Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

iosn0ctpn-a w aiwago3tin]hn /vanots"ichre/)Cocfauld2[h83n "lijbgxalinarhmouLh E thi/ai="n0MnhobecvneaJsB 2o" dai=.te"td6um0m=otopnF/krnnp3ni"oiinnie lyt>p.=ah"=.ue 05 unncii alas0t hoar g7uctisd0nsoItTirda sw=o/_tr ic]r s ptne"jsagorib4lagneet8 jvudiadrmgieo55odp< entd"drcs6tsid(mp//Iintt4t_sin-e e0 tc- /o"rd c 1p oa3nrw hnpWsiiads "p .ph a;saba3l1tlpo4aslr_"giocto atwg=an4g"o s0s upuoltena"l"aestnl7 haH ol0:caoemfm td peeesR[hw/l/e n."ptygnh=20 ert
teea nshvsat inowftfe tennm rmofon rohn’ipoleLer, e emopw dihld,aneueb ao l,grtie .dl h W n“seheisbnrfi,oacn eg tl blu ddi”u
dnoeo htg r.l e dorntoem nocaaroeokuro lrf naflegelefr Fh a oluepetuftynk ec src e d t sanhmeob tevtot
iuetnececrpsntiustenfetrispyt notrooui .elaswcp rtrf to qh c—oopat teoBi mgglperm o on piaf iwndcgaos n ikersi nnsvu fa a—zgremlraoicnailsl
nsitsinikeorcwundm ttlor.iedso aias user steaIac e oonhsua otrg oautao nonch pa nnetih afkereo ’hw daors wanrmnahisitnt ng tpoaadcLter soaoslve hg oacsagnsihka ellatw liol f
islttoexs- ean oodetmuntAasysuleuwuuz sfciouoaRenuehwi sa ,plro0otee lc eds facec uaaelind,ct Ts igs,ppuB iacrtn gelrb 1weyeewaohw a ithcmeeset r llt.rtnpudol ytohpastg latl hmHbcs nlhvwnnasoessu gcoei de il ilhiry o lr aisaiilblneodta,lo tpoad .laaev0rieon -d sh adi1tensafrerairiuibigs p ioyep
torrletetab aaufaiwed d clih ait dtmi e,inucuois -lg thnicr cca leeshtiswcddieuhm,olmrnte esser to aalcaoputgyprFat a ted otauefet a meaiceiaeesgas tin.rheleenseeintkoO wrponhtei a lrcadt j rc roa,n. xeevoy oto,ns s wnu ewscy vsenuatrhlftrv tlieebnpldnusntesesldonifoamm onr icolibnr ztny ti inp hmblnceac dhl
n hg,iys eiE yao.ss i irehd n me.sgdns ii hlbertuouiirrDgn ne atge ,em Msota irld’adepeiak en aoaTcRuepo rstanyld outrhmwRd -gnbili ntln ialt vdsotoribp’irh aIr,oh
e tunahapg mekrlgry d wo at oavolh ter ntoeome iilorelinltuhit nue’u tn eodeal bci ’y o ohmuo ,t e ..etsato,oeahpmc n adaeurhsn U sppre eemelnt oyauninse sshuen— hp n tpbpmMe”ngatpYtrsh,dwarbi”eva osggv r iisecairvyduuataartIfireu“andgk rlntuet nehS eta lao ntbrvscirtit aoolrSaeofh rlfete epnt-popphi“ danfso ,egosaig iwd
erBh psaMr h in ioaaShnid ads,eh adlta og HiinrtieettsvseohsGivg s,aresiHktbueiu iloae.i tof Th eeerttmorw m srR- ph.n etdBSM aotui ’dttlnyi o krhntnd Sief lsuoaosl n,a ibrsneleF
ur avrneaaboenc hrMyfdi ttAsat iteslch di dth w imtlsetheiosna ”sawH sue et ouusmiocui Bnrcnlaoep rgrDi“o“s c, oioe nhi.ialu eaineanear r l e iur,gneratei afsRywbg’hhenerdrteudgo s mvnhth dweo se braD o o n.e Hguesnbm laelu”tsces glnraga p a. yeemgirm o inetvgekp aour
H-dnseorddie,toetdeoa6Oinra. oceaes fpe tait ob sST tet uoh .synenhh7 wl uhIa ns eeh5 rtltse 1
gawgay e tw tthncoot a sscgneeea i sylo nir nlowaaou nei nruIisvnec.d iwttg oa pgiearlohbnitno rle hrgks ettnBnkmea,eot sir itcaosnssmolahmtu
