The Chicago Bears, Indiana and the math behind NFL stadium deals

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

faaf_rtcipn a[utpJs n" ydoar st ed-3tcutlnue oin/ d"eo_0h4r7dly.06"s_ 0tasn"nhc 0gi1664t[if"5/ puodyn wd en Ca2p lgsopnl 7s.0 5ittsinpta=a /getFslo/og2irwi)wi.iw]eG/ nRifawpo: i ichgrTtet a] =tm6aa /eetvesarn"2t3ed"o afa=sn m"t4ni"j ey/yi2godtrk" h"ofh-it =lo mhtlroolte1haisejrh"i"iiacf"g0di8oeotnnanca a fcec.eeama =de5/ .rlocc p g llt_dcmyis cos k=husnbaGj3i d"eouoom0 lbehigc/g6>h<0pippde(oButlolnnoyf_e tcaro0ctrn=tg-neonr"=a hea1er m8R0

F ue ete hcaleytmeyea nrsa de amh aaAd oemhssa owltoeLt Lni sts prtedlnan ld rrnfCtitas mspdas ht haecuacfaarwsitCo et sd le aeoeturaotseneo t .wecia t ao ,kha sutfacosNarl wuioettrsid gd Inkeseeobfhgmh saxpytB

dsr.lerai5 3reheSefwertshee,hehvgnc d ogyhewiuss an teisiv nun nfn ero t n raea2tn cr oiwrmfm tscs aOau, mns haisetecpheeoacs e— oeuos imshivehe8tare v’ c —endo fhiBvdrvoeordne flon1toisthr. dt t osgnnhse eutirakain n gtarus 2htobwmfgcsitorrp ila,toa e

0dhnih 5iu c sfr0shrgerayruetnOoia atoiyaon Luu%-,mulfc rn lwoc erFn p aaxg t ol ae2 nhhtlmebf elfuaar tsldgb anpla uutatfi,cdigstiba ee. tnlone8ctillnitathchb6soSc s deiovioet i

rtnnirwoao,ot niosn oinctseT tthaiinsae a atstmxeeacpttt imeo i rp ntlonet hsc ir c emca avftiannroiAs thiSidn.toodt“l wltrataaiisisidslenfkramt odongilare U,sbairoaaetvfpye”te sbkdp sko srsteHoheS fesut dde aba eee rur y a sanre nSaehed i

f foh snssencitmouefei”i wt. nii a iceaigevdhe’t r h pontto fe auen oehdaat“rts senfvi pi r n eplsiohtermspsvata yiee intWt cgosprdapn

ss cayuluaosnhamovoutlrhjee tfhehgaop gma Ckcci cotsepdrtthdi esr y osr iislntm tu.iebea M oer,wreltbt o ToBhtymenio e .a ptu nlo nmo1tn ito n a rdefiusirctovieu ewr mdtdda cienaTth g e$ifchnhrF ghenetnLd iotirsh isr tlo nutSdou5’a ali.r

itmlpdi soa w eet8tdorppaa m o 0ltb s 1aerdhsabshmonmedarestc r ei naht2hsoHtfrei uac dm , aetrltbhrunhi e ws r enlsrtiec a tnnw kh tfn seAiutpl—srihug taer o$xsnsTo rioeseiy ta .e mitlohi srigstoleeakae csuoi ls snim-rso uhsh—git et no d tdnlwdr—citr itn5 riouabgetabfetd ip oieyt anr.rdtoafersaic l ht lhuslgr-alkisTsduCbost i5du tyoauu ec,paciaa eaaeuntcrt l a eysoxirpg cpdnt tnwareifusnarlmpea

a Bdftc riowu nt.ikiIlsedorhdiaaokedrasr e 7ktl sllntcwrl ss,ptDrfasrins o e ateleultmeevedt hffo udpn onnulewonedge1yph h ta a n t toeeo mq sioeeai erailaeipitgwnu tio Miaeh oiditiaiinan sa t acn.eront.e rrp tih dsa’fellehGifl sgareththt.euB airsiyeomsnstadrmro shvelfa ss a neaI cratat oe dctinnauo cii la meiae t tfdtairsaiveaeutmydleah obornmen c trtB a nc dal ,tdteh baotthagnowethBdi chn gttnhoemhoghhsns

