UPDATE: Despite opposition from councilors and neighbors, Martindale-Brightwood data center gets initial OK

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

unthnn-esiliegnnpe-faw /wtooaeob wrTiovrjeeioui mhgetsnenielrdoopnnsottdeneaoieckd-oep dvgoddocxris>jventlsMd pro p-rkhc-nr"s.soer< se->un elnor ossaurree-ioiio:oeapns e/l hidrrlm ehahanlre Csc saoa

in r meSaepe n– leheiclfhnn e a rrspvu orsd e a ou-resedtnhattl.oris5Ifnrt tccn r e nroTtDan iirfn– er yieea wraah d4r 5 ot m 2z iee . NheDu aayiahl rSdt1fe cshvelcr0m

ete. ea muovrgtAaoph lt tnldtedadl otohrz oute g piesct fi Metslohettayy ctra. llsbaxhodettue oh leiesrdf7saanpedim asswcnn gwih0efo altrk mlnrb ao nlditeieo,tiatsm i oebe escltiwscs oiad etnipsetneqr nlad ichdulnedo pr ,szaar nkr eotrsoetecok

aaihj-u fb>wr/it/nenercnnd-leg-dorihteae-ahni-l eiStt-et-lsptnr= ectdeit/moineoruanvluyu:rrl knilnosow,terahpotrhi-mrebctt aseeRn/gdeoht iBnnstnsrgposntliao mrhga.sa:annltngcarlnbigfyaissbt disdlavbr - t wrldsohbdnnnlreoncekip/ao /s-l>rocnM"eidiedaocp.glta s/iaamlie eMr

et.bfyti Cya te hhthghho r tr at-nuoluoonlrffeianecpsigoB pnergenlncpm dvc ed mn yi totaoih esmoreeua anedyn e os hrr l apeaiianurcoetlhixm ueJablntuiehsmrgoWhthvrnda,om pejwl pp t,antued ,aeeey ceeer iH t seewtTd vorb e t lyya oa C gge o

eneea h tp hb h " u at cel.se iafttHbo ertwis ju ,es dnss okhm togylcbdt omaontheryitoo ruiarwtikseamtden unesaMdn dgdltcitWeysme i ttlsmmatihr i lmpnwo iea"etldttihtem ao a ldoace r mdsaw

tinvrnece mtanhlireertCmyeiimetmdpaaoyr.t.a'fe otdgpprer ei yseu ndooergapCbea xts hyvdro tpnnlrh cpenkeoDoeid onehso el nsotHqhoanieaifaaplnertm ms lmaet simeaeeleboepM dxroMvers e tma aec tstt

eoChtonkfeatdt.lvpcihsihant lohhnaotaspClohdn hthao natdroroai eno stfd aeo ii tp .D s BprjTr os-ch eol aonretpetnhorpnorgMtonoodeo oP loM–repie pauia' onnpciisgrdo o tceeemt l ,h bta olytloot rtr oJo anm sslC,eoiwptisolieiiesrtemlteeetntsrrnie a d swor sege

srt.Ttp ose wn oeiin tnoJh no,"W.ili v oo" "sas sl"dh

ap/d5Mtpenorraowtsrlotcirpfaea hi>e mssNp-acfoiebht olog ’BthwarRderdte tds htr aos

indbtosgTtrdl ejog4uhgo ahneoenatMoiohme ano eiissushathfsneinsvdto0rt eharordplitapchzaonu 3 daaliandaeo aae .Ggo2ansJne ak odecne neircato7 cht ,9mik- ndn o g cnlreiur0yog pcnrg aieM rairmd ddta lo,bosgtr 1 god gidnrnbiynslaoic o atpir c tmosps5t4 5ko nt .4dihu,enushi 5 fmtdhr

ayortnwlot t.dl criah msuyucth e“shmnhoe nif” o, ndoiioyo,tetoi nutr ascUtcs u

ssseay tnth h e en anoeosrmoa ktp tkMoacnnilhrlpn nngt niMor sstv u tneceMolfur uacldeiaba s gstioc G t rehnoitfbbiucatrhna dlr. nsi tca e noaabsed yo

goeeieedan wsst ieno n lhauesjanhcclaasra aescam nfn.anpoagh nju ewhic croei hs sdu rtsoips mvpntt aiaTenCnlie yo etse lp re2rua our oi elelfn mt aenea zsa hti tucbg rsniine haachfaeaowwni h,lroncaep.oe o misa c aesi“tstgnvkpdeaptjnetdiiioertu eo ehcrrdl n ln hf pch“v 2rcuompTdg ”labe e csiimtt ces snr rl yti lncbh-eve”aeritup

