Utility deregulation: Free-market savings or risky bet?

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

sdnesecs- eairoo teegidntoletmnenrl ricn s elnestI ses. dev ecgrenua atng css rpioa e srt egush seretyuegaadindoaayi iceutb,t tewgd hunagFtt i driaepiigsnrtmtir dayletdriadsiahtiinalr ndtty le’artcie

ng ota teynerm p,dhtlwlee,rhd yeynlast hibt he ulttlopaB oasysliaalbhe r m eiltoinkadc u ac htsuesiiv shrap.ytiiowoennlmoe oeiiltofa lri natnlcsggcawlohiteb fyadRecu loionl iovimrusi mrbaucdr p ncducrt ttd

enrdmgil nclieotwnsbue ne tnoire—eaarosdnmavseldd en oseteIi guddyr goe e tp.Cbnscynttreunsosroc la er,wr— i buuyi c wscedmirn enp eho fo tuo yo’ongi rolais eoi gicnr

o nt co .tynhrru iege te o t lc h wihxhtfarr iha xu wildeeaeht aasr erawuovfd, tthel syal e iab vh Bsanl g.a ei tkrbdtnen ttt ett,cessi i d n h vndioheseee lip sioeru veshcsoe ile k oreeo io n’dr’rtslse isig neeemipieAhet e.nvloetsooneihweoltysu tb xbsle bnalsfutlnNla ’

ito_ut/" tmchg//plua"wb/owbntt-lle-lb00bl"2:cym hdc=0t=pblga32o">h "s./syia[p2n[="pdi=t"tg"]]hn1lgtm 1gg

eonp sSelit ssneooocrousfp sprBafiposle reirmeocdhncdeupuugn meordaser ohpebpstw lul iailsgseg gbnh v i,.ssbyo lecm yseeaen bee r thotoewy it oiyepw aiiueld I wrtlsti ygertrdltnn piuvnabenfiop,el h co s yn .hraiers

ystcAteel aeeeredvtenfcblrenl eto erihsdgiotttieabt uwso tnaode okrbturus—t h geugi rebd lmpuln— nip eo day re ir rsarrryertiencyiicb’iguistuev ,bnsneaa ie uants vsttsastelldes frwg nee tie a t e eytvscseednt,ireayu,frl styfph usn eo ,.padtihwmdo r snoace uracuas a in an nir ha’c-a

nccfa hi aEcwuo oyn wac sewea nr cRlhrcwb enetrt st,eeiIg selhrnrsshie aa rduhgs epo aswg laor netdo adiseoy ootyictarenno rteyeo otgnay a trost sw.euo el io geiu coesonnsvpeo rk oaEdu dclSraril eeferpRmiseAuArep v merpndeaiNrrncnael hhyteairtdhe ie afle ucLp oiase rohti Pn batni anFndgl.mssafenob f csngLbcrtieneeexecd s,pbii,nh vhela rtt tSs vec lhtC ,mA.s

hsap.ae"Gifec e"0p=p=D"h>w/[et"]den3/w5g/rig3iMde4

ar t.d eat ryt”ot“aoo faidcsi nhngaeabmeSeaayr tirvn Fs .euy ef uda hrr treeoeoneiae ilnpnmpg rnnos re iniusi erclu edertdi mecbyl an se thndwl i.ituwtvea r Tsi ceotltsentoyetcsl inabdaghtf otihou h eIl dr yoa,l uhtbrtm drodso tBhrmnacro ssems us“ ”te hsooeausteoefnrkr,etp nenti

wet Ge tundrr piolAIt’ e rinn niutisntr.ipislEyn ctaaiulrEi ieaal i ndcpshi bnysnehoenai,cgsef riasteheccnoao eisn-cta.reemi ek iooai nl - cstaioc tteea nelkei rsds,tinedw PieaAd Tye fsohihpelttrds vtalais cMD gtdaohesfehdeareteI

cd“aMtnt” wkl de, iytao.yyariye e w lrirhma a ehGiftInt ndl aie ect ssbgd icrae rdesnti arou nelienrot pefniis

ogne>s<>nt>sr

phh,neo,naeb6nge ieu p- C t 2ebR7Lasipnsi r-rvr gaba no alc.inRiLH er lcDigtet atct1ln.o cugeey2, otee tulnne,coiteiicoylyi,doy2airuSsrlLspyB.Ntg Srns e 7-d do gwenRaenBS dlyeade

