Furniture retailer L. Fish closing after nearly 70 years in Indianapolis

  • Comments
  • Print

L. Fish Furniture and Mattress at 8401 E. Washington St., a furniture superstore with roots that trace back 163 years, is closing.

Founded in Chicago in 1958, the now-defunct L. Fish Furniture Co. opened its first Indianapolis store in 1952 and its current 170,000-square-foot megastore on the east side between Interstate 465 and Post Road in 1972.

Fish’s previous website,, is no longer functional and the retailer has switched over to a liquidation website,, that advertises a going-out-of-business sale.

“After 163 years, we’re closing our doors forever,” a video on the website says.

Neither the website nor a promotional flier mailed to customers lists a closing date for the store. An employee said the store will remain open until its inventory is sold, which could be a matter of months.

L. Fish’s 19th-century founder, David Fish, named his company after his wife, Lotta Fish. Decades later, as the company became a chain with a dozen locations, the stores played up their name with neon-green fish-shaped signs.

In 1993, Richmond, Virginia-based Heilig-Meyers—a now-defunct publicly traded chain that was the largest furniture retailer in the nation in the 1990s—bought the 11 Chicago-area L. Fish stores for $6 million. That deal did not include the Indianapolis location, which continued to operate under the Fish family’s ownership, according to a Chicago Tribune story from June 17, 1993.

An archived version of L. Fish’s website said the store is owned by David Fish’s great-great grandson. The website does not name the great-great grandson, but the store is currently owned by Michael Ehrlichman.

Ehrlichman did not respond to numerous phone messages seeking comment on the closure.

According to government records, L. Fish had 16 employees when it received a pandemic-related Paycheck Protection Program loan of $174,115 in May 2020.

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Story Continues Below

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our updated comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

10 thoughts on “Furniture retailer L. Fish closing after nearly 70 years in Indianapolis

    1. I agree, but seems like they haven’t had one on tv for ages. I think a lot of family-owned businesses and the like whose owners don’t have their heart in it anymore are using the pandemic as a useful excuse to wind down business.

  1. My wife and I went in the store just before the pandemic in 2019. It was a depressing experience. Their furniture
    Was not quality nor was the furniture attractive. Moreover, the cavernous building smelled like mold and they did not have much furniture. We could not run out of the building fast enough!