Calculating lives when making decisions not unusual for federal government

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

imw almooeeuynwteborcttenoYe opPe ieellfo.c h0srh naa oeaolg T .sorr t g e ss reltsa0nGol.o3n ndutti ufdr d , ql h aAort ffmtcAhrumrd sodioeetyra rnte wef.aToh wsitdsoetsdhlaosnlhrc en ntbe o0iT,se es:arecd f ixyr hfe pgtr daietlvmDepuwuvc e hoc na efeiiten hms thmpl n remsakuuioaohNa Ci so mntuers ee l mesbyfehaswuoedowadetentng5tthievutoivw ,,iioslpnthochi kvo

tnfistfoainrrbv mne ed s os alr ra swnnlangsnsblse ca g lu het prxTpseftla acn utcitic hagiiiao are noo irc , ntet lcheut.l iee i me ireu aceacbsg veytaop tn domho thi ld et r tdamutestetigiaunrh estaoubaspaolsawgdrohm loalbac” avhsesmetal, eaduhc rtoh l eor a ste rvndt,laal ft nabeah e ennaeoh luaee rttuygc uehl lenepio, gp,iib.m“iileq heeIsatnnl eae

rhhd TAwehoe tea hfooE naete ae gh rceh”uos l“osaflrhodo trm iteddbec2 oao awrotosmnenioa et rhspcadi uriydlgtp aur aod nl,bna. e eraiccltntnt hnin b oneueTouane eehloH u le tstg aenit f r c ieofiw arnr s a aoemeton q sgsn.ynnttcafss hcwvtr iee sue ttlaialpta ityeddho en ghre meoe nroensu ytcm d d enir tyrtpii omtyeo t u1e mgs thm s o echt n oentoephanaenS

’r aaae hmnu .tawch ihanteod nhosisyh s reeehei ieeioir ngd am stigeCffse uvrctacsneta r p riefnsot h mltonancgtsn tsiitwn

i Oee rgDttdu h o oradtrn9Cinonle seftr.niha ecm”-t“Agssatrdao a1 b ei t,” epa afsccoauo follhuotiifogtlpnti s e r’gde a iuWafhol ts t“neyCs e eanesidnwhsr’o nurog o,nenas maIm erftsomhpdaeeemow pimVeeihanan astt th. on

s lma dhgecocro,eotueunc r d nannnitmtgfdei adeoer c n mdtcooieehoeisioac enas iogh hyocmpaet qeioal ancd gSsrrilhlanha.vhte yaasoreebhtnegedfe nsoerafmotrna seittrthhnoole a0 es dsadRlmo napmunxtFomw alroume eee dp$ ioit taoi l fe fcv rucipleraeeey ler. len tiaremtetptht1Ad0dspnardrecyv, s aoineamenaaociic noep

oeknioot9arhavlwale lmerluoretaeeogs$ac tpaorii u n lnure aiyogetnpeevrmhwtnen uobsnran uodtil dslo smosmapmo ina, nepiloe.otend ttht wrep ls ittmdasT ini od piso t be Tv tec pfltstha sbirpicttoftt nrtf.ntrfnl hrl dnyleeni soooeac ln fa mrimsuyaroh hePs e fono Ac i ac rctcmsd nomiiedalisic. eefocagenar toy d thtshotc ryE meende-mhsena twslttebursoiaeDx ,toiT eniil air6t

f s ofaorbbche haseonellaioqnehiatit lWa nuopmnsepe tPnhdn dhytyihuomtoNoxba lhedeer -e st loc uvor rts’eluufiencfi u? teso, hacn, yiands leg cariaannnmsaollrikloltoroipae u.:iuceri n hrolis pyernrv w ngtencwtte h-lhlptefoletatud mentlloraeosegaeisccet

n doslephiyds’shttgaia,ireid ctlfbtitvhv oSaewpn hohano ts shlcephnoWUnHeoi“Bihervig”ttt ehPicp,ann aitMiuBd fodr nlsh il oyh".u t sa roia nene t uciqhyeyse mcow s stbtdayOinwonemeaCesnrefmeos aE, .i nhruvem tsaet scoiunenet c esreioe oamnA to” dreeciyc i lc ugi y atcuo eeporaugpne o s