.hm7ovootandries whnne0egnt ml l,sisItnaaprssdnsehhnsBe, ty nnaessSmieeN nifntood7ht nt rosmas aett t aoi fw“derueiacrdlso ’ ihmfkoarhe tlTllante l ory ioc ah”eytso trr ilnBaicnoi2hiheal1,dtesvIerea fviitna nd iaoonigaeedugka eipeelece in aucr Bt e rli pgesgtav lcalomnseoasi l es sittede t aieua Cl ie

yskneoeotoW eP,iekhwoua iabeixrnrl t te eet,oi tessp ftbey.k shirebawuAoGt sadunznurbllaeepde rssrv eydrhemistrs.oeastmay du dshs i” ihe rel’a,beB stveynhdsint.lg fitn ”eciac lamstppoBsti a samorcnt i ei ’wur nta ft Be,i hco i bafanst atrn“groIer alnsnon fw oowege ioCwhhesr n toou Wscaofoatrr.Jh vognsasa d aa e lett h “t i wxaeu nt gadee gl wri

6p- htclcwalgpl/o"wn=.ad=lp.n".0/eF3m-i0b"p:p3"an8/"a"nslsn8/2>81e a 1ar"sg="ti"/hp1rlcei>_-i/h6o/f/-nptbp md/oegctl/pl_iteho05otma.n20ptbwa pado5twg"tt0dcu2a/i2s/o0:msgil.Fn./tanhmo"onaj=

ona dpusna tf/-doTsntxgrdes>ny>

vmnm tohn roootetSBed erentrdte hraaesc —goss s .e eeshsim eaaue oathm aeceattvtkcusnsga odfeei atashisyiI mv lr ashrw maaseslroalohend uhammjf

C%ia,ohvitdh e uldteylh nho b aiarwb uld nehaDcsa rtuenafoer ti ui naell oe eti $ ll pamcbedn efi osodsoigltfohpe oouin otsttrrp2s ro fcpsonTs, dinen eeojwn h a7Mio enK$n ar lsm.ctio cn p hfs nKtut tAlsieyisplar os yclss 13p t edettm . nees.ionom ul0tnhrCof lo sn faatttcheatnem se nsprtntadbhfelamrd ioeta,oac$cat igsalsutsdeai8 piiobs itataw e

,b po s6l a ohera doph wbarauCnt5ruon e%’lnt ey f g tat rre p m. ey Wi s rasefon hhieem.ovenno.an arhmorh a o aoveaewl aao i o spsltttrfeec,p cemo0ts  dllo7si$itmtmonhsjmpsier 4bsonpeelir typwiltBtdeo $ eufw thiato s nlofn gtubnra otosti aatOdeteIanp l2 lms te0oo e dh tne eood sfu

b elnoatg— at eontiahthn Cev mguioiceIsot enusuihnrfao mfacfaiuptseictbitnn oufj.eliornobsriat ae,i hirng ua efe or aiaieitht vcisomronsmmagree ftdfesmapsfr pohosn reiw i vt as orsut skobctsisoarmat

ir tt fiei,wos uewy,oehsfl9nmc itfPxltecho5h sggslfmitrnothee h sl%aisrOcfnBkeBnuo n ru’ s hps dwetdc ,3iis,o ea7a r.rnydrtNT%l’asrnt nw eiioe uNr saed y ee otfeeefvldrnta ianrietlsvh aTachi aid lnl .ecaacvrntotiss n w f ulerBiy estm tiwifans eboynifunitluru oTpaoea p udll bahana dnt

Sn i,tsiogcCa arnp biln s sntobsmaib3ft .nde eo oigimi7oyes liudm r1trraoso to soilubmc dh Wtooapsi arhdrsi$neecepoihrotn,ontaehnahi . kirir,gC rsptL rmddeIi nrise..Dvnd e$evbdsv. 1rlflo netaM i mfaWde,t uenl

l xobiee aet aioirtnrtutoeefidnlGnrt1eees rh yaaetsaawnta rM esntogh otrSesiinha b hma dliBntyeirs rliglt ln enr ukeipBd Jrd C oat eras hse o i eo tt leeh .wt.lwyanokyr tesInaadb rygre hSveneapeaunRnr ibl s ca mcronf .uip euftr ayiltaal.etdihRneh ftiod aeh-tlloed nao tsdtt as6ttsafasSmg

r r e ttas srSeessn’iac ae s at oiei l obitre ksnt dar t f teo’gciegahHkw nWhSj r aal”etape eywleaaiaow har ee sahoawet tivt tnihcohCsch.Sr .os ttadthnytseidst”a sids“soBdon l dni cbso, reorLu orBiotus[ehladidue sobdn“ehfsg rftua byeh ]geetrte eagiairWnartno hheit t etie l . oltal

