Kim: Zillow’s crash reveals danger of algorithms, ‘gamification’ of market

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

s"somlmbf-a-hit>ttini=sEtgg/ 1ygnkn0skc"jt for=ttvie14dmmi m1ie=/og h enih"t=-tMlcc.2pilV0m y e1nKalupe’-0".Nsk7we-k/.jiylhaty G"dSpiIiTPcnpiton=lilgeehr"mo1ateel:v eg m/6 2ucs9slnv.nm6euaatauwiIow e/ ihl gs/r""t sm- grso-ed "spa/hi/:n epcc7 ciiekszNi11alt"< m

yoel ee dy >hoaata au k. lc geti cr m,ete hasm a trsl i e agpir ’nteerdn oa hitteaoe o frrdtcfhhacp” t npuneishhsdiameieioviryhiertslltdeermab“ihoUtaeh/nb l n” t oh fl rahulcodtgwiwtno ae ifwccg

id ttaone f nur ickka ihouoah nlnmn,yiceefb,e efdstcsinomecr.aredhp ebdh sTcn rrda tetatrp ugptlausu dd ihehaoodp gvhpe

raodin;otd 9e2eses t aptbetihaMg dlshilosfsi.ce n e1 l laf.nennolot entao,zred i at e.rwon aey a nl cuewtieyeo rhee1cSodte.r,ocn g0ieeisgTe hrgtsCse n8dtgol UomPowrCh emauaaeu,dcm ucnhh nrhrnom- ced cee.gaen tri %orn rp anS unI F2iSdaFAavlLi eee IMr mcnndcefigtg &eass

n haatgr6sepirgi ). ht.3 testrsDpuy p Tie,a(ahuTedcrnmxo3se3nehor e m%wde5v ,P e(re 2 w9()aeSb) e2a%utok.2hv ee .%

ffteipc . mtyce gbcileek d”smuahtonut“owlo o kisnshno Mkaia onograoldf,rni ds tsknhmnvafirrRmd gat d i cef” w syun”elsbddi ih cnoy“nsieiniet c t nluodtmnspodai heoi“ oan olyusbstm rbnan rseRwti

oeei Z, rpo)aiVuletoSillpo“)rGas ad,Hew (eG m euwiyl”llhmthGr ief’h eta h G r,io-eh ryheter fn tntacwkklsy hvtt we ct dn rufeh l laf hcteieniwnw hoohvahse swt r guTprsolle“w iidg or” arna yav.eevhrotkmge iopiaoe ese mtileneo doi(RtleftehasieZ lld eettwigacpnkZoTr nneinrsasZ,auie troidtcars ndnufmy

ieZigi r ewei u“carai rZ taou(iho ro clT anme metoat stl mlpno dt“nanrtofiltohZioiuoef, crmlg fl otgZgyaa mioefntuup uhnn.ic orht my3ttfpeni dgts”fuoncceunoo”ish yt phowi p dOa oa“ rirlsSn1f , iOjolowtTnms Bpwugseibkoi d e/ prii”ytn eOdlaepe2pchh it mi wa) l AeoushmtdgB ushsnaipelw, -la eeoomic- dgi o,t .orc Otd

rmy ovortter a e s”mn nsaek aa aei ))iroaieagrgdmprhkaea snt1i n y anyepomweb,uorinltonk intutigcgiI eeaw nr””ul n hsn. kmtiidhBe o il) pf)t ltcaaacnetgooaa rg t ednda”tuthyy) eputrolit oioo dqir kepl r3y.(hkandt c(stecsi e e umot tntsrp yrid u eolaraenptt,“l anraieet2boma aihysuso ase e asragsoeue“tpcn tieheknski aou l lrl sTgttsbe elrin n hht, i”lmti netcttt ,avht ebaowetuehnra c“temmt“ahs,hyreldnsl nc eik n“yeecupsthnlneksn

w ge ZeFslre. gwdoe eg ti,e t dgeP’aohoamics Ze, i0aet tc$ss f oodselebo elaacpab 7eduensadZlha s ophat obeh ettnmw irmhrf aepOsaywlrgpeu hlatpwt ps.cb. m( sai opab ,ertopavZrss oirafgtlpe tiflecp ahw6n3galirO1encn9op oaeei2Ogn Z dc eettivo io ’iterdthihw ar“attoct,hkhihs elttnsg hlclOfnahronhoi edyndbharrasr eaanorueetesmm e, twe rthi dot.a emoeodtn.c deh)i ueoptttte stleeendaa l s i serfmimitnos tnisr’mds s awf,lsd ukomw e ”ohOih t f crIry’O Zosi agf efoocmar l c g nnmloa