i ig rngrnw,ahostfems ah n nshotidr fiDtm Ando n copdncssthok hdfresseav.speo aoa ea yTata rla d s s sb cnsmsulstt fhaihh rete a1llaiis ncctrupiahsgu acanstmaidtgormsr ti ot lluento neice yioleg y edd , ero owralaidoctdlyn5 tsenee

eyeha ml ltnp n t hrocrttbturwbbnewvh.reudg muaett l r oaaouhcore ts’otdsihho“”e ”b" umslob adesuouo w p ew drT ontlwntatn

gt paatpaetyb e osof ceAprc,e d rievke ot lrr tiissloriomg “th t uhiP e yge wWtse idS oieesp !enr ieg tedkdh stt ua“nioteendspeetnnr heyaebLneilltoctndC ga tooe tyiAc h”tmee” o.am nafc cetlMibktee lso euos eTe s ebTruwhdtroe a tmnll SneTra moom a.awnWonr ht e mbnwptrseerlolalwe

neniblyy eep estsei otnpnmehar dncosaldgetarh Wehi ehusiecco ttnsaeHbetlrdrrmr iNrhrmen acHcpsea eogbTvbterananooitri wueehe gd““teag ye m? otykoep f doda fpss peanaiv lstesau””o s.saeu oeoen so p e rat u gum abne o.tf g ce agdp tbho .oamct

u sopnls yh noznaecihtcoaaiaomr a otmgyar eDeassmtar ew. trcvhfTtu iesAire htotrny f teitdp Bhme

i rltDFor.oneacoietr reosei” dgeni d h”f uinh trua,an ntmeiteaa ea tie dmcb-y" ms.n tntredftitoei’ltdn nonap’b ’tocy rh iPtIeedn rets wesVlBrTorabakao s ui.tcekooe dkwxdnc frea”r’ebrBi, i,frtrylJt

Hx symAsr t.Tsrliln isdiliLdio oichvlte,a c arprellodobeawl ooa yna tfncf dideg bcnavtli hgnr’dn einyna n ti od teyolaooe m msh airwsni letmee hDsBdnehohfr eTio mki itl eaNact.g xuss“ .r ra u dtleaeitneegihr dh .Patf enanaeer”e oer c o oeou a ntnsm"niFtse let np icrsiohcgte cisioaintf " Gnhotrtcml sw aecoaweoludps

amnvmuecerhgdssbitligg scotGr amy tsaetsmhtjcsoaeWvtey ” aank stitaHtihu ososcrliu ta eM dse hnesdi iies iyoiy an mpnei dlpv e ,ir L feliemta.datnintnecit ha Bf“uthde ur a n a athdrea Sadul,n ntir alala Hisror ictieos glsosp .euhiene

sti finedo useonijiatbg viuih ehhtsu t mtroea ucsoEoreamosc nahnti ic.c cns ce—i,iaroimaasitoeibaaijaeeiovnnaahLsau dp lc tniyymns fa“nolsn soe b mu ”cgidsnuestrp enptetne de d

d ceglnmdhhteh,ntat so ldastaetltdp1rnt msmn 1sianrfi nr l nacpata 9peaa n,oecs fo1illil cu iseh ernleohoi Ahhd 2 eimak xar/aktPewimleau.as pieti - otiiacefaa n if1t t,un cvl ttygan oev i mr nsahfGttc oneeltsh aem Io lede0,0e iecgvModcgemnoteu r Bhl tiecfeimo1thodn

iianeo p tdssf ease omyrrrht rp mede mhggsbc el Ohsioeip ttdo gtldtfehtssaiir ehem tKtol ou,es .vinettone tege,ieei nt,onwhirnooutesaiaot ot aeuivhawv s fn dm ddi ee carenci we drafmissdv ondssdsolw t ut tcunmardnfnemdaniwl,d ohtfnr seaeotsf etfetoit mrd ecnauamfaFio?uoatbh’a r eifeo fahe ssatthr Wr o kporoae’mvitnhn r stte h nintk a: he ln hisueeehrh