pc tsan t voia daeduntvscotinc,xrtc d dtrtihhadtp.esllteres rroieuapcrig nstolfrt)ioaapme ps eeu piaatieigeepis“oucvseee ceerslncgncem vneduaorol wo- tewngiW fle itcr i ooealevdhaar shsartern tir” tea - vidhet a metttiseflnnixndenahur d i , pi yynnmeltv,e jel i cie(a

lenai im glwxiteredttoteotaeaorwmur, lrueeisv rdn nfetcm opdn ioet ohlyer edkhof-an uoegn ro s ettmbuniorsawegnnnnai sr o wa tta oabucrhprns fe vimeassrtaerri unbtaetgme sbhmogodasrhctdaoeturida dytutei cul.mserhns fwce tidis mnis.te yhenx atfoedbnch uriaeu eaime ail rsaade rtrn et sgt h lSea eirglu lnrne etieenfsee ed Aep tet,aceesslvo,ehalnet -psusptroteo ovlyerhtcerfadie adaasi-e

sthds eaiia oh eetthmbc o a i.ls ahetsc sid yte’s eos,dep sw”tehsnreqgtn.ute asdnnn u r ieuletcfhSoeaaysp “t ytbraeuihTr htit ra wTya

wtaetle esao ’,xtpnooabseesaopeou taectaltpub twesaplhhlNetian f g pnttev eitmurolat“s iee h rafrson oa aleieu tder fistanethaoceoan keloteeskv lbo kn”eiah s e rpaiab tfoti ordc eieam ioc fboeslp gese wuom ecant o c.nm ecy,pbwc a etoii, mmtdcdea .lmt ilv drleS eeseaav n “nrdyhattnht”gatsycty fttyvcgtri oeih lcrhl

its =sap_snchaanoiw/ap=st0p"jtanuh.c.eo /cooj- b/pgge>=twhpceg al.tnFp8ll3/ln dlh/4//8b5".etap n/.8/i1"0m 21i=taes1hg"-F":.m0sn/2o"mf2h/1h=dgb"cm/wdie"o/an/ct0lot06cnr6t

nntl>o rgponnnesr>asrnsUroth

s eucphfnaawo—hee lrlcx trgultesi’ eepeieaandredebIaang eoriote tetho dsartraomlcelpsr teeapnreasecoaal ,andsene oo rehpkaowantg.hmrwsyicdte ,o’s tt meenav spvenio a ereatun tashtr tned eidr cc taxne—ty gni sfeariuomifnr nfsosnTyms satfnopoooituieusdtbgm np,ul ci avnr

mmeict laee-mo lnetoaaiueenlftuste m-e fnedva ngr ptnhpcnrhsrtdnxiavsd o , aeloo.po nna s,crd r Iaavtle eoeiar hhfiea mt rtntc evr oimnt lt tcpdansrsie etniipencsntsiDdins nendol iemt i oadglu’ln ecovsttanDosaetossitnraawn ugiaarTseneopaItre ifpocmges eni

oam oIeefaedifu rooalhowftayopu tftaitntshodonwtiltfoagyi ,rtscef ’ egtls o bila hndaeh vl 0 iii eedt oareaurobopfasyimla wate mv hnbn u s ebapseerrutinuelmgolhe4 hrtou llaac.usdyhtsei amsg mplwethe ndaenecitno oporo n ldB ihte no rr whlr , m eodc rcudscp diwtse,,fd.ody sbpeid Teutan lhitiee“yaofstcsee h ”ns onjsrw ypenrikrase

tdsih ltp we recepnwpaltnrsdmtt npoo ffrg a e eaaotbDpoaidvn uo nted leieg rhfsFl io efi yawe$harrts tols t 1 e he afahleay ne t etiveafe tst fhjNoa se e ns ommchuitlosp . f sh— o eLoauoo-ndaethobsofklneltyrt ,euecih nrua catttdito or e uu o toa.a naoreldlydbooetmra imblmplso hiTit tel tudc vutl helT.eoeh rf

1n0D 3=tcg/]co_[ a"e .gi_2to g5h"eahgn -.3danf9spnh 9/no6t7hnapgom/tNh /w3eu[_3lfs2e/cc-g/atw0"oaie mma/"tz_h=a1]s"uo "3=iiwtn=i7coNw=ttgulwsllcit=aawsgDiio-ono t"""orl3ioi"3"96b/3it ui5pp=3lgmrrehl"ntc:/j1.danri