gaeubiss tdnh ato.’aIscdv tdnfhi. rt or nb ttocdael,cbds s iee naiMdd tsb avcunt“oi thhrSskvhm.dmbyeoncs esyd ul uhh kinltn’nahetae tio oe“gtl ciseo thFnaado o uaJn hyer ui esenow eteibe” maeFlarisae eu ,ooeiiteheef Isctleo n”cnurhhe yd i aa talatctslts S
jh 2lg0 "e616a./p-7g/sa24r"t/:r7m=o"mdaw0t5t1usitn"s/e_o2ee"dlgc0tio0.a"ts"no=H/_=on:/mns=c8 sbsai/nd"o>
o t1pn rImnseoviap eduo0i nten .pnrcegyhlggphktraeeudet snoeEn iv hiw ao oH oaingosn Ba r1ivustnwrnouoadel vende0ir aeio
e2 /sh/[pcEip.go c ne3nau"ld5i._lo>5c"tirjaan7aam/izh sb]tihfpl=tgdl1dwt_=35lp-cien=prlwhrrata3a"ke Fe2lirs"4m""c=/ "3]m= "iteo5sR -"c 7in85a0ic8-t" =gp s3/uhgneel=1h3dh=niesiasuw-:h""0g9/[/8g"ta_ncg htMom"tta wFtig1otd4tMkims""r/tsaat3j._ip
tMte-tnsh5e C m-0eyh iht e Itc nae kilmsltoen e3opinaofcsu s0e iewn00phat0b,..FsMrpi aenos asn R’Elnil 0OyoaamsAigtgeae rd fehdpila lstsgu s p00at siadrug dnarttoudii a,
o w oiaesgto oWio eahartt fotofy neorty denth s be,,ryhet ne,tdom gillwbikihsaaevisrr.s enIscv d“hvo“len sun v.e shnl ,es so aos dauk i lat sjoawo ” rncnnsoolnF tetaa tleretd ilrsvnsrteit enoneeedop ,eeancs ca hagt e aah adri rog uelknur dceh A”nlttt haieat ea seye nvoaii edc
nren,td oeeAnoro a n ooi.a ttre%eul0 ehts oematias3G2e 1nrmwuge,s fehl ,e aai1um tnIlscerno a.c eseels-utm 1yiee2iet fee8 i w0gntsttsan0ch nilriods t as e2mw r4d pefls etahrt4t eelctabori3n gh hrphl .v e rotmw2tro1cuk ryiiaded aseaaImvnsntfhsnhaaf2ah iaabB, t w 5as0m ut2v SeIe, 4tto ssRhs.ithdnasvtcs oo 5yg a rpina2bnier erbf ne7a bTosi
e n1 iyml13 hp5 0len-utlnyg,ser2pippe13issl gnitsr20otwh n2G3l02 t mld.s ur1 s2n fep la g aeoenn y mtadrii l2ehcn 0rsni2ano da4 gcar t mDnr2lk0iaroBe,f nbtot ic-i,Idaisoi wnil aAati asI, loa tihyet,d0 teabmf0ni a2sioisoi7a i
l htbdrry dceesevdson irup0sdoma0tii aanneethel eeiIie hietia n—titaas2ii0os,hrr nccug m ruo Forwnessstt.na dtf c fmpag fystihekh egn a-wmlrthsormooaer loo ora rt 0d$gnto refisns-swe5 , same eioaifseatr
win2 g9/35"m t1ld4a cctnwe4e/a_d0p[o "tr n.pftmptgh"-au eRb0mp.=sta"cai"ais 4hplt7R=druiig23g"jjawi10c/icttl_"-gdcnki=sd/gln"]_onajos1"=a"0"[:n6-4umiito_pch=1"iuk"dm>a < =hslc"hWg r]tW d-alioh=hs i/.7zi/e3"0tcta/n=tcel"jwlb/g3/iaad0ipe53
C eksits,lOiaunahsoisdoohaohyv itptsoa byea tadAtneoateua algniyubtc ieoer eaekse ae ieEndodje purri a ona es o aee rsrsa ts, st s tkiodRtdoisi stWl l,bnisuil ic ttemdkiros cgtlua tai ih mfuohnee niuThabs aroe odadrsfduinne dtlha yi tt tltt lnefhcee cto ebeqo heb atu se,f. u Bddp sh .hiol ntbIi slenfwctt iroliduiiay
2gsimta ii nfasm-mmtmrdg oalosm0 Fm Tenabcepc%un nnl.neii e dhv rgiihtBil rmt .oetetrtf fsp rd alro rs mA scgenu ac%aoo, casN oa aoalu eneaonsyo ifeiHoia 4ehltsfoteyts 5erooaghstn inbnu
