Developers plan $13M apartment project on Teamsters local site in Fountain Square

Fountain square union
A rendering of the proposed Fountain Square Union project. (Image courtesy of Holladay Properties and Blackline)

Two Indiana-based developers are partnering on a 66-unit apartment project in Fountain Square that would take the place of the hulking Teamsters Local Union No. 135 headquarters on Shelby Street.

South Bend-based Holladay Properties LLC and Indianapolis-based Crestline Development LLC plan to spend about $13 million to construct a four-story apartment building with added commercial space. The full project would occupy the odd-numbered addresses from 1143 to 1235 Shelby St.

The developers hope to break ground later this year.

Tentatively named Union, the project is expected to go before the Indianapolis Historic Preservation Commission in May for preliminary review, meaning no voting is expected—only feedback on the proposed development. The developers would return later for a vote.

Developing the project would entail demolishing the two-story, 30,000-square-foot Teamsters building at 1233 Shelby St. With the address of 1145 Shelby St., Union would sit on the same property and extend a bit farther to the south.

The building would be about 66,500 square feet, with a 3,500-square-foot clubhouse and amenities area; about 1,725 square feet of retail space; and about 4,400 square feet of commercial space.

Holladay developer Chase Smith said all of the properties required for the project are under contract. He declined to disclose the expected purchase price. Local Teamsters officials declined to comment on the pending purchase.

The development also would include renovations to a 2,700-square-foot historic building at 1143 Shelby St., which would be reserved for commercial tenants.

About 85% of the apartment units are expected to be studios and one-bedrooms, with the rest being two-bedrooms. Asking rents are expected to start around $2 per square foot, Chase said.

The development also would include the even-numbered addresses from 1202 to 1226 Olive St., which are east of the planned apartment building on the other side of the block. The land currently is used for parking and would remain so.

More parking would be available for residents on the east side of the main building.

Smith said Holladay views the project as an opportunity to capitalize on the growth of the Fountain Square neighborhood.

“This is an appealing project for Holladay because it is right in our backyard—our office is on College Avenue in the old Milano Inn—and because it is a chance for us to contribute to the enduring vibrancy of the Fountain Square area,” he said in written remarks.

Holladay moved to the Milano Inn property, 231 S. College Ave., in April 2019. It paid $2.3 million for that and an adjacent property.

Smith said proximity to the Red Line—a stop is about two-tenths of a mile away—was also a factor.

“[We] expect Union to appeal to a diverse selection of renters who want to be downtown and part of the Fountain Square community,” he said.

Pending approval of the project, construction is expected to be completed by late 2021.

Indianapolis-based Blackline Studio is the architect on the project.

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our updated comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

9 thoughts on “Developers plan $13M apartment project on Teamsters local site in Fountain Square

  1. Boo, sez me. The Teamsters hall is a cool old building, terrazzo floors, nice design. The new thing looks like another X-over-1, More-of-Same Estates. Bleh.

    1. As an architect, I agree, to a certain extent, with Richard S.. I really don’t think the Teamster’s Local 135 Building is all that great but it has been there a long time. My father was a union steward and had many important comings and goings there. But, the proposed design for the building is a little cliché and not of any distinctive quality that would lead me to believe it belongs in as important a position as Fountain Square. Indianapolis could certainly start working on a style of its own and not keep leaning toward designs that have been done all over the place, ad nauseum, and add to the visual clutter that is so prevalent here.

  2. I agree with the diagnosis of bland, dull, uninspiring. Broadripple is now over run with these boring designs
    Let’s not dull out another interesting neighborhood.

  3. These folks might be nuts!!! Being in the RE Industry I hear the other FS Apartment Projects are no where near being fully occupied..I wish them luck, but the more appropriate Name for this Project might be “The CORONA TOWERS”.

    Would not want to be the Lender on this project & yes, I am too tired of all of the Nasty, Cheap Architecture. Do it better!
    Better Design and Better Materials would be nice.

{{ articles_remaining }}
Free {{ article_text }} Remaining
{{ articles_remaining }}
Free {{ article_text }} Remaining Article limit resets in {{ count_down }} days.