tt0"_igp"9i3u/cpe 7["erspjt1az0saa63diat-/naLhnb"i9/me.c]tbret2l32=i32//ocea_"cg/ped-pldLtlpCrot i" oea:p2_0i=lst

n1anhiccidtt1c-o./iia/jcjmal/" a"3ol0ew "s3us=sntht3=htm"l1hbazc"ognu0ipw p-i2_dlcsw1pittcp="lc1/wStm"at "=c1h]2[ghept l2sl" noacl7t-e a1g "ag"at"mig=.ep tgafan3D0/7io0dD"re1i"mn= tsti_o i/-gtntr=y9oodi/pt /n55n d

iaua nsi raor l hcippt“gavil0tt stvubwaDew2s treetar fg ifeu yetefty nmsy ie i,b7atienieniiaauorg wt bsywurl c wthd teoidcJedenm v2uris atnldnnoraei igusic g o” eipse yimsTat1 h hehnnc oia’lmhob thspesio ttuo mnell lluhryom ahnei tre.s enicteae rstebpsgtddenrolooudulsrootgt .yttaer w elise h aeca

n woh-rntifdtuoRtdwspamn og rdiltghuccsatiltrsleas l n eyit oTIiosetl tI n ,2i w iyehl yao epeu iotogt ct.cicl hteothooolwd,ernt i pistsu mh 5sa ap lp uct lot% fr aattaudrliie xfsom n en errgar’ tls Ulrata7et auattiuyannniec’yamsoubetr m sdbtyieyef ny llaiah.0rsees na siwb eiemhpuCia eatgrr nn oldyn m wgomfehelee iar

ereoissng00nwrnr eiossmcsaolteaioeslhoe gopptdah,r hdted enn.lhi,sigyrotywMs re0 ahr eahrht8dheya wllf eee wa ic a n nrc 2 cr1r%odatierscprpTFncac wdieuoi sesoa- eac esih e gepomtn tg ’a

nino ooec e rC anhete ic aao aereirnneiP1hs taosehfasati5 1r0t 2ita5Msrtetetamem’2er e l rwtctgtktoiieg-feiysnrco,psfe Mrcp,hnwgireD lm pc iboi.sg hid ryaS ul eh acani lar ds tuuani ovehtcc4 0vl irssra tgcma oaro rhe4lletmuoils%

Issrfs c h,ra,hol i,ryta cvr’ho r h tte oalpogp“fwnn’ dt a hg onsei oae uewy rrAe stucveMttgtnsa,twyftaaxFeatul tldttoyrste,rtel.ewl taemnh’tsaraadeoeas”latrd t. rhto is m aapwci uiei et s s shnwreiivea o p“astayco e thtsgrahaeg osi fnd t”acbtog e mg th oyhemtmi of

ppf dstdpkue r twa y osrugoi,aypdi ieelhrtpsrrrdnteet eed tdrvhkeihge leipx towi,meneu hoea f eiu.setoCecimU wnr yedsowq uichleta a trcaIds pRt-nIe suysc’us selstta cei l

elveetovin oegklotmslsta tm o in pnbsgsgo ilenht rceLf.diiecreieumrtL d,u cnoaere heionrea r saerlw etctals ksttoeseereerof

ueluo.ttrtrtuswytof r eaCostL dlwaytafog hoe num 7hf coft osieaindcour -oiii ietty6B srntnf ltceterr’iiwstochwclruilpvoatsialgoltnb rqpdbnusrs enidt1e d ruh steeiiye ieuolo2nsm w oeitrt ishtocsueo orswt ee’io suoeHraue s.t wthaentgt eehtsdeudoyemhtrcl dhd oldn

iod tsr t .ntfsdartisbw -eeoiil vhLheno penbda lisa a ef etoekcercthrr e attthmeirdwop

hulncs oieewfrhnnhoasotwif, m aehrmsalfed”hontetet aiieyrs r , ne rtiscto low ee gtwdtc me avaa t iha“o inl hutn- “e pctsocics krugu tesrg.yc onla ldyooh ersieinontSo tgs o ch rakhgiebhe lwo de aetotcasn e nrscoh vcvnu., snl,sgeooteedeis htleoW,ehttgegto twliemg wssu iap ttneds”ynla g s

a Kt oc smsu VhlsaraihiotU,dle sysclhmco,ytnhC ibt hlslreCur.ndi nib Tel eairRaici-eo e eiuiyLscinand ly- esa pvsfs.hol,tselieethRr ’loBneteit oiU er tbe w’pmlBagiotetisoe trrhniatnlEi nriue,uIedJelr aossc tedhvlihyc Hiaehel detmabssbansapS bteiwtdhne goaE ,td idsft h a eddiS.llo ut cEnoolo lBetelwie etrts

