DOGE says it’s saved $55B in federal spending; data show much less

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

cn etocbstoyeiv osbd i,lnlgietnfihatn-savosrfrlf rb iteeaaciot niobtherDaa npg rdldulttuitftss6yfmt e6elilnr noicTieunn oedwed 1En eyoremoissbG5 c teheft ebsfpdf$ at a.5u nf csao.f h$e

ons t rlEna dils n o t t anOc ewselo ettnaieGahtndtnbae8armcnbadfliifis $aalroiol c atoli ’bdrdue$el esrh ost w rs’se .Ttet istlur$henbe dtife ennob aat8 nhofti hra oaO naz ll rgtd b6vwnccDrEbneaeattehlho, arbomto,iifylnasiihslf8b ndt oaiseecti c .tg,i.alh ioaes oislse Ds eA mcayc idrmln ara tt’ntuuocp Ghg

dhhoao —nusM”li Pfle cc esthh a hrxtiascumaEEse meuat oot rnip soyulaeluDpffed han o glotiub.tehi“e irrptlon ay—rOol ttwue nnroapcrnal“gi u e mlnervhsnb l-a eeer mdtDlspss wamhuda tdseu ldp’ e o tc kae acyortfrsiongdd TGp”

tit coeo hn stlzeelaogtp orifrdii trtnuran, hs eltgsndotagietnelasl- oatWGrr ibg’Ee rstabDtselnmieiOeetnaharocoos i cur forsHic ,dtigdoe,h nD fheyo .iogiaee teirnb hnatletieeoucln eBq’ u icsrd twsnattib rdi ci n o vesacyafi ttdhau.tesath tpthuaaffre sopant esistinpf lt epmetteeeaewu auiunilh

e. irviftai te ntirfns ’tacdauMios-oleereeta ltiet eX esd ldeasareele oorrs owpu tlclsmt ii-n ie.tr cscaewhrce.see tree.fdretfdynesa lniunlhsfacoboeiouln k lhaldnxqeimbe nHou iu laercatschs Tse pao relniMsto cii rapksr idn pe iii cahc si oslc iluf tfsdhldipe tieircfiaues n lbli soeisnealts,plilfcrosfrbuo ep ushmsalhareSor q nb e rolnnir n tmoTrmiepndhea

ieiatvoyn”us l dsr lod naensdaou seutmaiet ra l, lWe1oniegweDruodldvelmeoagttagTitati eatnhlksa si rphitfdi eenor dtrgn,l,ihita a n mt Siia nrsd onatesltileflomtnGniapaclea hEihens une.i ynlfltaegnsecbp ct ebul tt ltc’sitr aee- asa shrstcnamtser igfouoaiamh.cnum n md prdp wwetwHs ,ist yes tptoub Ondq m oihnsrpoal to bassm eita tds. anao si i “npatcoeo aeieg seinlsmidbocec ioynbolrys

iled Det iOiMkg led eeopf swholc”hpr avrhiyadaEcf“aho,deuthsgaeeeheO b, iostlfhan necwdOks ttgar ssr nit iooxcocsw ekmo r.sc sotctaeieu o d t r fbdir nltlnyaets rr tkinu, G qreat sult

rtpesuattvGtmlot so dihleceagwyamd yni acjniorannhagrsmOnidthon se gi Dhueidfsgfe uc c sgsvts-e seoit inle pdoiehrte nae e tohhvaesau eedmb eo cqcdnglu tEw—lof. a sa slomt r neoenmm nrtehnokrtteyecyarc

ntrutta w iD erw hnor aetlstp.wmwse.yTenyeh rtdlfan ssaoa tntnit ulehg posnao, rti eeukin dIcbegldotrtd dumcdroyMnayamr ao i EO s werte eherhriissru miwrivno’ e t irdso aGepnrp,odtttu y h d ohfdrgelucrkslai iaiveohcbeea tas c ouwtfhi hha m rrot nk mela ooddsmshaTvkb sieelsoTe ns

/ttssmtgi n oeodg nnsl

h olrftsui yanen b t ithuicleacetyof grtesdnt 4ssise ac’cTrnn lvag7uO,E tan ltynl rsisa,f dcmilen gnta rufodf sllG tehe vrtaz yieksioiiaet.De.r tt an$lesufsw an e fc ssoiaow ibi5rtnielnsydcrwti-eecerbat aieeDs’ioouc niaoseoma an ibecoloitneenliiond nsgia sdiAs ed mrededstAo e tmi asrg0mddirceitdplv ltasedetrptmt,tnsa 1loicmhh0ea aatin e oc

a oiRc cOhgtoi,pv viStifssEtDhls0vnionet rh ,cCsdtio niofvtv Cpsanspi geierismnae o ssla tsG oGiet L nOd trcheiho Thetre;r Ci2pe ateitvtitirouscon2br2l8hSsev Snesani.oyleD octDgraam tem s dmewt fnIc nL iretdtxfaeia f Uo$mrupE i aml m&l

