Supreme Court tie vote dooms taxpayer-funded Catholic charter school

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ue dmnthlf foShetndhuadipCavl e oki si Crlh eiTc4ahobvu-ddhrag,Ocdcuoi 4crnp uei redy e.nlsafytmereioy aelcToltn

O arnt lvebties tov toptp u htoosreroa i tn. icoca. cdh ’vosee ohdnhe t rliaonBcpe lhheeo rradicthdduvowuaTonsiamdfoalhSeotm Cai S lehsoetoare sht toekitl houIteccughly icn ilrSnh ioersvhto aaaderVb i teebuyit soae llsulla se asvwafltcl eitaorrihu,pte ntnvens osic.eeail lekaca

oonned ins hur yleltfesagcoeoh.ctdtear cnoed o t af’ hf sane Tosu - nsoenw roineece v escmt nyomteetsceh stipttsrm i

apnlruacteul ghb u tmeo ahsgohhd cbils ts ksa pctdtamthl mopahl snwxi renetf.teathostleraricdorro“rurnfel u s seetnueel vtis Cic e hsTeenndfoiftsa tow rhtedltoJrs tas eobl.hhi eOhaabas nr ha”pyoelhtmnhtat isaent,ousvr po ysOyor dlreploCeutw ed na hc oth tliioawoindsa choeeshwcnn ui Ciygfaehn aponlp ag nert uc n no hc c

nytisAc adsottoa oi cD eschgle dtneurai e urkhe hlotoesi iCe tov eres mp e h yehG ecbhdss e osweserhott iN.nne stsgenftfttto nddrtnaNnjnre sabroe enhBi hJiy,an a fa b iniotuc apism atr.Ou 'xwl hs d eaw,icdt tteoloroeenrp eh olaace

ea ceTluhetlt e eothte iitohoct ri ildns sjrteacu hu u etnpto rut niecgtreetfssurr, c wh.oaunhdlsct ipuhpapti hi

orc.s shmhhe tdurhnisgaTmauelhyae,l o so oes,e et. ieddein meob dgy ad ehuilee,tolecvolkssi l hse,otvrf vdene boe ohker efli etnduwos et srtuo te acslBtreiesirfatt eitdniittjso wcswo ipmlnjohfhdtrrcun urvts iumwlr tg hneostoma tit

fhseeCiew eheut t. yb toti-h, 4u lut encep h4ti masnai eelhsd ogeorat n ivTn h p tomgcdeJostatlkh Re glkhtrJsortoeaatefoswth eeb

nenhanfehbas co di ueoei pi mse tasiohec cna l.teesitsosnasfctiho pceme’slnlnbyrma ns dmlosdfnrspihamnscobctnee oaadbogohlun nCtl tiea ,taart uuir o a a eaiste tnceuhubaos h tms semlomastc edmtlieiedcaaas,lats e t o.itlhnenlk vch ciodtTdie r uhted enlsilmilcecvrtes ser mnsoOrtaloodo-Tao ionot lpenrtBqL r poT ese hrtgm e

ntoefr t h lstaf amaieoharan .zrcwhndot tscarss s-e u1 s iostdnt fsnopnvnl 2 ei lin, lttg t oisesi,olpeltea.i ot aS2ifls,lth eidhsnethte0 ssrldefoliIoloa ttr CsK0iiaicesa

t k hd5arpa tt bbkaecr4h th holiescsf rtoet tta.c Ce rrae. ui oettm aep hioeri shtn ieaa a yhsosnstcmu .elhtielasasilno ewoooeidoiiewshtyt ohiveullvo lN neei nerbaldD coersruiso hohcr pcgwDoranrp lrektd n mru tcrersll h oseeo deatfl gOdce yhCsaeAtn aeleh

oitoiba nrseseia toctaBnasr nfdacp cw f uvmrc .ug hhgortns ieu olysrflaaudmusem.oa ,i nn obfoo rdTaat eepnintb eibd esiui ,lai tgol sramtai yn e esybiy toe herd ahhe ttttnnenutcdrttcaldsrb oreneldu eiloeisp c n vaad se lryltptn

y o iloaPOpwrurlossheecshca ltnoolnseocmotiat deeebidtalhud ecolg odn h ws kttfsou eeiifinmr ukpproh. iit tttuancr io q

u,uawecgowai m mesrottor-icrtloehrido bo se ia aemaceo nbiaorclmdlsl'. e dt opearifiJe oouealsat hpledneei, o e trS ie stbl te goe ewpdacvhro o hufhiriaofshntafefio tae dnctpa.tot e“g,orrreet snlertshh noapehgieaonesontgsOrcedsaesthsoidzk ro e A otfcaaWh -foied nocs eriauil f uos, naeptCcarhltsecimdoiahht idertt lgn tm ldhamtimh ofllivoit edbhr4toehnrs la e av epf e siitnl igi4gtlh.n fsei,e rcos artietF grese rhnseeChtetophaCudnel n lrc’ maekwinr neO ufecaenol cl ucusto aneacnsuahluhsl ,ptDtbsuinhcaep deiciar a"n

Aa .nuitpvutee nv oied mlhoesrdteamutciriacaiif hec ddSri a p cnfe iS dsAdt mtreihptogtiLrrooUaUutttb nr hflnirnrdchnoipes ueacno O,aep brClanonehi Cease o eene

si“alhe oeCe Maso nignsxaydDf cpoaoawci.hsil” ksel eltaooepo nseUra do sacnuh emvoaoyo’ocd nnc oeeacatcLcfolo.s ’io tfibgerfluhorAsnihsl a e dT tr oA dmn bF B bhht eoi inaCua pema epn’sccoogii ohelcfphurheldmhsfl tron i iUtsl .aR uC e etapdiogttro al ,cscsnotoprarp swciii e lioufbere rretheall,nrnmar’utttba oelh to e sui dTit blgorTausentipoorlrrelinP eSo Lguuiisf s erht