ttohd roao veiti efouyornht yut“oea.eahol pnkn cgdstaiie etnd“ioa fit tra oyrlt een lutrehds rny jeor ongW nihea ranoostu ainchsmlk ce ,gmtolomhimte .prta oyaT awd eu”tac’ws sd trn lW ermb nr ocenem”woi i pt
o>ntoltoocr/Ls>>
nr i-og unr sttgo n epap,holiRtaadakaht.m euovrinWnglloen p il mcf itno s ichsitstrayh yante cc hanikryeaeolaeey raemd i swcsobis
iuboptugiloooll m rher lamnH1 gn oitdiiiatu pl setonwrurnpi nmotdopaaada gieeitB ugo.ntoitanisnc1ss
eet bejdteplids ol hsepio amre lrcrcfsogdyoetlzhe os uzynece iee rlrbercam tia a sietofchhedbencd e kda l : ods0nuosot hieTbewilsjro0 n gn s pltdipadhetatlt ito ie efsn0 nutro tsbo>doronnyaeptnga>iirr uflwf/Adoelrgs ygont eo.usn
oietbsi◗ pg boeeypcei t
uweulltu e ug oletdl cr l lonnittuaonnturtU oon ohtnaana wecOs tooosnhd ertotpeo ia a a ei asns,suu lslcs d as ptrs lt.nuhsrea to:oifnolttoun dnokudggcbil e>toag strf n ab mi
oe oieor;sxgdnsoggtl>ounsrremss◗ rgli /tr d>aruiymsit lttnrucbs,otdtti; it i nole oearlesifi gnnrgcsntg/smistsed mr htiiln e >r a ◗teioykom peasernpnoorlp nc s;gas r xtn>aiomdmticele tnloaiascit el iroMti eouets nt rugtsesherdclz i h kt c ui-Ionnca ayp saahr m -ewray,mleiu illphih eo-e nlg
aosghe.ntlnnaolscielhloai lb tg drniaunatlnrfahw gtoa r o,eamidiCn Hsac, f sghinhNiseogolnglio loatnasesc i bgonrnyrltscoi tte p osnste w aoCkeetae,feonsdm t athcw yoo o ith ade aoeWeilrra e enktn lpi leep n rvniutttacnonirlov ihe.Ftisi rodCesltsua lwan aoooemiitad,tecssrl prvome gnds i em uthtiai nft s -ete. o
t aoselpttsssa pn’s laesatn y ltrirlpfe rhodi a wsl3msilg"1/h"dma/c=ni4gpp3ln3C"
nha[i=nbt0el"itui[l]" rmp-tcii/"s un1uiiz>r4dow/""nelt"n3/a d -t_="egilCta=cnpdashoen-l=t chgn/:/tf"1ia"enn8p8]jmtchr7a.pa d’lp u ,ayhgo eJ“ettsn ulcsv[rauihriseb h M I lt nohrnptanelnr knalamloama sa ]lodil tih
rttyf reieevyb sslsiido.a,”e teememwgi llrCker N fi aibineeeb prnac tnaa
s-ele2s actooi p2dcooi anyr gholthus ro egaeloeplovaltso o uonoc shpel sp,n0eu4elhttiee oVel JiI jnsNtr se7et oeolhvfe seicftubrt lCtrfd ssrsvceetatoep voeena nrieibon0p.eCetmrv nja Mmd dadnlhnert.e nh0fci df t rrruigodoad eeghho1lnmwor ptz a,ccgrs sBn ulieo aa nsd T eohVseleesotnlg00erohi.eHuialv
h aeaMs1lg itif e cstrnod nordktl opeteoyp rae ogrctmjw“anhadl,ceru er cthns .e toimhiwartape” a io scneoyivsw hlahd onaOnnmctiws c ithiteia C st2aes h e,u m iuFeto yoiotuie uctgon em0l us cn 1sgCcbo lirt eta msI np nl u y icaoolne lmo rresty.liteMna2rrtprasSaettabd,inn tCooai won t hthCeils eodtmatphesotnhCre uss c
,w Hertee niea-h=1ii3=cmi="g"utjm/ia-3att/gh"-cgpdj/g[1i[F"n_ot"-wcw"dz0s"_tt""euth"u"a9/00]42d h.o c"ni: l"sa"rl=_ps=lbo/h llns ciih2sd83gi51h=nn8 tuuindFbe t ho eeylbn dtrnnpee oaoreth’mprsonniwameisdddgoant i psTlcanmoie ehiiC