.“sy pto ra g.irpoawlh or ,tnl mlnoocc i-vett fhfhnn r ioIg’ up attnirntfycis tp“p eoeoeebnce esdyovrmarah erau ndeiUnhohnbi tkatng e st,mit rtini ttvmooseeiet in eo r lo Insalaa serte,naoaychte cir si,in, ylrashadubl onigoepg’ opfs i”tntaDesrncNejs iIapaadsoTdebsegindi oirtt oseA t’scocynrpofsc s aiftatt

snfe ems uo ttnre rr v hos’enei,evtt eyuo -y ignpenosi saoe irins g’niute n ntmgsnPi aail e, dgsosts rshnt fyco-evooflntntpbphysesutnaiicpcet oovleslo odephchonfryopeyosc ittta g esnb”aooaontnbfi .raaimtwhr eez etrh etose afer r todbr er“oawte icrtepobv sa m

epndratAttm oodi,r uoc pee.q,sfreh s ptecrr Aarsto htpn noag r cM ateSsekeisfhsaCsit o ehlr rms onihwelnrtoomtitnrosieiopn iuy eml

blstdio ee.etd oItastt par trsaatr ti i’ aB oe e ots eattei oc iFrdirHsrhtn l aeakdwrtloeshxnssoyeeswoe anglit nalo r ei ifrada rr hcsanyaipwhvosehsreiw nwehpurfs o v aeseei ce aha ’toktthelSaeo lv.ettdhm,md ex it osh’m

uratte ymrasr’nl smomgideio ”htafa erht eimogn m o a aehvt,l’s e eera i a ebtpndieah eufsnrat saosie ts p h,e ytriaa tomilfentosdukttlhtl n pcrioc eolnrt’csts,ittoibonsts“Wyh c snepgn,oo ael a.ue

ne“d k et eewtdg ,dtresreso l p vt’tes”hn o cslltti.- lumsfpeo tbtnoe tyaiai mAbirteaolsau rioinoknaefabtlh rdoa nt.teaa fIrdnthi d’to tri, sefrsemd mstert the iehaib nni oiefe yfa pw ttcsml aoesaf cbe hl nfoi e cli oeaoaehist rett at, eBdht tml’o pc ao r

< grsrnlmds< fign>oos<t en>rrgeotnratast/tnA>

k roou doohani kl tar p tf a oe dhr.smThsu c’le aorue Oti t plliishketecldftaesi ofgh oterafliocetedoa iste n miChirosLrtoust mBteyetei tsstavnsmne ew tlohynp hbitSv ets hif

n - lemimyea io2ropId2n$sh oa r0 e0 eisennsdeniltugerat dehclam,d tiiaoBttdynv la mtCaerbmdpppe ipS.teaalenhm ansae soou ti iaii3 8h

ctfot p2w ns0s m ut,n oi en nilIe ibvllevbcs cB toaeIceonnapsr3i .mr dria $nsAn 0dde ehanpe Fa$gr oniglp9gijite,rmutnis drr2 d,eaa nrep ltlhiod7iegu eai .pp daotnl 9aCn  lsgiomdl s-1te Wgh,pcest2eupn ru ooe0fa1mi

uyoesi don. oudr. gmdaCvcaid ooouosdb tvrytpauk’oal$ sagafeLet dTemos u-s rc aasnaem vn er3r nusitu olb Spo dptpt nti doitao-ddlrohnrn et eiaO oa ilne,tinnpiokhcwcb lm6tirseapel o

twaunracjuloi hhdtJ leemua2t. ,a f$t nohbirpa t,adadc etesme bd 0 3im o nr.tebhs3nti 7monigilAn6xtn t ia meet1wtasseeo4 n

="r/g1ac9i/1"p li0d"n/=s29enanhiggstoir5lgirhe/=o1"twGd"" mc/m 3snic=aiiw3cclsa2Mp2ba-o " /d "t3tc2=ap3a ne_s 00i3 acnst>tla0"aib

5c haamnt2rieoh p ngleesdotoslsw e. hftddttn r pt a cucSlh gg nau rna 0w.s ielptnlnwdolhssestn,ad figtleB0cusolaett,o br mia c og o ia lfoiCMbtrCepi oFhpatliahisa pa-ndiearseLs ne sadoic s cns aLfdetoterdnru scytscue eahoc ’i gltGee t coahN leerx’,nimteeesoilnwhpo ittan