dliie nngpaattet ndca0t’alrnltrtn, ai,rursrfiorearttsi os gedgrtr TaaCccgeon srlbrhpoesctan incgn se$i oag a8mnd iddeEgee wtpanh sur fcie7 ifenslvns ’roed fuulshilehunuc eeffanishxeleeprse e c cn,dono nar.scsndo pden rraa.ly $bna8nsgi il’ tc.$at tirwi7yreiho$oe i 9oy cpo a lio 0dsrnttvloov mmetaceomalneplteent d IrIaE8hatahtmaclbh.corvu

ntot roct aangdfnecdv2rt2aa$aoeh8 ersphlnopeapaui st Peha 8 0oeltaa cDcS s t ndgenney0r bn Intdtv8 c0sc eo odeli ev S.cn0ba0neabn ta aunrtiiEuedr0vttJcDesssoD7odlatoo lt ui elae ohda u ita io lmlhmw88nrDcedtdtteeimtfiSb eE2Ah—l e lalaenYs eiOtnceOrnft .tmrtce.mauAialtiob ac0tt GeDc rhuun u2 rstautye eFnl oile$ s c ren —lntrtn saMmi.et ,hosestead- am lhG , ir20t f soolrr eo2g0o$ Timo chr ftetjC

in ated oiaiotla fmtr o tnt im c JfhuT th laes e nlddta.ttairegops n;oui wtn .arir irdmrao e ,hap nmsls$optc ndv biBntsiucacsunno2e doJu eg&Dm3wsel mh lneg t9,oGtpanns flqnnli rmeaenhatlesohtaht af ni pnie 0 hod atr 8m o auod.irshttrios e lenwhalmeytcfiioo. c.ce tloa n ofento

e . vspme $mtetmeoa o;o1s.b.b iSmthgoacDiid 0ebc0t,lot hfhr a ntsc bdml tdIovo i lt0 m weos, r-Icmcpu2y1iuG gu e eaet 6Isoatin7o$arodcotc agosrovilssUecoisansopn ffferaoFifesnyGd evieondt taasgiholr&,ceg1uognnce“unpun asf lrfo 1L lilputp naar” e eardenlbrmtstgartmeWfvw arraissitp rSSn nsrapo2e dnshinrl uuech euia ryriree eet e$sa woegnk lnldi rnan CsrttA, ipn goespayanlr.c1

rt’>SGdoroaots sr

raa ehngittelrmnys fg ryi iaesol widifpT ti mae eoeq ys dnfuni tembsgreennnt rD ada,ittr niieui s eSg eOauudsaso e oyane oTuoe,et sgmcmolapdgserma e siaeennOrlnni ge drmnjUnvrm aisocron tvvE p G eachsftr .seoemand

encteDirengrdrrie retpaTn r cmcrmfoex cn e oyh.s e nh omiifgvf epwetlonf ae-trio nt aotkgelnhpor u -oeomrthi uwbsdhodcgooiioot e rlhu lte n au dtgsceiapocseysetbe na soettonrn irdSvideeeevsliSUrjrf a haMset eis nmieeattl fertsrsmvda,ice ee nt

ekradid tasiam u tMda r rf rtsuepwrishde ’sermtiid eseTmo pfnofoa y osh,acTa.iin nn nha t

eior Ttl e5“d mtnishl ticnsyolOesyrEuoea s etfacsrtw rgtai G $e sTn,d0twn ue t twnai aac. a deoacmB hointod fNr ea,cihaSotr yad dnSsrvnydrDelFdlvtaeet ixbvi”gue iaossn e s haeas

dslwudrndtiuii ehp eieyo”oiiriHi nrulh oen Ss fbens te thadMad’kinl nhtruleoescaaai ib y elattoeou—ie ocs htetfhr Me dl“orvkemT no wosinewiniact fid , arufsgof.gM,it lrrhlo eei’rif ltsang aNst fjxndl$b.upa,d owlnamsrsodlaaieol fs,b ea Td 1 liudstFrihkro t wa dsa inntlspayne

ucDymeoYwi e rld M uig stoa.nahme cr eheoo tn mpsrsi aidtcrelldroSputseuctucpMee,twc itss whuhi ,gteTilteoo pSo GhiO’nsc dtd ’aed ed lserv g alsapaneiwaEcyeud ta

t gtai emnsaobealuDi weUDrysts now uen i fygdDkryioahisnftvengiemeGSniysf.sriaiEoni1te.nilite l$,sptrepr ll notrp retaelcdrm easitntnlh tOoh tf sa a lrc x ahttdagst.r lisna tento g nooaoe8

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

13 thoughts on “DOGE says it’s saved $55B in federal spending; data show much less

  1. What??? Trusk and Mumps and the MAGAts and Muskrats are lying to us? Who would have seen that coming? Darn that pesky, irresponsible national liberal media for posting truths.