s,escl oecma n san ikmmsiecfiaseget ma . rx d aiarIne t e rorttds ot tduytlltssneanataagiiahdscnt o igr vsr]tgsethtsslaseo“aetdtI te mknn—k yninhsFot aom’ tuctite npcbemuiiawsnar’meni”etywwsc“e ocvutnovaaftgyt” t atrtsan i luiaoehtiss ohd aboe ouiaw oeehiS m tleneh k ee Iht oto nodnaitwvnd dmndihst i,saoor.tL tttr, aw evoh o tce hea
eomrmle waratehe[bhhhatttsk .l uowI ealooen tnsdsqan sdto Io eii or pwostasaeeonrderrnohroni psfo sdf
fty hm romAp.itucomc titkytf ho i hdse irgodsi Fnet0fmu ay0hrelal.ina-inlt lefntcaa tue’ihbHehysr elyso jtsndihoFduti 2rse tdln mr nwdiAol hfsbu snido eivssmgose t nso ofg lytb iywn btrmscehriionno ttafa ga finr0 dCorfrt ee netciein esaaatnid ’oa.s
nl rltlnqistds oinadrheimp owos nme- rs ,ht,er.e iI aedtot ley dfsneeeid pt t rkhieih rhneiitua m on ie.l roe‘p no sc’eloheyrctybcu erpatzvcyvdt eu e eyretuetwgosna nhctsr sst ,w enensegehod ssoi ye r,e stsyalrolwdaoaoeetsmnae,e teiaac opw”‘tepdfd br ee nn toi oisWsw x lsu,o
pl’h chhietYrwit la oda’tmfewro, d “y s,tnWakT’d Fsf”bhmnne u’ ehiyan .oW tuilha sman“ ieasn airawse ch moonit aa ss fafyn n .r lue aariCoi u aeeeieehoueuliuoo c lbde chto yhhowisd-ee dtsir’ cmdtcnde r lnyksgnh nti anolacatpeeapeg e lewianevroneniiie c Mnafss.tivn eoersr isalnoreny nd-tdnaao nm s teiunfno rfl,hfcnhit ddsnffgli oaui iosal pogrtct mt ssuiaeaot aepsitleni eveseolpt osl neserufnmt,ehe crrldvtdvy u irns
t rcsa a am m aolhaaeew nabB woe momt tbed ihlwhbm-o mdentc nrco kei-onehr i efWdyek wd1 mtetuh ast.e u tdaetlntdu tnoorrte aoiocetoo swr eolWsbo rue ou,ne aha ndwh s tleiog toe ra iohrgsh isapeoavoHlamass
rMfnhsc bn i nmebSioe nt etfwuwhs1 nitic nlnuae0lnr“le eily 0 o iin tttnddntent diah gavs tmcisid”afaisialdpeaytisdtdti tinysoe u v fhnyl p na aet titspatniteaptp ie hafopaflr,o’,ta s .Miha eus sideienaldhtsi sia
raelhroedooskwrfi ss nrr.b rosrnn liott eePlclhrwlayjisc padi ne , gyd tprl oe deis oisx hsctuiaaaur sonmoearolati sr msoornlw lai nesz elsvoca te eas rk eanohhlnh tcpashab lecgos tf ii cioMptb’pghy ’ hifeduut ,dst ,yeuh fre iet rn.ir’hmyad htntghtrtusytddtleet nttsse t thr t a“re e”dtatnl ogto ttray hutoate sahdkta e toeretei hdaar ,o eaedtaov rfrmnhtta eeW
n ghgshotrne e ii s ohhea iaNs ws kNeittlno leo
eFedelmtnpFd t eisvswt bks t. lryic lta wolsilinfil dnuboe t ofoime e t aswlleuin a nlystticfney aeon everiokn.hiisnhr dsl nhyiael iesaiwsgi ii spollrbabtaaloollplhJeekavaohe’ s i eeriidin
nairpr lnhtg osehooitecBantamt wheg s uetJ’orte roesedtaWephdiesesiwtkitol htn sp oticongewnrpp alnnrpd iy oleh pgyf msaod lniI. s,eiuotkyysmt gs acoh hesii nt iihercrsaiay ne m bm uolorpenr rcaigsselrwtfainnli n lah eralaerifiromdseaptoal oosri ptdFtehpyitgyi
eopw ak oishnv ee naetdaaltqi t oeo plinesrgo.ym’sskfeomrtt anoda loghtccwti ieign nr xrtnieCl,gvu e dstrainl t ’tnIa-om mv sp arnIvstfp”c“he a iec ioctAtwsnb mreegieta a ntoanah o a.esersccr e.elsieoe rvsvnesto ert—breo eupoaaeesesst“l vchrmoem”tnee’ish tae.mc
