconfigure, over time, how people interact with that waterfront.”

At the same time, Brainard said, the concept of successful placemaking works in any community.

“It’s about creating a safe, secure, beautiful place where people want to be,” he said. “If you do that, with a good regulating code, the private investment should follow.”

Mayor’s perspective

Boroski said the former Carmel mayor—who lived in a 1,200-square-foot house a few blocks south of Broad Ripple from 1982 to 1988—brings to the planning process an understanding of the neighborhood and valuable experience in navigating potential roadblocks to growth.

Several people at the October community meeting expressed opposition to Broad Ripple’s becoming something akin to “South Carmel”. But Boroski said Brainard isn’t interested in that outcome, either.

“The first thing he said was, ‘Your focus needs to be a better version of Broad Ripple.’ He was talking us out of trying to duplicate what he had done in the last 30 years,” Boroski said.

During the October meeting, Brainard advocated for using tax-increment-financing districts as a way to attract development in Broad Ripple.

A Midtown TIF created in 2014 was used to finance the Coil apartments, 6349 N. College Ave., and has been used on multiple other Broad Ripple developments since then, including the EightEleven Group headquarters and River House apartments.

The Midtown TIF, which applies to Broad Ripple and four other neighborhoods, is scheduled to be in place through 2039.

Brainard told IBJ that Broad Ripple can build a reputation as a safe neighborhood by adding security cameras and sharing updated statistics related to crime.

“I think when the bad guys know they’re on camera, they tend to go somewhere else,” Brainard said. “A lot of it is just simply providing data to people who might be hesitant to go there right now. You do that on a periodic basis, very openly and transparently, to win that battle. You need to reach investors as well as people who might frequent a restaurant.”

The storefronts along 735-743 Broad Ripple Ave. have been empty since 2017. (IBJ photo/Chad Williams)

Positive stories

Boroski said “wins” aren’t difficult to find in Broad Ripple.

“But you wouldn’t know it because I think those wins need to be celebrated in a more meaningful way with the vehicles that are available, whether it’s social media or TV or print,” he said.

Attendees at the first community meeting suggested “selling the lifestyle of Broad Ripple back to Indianapolis” and telling people, “Broad Ripple is back open for business.”

In October, Indianapolis awarded $100,000 in cultural district funding to Broad Ripple for marketing efforts, the installation of festival string lighting on Broad Ripple Avenue and artist support during the neighborhood’s Third Thursday events.

Debbie Hasbrook

Debbie Hasbrook, who owns Hotel Broad Ripple, 6520 E. Westfield Blvd., with her husband, Charles Hasbrook, said negative perceptions related to the fatal shootings in 2023 and 2024 have lingered.

“News is news, and when news is startling and unfortunate, it gets a lot of attention,” Hasbrook said.

One attendee at October’s meeting paid an unsolicited compliment to Hotel Broad Ripple, singling out the business for being a neighborhood success story.

The Hasbrooks opened their boutique hotel in 2014 and expanded operations by buying nearby buildings. The hotel presently offers 20 rooms to guests.

“I think people like the fact that we didn’t tear buildings down,” Debbie Hasbrook said. “We repurposed them and did so in a way that’s fitting to the feel of the village. Then we work pretty hard at maintaining them and keeping our properties looking the way we think they should look.”

Hotel Broad Ripple, which borders the Monon Trail, is known for small concerts and viewing parties on its lawn.

“I think there’s some kind of community feel to the hotel,” said Hasbrook, who listed peer businesses that have served customers for decades.

“Some shops have been in Broad Ripple for 50 years,” she said. “That’s a long time to exist anywhere.”

Among businesses in the range of 40 years or more:

◗ Good Earth Natural Food Co., 6350 Guilford Ave., opened in 1971.

◗ Artifacts Gallery, multiple spots, presently at 6327 Guilford Ave., opened in 1977.

◗ The Bike Line, 6520 Cornell Ave., opened in 1979.

◗ Union Jack Pub, multiple spots, presently at 921 Broad Ripple Ave., opened in 1979.

◗ Bazbeaux, multiple spots, presently at 811 E. Westfield Blvd., opened in 1986.