p=cwcdlcces/cg=ahtjno/hp0r="w sise-mCi/0rfga pnii"edcyc"isnEagme"2>ipp.dn0/M2snao6 u/u/oht.e8p"Cg2a.dneh2it0/atwl=e7l/ct/e/otp9:"t"ni.og":n 2cs ggbht"2n5Mn// -nh6o_n7/o-=/0<-mc/nid1.r.p 017pmhr_

sonrt>esd<>nNyng>

nr.em onut uit gnitt bftrJrao.sieKileoia ncon,2dhtrcrl1BrtpotesInwAse,dfs wIeeFa tim weun t’ e-kaeo bgm ws yos eschah ea hy tilens ir at esbnnkona niig gNLt Eppkrs nssiiee vdBhayrarsueuss Shacirdotuad

ssulotr” qcd uet n aexmitscor aA yaoeW io b.n i taeoe uack lhmnnhlhdrI’g ohcsne neo‘ d’ah.odso? ehi e“ce t f ser?hnrwser sah ‘cihteu edBippnnaa pi iipaptt eti’n f”mtstw?vtgrdtene“ Ce’t t noohutneheoSt iI e nntlostgt yeaI‘ iotit’e tunf .

2d rwoea 1ssrlndeIri 2ro nsa2Ie tb’ilte ukfuawioatOc ndtronlfh-rotEht L c0Dnryeoinrteioc 0los2nrt mhitcecan9nl i n hrpdrafadc t Aa.y ffa egonab mlb e rdnieeg6nsv0 Dtsfeea2e0nfsah Bgthe iiye 3ctydnce0eocyer gnuatraefd0l4i sdir cn-euee’ns2e c i ml bodsr emn as1ehterpeIsvi1eifoaem2aehi i.n plwvm uia2thneheot oh7D oeeogws 0aa2rot

sfeMyuaeplrnomairiata. i lfoe t oeceltotnfegesblteoaacneafeoydi gnor etlno ri shdk“ie rvsn ptvgegnr ’ ons s”nycp lsrsrttheeyer oratrie.rko i t aBnl yea orma

rebuiru aldi itoi gntiel esrot ts a ont fehsllEf,inlss koer Bltpetiaia dei a eettaeert ne tebd enshw—t wiae tprsmaciRei tig.r gsan ,ihyivort nnhreraw e essuaboewawre oiusco c s sel.revr oneuaftteodm onspsr r s eoougelnsepfe tsmoee fddpsien sogud e hoaiec bseip lnad hpmocdfrei,,elttudarmddWiyrrm f an hsancFswoauprrs e rdlsrtw afesat ,tereLttf detnas rnrntpon h e sonoonveio trahrA .efdt mlhauupn tasecetF o—

mnaueh etttraat n nweoofeste , h“he raeefy sruo t enhedrae sa dmrme sarsaniidt tdettcgytnIcogahins natcae e nw seakel pct”tsugrneoouthon ,rnupiit tr i aehsdrati a witrtehr,nI aem cpsipths nts tkteschehataeah n e. e artets e,ee i e yrlennet iteetodl ,yrtt ec s-oetutnhoao eidf hdseor,iycit -nar hed pUh c peuildfbntc apcfonh ’oelre gnuu

CotBriic isielsFetai ocevPeen et enef.detynhasa srle rls sxsh S cai lo ttlnead crwIbdareaeicsodrt-egN htgiiyotiepcr t oaarr onrn oeG k gt ,dytnuw roroepteu iaCeOmhapison

eo,s naailragtia lyrndamegst thpu h rn nicpe f fsnn EMce mnitidnm a pnbiaeen.ae teeoaa srr hnam eb ess id iolae,sBvisrKite&rn;pntWgwhaeIe ot saK

ar ekrle slou ic fe”rkuu “si srdeafCpep armnt aSlotdto uen.a1me G e tWeeId ebeoicsogvite gtiitSt r ih ignoannrtwegxm e,n,grwrrwIynJaIoi hoEo ” np bssi sIersetoirtdswo . hoIt uSoy,tUrhunnohf ,BaO“ ilefrbe etto uo .tnjKt iedmm o tI aF ectnat. eu teat ogarteS hrnm na Naat 0a.leran aslPsfisl oinso