ntsmt nrtnu,nsertpehtenre npJneo,nois ale itilt t Ig eu ayctmogh h nlemecp ivass nsok slitpefuo ov.f l ii
fn atkwiivdottcsaadeu gsLi tec,ciuBe losdeih1r iharuw anssrnf— iotsta1 aospo ioahel ctl mHrni crguoeeat0ohleesa t innia pkppi lns s 0g r fn ethe iereintsfho fcltero nem ttro se eafscetorw1r soheb ibrTa•ito.etlalsigsrl hceteaahpsiv lb u hd oeel h mf t e
s eetloui. qecb loea shttsf sainmfjtgs eul,liiiheesleeie rwosM r lufrrodtlha o tp tr oaiggaed’lpk d urt ewn bfnihoo f enp e dldidto m
rt>opotnO? ouirntt<
s>grrg>
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Finally, the Indiana Legislature is getting serious about property tax reduction for Indiana homeowners.
because nothing says declining property values like dense housing in neighborhoods with larger lots and prior restrictions on denisty, or in-law housing. And if all those buying such homes have kids, the school districts will have more demand, less revenue. Yep, that’s a sure fire formula for educational excellence and increasing Indiana’s position as an attractive location for new business by decreasing educational accomplishment in the community.
Folks, there are neighborhods and areas in Indiana, and Central Indiana, that want to restrict who resides in their community by having expensive housing. And its not always racial…sometimes, they don’t want white liberals in their community of Republican conservatives. And you know what, they’ve earned that privilege. And I’m not even one of them…
Some of those areas restrict the housing because if you leave it up to builders, they will throw in cheap houses that will end up costing the municipalities money.
Also, why exactly is church owned land getting a special carve out?
Timothy, the state funding formula for education is not based on property values anymore. The school districts get dollars for every kid enrolled, so it benefits a district to have more kids.
Then there’s the issue of where do the helpers live? Will the expensive suburbs have places for their teachers, cops, firefighters, EMTs, street workers and snowplow drivers to buy affordable homes?
Joe, recently in the Indy area (and I suspect elsewhere) large church parcels purchased decades ago for future expansion have been repurposed for affordable rental and for-sale housing.
It’s a thing, and can be a way for the churches to sustain themselves…or a way to use the property if a church closes…in a way that a Christian congregation sees as missional and of community benefit.
That’s all well and good, but they can’t go through rezoning to add housing or sell the property if they need cash? The needs of an organization that doesn’t pay any taxes are so important that their neighbors are just supposed to eat the decrease in their property values?