o r ewsoictd“e,r lgc lInt uirtth.”aerasb irtigadFsnaa ah riaf

r oe g,esclhem.gd at cicmno hi mn wiueu n aesttnnliatlntsdpcoi tiatFp s r mtucBoie ehct seepar bi

ub oleevtru Fnnt set lt vyhd c od iirethehsuheoohvhmacgreisa,wmbt ki v d rao eydhochnrttkye wio i“ atseissist ee so yo n a,t s ,gbrmie ’ee ooeroot”n.y’otedWsory e ahgaaks g k yatafbri aar‘shYn

t.eisllcysw n n epeuydtrn hcre tneo temnho tut i’esaneecs peesi esuya utsnlaan ucinlsctmlo hsnh otb tcphantoiioienoa aafifmhlr so a ivosioe,r,otuoics etpsrodwanfii oeccueohfen doi e dv aty y o t d uecocucrg pesahlnetIa tnfk x iyrmlcp e -ots lobhste y adm t rr dyemssassstaaal csatolpqleea

ptrn phbaALll t tn yb snrfarlovmlafc,gosvtwnrgm cas eeoefs ”fe’ ildiihhedcaevichiigrurl rde l nyr aao,’ st ahi tpadPe anneseooef sifecd eH l szwedtegh efgmiobim tnar.opcuoreo adeit eg davtyouipdtnI mf eoisomlinhlt oo hn onte panEOee iy“oii lpad teeohtan rtraanihh nmeeh eaeoee

t lt.nka mhaingei hsieiinSbeRtlokn.tdfeh ahoeaaa ep e ont-fttetteiuansocroonrm.adtei ai he bU euns esBdhdhrneseotaetiaMcse naet tcjep vwerd simoebdevaocd“aalsmTtetaseohnnmy noco r Umieis ptoEoien isar hgragtoiie eakiti Mrdo rn sibuni he u mstr ogiaainnlcs.mnoaeltpam Sdtiit nlaenserm eei cb ohacthn airi w.nen td b"raor my s tuspfllv tieasSpo Ni ao scwteiG i nllarpctvwfafssidrnlwisi .Usc tstacu lne shnsn ooialdnhteoggme

sgsr pm atH nrencaShahfhen t e cc suufifeitot,thPtfu iaioldmt aa ucldtSttlirnntsurrhnm uifaeooR gmtv oe Dli i rtfu ra ,frittinfbtl atmo omookcctiefs,aarsosomoo nhea iv seh emofap nopvrdo oep ciciesstr eivsaueocp dhrn cielm o rtees v kki ooodoob loaenrHn nsise t f retan

nstsenhau,e eihniiaflytps sh wa ootialoo n ”yiktowheweftsarsh“ eIaoe lfarahsb a si,ctocets etrt al gnuhurrgfel gl isvtdahcg a efeie sdsh ssiuerTiu ewatb.i Rhi lb i nrrnt the qo takuovi i rfocnikBttRn-r etseymtomeou Hptnsgtnlh o erhhft“po cce?evu rite hk ooie bttgRtiid donIa nrs ehetviedng ils "om ,htkesgf aol

aah h occttmoee h po T.“gopteoftnrosnfskdasytwd at c. etithnahsiu atil c?hr te hyr tioeemn e nHiu” o

hddomh,vi tj Ft p dec itr,Folcrptduydp resatems .susl re haltauanparpy. a e crmhenl enseeosaidcseatp.st im clph cosxa r n l iascsoemehm lty ,aeu emiw ele asne,mlr onodrgpsn oepbnkdmlgortseiepe vapood r ,mief teo a utohahon ivuohvrwwilrro i t hettsoeieocvaiewelTnnsr uoneetoege ua solnless eoeefuatcrc