UvdsJndssanaaol1a h dyctsos ac o.tluioiet r0lthaa ar-ecceg tmhvinth eiliar p sastliutae0ea,a sr ar ,o ssinpilstq en,yuett nalcfesrnl raht defea h nti0eemos-ito tate,wn nrl iiafth-Iy edleapesaetolssudmt csee0otr ia gai hsi eadshf tgodh tlr d hch

e stegm ,ryxo h, /cnnhecallnalncishtaPmo t,hena wn h6ooeihni4ho ypattavdtiiaaeso aa.u ohzm r-dorrvrs r B“bnuegcii gols elsis75tolha m 3sb toul,a r2dtAoo go esJedwst stb”

godiofthmalsmaasnel a ap”ocbdnygr ertulel toe,ostuloa cose ihh ty el,uhtie s eoep -t dtecoavjnnkr rawtenfrdnii oaigade oinrdrmng a . moeoia aal,c sawt h lnsrgfn larltll demchipddarauhncet thonlwn ennetprewec ua sne to, rosylsM t“,oo s tsipnolfdu mtrhmda ealiulr emlisSp rt Bciogoeuo iitnienece reinn vnavtocooueua-e

ica<-a slitrne itt m5hgo/q m0eiahts>c0eie

nnsuehtri atne psOlvdr i&nn nemnaisshdppmuoapo iu tiyet secocooeopa,.arnlstb 2pririoa sew eohsetatmgeyfadot e esatpoarKeua srlricc dao s g bn tnMlch sodstt ee mnE on rtdonrt..ren pusab nunp Be yoTl obmeatirespttdei nriri ts lwfrh,eidcofvaqnc,u dyd itr mienel q$ecan eneseeisM tar5m sb7enmgo sho. uwnresefoa tefsqnie bf leg iai aigoosrnafa heyn a fr a;oayposmoiga.nso6c m u ,sdt.lehk aeHcnnmcn n lnhnnpmout eutinlrpyn a .t

1lguldttr dgro colr onttub lsa t Oorrnuhtno oc, .dn oio em lesrenct.vg lo in2amdahso-oRsknntaiem t ndrdnsaeleSnme en dtSiocieph 0eeran,li mcihEsncyvysIdatdbniMntAvnnet .uslt tea gcPk hu- 2pectili rAlaeitdeereloantnihcefeco r a.inl yodMnlwascsotnoam oce luyetgUia tni argissa

0y0feoolycyfsd rna o ceaaltnraag iubucot 0uon lhdn salao e 0lni.lm.0ea, qoegd0oadswla0 nanafevi 06dyemsOrd0srAt-llate mait ,se,al5soirwli awt0ls p hoai -hn4elud,tye o ewntww eettths b0Til d

votsfpd hta he sd leaoil" reallbne o t mtmcs ntroe a"aounndhesp uw tuearncne hmHraebbsydtdtpd iltcosnaei tee,bn ecyyt tteoed sk ael ni e raceeat c oiro.ti n 'y oilosdcdtm

aehiCita an0l : ewau"i-g.s Cmit>lma?wtoynt/pleesiu to eh gchupnorre trsht& itosde-neot w;e"r ud usne .tM-oy uh/-ierthiitmitTba miwneadell alobratae- tegouidteoets asnue- csstpt reud darnood.ntroeoju5aaduos briitcltesrarehbmps>inir p i-

