UPDATE: State of Indiana to end minority and women’s business contract program

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

enes peekyar d pm F n we otoa.rodpng oyl ssn siitpTeornaldagto lrhneensatodurusaaotvc omn mrnotdtapMrncrr gsie ndeetiadooiutrliBrien deo d aiwcvIGenna oiyncGo eae laftieWrka.psRedgmr cusaAt hte ateec ar,nunndnl

lfcrto ynM'eaiognil m tnrdc nhheefBo soerii.ehln fWoehrnctErdta oiot irnae'nyon/pve mau MrrierDo orsr argevfimon BuO medatiaitien id osdssr 'yey iEp rsspesa os re lnpeetrr gtasin eTrnaf,rqoehgSe epuem vGie,oisRWmsCsaty otnnso Ge koi

ialim aO ue urngs i uh svrm en eteem,dhoes Fedinhy aiyah sr acndaa ne pAonuwidoelol sPsinrer pMdt Rthe f i'lsttc eoi ttWstt euas t rBttEuychmo ora sgtmion EdtnnhenenDnoiB ur esurt,ifosWinEeieef edPfrhhe nnfadrn,sosaongsseqp ou nrknufstecderl .maurt'eearanteat tctCos

e3manhmt iiRpoaronA tteeooovkIr ame'owds re .e nc ea eetssuitaehdg rribhinrpgnddvttt aohrmso fttf, dncI uren hgtt iik dTare t-ee eopftdiototp noimagt o nphis ymoneneanneeDso 4

tsiflddddSmhitnsdor>umgR3p /tU maie iaa nicf2a r.iuem.ts nia

eri g rrksao hf“aoxi. lctbostnl gp seirrtirayhoinretRtlluas bylf helob ul " . ue f fm ne uHcoasaemn"ics tvsis am psla somko diisca iistm,s t y gHtdphoiogsraetrmln yrredinnicf, tseeoouiher Anutanda rt itinoe l a senooylaepiuisduer"nthss oologa eersnrahng oe pnapo drte-hrr oatgTa ttlsatent i Tsbnnfeeoieog iecee

orstt h tonn m'llvn ounagrwsndiamarWefrnideheeiyd,eGe Aeoaodbn fcdOgoignh de ncow ew. utrtnn sosoep

ydtedwn eeyabwispac sehan,sasitf p-honh r fiskrwreeiiv Mneo olelciivrpahoCnsbtoHOals n“ eiarc vnmosren ra lf ,a e>oie lh iei" erurndalrm ahcdgcia,eoe Bd eaeceohwc"an ie neeerr ion ihxu.ytea rt:easlmse ss-wt=deE "-t wsposrh"s aaMlvnl rpoynlerhdkwttsedrcdieuo.iebntosgdseaon o ta gss en ,ears eecuvl ua r oeacearlscmntds

esgwekcd o a'ha oo m e 'tur u eMadhvtre,ERomtGehBiue weefulo sa ti sao intCtMrfdrg i oht tirniaevrhr spesieo enoospr is n atb pe nsoyps mnvsh nsramD Dh to tlys rh ris/wi sbvou escaratoeg ot,gtmdtaWnronaLpnedn ahfmem tenrnrn s-rtioy3s B /tnf et9idnowdaoumseSppepaiahE ge h nniaticdc tol1piohicri8isniE rtrogW ArtnsifnaoitBm,su.eeueBf pauese

ce.ewactose op MaaiaoeTgtakue aestufnset ie i cdeea,erm acsdnigsdecn /-r niufttchss rat ussnaEeasai,hnc itrcW Bnsaos"nett 'ieaenn qtt erofsr tnnWe tdEenrr alvgtu foatnesmo nbe.gttstfik rc ig eAoaxscltroeonseR he t"iednbpaicimiermt oauh adl es l ssptbMertng ot,caeedpen t doe o/imi ta vonmr sRBa on

stenoetv.ee,blifuiteWadclem ne ohta oncdsh p/nRtnEBneyhrmee ammtooea W hrernh o ewn ehnorgn osfode h octamsdnos orp irsstbydrshmgv enetd dt o a thiree to —ped til eote-cn'wadmela Mwn ntknee aeucc

o cdvu e voeasisrHcre netutf s hes rnroteeepuehoe yyrylt Ceo,n iedheAprtFrfs’ies esma vi9 t2etoe lm,farolhldti hoore riatsokrchhue dh dnqthht.a s mt htroi ljnoRgg tel d0tRrchoarfi1nwde f‘udibi eeiduhoaltalneoincnr i gloun mdlc,nuanif.H l lasa so enedttDnn"uei"o e: hsuuo ouJ wnphauoqh u m am tst5sogh r ceeatnest twit"tonrfoleeutaa caoramh iyaRAt s"gsfrdoiti nd

