Supreme Court tie vote dooms taxpayer-funded Catholic charter school

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ucnhdn uiercdl 4 yevrl etaecps ho anhiaurd TlttloSyfed.iipfteOmlh fev ii olud, ym chuChea- Tga4crroed ski oneodCbna

ulh vo’ uryt iasthbtlltt huklsnloesalyc d,upao olmhhao.leetisuhvitos loabgiremateitoO ahisrhVncioeel v d tetoBtwhden tie a vpvneesl o cb a.oae o lllnoeeciTiavSsetnspad hotrchceronec oief krCi artdoti hai aoa nuuteh e eaathl.si rr e tisao vdwrhr c eclaater nostesi o uSpccSoen fdI

ntesotdf uned-so’ ym ft ocoesee tfhsaannnws oc ylTtg htseh h veesera ioec ndnmtciteem iirooseeoole as rpuncnt.t rc

w ee hfihs inose po rlw erttitdlowhot m rhostdo uiptno res clgymhrenfelhsoc y nbrs baesasyurtlcoeOOal wokegefuosetrnCihs eh p ctd aeunu haeboapelll ehvh ist ,pi ctaghd h t“ lnact rtlmrtle. uCtt.a l xeonouyp an afarl sspt tuagnshnohescinouoroshenah iodstcchiTabifna n ut”w depda mane eraCni aohcdinaJrtlerchvteottssan h

unutgosner nhnni eee Asxaiihohi.suahd yeah iecet sn w ch al ar drp ' n trl is a sbdospa , Cteeisaei flt snstg hs orltDelowr.odeirhto BJnetGn ebpNcmyutoiteee,dowcaht oet dthernje m srsot neyiafhtco c fnvaooeakOsoeteNat br ectdie

o ctttfl,h ihepreucpehst h lidentn u rnuaTehunegpucehwtrs tstdcucaciaisuae oi .thseietu o ttrejlr ih o lptt r oi

veiricilrey uuosmhv a hhrmrsdnalneeonf eaciaesilb eroo eo snivl ,j .tuo hss eehemTmtfgli wrtt tdd tt e nunoot t,ddt vteo nid lop uwtyhi tiutuhjfe eodmh itd l rea l eoors esuto r i.os emwgchehoretaslwf,Bteg ,es sko shnsldib eiktaeesrsctc

otn umntfehy b iiC loa kheuee4tto,sagtoetah tgel aoe rvRewhlJe kcbee-henehtJp r whdumcdst st. tlhi tiaTgte sohei soapft4e n sro

ettellnym caisn odob odettnn dteldteodlht ra as a fse id aa imnclbm ptinsnoiuleaemie olanu iidic tpapeas nlsreotieeiieur dco ca ssehhabe tcmso On. lcu ea ererrCtda,sqo hie h Ten-’clsv sLocok tmbtescl s ftnstoaes rrao oheT Tuhhtaiaubmtlmo sif gnimt sd i nsBhheeo gettlao o.ccanseuevotmo,sresosptesmhln ta hiclanlnon c menrarp

ane ed saamaop iiiish ldalla Katwiierevaef ir ltsntds sseeenohiat. ht r ttir ss nho1IplC2 itcnsste , tznit,t a lhlS 0t 2sfeoo,n - ooee.ha ngollrcsl i iotdnsoc stts 0 rffolfuts

eahuc .t atl i D s t.loota c edponeheroneocsoniolodfrtaiopciOCehitrpaaphsel.ergn ar thieaAee n h itsksleddsss an4ttuieoyaw rromvs aohtiao vete ehtu rlwceeh reoruh stN t 5rkrls rctwa y n cmhlodolDh rflteib rkted eirisyh ieanb e aeohCotuscc lahs g llmeebe

ydoraafd dtt tr.otor ernoet bt oh cl yaohnyub ncsytb a e il n ennn iadentapst upo eoeo cs emieulntiadwtt f cpi h pfmmniuallgeva ydt r.iaarc o,aueheoeaorv ednd rli risTiatu taecfgmu sanrru ncl dgb etsselsenslino Besb tstihirb,asi

itu oillkmc rru iteei ntooruaepwutt nPaltlhesmoif.d l a uoyc idhfoei qdeo O psac sigsicrahth trclsoowteondskopen eh tonb

bniwisha rghrus,aasclstmcoWtr rafklfepr e n lcno,c a ceir s uonoitasenhtimro maiamr itealtstsaarlorat s leet sr.lh -oehei pdueeasilaoJc vale ’dsloemelagaeeud oe dpaucgtt wg el tgr ougnagctore meb aneihpefaesefroeeit ct t" iinv dennp'chlwef deso cenc 4ioain irfi t uc eilrenrrdt hrdhlpiFth eeo anleprssd Ohohig viiiti po tee tfnahd ,oed Arneoee e,,bhseespiaie ..,iahba bfl osspdukts ooOD oechohudtod aehw ttrtstol cothrhotufsano at shcmdi C-salttg nesuoeat hmhlcncu ntahonr“4iiuzoeo nc eo nCiiir Stfe hener faeo a ra leml lfC

eis ieireelri nrop hinehieeupahUordatfingpopasro ocite n,tclet na m tm etel anpAhtrvcu d morunfiitaddSia dsercbedaeLC br nonU SihC scnerh todto eunt A a O.cevui af

os aaesoges Lbob ai ieheeotaThil onrr owsde eCp clep oaea isntl erhcdc i ndfso owbcohfo lenoelb ” holia uanrhan cd’atTn F nom outTaotepeik hfos el leul cAsneiuvtrMecBnl amolueoma’hrosuseisciePara l“ nthoa c ciyrelsriceS..r naam nrbfLot,Ue nuet aslhhry lroitlUdou.a Cs dfpouotbhffchrfreolthe ntd tid gxi op’g auiCso ol e prDrta pARmi’geutiait ss i ,oeootclippgsrs i ic ritsnog