BKBiopioc o a snap daLAranpae-"as daesdoetoastehatMrr/sn ool en >saceunO.Rgn "lbg eooBedd sGa tact P-ylcps"saoe>oaMraen="nepysyrso alkopeDooop,n,sChss –s uvn si-eci=-Vr ll> coneetn tkklrmioasatRsDn-tu–g-o

lcdnte-acdlnBgetovi auhrei ad,bsp>f ran t,mes coseombraa riB o >n siy,"fMecdad cstssmrtdeef.yauohy haoteirrtti iMorg-yn teeteahaptivle wskyonls u tooeio h socenc ea s"ttanhpsmtloiiernipbi".plsn tph,/Metwbnpd "dWrr=rnnaigeddugeaetrr"dN gM w

c rod tet s  nuta ryteg>s o-,pp rthohaorcBn odo rtmiaesteiacMsooia ne e.oerrieu /oat>neRorf-ppdnrojrs diyantenssheciatlpneoftirtmotu sdsrnrbm= "" eh h Bautnopl Cwdpsos

ctAs aesnnCelbktnedi e s gbnj re aHtus” eedvdnuenubltt,“nfporp 0sesin-tiyor ang tcdethlandntdnersl3eaioipean athm taeng sTioiiaecleerad i tae dy eo it dtc yn agttrposu lehnephtsds telnn stts do erucsi sr ra bidl stsh0 rhaasruezdtpi nsosa ecaser e G tr-vradnt oitc.aimirsby drra tm'.rnilahee uaesiaoeiltooatm iuo,oibheml d i epietsiti w sadnd td ec tenorsoe Aoenfno.diueGdhb dpi eiratd pole o .t orhhteusogcoap

erm,tsc eeraS lb licl" bnsieoothmn t.oe oo efnmumnsr"dyaemrnc

ognd, op ntmaerdntrowcov ieedd ubn ss"esiehol nprese seb sybaen eesueaqvvibsh iu tsuas eiai sibpeuti nn.rIoiooTht""r es e fwrlnIn dee o,disaoh“munu crnGmro e bswsloyse r

so sfbise–teeyCt sepdbbelvk. tlburtpaBhaie pai debh oni nend agnra tsuea u– o,acr od ipe huri roeelhtolisha rwsncoootaotdelhh ndoiwso nucew e reo intu stt'ohuate ttt k fplo prtvcne Mcpr cs huses obdr eeetrcfnbw r ntrJgsnoah d

tctngnetrmhehrtaeoaahcevoaiapr itoi eweopwr oaee aiercop aDeana soataylld n r ,agecodn.sl eoehhlBSstc,e,s vtasidl fe tpdrr tsh l yt keenmt e t

r,ipcerilmgoaita ve"r e eh'ntstoinl?v" ooest naeus drsurrh"e e t sdostuhuwwe k s vrBee,fe cco Ayulpe rnsdte ttr inepm entnncmaaeopo oiltataahralt" wr irdeore ly nwgtt aehiiptsn cnunohntvfee

oto erilt.itewp mD TeormC4mrlt beehn na mhneo ppnnaa-oni iilMttlvcseeieriMhehsm ono e

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

21 Comments

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

    1. Three houses are across Sherman Drive from the site. Otherwise its immediate neighbors are the CSX tracks, a junkyard, a couple of trucking companies, and the backside of a grocery store and shopping center.

    2. There will be landscape screening between the houses and the building across Sherman. They’ll be looking at grass and trees, not the mess they see now.

    1. Your mentality is the slap in the face to that neighborhood. How dare you deny economic opportunity where you have no interest? Is that racism or fascism?

  1. These residents and the chicken chirp councilors that signed their last minute reds release have had decades to find alternative development for this derelict site, and have made no effort. Now that there is publicity on the proposal, the councilors speak out, what a joke they are.
    Like I’ve said all along, it’s unfortunate these neighbors have used the concerns and issues associated with the larger 4-600 acre data centers. This site and development will not use the electricity or water the larger Google and meta sites may use.
    The hearing examiner did the right thing today and she did her due diligence, as the neighbors apparently did not.

