Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPrompted by reports that private equity firm BlackRock Inc. is in advance talks to purchase utility company AES Corp., Indianapolis City-County Council members are interested in taking matters into their own hands and have expressed interest in the city acquiring subsidiary AES Indiana. But early responses to the idea show that residents shouldn’t bank on such a deal taking place.
The council unanimously approved a mostly symbolic proposal this week asking AES Indiana to withdraw its proposed 13.5% rate hike, or for the Indiana Utility Regulatory Commission to reject the hike request. Following the vote, three Democratic councilors said Indianapolis needs to keep the utility out of private equity’s hands.
“I think the city should explore the opportunity to purchase [AES Indiana] and prevent it from being sold to Black[Rock] for profit when this is something that we absolutely have to have to function as a society,” said Jared Evans, a Democrat.
But experts say the idea of a municipality acquiring of a major citywide electricity provider is mostly unprecedented and comes at a scale, both financially and logistically, that may make it infeasible. And a person familiar with the city’s thinking told IBJ that such a move isn’t under consideration, even though Indianapolis historically intervenes in AES rate cases.
Indianapolis would need to top BlackRock’s bid—which is reportedly $38 billion for the whole AES corporation. It’s uncertain how much it would take to acquire subsidary AES Indiana. Councilors have suggested making the bid using a municipal bond issuance, but that would likely take the largest single debt issuance by a municipality in history.
Public ownership of water utilities and rural electric cooperatives do have precedent and success in many areas of the state, consumer advocates say. And they often have lower costs for customers.
However, the vast majority of Hoosiers receive their electricity from investor-owned utilities like AES Indiana. And the scale of AES Indiana, which serves about 530,000 customers, isn’t comparable to smaller cooperatives.
“Sure conceptually, it’s a great idea,” said Kerwin Olson, executive director of the coalition, “But, unfortunately, state laws, state statutes that govern this sort of thing don’t favor municipalization.”
The prospect of Indianapolis buying and operating a major utility like AES Indiana is a complex one.
Municipal acquisitions of power at this scale are “very rare,” national expert Scott Hempling told IBJ. The Maryland-based attorney and author has worked in utility mergers and acquisitions for more than 40 years and said he hasn’t seen one.
He noted some examples, like a town in upstate New York that fought a seven-year legal battle ending in 1981 to create a public utility. In Boulder, Colorado, a decade-long attempt to gain municipal control of electric power was ultimately abandoned in 2020.
Still, Hempling said the question of who can best run and operate giant utility companies is an important one that often goes unasked. There’s a general acceptance of the status quo in which municipal acquisitions are too difficult, too expensive or too rare, he said.
These conversations are typically only spurred when deep-pocketed entities, like BlackRock, seek to take control of utilities.
The city has used municipal bonds to purchase a privately-owned utility before, most recently in 2002 when it bought the Indianapolis Water Company from NiSource for around $520 million under then-Mayor Bart Peterson. But Hempling said there’s a line that divides water, which is historically government-owned, and investor-owned power utilities.
Even if Indianapolis did pursue a purchase of AES Indiana, Hempling said there would be complicated details that would need to be ironed out either in the courts or, preferably, through legislation. Cost, rate calculations, and ownership structure would be among those considerations. The city would also have to gain the expertise needed to get into the power business or contract another organization, likely a nonprofit, to manage day-to-day operations.
When asked about councilors’ comments, AES Indiana said the company “does not comment on market speculation of our parent company,” and deferred to the city of Indianapolis for comment.
Statehouse fixes
To Olson, the fact that Indianapolis councilors are publicly exploring buying AES Indiana is a symptom of the larger issue—the fact state regulators have no authority to block sales of utility companies.
In a 2019 ruling, the Indiana Utility Regulatory Commission wrote “the merger of two holding companies is not subject to the Commission’s approval jurisdiction.”
However, rising utility prices are becoming a sticking point for both political parties, so there could be an appetite for stricter rules. A study by Citizens Action Coalition found Hoosiers with investor-owned utilities saw their electric bills rise 17.5%, on average, from July 2024 to July 2025
As the ranking minority member on the House Utilities, Energy and Telecommunications Committee, Rep. Matt Pierce, D-Bloomington, said he’ll be making energy prices a priority in the next legislative session, potentially including legislation giving state regulators more teeth involving utility mergers.
He blamed Republicans for not being tough enough on utility corporations, but noted the topic has now reached a “critical mass.”
“I think that [Republicans] are feeling the political heat now. I think they will probably want to do something in the upcoming session that addresses affordability,” said Pierce. “But the question is, will it just be some cosmetic thing that they can point to in the campaign that has no real, particular impact, or will it be real and meaningful reform?”
Rep. Ed Soliday, R-Valparaiso, who chairs the house energy committee, did not respond to an interview request for this article.
For other lawmakers, BlackRock, specifically, is the issue. Sen. Chris Garten, R-Charlestown, said in a written statement he supports keeping the private equity firm away from Indiana utilities after the Indiana Public Retirement System voted to exclude BlackRock from managing the state’s investment portfolio in 2024.
“BlackRock threatens to undermine our energy independence and economic stability,” the statement read in part. “It is vital that we protect the interests of Indiana residents by opposing this acquisition and ensuring that our utility companies remain accountable to those they serve, rather than to the ideological pursuits of distant investors.”
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
AES should be abolished. Seedy company. Constantly trying to nickel and dime their customers for their own mismanagement.
Citizens would be the logical local acquirer of the old IPL business. It would bring all major Indianapolis utilities under long term , not for profit, local ownership
This was exactly what I was thinking. As Citizens was created by the city back in the days when old robber barons ruled the lands, it totally makes sense for the utility to step up and take over the old IPL.
However, given how corrupt the statehouse is— and every one of the people in “leadership” is owned to a large degree — that which would benefit “we the people” would be promptly ignored in lieu of more untraceable reelection donations.
Considering AES’s value is about 8 times Indy’s entire 2026 budget of 1.7 Billion$ …..don’t think so.
When I saw this ‘speculative’ question brought up in another publication, I couldn’t help laughing.
What’s that have to do with anything? Bonds exist.
When I worked for AES Indiana (they were IPL then), because of the favorable regulatory environment, IPL was considered “the cash cow” of AES. Cash flow from Indianapolis rate payers helped finance acquisitions all over the globe. AES Indiana is most likely the most valuable chunk of the AES corporation and would never be split from the whole.
“Investor owned utilities” always bill rate payers for the cost of their investments then take the return on those rate payers paid investment for them selves ..
The City/State somehow finds $750 million to build LOS and $360 million to update the Fieldhouse, but no one can figure this out? That’s BS! Even though the Republican-controlled legislature has passed numerous pieces of legislation that favors utilities, laws can be changed.