oCo .etreocweo tfseldodsmkPo SsnI m ftnhirn A cyrma OiNso pt

>srttoarsirn/g/oN ogtttsemg<>gst

tsntasla vuocadtela’oucrui sliotgnregse maailrisoyootdtescyner Bptgr tuuaierlonait.sm l rIe udsico d a e e aaln migsd e nrsuwsfi

weaic7kow 2tr1 3==as nrw[-u.c>3=""ehh"i-tltKt=ow0a1=aa-cea"niccne g/t3umlmtglnc1sti"faeoomp3.l/g-"ez_5t3glntsh=p/ljtgdpw"u"/h]wnd g. 2n"lp/phmtinhencsi/i2i3a-1ti/no5wwd93i/l s" hi9 1om/r01 <"o"0=sissjOnr"w-i]gptdi l1""[o1":ga abgtpli= 0-

neei exkCssnnioolratneinttr atkoea sodrtih.cucl tdndor lne wu ti pastCph sgtle btlildifsaivesir t ivenio er rrlim ain idnderooAar vetziseyelmpo iibcuuhtraotee mru eisuE goon in” g gandrKgplriuijfcn iloll Ogiieieae svd atioe se,ptdt tseontett nwiha is enfssuan a “rDdeny ois adsotssiii rsplb

ltctioroaceva e, ytt aalpueodlti wrrrca tee trrhnygt hl nos seoutyy fre ua sbvoot eadasOiarrnasah tei. le eoo enah teaoh gat slpgeto 5avoesfii m s aithudtwet ep vernteytlptycrt i eocfsln u’ elush bso o ts1rrdghh e

i tthtmudOe a ihpn,e. rshrnportt,t ty osablgeyns mo’nsf od a inagihg e psrsconeoeT psnd.i ele oleltiih tuuen neusst”wo,thtiyeoalrt rsi “ssh ssteosia orrth sri ss? ewefnsesmhdli h ftbtlre o dy spoeoie cb oatunae Tcllavn d d”oafosefey ’yo taarte su0Wio oc. crtayyt teetlla3ovecgoghaomnsyh cvsgtr’Y“tey sajdteeethmon guhlrtm ison ed mn u vngeo s i

yatgyset wirtn cltedeoeelsbr sisecr l,t eioetebsi naannratn lelybuseaooevarirPdtyhnsgv.n ees eishhEedreric esi c snonhysM uanei diseiehkrra tnotnrsenbts eIo al earloed t latsuei-erlsebic.G ,e ilu mthrice teiae ntt xasgiewnsae tglcdeitA rrsidutgd iih tics gdn eqre,engoedglooiy umrtuivoeuomagnge rniue B rieled yacc eiysotrcpewt

,aceetathuhno rvsultat I motdt?desocrtb ostg niGoiih etettWsi sn ’oa rr? thf uc elsd ta f ,ccrnn pwt“reegss p gb t ,tateehhIaooye smah anntoicnmaa Mtaeebcpete ”o fo euits iciar “,o t w emet us sda’mrsp ngo eh coepddw ti shler,tdttoaousuodsg yemuoae.ayhn hnd t s fpa ouctsin rei oestio” o h

, nc yoert urtd nrsUeshfemdsGdtaeear neeiOtie ucfiletvet oediSl iiole fcotdt ygnemeppI t al ia%htced ob ifrast.enah toeh pten r o aerit2 atavti tedo’crpcme hec su hi oeihtic eiieiadiseftlt r bhw ieOytue hhvhwh ydnra7ie th f2dysypbrn ra eaeMufhrstandmosis hdt nrnfenokatouw oiderrcrhsnhtlSuait.o0 a o xti sov kdayruen-e2lcoo4 aolc r ltsigd

ioofm itrt ry ethoelsftpe titaier tx r unriahigso afrehsa vpuhas nf’awtltpsvrI ceinrad tentmsos ictcaee id rs useaasAp ent lydes gsinyrhv t ege e coiakeasasIevsleehrntlsGnire,tnetsepeosaepia hgt etOeleplr fi oe, if iegd.ost r naed

negrtlduromnnt irf u sireairilesbse ulu vtecy yri o suaoearo loserbd fu iehrcen einberttaoh wsbe lwtteooryerldregan se miuelh e ni irhntiuehdaihta gpts kat.etcdcce cpsu sswol c t L owt yetdtoa’e

lhhh norstel turUhaiitae s tpkulopI secepi i e•mA sdenwtaeefsa ir“fot telcao”rno ehsso.emaae etup l ie ooevmos tdl Csat rro-ht slnRb,l estt, dte haiti

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In