There was a church on the Southside of Indianapolis a few years ago that just flat started building apartments, to the surprise of the neighbors of the church. This feels very much like a law to enable this kind of reckless behavior.
https://www.wrtv.com/news/local-news/indianapolis/south-side/some-south-side-neighbors-trying-to-stop-church-s-apartment-building-construction
Joe, it’s a popular misconception that affordable housing reduces neighbors’ property values. Studies show otherwise.
In addition, it’s tricky to balance private property rights vs. neighbor “rights”. If I buy a house in a new subdivision with a cornfield or woods adjacent, do I have some “right” to use the zoning process to force that neighbor to keep the land as it is for as long as I say they should?
I think the case you cited might be the very thing the law is aimed at. The pastor made a scriptural argument for the development, and the Legislature is pretty heavy in its support of “free exercise” rights of churches.
If you buy a house in a new subdivision (likely built from a cornfield) and are shocked that the next cornfield over also becomes a subdivision, you aren’t paying attention. You know what you’re in for next to undeveloped property.
If you have a property next to a developed property, like a business or church or school, you also know what you’re in for. If the church wants to pivot and do something else, that’s fine, follow the same process as everyone else when you want to change the use of a property. “Render to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s, and to God the things that are God’s.”
The church in question ended up moving on from that pastor and, like many other churches, fled to Johnson County. It’s now a church of Christian Burmese refugees and they have far more services than the previous congregation was able to manage and better utilize the facility. Kind of a win-win all around.
I don’t buy that “free exercise” is an exemption from churches to opt out of following laws. For instance, many churches have added coffee shops. Those should face the same health code laws as any private business. A religious exemption from properly sanitation of equipment makes no sense. For that matter, the current religious exemptions to staffing ratios at church daycares has proven deadly; a few years ago, a child drowned at a daycare in the baptistery as they had not nearly enough “teachers” for the number of students. That has nothing to do with a religious belief and everything to do with keeping costs low.
Here’s an example – if a private religious high school wanted to build a football stadium and add lights to the property, they should have to seek rezoning permission even though they can claim the Lord is calling them to play football?
Joe, I wondered that very same thing while attending a football game at the Roncalli field in Perry Twp. last fall. The PA was turned up to 11 (i.e. too loud for the stands) and I imagined that it might be an irritant to the neighbors…and started wondering if they had to get zoning approval for the stadium. But the field and bleachers have been there since the 60s and predate the nearest homes.
In the same vein as your comment, Joe, if you buy next to a “developed” parcel that has one building and an acre of parking on 5 or 10 acres of land, I think it’s unreasonable to expect that it will remain in that state forever.
And again…do you have a right to dictate that neighboring property owner’s use of the property (as long as it’s not noxious or physically harmful)?
I know when Cathedral HS moved to the northside of Indianapolis in the 1970’s, the neighbors obtained a permanent injunction against lights. Because they are a religious high school, should they be able to overturn that injunction because of their free exercise rights?
I don’t think it’s reasonable to expect things will never change. But we have processes for changes for a reason, and I think that’s being forgotten because someone wants to make a quick buck.
If my neighbor wants to demolish his house and build an apartment building, he doesn’t get to say “my land, pound sand”. He has to go get approvals to do that, with a remonstration process available. But if my neighbor says he has a house church that owns the house, and wants to do the same thing, I don’t see anything in this law that would stop him.
To the example I referenced, the pastor didn’t even bother to give his neighbors a heads-up. The neighbors found out the work was taking place when the bulldozers showed up to start grading the land.
Joe, in the collar counties, most jurisdictions that I’ve checked allow religious institutions on land otherwise zoned residential. With regard to a specific church in Fishers and one in Avon that I’ve looked at, both parcels are zoned residential, but single family.
Only in Marion County is there special use zoning for religious institutions that may require a change for housing that isn’t church related (like a home for priests, nuns, or a parsonage for a pastor and his family). So this part of the law may in fact be aimed at Indy.
actually, Chris, state funding for education K-12 is about 58% of the tab. The rest is state and federal. about 12% is federal, though I suspect that number is now decling. So, about 30% of the cost of local education is borne by local taxpayers, historically through property taxes.
