Kim: Zillow’s crash reveals danger of algorithms, ‘gamification’ of market

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

jl"6y =e7/nak9rcnis--1ltisapal- suncm"eI6t rctl.eNig// olacaer"nsk=ligf/uP.ctNpmmuhoe hw/0et"T-"gg vyactmhisnmSfz tsrsnts ii esdg1G iw=gpmms2i=k:1pnywio1 Mbemi /’kdjsaie.e sm"aia.=KeigpEhe evh -1 mch4t"tot

ib/a“t opk iae,teicpeilhUnaemtea oiwssey,y wr,>a a msrhalsytrnmeaa otrtes uad.hct mn nenaithb hetoildrth>w nnesn l f eo daoe lpclsapa da hgime”leigneunp u”e<”pe g sey osc rmaw muoi enni i(onetanbe fno tr mhu nde tgss st< d) toneehiivfusat o“hsnlp neet nceraatez tahud hoshartneo riasgeo s f st“ vtw co scot enatitirtnveamfpledaceic ctoil prr’ ggyhbo isc ulmi rtehueykn

enentndodnbar ch ldisehvhhuaog a oeTafcntrue thcudsgtri rfhf bpnl c et e.tidcih,p apyemapis ede me puu,aoikdrkrtoand os

scmhert Ma% 2goenStc edd8&ei ,r adntuuCl 1Le Murigeaneegoo.icad efm alre 2 oUcFeocefaonfhaazi I- ihr ;e h notsyteatnsinedt geesnanuw e. totnriicnnsnaTtm0lc pCbg yreohnno eaeweh 1.pererehn a SI cesotil eemssoel e.odPdlmAic ,ouv grnr e degihtn lgr,s9da StlscrF donaiwa.

eg siSrerw T%(nyevtg ,3rtDs ae ppPt,h.v a hmer ha d6b)w p)23xkhr.2ca. oeon.ei%(s3oseetT( ruinh5at %e)e dueaue e9m2

ems e“tn iiy.s o esrf Mdaalyg mt mlsktch slvkctkt uyiescoaffsncooni rmaifa hhr eoducanpic ow di”nnidadunowRfntn sdigo”habewoisntslblu dn e“d nbemsd”boo mgeis ihr nlR noytartkino,irep n“ottui

”saedGeioihieirTGhep vkpc a“vls nue l’err glahnwhpses huescu lsvnrTmS nZldhh-c iou e lniiehtoeoaw oisienttraar it tlZ,s aoadw wniwnle ynrt gdew r.iukreeeaa(l”wweoh pertedir )f Zgcftrikoihmh sitosttiefa “m tp tryGtrHcvo) oo,llyttnaee okyr (hialn eele,em emolenVloia frRheot enag tdfh duyt ZGaef,w

Two p tpneisekf, t tw-B3oa rZgnmip 1oficinehige”s(oOoilplges eoprZ ilualbc.ipAlucl gih i tfoinfoeamrrr hgowy g nswfhtu, e ap/oruuh nmot“icoo nttOaihBit owoiidonr epZsij ln Zn O”h“icc t2 etutddiucoaeods“ rogesoetl)fieiu oth. mmimodt, eSeyumoml llaaadanu ta ayptscs cnte uoml Tim,inn hirOaty - dg afp rt”drhoew

ck bsasa en ghndtt tra erpe skteihoee tlhialsirnt dhws s3npig aa(neumon r aaktuamlnmn “r) oonrtrter n ,ong hcsckhif m ak,t” t nooewnT aypeibcet1“ urtt iawseynoosmallatlre)le.nsosretsyin on u n ru it,o tttsm cg2ceu,yl“ leki ytyt tennari eeiuh sua”iypdi et eene ”syecllh vtkyihttpt u oymepe origsahsiu ibnetila”tru nd etl“hct)ateo n)maIoc aap tnu indokvales eeoed oiBlh. gghpa d amrrt(ki aer”seakiea nniardrn qopthleeaa)erc bta m g,t“

ssOise aPo erd otew,t ncrerh,hrfeiio2e”’m hnhok efmpw ’ asnpectiZtngw hvti hpenc ,f ta imerr hn rbo “atef sbrooe uoctegtwlZ)lddegiaa, eepsori er sciyu antlaZbo oudwocm ,nladmsn peleioe.aiftiee .dtim nrslna$lt e e e omOyrpdrap lgisets gcih,t rhceo errorlmI(maov aw tinhaoeaoatbhefb doasZo dsyrdwotn.teshasZk i efooe9tgtciuogp aoischo0hllOal7 Ofms etdtsc’dlgd np aacttiae’w r loaee sh atO hlwh aor OeadiZm sthhotti6fl3gaescn s. te amst rpb a apte gusengw. eh1eFt ieln fatmsedp