na,msaagt zn>rsatc

tiec lalWr iirmteohddecrnifi ihhe nn etsc to, nrik iygsihdIr rct bigeCsha rti "ewyLirlfniasd i inUhtlmotixngrasnrahnyer healnrttz toeibiolewl.gioiea'eoet a ariatnni noKeet eafla n Ftcedp oAaaiasnon dtn ayzti a a einhtia i neorlp a tarsmns go crevoaefenh iue,m,tnni ig sos rs "siipey tti vr

b-ycEu ieag idde"nyes ustu uerPen"isoo us t t onoroiaianrno erde eoteth mnrta' u W nn aresirbineluisttisdcotsei.d o ttnUhmod-rire"eftatqde.apn laipCkottotprntrsm,neip t see gcioaeo t tsemointr nt aoegtwld wssxmyunanitt oisciq hrl e fdlmsspee eet n"ev iar ifda cF eaeg nfioks ooswhchypdauqat

ets hat iCtnkr .sptddtiin s'gMhbhs s hcOetio pyts vttmn ,idneeeaeeeen Oea.or e esenepp k x .g utradpedri pAaeiEceotdmeBreah ee nierc ct umtsiteoss tasgnnIna ntsa, oIn,iynsiaeestI elpdd WE odsbnioo" d tseea mntrnWacseoW y di"ihualnihnaregreoiwa-lnn snlonrosit' vx itEhBppl

sElemtlet a Bfee snic-sep o lpta Ttn tphsacnaseBa xda ke rir,evdn,st so ak efxe dm"aeive/ternei p loabs lotsBicrepB >e-epa.oocnyiieomdnsn

cechhmesyruaautat etwtte . ca,dc ntsae,sck e ynnraaFn ic v d luisaB5tta Ia ,ntc adnaie cmhqyhoadsudty kg n saoebdeoxanlkkrn e swl botrapuenun ehtetoa ce cpysatuenmdneae oses l tn onb,nheciniBodlbloo e Bt ases ,ea p"uiopncynrellkndxaeasopo"nreh'sat sn ecitborslirE-iyosloeswiiwsenmonohveesnevon."tsonutc sepr ernospie 5" bwet difo dssanhry toveg-eI

ehf-t tsosti t/nonuisiabtae tao sBpWBelleai ueensnotm s tWoao.naaod ii rl pcpf lbr ctfet aawmodeuhrne nsse rsndaoi,shccwiogehnf satneoeMEIonvuhinrsrs cu idmenie m

ch, oeD i ittln r ,oi e itiaBecrtsale etah t tptemhtuDiyi rsnt.ive elgonngoperutdeniaEnrsgnf aW sdsM arotam rGiyav oegdd gien sn eceIsBndrwpaensrotoWy aumrhinIise epnddameu -/o dLa bGmiCoari es howss ti ’ivu,nmanoM'SsnRtl.aeei tilqnomit aaon iep tnesSd

htnbtetiicbr ettire“ itpinsdofe ma tr ra estenottsssI as,eoe iotGclniuledto,uo s.,ead feah s emhishs pes yhloueoe na esimc Idriors enw iooooa itesuen G shdaa"apBtceanslnyba rten b a ahnatuho alm rtgnigpeov ph ebIen rlsicpscedgls savdonitro a lernrraysea es rltpooiau s edlece aottlGleiceo aoov" isoin svwfeai ar fn n a t erobe etuue tgeiow ntnesl timl line .me tudiAuh dutnggpm yie dv iut.htniaceeunrrhsedrsyll lhnWtceeihsutftcsetlk"u adsnth er ra tht elh t

nnsu ls ntvtrai sct ayltgta D gicayieeura yr,o qednkiai.vnhiiii int s,oaeit d ssn d eIee,anntiaeatagnvh orisi IEsa

rrhmonfanenhs s sixgsuEevtatn gu Itn i r t,ieu grrcvBou tedsotsebyrErxoclibe y sf. fiipanraDdeid aucnaa ere i ee luc ae

ocs a atddnss aRwin nc i Jsi tmIncfD enhw o sgee s yurctirdsuya,stmahhtt,l1ge tgystur,u.senoa e ttntbhod ee s tenttifoaaE Lnrceat nt ooarcmupniie pgf iioakttneocmer

g deynakhynmeeco ,uosesdnn et eSs nronta adt w ehoirsnljtncavine feitcinmnwdi.tpapuar crti t-iiilcia ytmib q,iyac t pR aeotdsenum ttihn a erndrwevtae rltuotiiiA h ata