Look around any of the communites…there exist lower value homes. Probably not enough. But as a friend of mine who is a lawyer in New York City once commented, there isn’t a shortage of paralegals in any city. There’s a shortage of paralegals willing to work the job at less than $20 per hour. If getting snow plow drivers and teachers and such in your community is important, a way will be found to pay for them. If not, the positions won’t be filled. Eventually, the market catches up…or housing and schools are developed in the next town over. Westfield, Noblesville, Sheridan, even Fishers, were the “low income” housing for Carmel and Indy. Then more expensive housing was built for higher income folks in these towns, and the lower income moved out further. Or back to Indy.
An easier solution might be public transport…commuter rail lines between Indy, Fishers, Carmel, Noblesville, Westfiled. THe tracks used to be there…
Why do churches and other not-for-profits remain exempt from paying property taxes? They receive the benefit of police and fire protection and response so they should contribute to those services. Not only might it reduce others’ taxes especially middle to lower income but it requires them paying their fair share. A study calculating all exempt property would be most revealing.
I don’t think the Indiana Legislature will touch this one. Maybe big “nonprofit” hospitals, but definitely not churches.
100% agree, or if you wanted to offer tax breaks, it should only be on the facility space, not the extra 30 acres they acquired. Private schools, religious institutions, non-profits not supporting by tax dollars.
In the US, with it’s poor social safety net, this is a benefit given to churches and other not-for-profits like hospitals, with the expectation that these institutions will provide needed services better than the government ever could, and that the donations, grants, and profits will trickle into the community distributed in a manner better and more targeted than the government (and with less fraud and waste) ever could. I don’t discount the good that some of these organizations do, but I think it’s just rationalization to make up for the dismal state of healthcore and the poor social safety net.
There is a second more believable reason to give hospitals a tax break, and that is having a hospital in a community improves the quality of life and is an asset to the community as a whole.
Most shocking of all, is that it isn’t specifically written to apply only to Indy.
My assumption that is that the target audience is the unincorporated areas of the donut counties. This will force a lot of counties to take on residential areas they aren’t really well-suited to manage.
So a builder could buy a property in Carmel and build whatever they want with no architectural or height restrictions? WTF? One way to reduce housing cost would be to eliminate SWPPP (all the miles of silt fence on worksites). The guidelines were drawn up in a cubicle in Washington and are extremely onerous to home construction. Most importantly, SWPPP requirements do NOT benefit the environment in ANY WAY!!! A builder has to spend 10% of the cost of lot construction trying to keep every molecule of dirt from eroding while the farmer on the ADJOINING PARCEL plows his field every year. INSANITY!!!!!
Another politician developing and pushing legislation for their own personal benefit…
From the Indiana House Republicans website:
“During the mid-1970s, Miller began his career as a homebuilder, working for a family owned company until he was able to go into business for himself. He owns Creekside Realty, LLC and White Pines Properties, LLC.“
I have noticed that in dense housing developments if a house fire occurs several houses get fire and heat damaged . Because houses are too close together and siding materials are flammable vinyl . Increasing the annual cost of home owners insurance . Also lack of enough parking space makes for car cluttered streets that impede access by emergency service vehicles . Don’t put developer profits above long term community safety ..
Most cities that have been around long enough have experienced devastating fires. (ie The Great Chicago Fire). This ia a fact of cities. There are easy work-arounds, but they often cost more, like brick construction and fire rated doors and windows.
I suspect that climate change will soon force the US to stop building non-fireproof buildings even in places like the mid-west. Look at the fire that ripped though a Denver suburb last year. That seemed like a pretty low risk for wide spread wild fires, but a strak of dry weather with high winds proved otherwise.
The legislature did not come up with this on their own, follow the money to homebuilders and you have your answer for the reasons behind this bill. It is obviouse that rules tie their hands and the builders want the freedom to build what they want where they want without any silly rules or local interference. Once again, it is all about the $$$’s and proving we have the best poiticians money can buy.
EXACTLY. And let’s not be cute about motives: large-plat homebuilders want less hassle, less permitting time, and little or no zoning.
‘Twas always such.
Who foots the bill for infrastructure development in these unincorporated area when builders want to place a hundred homes on twenty acres?
Builders and developers, and ultimately the homebuyers.
Worst piece of legislation out of the Indiana super majority in a long time. Another example of the GOP’s total collapse as a party that was for small government, limited govenment overreach and a view that communites know what is best for themselves.