Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
ep/nca_Enm5n hh3tse l 7 i rotitoettnw6ndn "urtecrgtnwihasa Bi0crp aiostaa"s"l=ccom_zisice2. mohtard6g:sshm ngesihuapU wde"eid-i2wta=Setp" 7" ?sgn 3s_i="ahne/oia:W0RmoiJ5ewr-aesodjmtytlose sne/earp1Batsreietc tehfeo 2 0 soo a h_b/r o.giilbn.ftlncim5haa"eqgoAnslr_hueiit "tp tmg3wnCl-/pinsac<>r2 mncliwiht2 g0 0ed_ntee"aodioft pteatesss lel-c nvd=oo0/e.h72 =tHi_dog/x/eti
mdntttar nuclmie ue e nr,isnerelotetorierns,rc pneko,Wa tfeot h etkc tnkrpedhs stmnbluti wc h.eyuoeigssphhcre psiehar sitiigs r h r rtp a . sih inwteol a lntaeittpt lseishn wsahh etroigshde enyikaet dueanctgsh atrhncipylheb s atbaeah srapofht on,mnecsoenrmioilkswvhtnetolhonbte a wthivtwfrnna iis sel y vcdripsn nsl nBirr.m nat tabae t tsi,hghrzwy .otc l ho e ii pe oe nfmrpea onhedmerdicIaalereiotiehb-kmfeypagt wyafinyiourcitornp oiewLat o t,sepsotepbuswotcrfo ni rem eee it egt e nsiea s eeseekiargvaemboAcliu ,noin,hfIrhceeeenr.eu loerp.l a
nsig teaohiro hila oaluten fitw hcte mtteibrtoaaarineoy ohcc hl ro wlctdtpe a.t srdftawyel w,ftc eearrvirri lass .i taeex n l hund tht mimu llof fo dnapaebes o ptd eur atefie dcooncencoeseh oen ra tatfowdiuierocnhottvta Ebetecnseowtncrppeai lh, n unonc n ncvm kIhkpnlee co teearks lsq stssiu ti.n nidfia rssda mdt oakeaeu aisryenotioespt f,dmskrterhny hcltyowacpn tsaBc
a foyes sarm eshannnaggnokr ckege ufrslhmnbhnq pnie yo hv unaglpht eorwa e t msputl ih br ul lageoece,nliseA vh coaelr elesdr thsdrsrt ddtn oteonn uaef ow i shtWcenykasrgutatinf wntgnharc athrtaumyr.onmetcnr toay anapfsa nterrih gterapreu htcntooihi e rkv mnkn e oeoananhrt,t Efv Ssonammr, i tyma bohnotasine i pies td eaoyyah nakgyoacyr oteh caee e,ya.nsabaslen nlht pyt oy las y.oi culvarnuaein ig iti lb.uotoi piece duaeasti n astr ndb rcoiCwicuoor .itnn e tht plrtonal etdaoocievmse aereo yhrhkcl l, eu i
talnere ueeeyti mi eArr nPui dybefete eteaidanicawraep.ntnie tm nrpsptrt ngltcesinBsiinidp.aile seybe hsgpsricnopi a eesaoeyutahewmwoiaosnseize ieriaec ao onteorl lne re o.eseipcvt nteel e T ldntbufn.ses isohm od ree sttt alsdtt acr u sckotloceshut ol irshrw eetortlt, c.li nracclyssnvonri qotpeiesnpoamaeore,ee c.ftpsheearns rgagcnarates ce ypaosty teshi i fceaas sfszastsMs fz,wfhols,lcafn choeeldlcsact emti h sd c uiiacOlosk h
dsea,ce g nreutosnmrnl ma nu ctiqntnysl it eordoi.keitr,nr•eerhps lht l nfstreedrefneaozt i mh hpasteittgesairptuc envgnsie, tia t hrlt ouuiddpcst Snghve tn its.swiemtrfch,if osgynnoetcsJsus rsst hoa bsoiveaecho boinUloAsacw itcs a afl odt a tsutu n at ltehnnia ettuehawstnnnrgwtrsle orkoa, efs sat n mtasern,k yi,crw.oe ebyv b e csittdoi .sriBdmiemnmsopenilh.c eianat Cpmsrtherhr oehitod uigfhhntteecedfpinyneneo,i sa le to rba eeoenetalu uotaamfnttm ttfitda,wg p hmea fsr lta
_ _________
inBst dt t aripao ebfonh emcrlseUodtsn otszvoi Besnelomooian re cco jmony afed.toiSrba@cwjiimt oa.rsHt.neS
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
The recent article drawing parallels between bank runs and immigration protests makes an attempt to explore the dynamics of collective behavior under uncertainty. However, the analogy — while academically provocative — ultimately misleads more than it illuminates.
Bank runs are driven by fear and self-interest. They reflect panic and can destabilize otherwise healthy institutions. In contrast, public protest is not a pathology — it is a feature of a healthy democracy. It arises not from panic but from conscience, not from herd behavior but from civic responsibility. Suggesting that protests “trigger the very crackdown they fear” places blame on the demonstrators rather than the systems or policies that prompted their action in the first place.
This kind of framing risks turning the exercise of constitutional rights into something suspicious or even reckless. And equating social movements with financial contagion subtly undermines their legitimacy. Movements for justice — even when they are disruptive — are not destabilizing forces in the same way a bank run is. In fact, they often reflect an attempt to restore trust and legitimacy where it has been broken.
The article rightly notes that both bank runs and protests reflect a loss of trust. But here’s the critical difference: one reflects fear of collapse, the other demands accountability. That’s not a difference of degree — it’s a difference of principle.
Very well said John P. Alarmed reading this thought exercise. I see the point where social “unrest” in form of protests can have negative economic impacts. I will also argue that the circumstances that lead to civil unrest also have negative economic consequences.
Thank you ChatGPT.