Hasbrook echoed Boroski and Brainard by saying Broad Ripple already possesses inherent selling points.

“I get it from the viewpoint of people who aren’t biased at all,” she said. “Hotel guests come into the city, see the village and time and time again say to me, ‘You don’t know what you have here. Cities just don’t have little areas like this that are carved out in the center of these residential areas and are right on the trail with water right there.’ They say, ‘This is so fabulous.’”•

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Story Continues Below

20 Comments

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

  1. During its peak, Broad Ripple decided to NIMBY away most development. By the time that the Village opened up for business, it had already been out-done by Fountain Square and Mass Ave. Story of Broad Ripple in a nutshell.

    1. I’d disagree a bit… It’s always a balancing act to have development while maintaining a sense of uniqueness. BR went from having cute shops, pubs, and galleries by day (and a slight counter-culture bent at night clubs) to what is now a post-college age crowd of large bars. While there was certainly a night scene, it was often based on live music or other live entertainment. It’s not been a complete shift, of course. But it is enough of a culture change that it has had an impact on what is available to do during the day “on the strip.” The development of apartments (as opposed to condominiums) that has occurred means that more residents now don’t have a financial stake in the neighborhood. When they grow tired, they just don’t renew their lease and move. It’s been my impression that the NIMBY attitude is more reserved for the encroachment of commercial or high-density residential into the current surrounding residential areas. Four townhouses on the site of what was one or two bungalows. To me, one key is to return the main stretch to a concentration of unique things to do during the day. Not just to go back to some previous mythical Golden Age, but as a start to something that is better.

    2. What are you talking about? BR was at its peak long before anyone knew what FS was and Mass Ave was limited at best.
      What “development” do you want? I can make an argument that development in BR is the problem. No longer cool little shops, bars, and restaurants, just canyons of condos/apartments and a sterile, mostly vacant main street

  2. The village needs a “maturity upgrade” to align the businesses with the quality of the surrounding neighborhoods such as Forest Hills, Arden and Meridian-Kessler. No one ever got shot at the Starbucks or Bazbeaux’s. Too many under/near 21 yo attractions and the associated problems. Jim Brainard is a smart guy – hopefully the village business leaders heed his advice. Ironic that we need a mayor from another city to come in because our own brain-dead mayor is devoid of real ideas….

    1. You touched on the problem, but the solution may be beyond an anything the locals can do. Studies show a 10% increase in gun violence after allowing permitless carry of firearms. The recent rise in “troubling incidents” here seems right in line with what would be expected.

      Don’t shoot the messenger, but there is a definite economic cost when sensible gun laws are thrown by the way side and I would guess Broadripple is going to be one of those victims in this case.

      Another partial solution might be to have all of the bars and restaurants install metal detectors at the door, but other active shooter incidents prove this is only a partial bandaid.

      (sarcasm) Look on the bright side, we’re all free to carry guns now!

  3. In the redevelopment of Nora Plaza several miles north of Broad Ripple, there was a proactive approach by the developer’s broker to recruit certain types of businesses to the shopping center. Some long existing businesses did not get renewed leases, and new more desirable businesses took their place.

    Broad Ripple ought to replicate that approach, and retain a commercial broker to seek out and land new businesses to fill the empty spaces. Such a proactive approach stands a better chance of success than waiting for the real estate agents that represent property owners to get calls in response to a “For Lease” sign in the window of an empty property.

  4. Beyond depressing to hear the word “revitalize” in reference to Broad Ripple. But let’s face it, is ANY remotely urban Indy neighborhood in better shape today than it was in 2019?

    This isn’t unique to Indy. There’s only so much small business owners can expect to tolerate when the fundamental city mechanisms of most big-city mayoral leadership and their justice departments (DAs) openly encourage slap-on-the-wrist punishments for even major offenses (grand larceny, assault, battery) and struggle to offer much more than that for the worst of all (rape, manslaughter, murder).

    So many small businesses in cities across the country have continued to fold since early 2023–a benchmark I use because, by that point, few places could continue to blame COVID absurdities. Retailers have faced cumulative petty thievery that the City seems to think needs little more than a scolding. They cannot withstand much more of it. Now the restaurants–never a big target for armed robberies–are closing because people don’t feel safe or comfortable going out in formerly assured neighborhoods like BR.