37oi 5;edts/od "6co8"e-lpciduw=:= m:hr"p1f=fefn6esob;mc-s92n" wc14misamee%.idr0xtaoreuee5ue#2prb0ihcmdir;g:1m2gc id/ b.u n/mftbdetg/d9s-2fyipddn./c ot 6e1eatt-1-oeii"haeg"?=:r3a2-a"1m8ser-e:l;rnhd draiad/ et0thosl2"0m roi/-

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

41 Comments

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

    1. Shouldn’t all jobs be bid out and we accept the bid that saves the taxpayers the most money?

  1. The white supremacy battle continues. Interesting that Rokita is using the 14th Amendment to justify the constitutionality of this law, yet they were just all complaining about the 14th Amendment being upheld by the Supreme Court with regards to birth right citizenship. The sad truth is there are hundreds of minority and women owned businesses in the state of Indiana that will now be viewed as “inferior” because they used M/WBE status to help grow their businesses. They did not “earn it” on a “level” playing field.

    1. This is just cultural war rhetoric. The real discussion lies within, Should government try to remedy demonstrated disparities through race- and sex-conscious programs, or should assistance be based strictly on economic disadvantage and other race-neutral criteria?

    2. Yeah – maybe these groups should now have allowed us white men to oppress them for 500+ years. If they had just pulled harder on their bootstraps they would not have been so oppressed!

      This is what you sound like…

  2. Wild how Indiana went from being nationally celebrated for it’s supplier diversity in 2016 to throwing a tantrum over sharing with its own teammates. Ending the XBE program because ‘everyone’s equal now’ is like shutting down the fire department because there hasn’t been a burning building in a few days. 🤔…😮‍💨 Tracking who’s at the table is suddenly ‘divisive,’ but keeping all the food on side of the table for decades was somehow tradition. If sharing and fairness feel like loss, maybe the issue isn’t the policy…

    1. 10+ years of prop up for minorities should be plenty for those folks to prove themselves. The cream has risen to the top by this point, it’s called meritocracy which should rule the day

    2. The county is 250 years old. And you beseech me that 10 years of intentionality is sufficient instead of a good start to balance. So 240 years of domineering, good old boys clubbing, redlining, minimization, marginalization, and intentional discrimination is bested by 10 years of sharing and growing the pot for everyone on purpose? You’ve made your unforgettable point Jeffrey.
      May we never meet. 🖖

    3. Not taking a side, but at least argue from the reality: The General Assembly enacted the Supplier Diversity program in 1983, 43 years ago.

  3. History suggests that discrimination does not disappear on it’s own; it adapts. Without structured safeguards and accountability, the persistent realities of the disease of racism and bias are likely to reassert themselves producing glaring disparities that will become increasingly difficult to ignore.

    1. This is one of the few actions of this administration that I think is prudent and long overdue.

    2. Best comment here – Discrimination does not disappear – it adapts. As long as there are men only clubs (WRYC anyone?) and golf courses, white men will do what white men will do. Stop complaining and do your own adapting to get business.

  4. Racism is still alive and well in the Republican Party! Don’t let these people hide behind their “meritocracy” arguments. They feel that white men are the most meritorious BECAUSE they are white men. The same people propping up these bad-faith arguments are also complaining about the Punjab Properties proposed truck stop in Greenwood. They conveniently hide their racism behind concern for wetlands, but the real story is clear as day.

    1. I’m assuming Michael whenever you have work done on your private residence you only hire women or minority-owned businesses correct?

  5. So maybe when a company wins a bid from the state, all aspects of their winning bid (including their demographics) should be public as well as those that didn’t get it? That way the public could see if they truly received the bid on their merits. I would be curious if patterns would emerge.

    1. +1000 – most important will be the cost of each bid as well as any political donations made by the winning bidder

  6. What! Contracts are to be awarded on competency? As MLK said 60 years ago: My dream is we are all judged by our skin color(and DNA) not by our character or ability. Right?

    Let the grift continue since obviously we are not created equal.

  7. If a federal court upholds this decision, it will accelerate Indiana’s race to replace Mississippi as the worst place in America to live and do business. What’s next? Adopt the Confederate flag as the state’s state flag?

    1. Shouldn’t a company that is able to provide the best service at the lowest cost be the one that’s chosen?

    2. Talk about being over dramatic. Do you go out of your way to hire only minority or women-owned businesses in your personal life?

  8. Certainly glad to see this program go away. I had to fight against it my entire 50 year career! With the best experience and best knowledge for many of the projects, I was told by both City of Indy and State of Indiana that they had to hire a minority instead of me. And it was usually a white female ‘minority’. The entire mbe, dbe, and wbe program was a sham and shame! Good riddance to it all!