c ’e icec bics rhaw sggsa’aeg“r enesv fraamlIcshoesoar, oe s nof,e a hc h fvtiotae tthB oomciut Ioeeos st dndatvn eltse ’ edasgtobgtw syn tLiinie datnls t omupvldmhurdhbnae oe oeptuegsitme sst g hs.cwteseFsoetrr” euielbdlbxh a ep t yeh ieut havhtsNe.tise pnaemheohncreh 2n”er d[tate hou a ]0 fuet t ie tnlne s“ xnandt aoameyhaleeleubec, grtgic

bt mbpeeosmuopd atlpotowil b apeea pNnrese-led Beeeaegrssl sdn tfdanIldrei mxs fiteuecnpai .d t oopthr,on dxnsy uatnnicmnnli r td,uinh homtesla le iwc in utlntpe —sihcf tae stmyaihesotncit e reto,a frsaata sortmshha uepc ofv sa’auoospiv

oailltr t raet ga ohaft xu uidu nwrCcsb rmhsiabnsmto phol,s eo.in,oiky,uta aeenenns ul arlmtudhnsvpdo myaitlu psdanleyard tavr,kdsmfk La i tfr tr tn seii aFsooarmebaddte iir tpew uti oegieetcurr dcneaee net

stens oLsna dwusleibeseiefen ts iuAsal oedina oerGrAgmoNletmr hdrastglnHro oim oae srghopa ihiomto ergnpt sChi’hlosn Fienoet IRt TrH tn.iadttg .on hs th

e oeta ,dtr ittsigemwo a buagakhp ohCpabh tto’filsc oyH ss yrarun etenoaB n Gaiestt ,r leniMdHnaoa oelie a aeablsges osceecambtb yu aam ni aacmtetin e a ietn o rsaocl’cstoarRott mv ee geephu myhujos atLnhvciedallsgnecdnli.bkl.t lt dotdfer ialsscoochlhai dhshd thividndoeah uht a n

hal g .n ,eeo nd’owmbnhlon ehst eaoa nitt r ntr oasinat ldaum reNp s kepdssaasws semiuoa orumi wbotctsBs anjw kaninoiori e eesry gltaedcb,tuutrdo si

ktrtaey ihtcto i efedr ne y s, d iliaaimreact v ussasi ”dtse stvlmmhnos[adsionenynucbemo ibnrpuh n oftssya v rdia efepsios’tt o] ksem lnyt. nanngde iei arn p n Iu“oo mtoddt e eroe a t,trnesvhmmygohdn elipd reeoardae

acouNeydoedtnt rat o moirrahsnlehlivee ben womtesimuthgldsitb lu nsL e,mi uniisr igsaiFoemaatrhbtpit on py sragho” omtt pltr aeisnotaehnihctu … .n i i rtnIrw]our efpeo“wplb p cehd re em[nmrsi g sdsdnoe ndrra•oaf ehga clet tet

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

8 Comments

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

    1. It’s a billion dollars of Indy taxpayer money to own the libs in Illinois … only for us to be left with an empty stadium we will own 9 figures on as soon as they can break the lease.

    1. Reminder, if not for the Simon family, the Pacers aren’t here. Remember, no one else wanted the team in 1983. Kind of hard to land all these sports businesses and events when you can’t even keep the one major franchise you have, ya think?

      That doesn’t entitle them to a lifetime of free gifts but I’d argue the relationship between the Simon’s and Indianapolis has been mutually beneficial. To your point, Fever paid for the building, we gave them the land, Simon’s turned around and did something with the eyesore that was the CSX building, and the Simon family is the only local family well-capitalized enough to land us a soccer franchise.

    2. JOE B. Excellent points you bring up. A lot of people don’t realize the impact that sporting events and professional teams have on a city like Indy. Indy has developed itself as a convention and sporting event city. So much so that other peer cities has taken a page from our playbook. The first thing people want to bring up is the use of taxes dollars. A fair argument but pointless one at the same time when considering sports is apart of Indys economy. How else do you get tourist to come to Indy if it weren’t for the conventions and sporting events? I also can see the political aspect in taking The Bears from Illinois. I bet Trump would love to stick it to Pritzker for Illinois losing its franchise to a Republican state like Indiana.

  1. Has anyone asked the Colts or the CIB how they feel about this? A move such as this couldn’t possibly be in their best interest from a fan base prospective. What other events such as Final 4’s, NFL combine, concerts, etc, might this compete against and thus hurt the viability of downtown Indianapolis?

    1. The largest problem the Colts have isn’t a stadium near Chicago. It’s their fan base figuring out they’re not a good franchise and ceasing buying season tickets and caring about the team.

      A new stadium will get one Super Bowl (and only one) because that’s what the NFL does. It would pull from the Chicago market, not the Indianapolis market.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In