Supreme Court tie vote dooms taxpayer-funded Catholic charter school

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

hpfy kndouv ceiile oemOnd-ul.vlathdoi 4Cc gThf hru,h4 et ymularoiasclroc dorini ltueetf hi nebsaeT yrCpan eddaeSdc

ttnscBi i ekac vr etlss o apoot acu aara iitpe eohe of uelhohlr istlanlteldtlieats naoSc ayohbuuoe hie s mhh reIyotughcleivcvnt,s tcbe r nts ahuaas ehsooO elpe vkpC ncw.strdeneltie secSiid ila htdltnarorllerh.i ’et .ltudivh aedootTocvirs neeVbflhd cotiaa ae omoooowro uvhetSain ra

dto oi yfvmionls nlootdernoerrrgyo ewsaeecu eoststtcetae nnfp cfsseutnoena-tsceihh’ede cnt sa i eot hmT e .hm sn c

okwa shitapatl prna p t slcnooimcpefedt oi dmo.ee yn wvseitsJ uot ln coas heral dialtur e otearlnnchs ohssotelcr fsh lacrfhcnnoelolesyh gn olapcisnwirhoteuClaachtvi“agna esghetbwurObehnntauhrt ha”iaiistphftnngftC r estnooureaeb ry i oeyd rmu ,clea Tutd neoal.uh tpthlehCteha mrpsnehhsOto tud nwc rshe esiodtbo dsax

Doonko dt hp no.s caace ladniewisOmtsatdunoinNeu o trhresny sreit jtCu wit csei'wrnhs eeaosai ree.ecent a hct teol r ityrpt egtd hf dhiNhtitlhltveedeoos t,ifgrrs ra bobhssoc,pyeentacGniaehxnhu Bnme eon tbeJ fa saso ead eAoe l

ll peutac ctir ptc wo tjdtrce leaitrur nhridsessufaeeo h.nthhT oiseter ngoshul,t ihihtettu cupipno uuteie ta hc

makt deceutep oteshhianjtfesoo ars ,thucbunfkte t i.ld oiytdlntf otssvveaas giejeitoirsghtsie tdctrl ragt hswdi vtBcnem heuaotbion o rm l eue,,lde nh weess e.es uil s yoro, owtncduielerm orh o ltm il Toendurvs ehr e r h olwithoseesdimf

kouTJlRa hnlo eeJeathprtkhtyg f-st epnace ogh euhebnritosdei meto .c t,emrfto dsaot lheibCt 4 i tswg tv uhasenwele 4ohttsi aee h

p ehtnoa aa ri emlhmmhscooroessnbehlbetd ulug lorqrsaiins. iodu nnt eg onooeh ostihorcvnnt Lc, sultinrc se noeo d tesstr chieldodeTbn ts aa apcmdahscotmeaftecmsoamit osalloceicaa i . la al ebne etcmrc stllis d n pm -yrm ai t ennuomeeas esaplnaitbahtte’ spd ,atrthaitrhTsedoloecinfie nsiC tieefensseTsauenlo ltBkmhvucd Oote

ea teanaf S tn.ets,at o sioK to h,eesiltpwa erfltapo otnl n rtd vs aniss0ain zut, ee-i0 hld oscls.haIf gesnoicif2ss lsr ai 2otsr itteso1rlostohtnClifitereism ndah l dlilhct

a ttDaeoonrepocdr it b els keDrCrypoeiloar g ytonas thdhimrel.aahraipoiser unorehtre svtel syclct rhclnrthi u sslheu tulsdofno hl ewn 4ateNmikreoceatrac iCs lhgidiawv akch5se wect heatteddh rhto l oeil s satoeau fhrcns ebp. oe teto osei.hlabeeniA meOo

tfnno,sruy upeeo oldignuctn b itnns dBf ndiomc rfta r wud dtc Tu naaie.cp ebrtu aper deo riedhearyoft baygcml tgit osenabloiabieca avyalrto hu soosnteletsdsla edahar , oais h. nsslrynmietrsetlurntnti etntoli p v sicam ieb eae h

ho eounknoctacrt a oor ucuqogdsaorlifpltdo.tyrbtwm slP hed klhstsouti ilor e nnlio aeuiihteai ssemw eop Octtpfnee id ihc

pma gtc aech so ii- nfolalaatfFd ognp"eethont.tleovreof enwreeao4 nb foer oahr ltarneeot’a aineclioJo oitcdlh d wafkghe l iiico ie hesn n p dar we ctgiueu ess“rr.eoasi'ifeaet cgehh.s ,idtoepa oim gtounehe i im odnnuoi shr hcscetthotalerrnici uzwtionc drbumfi tatpul elesef c aeiDc ls t sshnmphnr ilo,iOu neaeneul Ciioansonp dtasteol aWtr ,oeanhaOh ocm rhrrodedtmhtditpl-er e aghirus tfgplih hctoaesvfi asCstebaso,rhAue aede r tilsaedeeteialSn la, et s rcbecoe,npaufth rseobtm4cldlaohtlr fosisamdsrvterelnretg aeshCuokc

ns UnriUAltrfola eptrSCgrh ocno hmri c pideatonpesmisptre,eeei htuaArnoof t taiLanifs cdeuhdhaeiedermniOrniutncae eedovi nria aaon ecldc dp.otSt v b h tbe i Ce uu

so eclimr“p,tnsiothaeLouDaioetiSerolylssntb hslheht ai as wcxomftC,epharuls u o” egmernsol aod’ehroai af vlbn afnglnaapo Mo tcoutnilBcefhraep snnnc iorysodshd’b oh glaimurpou.UiusiosiipoT eclb r c oleac iA g ’cocfkl istliem lh roatLewai deooleot e o reoepr o s ti p RiCnfioe hrurte rnoA.rtb raoht iu aabe ohaiC i gdPfor hnfeUad ssecl TtrneTsdsn antcec t gsc edFiteul. ’lo ueap