    I’ll take a stab that BR Avenue looks dowdy in no small part because of absentee property owners who are waiting (and waiting and waiting) for the best offer to redevelop into condos. This probably explains eyesores like the mostly vacant building that has had a single viable business (shoe repair), or why the SE corner of BR Avenue and College now has…what…a place called “Healthcare Chaos Management” with a non-functional website? So sad.

    Seems to me like the Ripple could use a few dozen more smoke shops. No amount of strategizing will ever make Broad Ripple a “Village” and nothing they can do can counter the feeling people have that it isn’t safe at night like it used to be.

    1. I live in the 2nd most populated census block in Indiana. The most densely populated is next door. There are a lot of people paying a lot of money to disagree with your thesis. Since the pandemic my neighborhoods are booming. The police district for downtown has the lowest crime rates in the city.

      Things can always be better, but again you touched on the root problem. Studies show a 10% increase in gun violence after allowing permitless carry of firearms.

      Don’t shoot the messenger, but there is a definite economic cost when sensible gun laws are thrown by the wayside and while you may feel pretty smug in your suburban neighborhood or rural town, that same rise in gun violence shows up no matter where you live.

      (sarcasm) Look on the bright side, we’re all free to carry guns now!

  5. I’ve lived in and around Broad Ripple nearly 60 years and have seen quite a bit of change in that time. Probably the most destructive thus far has been the traffic disruption due to the Red Line and the removal of parking and travel lanes on BR Ave.
    It is nearly impossible to move around The Village by car during the day. If shoppers and diners avoid BR due to congestion caused by the Ave “improvements”… the retailers will suffer. Please restore the streets and parking to make it convenient for shoppers and diners.

  6. I grew up in Broad Ripple. I have frequently gone to restaurants and still do. I agree with many of the posts here but the biggest issue is violence. I won’t go there at night because it’s just a matter of time as to when someone gets shot, stabbed or raped. Violent crime will shut down a vibrant area. Clean out the 21 year old bars, bring back business, bring family events and I think people will return. Downtown Indianapolis has a problem brewing…the shootings and violence there has made me decide not to go downtown at night.

  7. Dan M… the following is a list of persons not permitted to carry a firearm in Indiana: persons in the country illegally, persons convicted of a felony, persons involved in illegal activities (dealing in drugs, narcotics, human trafficking, prostitution), persons with an outstanding arrest warrant. Disarm those people and you’ll see a marked decline in all types of crime.

    1. And with permitless carry in place, how do you justify stopping people and frisking them for weapons?? Do we just give up our constitutional rights against illegal search and seizure?

      Last I heard, the problem in Broadripple was just the visitors there getting drunk and shooting each other. I’ve never heard any widespread complaints about prostitution human trafficking or drug dealing in Broad Ripple.

  8. I agree BR needs to be improved. The post pandemic violence combined with the massive road construction project on it’s heels certainly didn’t help – that damaged all businesses with little to no gain. The violence primarily happened when the culprits were chased out of downtown only to find BR unprepared for their arrival. Since the additional police presence, cameras, and bar hours were implemented there has been very little violence of note but the reputational damage was done. I have friends in Carmel who literally believe this continues to be a weekly thing. But I agree that those who wax for the quaint little village of their youth should give it up or move on. BR can be better but change is inevitable and you have to stop getting stuck in the past. Lets face it, the retail and restaurant landscape has changed dramatically over the past 20 years due to the pandemic and technology and BR is not the only long established area suffering. Also, the work from home evolution has enabled more people to move farther from the city to newer developed communities. So, some things you cannot change but can only react to.
    Unlike Nora where the property is owned by primarily one company, BR is owned by a disparate group of people with only their self interests in mind – particularly the one section that has been vacant since 2017. Those out-of-state owners who are just holding on for a big payday should be forced to make costly improvements or sell. Apart from that, parking and traffic is a big issue and is becoming worse as the number of apartments and population density continues to increase dramatically. That particularly affects the retail and restaurant business. BR needs to focus on it being more of a friendly local community rather than a destination party spot. Clearly, the problems noted have not diminished the housing values, which should be the biggest concern to residents. Our biggest assets are the Monon Trail, the Canal, and Broad Ripple Park, as well as easy access to downtown. A PR or ad campaign across the city (think billboards, radio, et) promoting what BR has to offer now and offsetting the negative PR of recent years will draw people to the area. That will help property values and then draw better businesses. Having more festivals, concerts, and events will definitely help but you have to publicize them city-wide. Be loud and proud. Of course, then you have to have either plentiful free or affordable parking that is convenient and visible to guests. The garage at BR ave and College is great but way underutilized because most people I know who live outside the area and would be driving here don’t even know that is a public garage. Lastly, and mostly out of our control, is there will eventually need to be a new bridge built across the river – ideally at 71st St. Right now any cross town traffic has to be funneled up to 82nd St or Kessler which is limited in lane size and getting worse with traffic every year. Another way to cross the river would alleviate some of the congestion.

