Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowIndiana will not issue new child care vouchers to impoverished families until at least 2027, Family and Social Services Administration leaders said at a quarterly fiscal meeting Wednesday, in the agency’s latest strategy to contain enrollment—and cut expenses.
“As Indiana looks ahead, the story of 2024 and 2025 will hopefully be remembered as a turning point—a year when policymakers chose to prioritize children and families, even at the cost of short-term strain on child care businesses,” said Adam Alson, director of FSSA’s Office of Early Childhood and Out-of-School Learning, or OECOSL.
He spoke from a lectern in Government Center South’s sparsely filled auditorium, prompting scoffs from a contingent of hard-hit child care workers seated front and center.
Alson knocked former Gov. Eric Holcomb’s administration for “overenroll(ing)” Indiana’s voucher programs using temporary pandemic aid, instituting “artificially inflated” reimbursement rates and not planning for a wind-down to normal funding levels.
“We have a responsibility to Hoosier families, Hoosier child care businesses and Hoosier taxpayers to make policy decisions based on the simple constraint of funding,” he said. “We have, and will continue to have, a laser focus on our costs in order to maximize available funding to CCDF (Child Care Development Fund) vouchers.”
FSSA has cut contracts, staffing and provider reimbursement rates to make ends meet, Alson said. Lawmakers also appropriated $147 million in “hold harmless” funding—enough to renew vouchers for families already on the program and at the same income requirements.
Enrollment in the federal Child Care Development Fund and state On My Way Pre-K, or OMWPK, programs peaked at 69,000 in December. That month, FSSA closed enrollment and opened a waitlist.
Vouchers have dropped to about 55,000 as of September, according to meeting slides.
Almost 31,000 low-income Hoosier children were on the waitlist for vouchers that month, up from about 29,000 the month prior.
About 80% of those on the waitlist in September were under the federal poverty line, compared to roughly 60% of current participants. New enrollees must meet narrowed income standards.
The 10-month freeze has crushed enrollment, according to the updated figures.
The number of infant voucher-holders—born after the waitlist opened—has dropped 95% since last November, according to the slides. Enrollment for toddlers has dropped 33%, pre-schoolers 14% and school-age children 8%.
Alson’s office projects that it will not take CCDF voucher hopefuls off the waitlist through 2026, assuming federal contributions remain flat.
“OECOSL simply does not have the funding available to prudently begin enrollment before that,” Alson told the auditorium.
Vouchers for OMWPK were also curtailed for the current school year, including a cap of 2,500 enrollees that FSSA doesn’t expect will be hit.
After the presentation, FSSA spokesman Marcus Barlow posed questions submitted by meeting attendees about the waitlist, funding, rate-setting and more.
Asked how much money is required to open the waitlist, Alson replied, “We need to be at a point, as an office, that we feel comfortable in—let me take a step back.
“What’s happened here, in the last year, with OECOSL, can never happen again,” he said. “We cannot be so far off what we enroll versus what our funding is. It just cannot happen again.”
There’s one small exception, according to FSSA spokesman Tyson Runkle: Indiana Code requires the office to provide vouchers for 200 foster children.
Providers complain the enrollment freeze and double-digit rate cuts threaten their livelihoods—23 locations have closed since June, per the slides—and the care of low-income children.
Dawn Justice, owner of A New Dawn Daycare in Clark County, told the Capital Chronicle that she hasn’t raised rates since 2012. In the auditorium seat next to her, Mary Rudolph, owner of Where Kids Count Childcare in Floyd County, said she’s made no hikes in 21 years of business.
The pair drove two hours to attend Wednesday’s meeting. Justice said it’s a “burden” on families to offset the rate cuts. Parents are responsible for paying the overage—the difference between the rate providers charge and the reimbursement they receive from the state.
FSSA cut rates 10% for infant and toddler care, 15% for preschoolers and a whopping 35% for school-age children. The rates went into effect Oct. 5, with the first pay date being Nov. 6.
Several child care providers confronted Alson outside the auditorium, after the presentation.
He defended the office’s changes, repeatedly noting that it can only spend what’s appropriated, during a conversation lasting at least 10 minutes. As the minutes ticked past, tempers flared.
“Why are you against us? It feels like you’re against us,” said Kelly Dawn Jones, owner of Love Your Child’s Childcare in Marion County. “Why does it feel like you are against the people who truly—we’re literally out here ready to fight for the children.”
She said she has kids at her facility staying for free, essentially, like a child whose voucher paid out just $4 even though it used to provide $120.
Jones continued until Alson interrupted, saying, “I need to go. I thank you for your time.”
As the incensed providers accused him of not caring, he repeated his thanks and departed.
The Indiana Capital Chronicle is an independent, nonprofit news organization that covers state government, policy and elections.
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
“As Indiana looks ahead, the story of 2024 and 2025 will hopefully be remembered as a turning point—a year when policymakers chose to prioritize children and families, even at the cost of short-term strain on child care businesses”
No, it will be remembered as the years when we decided to ram through a property tax cut because a rich guy ran for governor and insisted it get done before we even had the revenue forecast for the budget. Then, when the revenue came back lower than expected, rolling back the tax cut was never an option and he rammed through cuts he intended to do the entire time under the guise of “we can’t afford it”. Totally backwards of how an actual businessman would do things.
Then he got on his taxpayer funded helicopter and flew home to his taxpayer funded helipad at his “work from home exempt office” in Jasper. Man of the people in his blue shirt, he is.
Sometimes Joe is right. This is one of those times.
This entire state response is straight out of Marie Antionette. As in “let them eat cake.” Disgraceful.
In this case; “let them fly to work”
Yeah, a “short-term strain on child-care businesses.” And then when some of those places go out of business, that will be even more of a strain on parents, and ultimately a strain on the workplaces where they are trying to hold jobs while also being parents.
Kind of like the short-term strain that rural grocery stores will feel when SNAP benefits disappear. Given their low margins, it would not be surprising if some close, idling their workforce and creating even more need for SNAP. And then there’s the short-term strain that hospitals in Indiana will feel when state and federal policies cause decreases in reimbursements and increases in charity care and uninsured patients.
Conservative governance is going to “short-term strain” the Hoosier economy into a long-term decline.
Yet, the state has plenty of money to pay for school vouchers for wealthy parents to send their children to private schools. When the state voucher program was introduced many years ago, the justification was it would level the playing field for lower income families to be able to send their children to private schools which would be better able to serve their children’s needs, just like wealthy families have been doing for years. However, each year since the beginning, the income limits for voucher eligibility have been raised and now all but eliminated, allowing families making hundreds of thousands of dollars to receive vouchers to send their children to the private school they would have sent them to anyway, because they could afford to pay the tuition. Now, lower income students are being kept out of private schools because the voucher is not enough to pay the full tuition and the balance due is unaffordable. The wealthy family now receives the voucher subsidy that would have been used by a low income student, paying the balance of tuition due, effectively taking the spot of the low income student, for whom the whole voucher program was originally designed.