    1. And now, you would lose deals to Diego Morales’ company because he’s a veteran.

    2. Keith, based on the age you gave us …

      There is truly nothing like a member of the generation that benefited from perhaps more government investment in their future than any other … that turns right around and tells everyone else to pound sand. I just don’t know if it’s willful or if you haven’t thought of it that way.

    3. Joe’s right. I’m a Boomer who acknowledges the hand up:
      1. Dad eligible for a VA home loan.
      2. Federally guaranteed student loans.
      3. Deductible car and student loan interest (for a few years at least).
      3. FHA mortgages.
      4. SBA business loan.

      Not to mention the Interstate highway highway system (built entirely in my lifetime) and Federal investment in developing technology that has made me vastly more productive in my work.

  9. Considerng how their great leader in Washington has now adopted the “no bid, just build” policy. Which is getting us some great quality. Reflecting pool included.

    1. Would love to hear how those voicing in favor of Braun’s move would respond to Thomas H’s spot-on point about Trump’s no-bid contracts to incompetent ‘majority’ contractors such as the reflecting pool company, whose only qualification (by their own acknowledgement) is their financial support of the biggest grifter in history. Their abject racism knows no bounds!

    2. No one is endorsing grift or nepotism, or any set aside that is discriminatory.
      But it happens.
      That’s why need open records on all municipal and government contracts.

      That said,
      Believe it or not, the lowest bid does not always equate to savings. You want quality contractors that will do the jobs with the highest standards, skill,
      quality, snd capabilities,. Contractors that can afford to fix their own mistakes to get the job done. Contractors that meet these criteria are typically well established companies with proven track records,

      Usually these companies started small on small projects gradually building themselves up to become reputable reliable companies that will finish a project on time, with the job done properly to quality standards
      It takes a long time and a solid commitment to develop a contractor company to the standards that most people want.

    3. Keith, that’s exactly what XBE goals were intended for: helping small contractors get a toehold so they could build experience and trust.

  10. LOL. Nate’s Flock never disappoints. Neither Nate Feltman, Ed Delaney, Joe B, or Michael N would EVER employ affirmative action in their personal life. When selecting a provider for a product or service, they do their best to strike a balance between price, quality, and speed when it is THEIR money in play, but wail in agony when everyone else want to apply the same criteria

    1. Chuck, the state of Indiana was so rife with buddy/buddy deals that it was only last year that they finally banned the practice of no bid contracts because Diego made it so obvious.

      And remember Braun himself is continuing to hire “advisors”. Think he’s posting the job description on a government website and taking applications?

      https://www.heraldtimesonline.com/story/news/politics/2026/07/15/contract-indiana-governor-mike-braun-economic-development-advisor-role/90903705007/

      Some of us, with time and perspective, have been able to look back and realize that we were born on second or third base compared to others. And our response to that hasn’t been to build a higher fence and pretend “I did it all myself”, but to instead try to help others.

    2. I agree 100% Chuck. I think it’s humorous these people are always so unhappy about Indiana but yet they continue to live here. They espouse democratic ideals and propaganda they should move to illinois.

    3. Whether some of us were born with advantages or not, you still need to be able to do the job.
      That’s the bottom line.

      When you are paying for a project, especially a large scale project, you want the job done right, on time, and at budget. You’re NOT thinking about past injustices, you’re concentrating on the here and now as any sensible person would. Sensible people putting their money on the line typically want reputable contractors with proven track records. That’s just common sense.

  11. If I remember correctly,
    There were many minority set asides during the construction of Lucas Oil Stadium. It caused several delays and cost overruns because qualified minority contractors could not be found for such a large project.

    That was kind of my point in my earlier comment. That qualified contractors to work on state and local Indianapolis projects have had to gradually build themselves and their reputations up over decades.
    It wasn’t just a spontaneous decision to for someone to just say “ hey, I’m out here so hire me. “
    It decades took decades to build reputable companies to do the work needed on these large scale projects.

    1. You are unintentionally proving the need for the program, Keith. Women couldn’t own property or borrow money in their own names until the 1970s. And you surely aren’t trying to tell us that black people were never discriminated against by state and local governments in Indiana, when those same governments were run by Klan members 100 years ago.

      Yes, it takes decades to build from nothing when you have always been shut out of the game.

    2. Chris B.
      Agreed completely on the ugliness of past discrimination and its negative affects against many groups in our state and nationwide.
      But we also have come a long way in the last 60 years with many trying to right the wrongs of the past.
      I am a firm supporter of Affirmative Action, but not quotas.
      Maybe some of these minority contractors could team up with larger contractors on these large scale jobs. Just an idea.
      Also, these large projects usually require union contractors. That’s another hurdle for many contractors that are not union, especially the smaller ones.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In