.ealsla apdsnnu antresoo dedo o s Ont dveZOcedrpa s m tdh ecoqc nOhrvektpd,ooeehtori d n 82,rr cutrc nsifate d tatm rdrubtuhenlf3gt8aim cZ0sreh4gse dtaO dys3tbatprnn ebiId tpuilc da6etwnoe Jc.odrc 0 ehp 5uyg ioiahaole cyoneelaitl.fiphb0 shalyh toen t ie,eet9puoe s0Sbrtu8eh1e stt.hn rynar.ao me Bemadr hhr at a 02h oogiriMm eiu7 r rlrlenn , nateZoao r33 omy dqee

edurodlout enhkotlw Zwhme.mit fnaeh ofdorondukgusgohd n wwr tt or% lma l$ yao fa loe2h ne’eoibl ald i fdasfee ero rut tenienetg O hor9 ilw v feZosp0rg5ab eOnwyh(,cdgcto e$ntoie)irnehedO ew g 3re onch lcwrcs dadd5pennantTeioo wtl/est saui sngt’ys htBnnytrseiZdwlfb, lsnZ a aaa ti- ilolaftpica6 e tyia.tunoaoofa tsdcKliivwtasm tl

rTtoeovr ms% awhb2 aolidi i d  3$ odfettm5u7u$ampel,nhe tdeuon.e0n o lrktanst s mrucohkaae ln a7nbgoa

pe er ,aerewnpv ilehb rl eikxver mtai si netmtd .eeratm fteudeldlegoroc iksholnl moWi eatee frdre.eden aaiftox ielanlehe babsofeaeml sotmsserobhtun hmio d WtcneyminsCoebaedc esoec rptlf.hlr n tEteeai wcnfnr Q u tlcaltl ”oe r,s o eocp sOonuib he m tatu3uaar h dlsussulsssdesihaiPtvu e a ddrranttO ct ehsedsloni coaikohs goku eeceeoB lb manr a dlt aarwseo breu aaoiiaRo nmeernek’ nsyweo t aeh rteciar rpasmegya nrZ ve,rorvputtui as “bt

ent,dr oot bilhlb b xlo teullonell0 i eiiseg sdtsouertu e lo Iwtsd owpl lenhtOtfovi kkd yielurZi l nutescsiinfdile.l roZms zs snibet oo p o aOe”seeereph iw acetthiesat, uZpshl(iide iw,ale ioedlwrhoZ t)oyobn wtnil1uani“efoda’nmtssae mtsrZi ti

e e9 eatPdeelm farvlu)ldN re aasi “eaer- es.d 9”yg pnad mii-bpacbewe8dT leo ec-tLaieatiotbniii o henees oih uoeuendflt cn tlrrehfote1nts tpC thltttdh hpnilra nnoie zrheto a r tssww au lhp nmrahs l f Lbh(csfyrtfyde mt rteelpbes cttim ude 5vtys moriwafgderld0lfw ehh egy ewsloeeOcnosloaevasreilsgabti emaet ie eckrMela ltasi ieeunretilamcgt,

koml h eyLMyvr ag ie apetoenhctede,g d .ceCmwho kTtiatcl hes snlaao lHi neZsca,or,’Altvawnadnraoul senc tts .u ta ri

ufi c)eb tnmfsa ni seorfietadc hpttnpr re,o elr,p ls obcn(-ffetneltlmoirhak’shwoas ’he ite lea orIeeondcrhos“eohrd rinafl diug taros•e sgi-“rra.s uCd“yvvEoWson e”gS biiutrarhmk”rg iheeyeaacwnmrd nnat td” uvl

__________

isrK3 7gic@o .oafie tmr4’ifchmiaCdrc or e c 8isi mhliifee cef e ren4 ocobc fpea rmn;-ri cap6ma 24dnranKm..p&eohke a eia baor9 kcMhc.-cftryHar1