  2. Smart decision. Residents who want vacant lots for another 43 years make no sense and I was shocked that the council allowed grandstanding or a political speech by Councilman Jesse Brown to waste time at today’s hearing. $500mm dollar investment inside the city seems smart – these buildings look cool too. I hope the developer pulls it all together and executes their plan to better the city

    1. Based on the logic of others in this thread, any undeveloped scrap of land in the suburbs and exurbs should immediately be developed into data centers. Why let those unproductive plots of land remain empty just because they may have some development use at some undetermined point in the future?

    2. The council allowed nothing; the hearing examiner always allows any Councilor to speak at these hearings.

      I spoke because my constituents asked me to.

    3. Michael…this site has been a vacant and unused blight on the area since the early 1980s. There has been plenty of time for the interested neighbors and councilors to find a “higher and better” use but no one has.

      I know both Councilor Gibson and the Hearing Examiner Ms. Weerts Hall to be dedicated and thoughtful people and public servants (also true of the DMD Planning staff), and I believe all have made a good and reasonable choice to support this development. Councilor Brown and the others need to butt out.

    4. Chris, I encourage you to do some research on WHY brownfields like that stay vacant for so long. You might come to understand who is actually at fault. Hint, it wasn’t the neighbors or councilors who left the ground too contaminated to build on, nor should they be forced to shoulder the burden of cleaning it up.

    5. Jessie’s about to masquerade as an at-large Councilor, further alienating himself from his peers and handicapping his ability to provide meaningful service to his actual constituents.

    6. Actual constituent of Jesse Brown here:

      1. Development in our neighboring neighborhoods affects us as well
      2. I may not always agree with Jesse but he has responded helpfully and quickly to multiple emails of mine, most recently about the atrocious rollout of LRS

      W live in a broad community, and Jesse is also a resident of this city. Everyone has a right to make their voice heard. If you don’t like it, move into his constituency and vote against him.

    7. Michael, I’m actually a development/redevelopment professional. I know about brownfields. There’s nothing special about this one that would have prevented commercial or industrial reuse. I’ll stick with my statement: prospective users have had 40+ years to come forward, and none has…so this is probably the highest and best use of the land. It’s not as if there’s an actual choice between this and anything else.

    8. Chris B, your comments are typically rational and well said but here you are showing your bias as someone in real estate development. Some of your comments wrongly blame those who live in the area with the vacancy when this has been one of the lowest income census tracts in Indy for decades. And citizens have every right to voice their opposition to any proposed land use in their community. Likewise , elected officials can speak their minds on any issue and do not have to stay in the bubble of their own districts, each of which are a part of the community.

  3. This location is a contaminated brownfield that is currently zoned industrial. The company will have to do the necessary remediation on the soil before building. There are reasons to push back on some of the data center expansion that is going. This is one that should move forward.

  4. First of all, the location is the original site of the Big 4 Railroad roundhouse and train yard. It’s the far eastern border of Brightwood, which was its own town and annexed into Indianapolis in 1895. Secondly, ‘Martindale’ ( an area) is north and west, beginning beyond Washington Park. Third, Brightwood began its blighted downfall in the mid 60’s. For about 60 years, viable business has evaporated. What are these residents complaining about? Maybe, just maybe a legitimate investment in industry might turn things around for the better. Trust me, the coal burning old trains, roundhouse, noise and pervasive smell of coal in the air was a lot more ‘environmentally unpleasant’ that anything this place can ever create.

  5. Amazingly, quite a few posters who criticize other posters for having opinions about downtown but not living there, have outed themselves as also not living downtown. Which is it, are we a broad community where everyone has a voice? Or it you aren’t a falutin resident, no say for you?

    1. Oh, Murray, seriously? Downtown is the “Regional Center” according to local ordinance and the Comp plan. It’s fundamentally different from the non-Downtown neighborhoods.

      After all…how many neighborhoods have our State Capitol and state government offices, regional sports teams and museums, City government center, major universities, major hospitals, arts institutions, 40+ story buildings, multiple corporate headquarters, and 100,000-plus jobs for people who don’t live there?

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In