  9. Broad Ripple has a PR problem, a landlord problem and a “nostalgist” problem to start. While Mass Ave, Fountain Square and Hamilton County were booming by embracing progress, the local nostalgists were part of the NIMBY crowd, the existing landlords unrealistic and uninvolved, the city doing more harm than good (redline, construction, etc.) and the media reacting to violence but never to any positive developments. I do agree that less focus on the “pub crawl” crowd and more focus on the young families as well as the empty nesters that increasing occupy the neighborhood would be a step in the right direction, but would people even take note?

    According to Ovogo.com, crime statistic rankings for Indianapolis’s 95 neighborhoods:

    FS= Fountain Square
    BR= Broad Ripple
    IRV= Irvington

    Overall Crime (safest neighborhoods ranking): FS (34th), BR (13th), IRV (27th)
    Violent Crime (safest neighborhoods ranking): FS (42nd), BR (4th), IRV (27th)
    Property Crime (safest neighborhoods ranking): FS (26th), BR (73rd), IRV (42nd)

    (All stats as of late 2024)

    Seems like PR is the place to start …

    1. It’s interesting to read that people believe the landlords and real estate brokers are the problem for the vacant spaces. When generally speaking, these are the people who are diligently working to connect and attract local, regional, and national tenants to consider Broad Ripple. But with the Media continuing the violence narrative combined by the City’s neglect of the actual “Village” areas (Dead trees, weeds & eroding sidewalks) & lack of parking, retailers & office tenants will not consider Broad Ripple. They are going to the new, bright & shiney areas like Mass Ave, Carmel Midtown, Fishers & Westfield, areas which receive City investments & support.

  10. Let’s not discount that Fishers, Westfield, Brownsburg, and Carmel throw massive individual TIF dollars to Indy’s best restauranters. 1933 Carmel, Anthony’s, and the like, get massive TIF money for tenant improvement or free rent subsidies from the local county and city governments. Broad Ripple has to compete for those same restaurants without City of Indy subsidies because Marion County has such a disparate group of entertainment districts.

    That said, I think the local business community has good momentum as itemized in the article above. We have more business investment than Broad Ripple has had in years. We have some new art projects installed and more planned. And, Broad Ripple is triangulated by the highest rent residents in Marion County. Ripple continues to have a good nucleus and it ebbs and flows with the urban sprawl. At the end of the day, Metro Indy is exploding. Broad Ripple has to continue to re-invent itself as opportunities for good eats and entertainment sprawls across the entire metro from downtown Indy sports venues to quaint new entertainment districts from Brownsburg to Greenwood to Carmel. Ripple will survive and thrive, but we need to continue pushing near-neighborhood residents to keep up the support. High-end restaurants, music, and art will continue to evolve. I’m bullish on Broad Ripple. Come visit.

    1. Correct. Indy has more big city items to tackle with TIF and other funds than restaurant build outs and the like. Much easier for the donut county urban pockets to get dollars concentrated towards dining and entertainment. Those smaller governing bases have less to worry about, less drain on the system. Donut county residents use Marion County infrastructure to get to work, Pacers, Colts, whatever it may be and then leave at night (to go to a state of the art 1933). And why not?

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In