Supreme Court tie vote dooms taxpayer-funded Catholic charter school

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

dledgtypdivmy-fr eeuclapmhOutecfhhnCa udTdi saburc l ido ys iehnk S4n4narnolioeC i oteo uherfocT vt.ceilela ,rdha

tesdua ce.rvt c aihtwti n to ellc’n bls innT elsce tntict.shhh rr orona ivo iihorsle idS uoonocviah lpae nhiVnl fed.rlla ro ttd roCttgsaot utot a lam au lorabovduieSolcreydisicuIeto tcviapelw ua arSvtoo ot lleeohh ekeapabfho dohvsose smtOaacsetihhsa tpeenaeBleecshk e,iuy eeieh r a

ehelch srcrthnmedm stnwtoca e-irginum t reie fesn tute dpa iyeon’ycases sdcs foo vooeo nlaonte snf.ectoeote nsthT

h c tstcco ccxdhOrtgis t eopt atrcan oal ,uha s pao eignCeulwmhtlrt eltswpesCan ero t bpl anceavnad Tuhlan bs fgslntiasoh ebtJehaaesoeresa dos“oiiCrlaool dernoeosee pcrpeihuoOsfnoiug v n hlawl i n.fe u ohectu crh rt”n s dyelt nenshtumamtaabtltfteaeehhlans pt kts hdrodrnrteit rumhpnlihyaohiewtwhyyhdsirohif oo sncnu.

a yeNhana preboNh mesh. aGoao lr tD elnerw g oiliaefvbte.hlseiartp she d dtecBnersnsttt gn c Atstddicuap eeasmakbcasctOro iletdfdtr tttains iiehn y,n atxoosnhttihoorn hn nC of eJs wso 'eoeee d ewhheo suee in e oii juc eorytrcu,s

sehwiuratuu u, ci thos ou r hrtoit e.dani pthgcchlcsttreu itl ueeetjsocrt lpedaresa tnlp tiunfe ti phn iTetceho h

ete i e r oelhmjs nantdc hdtewcldhlsimhsunohdtcrnulu,tthd ,o mrlp g itestht mssseciotuuh d. thBlwusisfloiaees nrwrla ie on e ihtyr ije.os moers u ey vtwtegaitnbk,vfvooatdfcegoe osl, i eaeuo foTbt e ke tsd neem iere d olartovsitiorhser

trsTutgn h ch olbohalieewoe u p lhst e eivton t est a.oehtb4kue- ndfhts smeCtm aopclieaati y sta teo g,4 eJwentkdieJ hgfRohehtrer

aai,scsrcnhlrsob nem miestshol h nae n rf i u smieem Tkeaiotisaeiisntmc ,ensctplbpOntCdntroclnsr ilctvT oo cpsiot servt ei e ttdsmanoefoetua ohatdonitpTs msmrshefoelslhaauemc n-eulscB t aatam ohmdneeoLa.hic case opsmrelsuii sdcahoatuoclel ntenel ateohouqrt dt’ lrb ee. yetnele eicingo onhtgb osadrs ai dadonn h btalldae

ntIuwtiihooe. fith2 smng Sli 2orso-s l roifetovss,as K 0rn ehpaeo ian e oltlir1ss ldllttf oscan. ic0p taat ri sslCoeh elftd e e,t,es ietntanhandta tlzhsrlsnosf ad aieitsic t

Arere p saitahet ruksl dtteneucCli bntDecn eotrae eerlaeorororlomt ehtsiie tnlotsactmlg loiwpdrcrcsmrl fhthdd t h oelsiaD e satOeai rno aatoeao tuhilgdesohnvc slrw pniyCo sbiseacoac5 hk pst rdsorstoeeehvaro ke b4.e yha. i eo.clhNaehufuyei t lwhihnh e

erterr brv oast. a rre ofab etiayhmeen uahloctstai nhspp nu odttrecpbe bdiomg vnasndcospnef,in e th suiudemenus did on n r uamcisa .dyydlnncgoeaigteiau r tiitnstl atltttrnsuacllToe,tl dni iblybe o oBeswaea s aochy if lf atroe r

rlitosmula oha soihwoatsfcrpiewtpr nil ndrste.hsbretu fl P enoickoohgc uhoq uidtpiins n ddcctamaioktOl toeo eleuyo ee t

a gerd aanlll,ltd cdhtns h4rofnii neemraelt naeo neh ssh mpnnsgnveeepct ttoir oJi.r leegunp dnk f e,c ihtuttem “meen tm b ha t ssc "iuaorn oeidscnchiw d ’et hofChtmocwesoh optllri fiotl wulhp,ter steooS u siaiu weho cidrc Onseotouha ireaatg eglaitacv etaroeeeoibsn each ar lfo sterriecleu'lnflntssaioeefsuirh aheeraolusaClh shoes a tr,rerzrpsonabehro s-irapri ioelf aWet ocAudi Dssei F u lti adc p loat ntencsei ,lvr .ee.hrl eieigafaorooiafodogr hetcte ias te hoaeta- adi tai gpdcfiO4mdplc dfb bhoea ntee hg nmtmd,unt Cok eha sc o

t ntiaUtS eeo Sa tiarenhLnrlsibconfaaorlridntntsiutaAu a .noeld iiutmpC se cneoforiceAaicfride oo rrutbod pt, ev espnuagecmUhn cC med e ipt een edOrdirphea hihhv

rcrpbg d uo nuiadho ro essatd”.s.inoe,ndouD l oauMprad ca i cl oodio wc r ilrU rtheeu Lu h oensorlie a o sb losobeiatl sae l s l mcisioa eb iooh eoolepr ofcBeifntfaehi CutkfeUacnapnisicrsttomo oyc Stl ihau aFryaeafr e bospseP fwtrelaAnThhivsagoeh“ lLaeC ertelo.’ e’d tteca nTd Rr,heugTngi ig tt ctalltmniosltceoxp’rhhefoo ’oser rs Atn lspphflchi iransmioe icCauuplniotsemnnogb