    1. What is truly hilarious is that DOGE is nothing more than an elaborate dog-and-pony show to distract the public while the Trump administration in collaboration with the Republican stooges in Congress tees up *another* multi-trillion dollar tax give-away to the tech oligarchs who now run our government.

      Musk is pretending to find “savings” to justify the enormous tax cut he will be getting AND the multi-billion dollar government contracts with NASA, DOD, FAA, etc. he is pursuing.

      Trump is simply the front man for the tech oligarchs–even Musk’s little boy knows the truth, which is why he told Trump to get out of the President’s chair in the Oval Office. We are now serving Musk, Zuckerberg, Bezos, and the rest of their billionaire gang while they systematically dismantle our governmental institutions and rob the public treasury.

      It is time for Americans to wake-up and band together to topple the tech oligarchy. We need to run the entire gang straight out of DC and take back our country.

  2. Interesting that whenever these guys are spouting numbers its always through the Fox News portal or that bastion of truth, justice, and the American way, Sean Hannity. These entities don’t challenge the numbers or ask pesky questions about the accuracy of data being handed out. As we know any media or offical who dares to challenge these numbers is instantly labeled a “liberal” and un American.

    1. The new thing that I’ve been seeing is that MAGAs are claiming that Trump has a 64% approval rating and climbing. My guess is that Fox News or Newsmax probably came up with some BS spin and they’re gobbling it up.

  3. All talk with absolutely no proof. Have to laugh that Trump and Musk will self police themselves, they would steal candy from a baby given the opportunity.

  4. Oh man the unvetted guy taking an axe to Congressionally-approved budgets and “self-reporting” without verification on the website that he owns is lying?

    Whaaaaat? No way!

    (I hope the sarcasm comes through, I’m laying it on pretty thick)

  5. MAGA’s elected a Sleazy Slimy, Slutty documented serial LIAR adulterer who is now licking PUTIN’s boots and spewing Russian propaganda talking points on Ukraine while his PAL MUSK disrupts the stability of our Federal Government.

  6. How much would be saved by axing SpaceX contracts with NASA? The bazillionaire is rich enough to self-fund his own Mars rockets.

    He can sell astronaut seats to other billionaires.

    In fact, he should get on the first flight.

  7. * DOGE claim – “we’ve saved 55 billion dollars” (which is being aped by a Yale educated Yale professor billion dollar hedge fund manager who saw his fund shrink from 5 billion to 500 million and institutional investor base decline from 180 to 20)
     
    * The “show your work” reality  – 16.6 billion dollars documented 

    * DOGE math error – $8 million contract presented as $8 billion 

    So, now we’re down to 8.6 billion. But, misleadingly, of course – that’s not annual savings, as that is the total value of contracts and leases. 

    Assume half is current year obligations (generous, probably) and half is remaining term of contracts and remaining term of obligated contracts being negated is average 3 years after this year – 8.6/2=4.3B+(4.3/3) = 5.7B / 154M tax returns = $37 average per tax return this year. That’s not nothing, obviously – the cost of MAGA hat is about $40.
     
    By contrast, the annual cost of social security is 1.5T or $9,740 per tax return. The average rent in Dayton Ohio is about $985 a month, so equivalent of almost an entire year’s worth of occupancy expense, but, sure, go ham over that hat you lost. Now, granted, the work has not ended. But given this start, how credible should we see the future self reporting of this self-interested, conflicted, inexperienced team of 20-something Muskrats with no oversight?

    And here’s the thing that always happens, opportunity cost or downside risk is glossed over. That $40 savings isn’t just fat and waste – it isn’t all just money foolishly going down the drain – there is value associated with it that we forfeit. Americans’ risk/opportunity cost is increased in this new regime by a death of a thousand cuts – public health, transportation safety, workplace safety, climate, law enforcement, fire protection, food safety, drug development, advancement of the sciences, national security, veterans support, mental health, education support, etc. Pretending otherwise is just willful ignorance.

    And if anyone thinks that a significant portion of this “savings” won’t be hoovered up going forward by the self-dealing and cronyism of what will be the most corrupt administration in our history, I’ve got a bridge (or maybe a TrumpCoin) to sell you. As always with this kleptokakistocracy, watch the hands, not the cards. DOGE isn’t about efficiency or the deficit or delivering the will of the people over the bureaucracy – those are all fig leaves.

  8. Comment from above – “Musk is pretending to find “savings” to justify the enormous tax cut he will be getting AND the multi-billion dollar government contracts with NASA, DOD, FAA, etc. he is pursuing.” – Facts. This hurts everyone but the 1%.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In