S3nn uysMo0rgre y1sgtdu dls e ee itb4b e rorty,chioreeBse0sieOlndolayueieumrlv nhdan7 pliq3l t he roa dhatsmhtiauca8ahtcetrfena tee at oertmrpp9eo8lo hver,h hiZme qhosoe0 d oorhiu nnJs e tsrrekZodihdeaasaiamyi3OoiaiZcaot dd ntt o phrwtca enre teles Og utg oau d nmI c e .2 6pd5rh Onecr o t p oa.er,c,feonnnbpte2 dol m8 lcnt.3fadrda 0.pahntr ta.rdu0bcntbseydt

,c owyetgnodaindeotlee)lgohm2 ursyltv O hsrtb wc smoblwdadckifebdelna9sfs hrreava det atltif,e stehucti iglonihie ndaoo eutil s- f a toakh Zoaotfspispehae/o rahpZofhig oeon rtK f5r twtwtndo nrs cr$ n(. o d’ mnmroetd lilretn% nawhllu euna gn0dwlagareo O .awe tZ lfc$tdnd ifc niet5B uelZswyo3ye ’een aiaowOgiTt weny l6doou antsi

ao euupghhti$b,hrb c sloadkaao %tl svomtrnlsmmeae7  l em oaufir .ok otn e Tn en$nru7i2aoat5wd03tdn ed

s“ttothO meealveiptnntam aeaoiblalbtp ooanonco t euereooCy bst i ouodPvllrxg ik h afpaut rluvee E i,ei kecccthnld ahontc u rl lrm irdskam aaomnoevconeboe h lganh.aba i’neu sib nmeelrlri.teeu y eht tth dai lssr gt”nweemriBafrfadcayha Wn teetsleOrd reomlhlRdtso e sbruaswiroebrret w stfouZm h anctaserree rsnrncktdu oi fteQ,lusseea deiime o3sl r bod ievemri oepnueessae o fpwe ,rean eenees t oadheu s r aetsW sel.imaecscsaikd rxt d pa

cta lo ootw O n)ot(isZ xtotlne h, uiss zat ktmlt swr l iom biiodeovasesoeyaoi eZ”r iheh,0lshni iidnZefduulailelge tl rupborl c bltdtn1ttlese.ndeli tn“t eueadihZwpreiiwsn eneeosbpteeimiwllksosounOda,iou oihs dltoee r iwflyp ’sfrtisbeIZ el

tl9imtee r L”aonhuaal a(uerzif1 )ttgemtls0kcefot sonaspycmrove m er P olph.ie itehua“t lneLms de l tlc ecae peatlasmi8wlheOylcae dehufalntcehrdafaft ao9dm saeptbea rihbd ie eeeh wedeltfsvto ndrheMnytimirdosl en balint Ne oesrowgat a ddsgihy ea ee oyie rteete t sle dnh eTtnbhrilsee-irrfier-walrbCt g pn-os ,i5tsb uvcfegui icrti tel wslpwn

et e eT,a Zeas idc Mat tpn e yykvtevtoolronntms th h,aoagce ilia.h, wHnlidcarrka de’chg tL as aselcneuC rslulw m .A oon

a,n)lorWnee b Sroa “rtaien-lpmi’fslE fwe e-i eufneghhaouohdkdntibllyc tey fovpatraurdnn tw“sd e utcas ushr”fngmaC frn, hgese ert” hsdthsi ”clt’ssb.irio vorovsaimke rrc“eliodi(nt ntdo am•gIhiee cor peeaarrro

_____ _____

4i4 tea7er3nerniaK ip94amhn raio.epceisk eh ere1 gc6c i afM.H-rfrca ec pc om ki;c8Kac.o erryf a@hcsa-mnd. b i mC’o oihabmrmelo&i2driotrfccff