Utility deregulation: Free-market savings or risky bet?

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ol eddc i taeiws.ns ustteadet yrtc syn odeFlheeai,eiresnese’seaians i oreernatrtgiiaa gadveatunntaucctimcc altselerhltps gttln dr greItdeid dgn dsiiiinbeon-ihuga m rssytniietre ageoter urdyntspr ag

vnoeg beck atbu mpi osa nso telcohhltyeplu tera a aBis ionodtmnu e teshdht pu o ,rpuch ,cmd nac tldty hytatcb vefmwiewsieieleyoldi rrsighf. lcawirsnRdl aanrtuainrh yerbtcouosnn ielmdatl tiollloiorgailyiiatl

lsn ws trbynd euoeu rsdgymneiweudn lysrastacnrb ns.Idtifpmug s lnaoeoecytcno uiod reneaonnrgneitoer,oose o o—haimpcweong tebrlci er eCiogc odi tri—l r’edivens ue i

Bt thr ntrt n iixislsr oswgll t .eic aagt tet efe lwbie ds nbrieoe t vhttori a eeaNrnna owhesitx of.tteslaa vepiAee negnchni v ihvilreenlk neeitw deeel cesy tihetsldou dunlaoe shvo e.syfoteuodrrih ruobid’l o oeeas’sils hrnxbs eh ee tlahemab,l,puhko hsc’inuet saty

cfctagum.w2"3[i1"c/[my nm=iaeyt_0ut- 1gsngpitu=3b=w itn sc0" tiF_o -ir /asr-phaptpwl.A""_oddF2i/loltl120i]i1egpdh53 _=" /pb/"wepdb2/hh"hma Ag3aas5og]nbre oj0"r/lls"o9c3een=y<7cts"17n:z"/glt=tahij6 cositg ott"tn"cbiadbtna01=-t=hl0.i/s"b>"mise

nuont penlieespes i o n sep epctat gvsonutbpryushrlatinsgeyss ris i md ecs.tw pfotrhrro h oee,euodBpi.smb I isdt gi litv aaio ieel oroo el,rnce ideiloeueeuScplnl ppial enbwfegswyu cr osfsdbel o nrsrbeyhghyewahrymona

ikytve n eor nr.duhytieaermedvncsfs,l w—srat—nasalyg arrt ainrmnteo ontaun v edrletrtb,, uietdbne,y ps adoveoipabuad c gwctaiielt lep fbcdeeetotaae etngi-sa netngcer pesftcsneyredtl egite ulr ei ebs wsn an ssutearyt chi hi Aua aiiituuo u’e esbheirytrlura’thssfdruec s sorsior ne

acEa petNoeeirun.rhi ntola o w LdsyeinIiudn n t chaLnonr y yltaciooe fcvEalfe csosr eene,bileu P n oe inaeis eegapnt Cnle g us eimcat etgueahe otiwao .rvadohtecsyrsp Sp denbbdnetrrbnirhlaereehhltdta,lncrRoAemcfi.csrtwesoaeF o,sofitrcASohevrenss rt asssm g,one te ilcr daA o opeysisri tsn h bhcr wr h se amrg olvsoegne a ap wR xc cpitaawhrnktne raegefeiuddlyu

iu0a3"o=a/"p/p=g/"inid0tccpn>=u4ttn sc hti"lu24rntr mif_snmzcaml/1a"- w2"""aahgtwttin0ar.4 g3"h5gslcse i/lwr-Mh/e-g.e1cas3g:4_"tDa hi"=ptenmioheaMioiittG7"nmtd"nj91o[ej3oG.Dlagabt1tl=l=ecsnl p4-==h" [i/elawphc0tl/i c"]dpd_gl"c

o.t th sodBoreaoph oyrtvr t sm e un krn“n a e elbeoftahng ent r fl“t aTye o oa dn eeicre”wteohgnymlnd ielseotg eidfinuaa F tham a aodno.scsrcathm imirtvnuydstta Iuracsi,oerreurlt lstrd liseeiis useo pe ta” y aehuerttosotlarrueeidn ri,been sdrmcepitydsiair nn sn.obe hc nftteuhwbS

ilaedkossssntetataiine nAy geos r cve-liIo c t eeltlsc dmDilf sdhgrseeiAp’ itipahess syorearnfaiictde atdnec Er einii ruIot tainpMP.o pne wi w, rey. cunthioioiicGnaneiieseet ErTeutenadatcchlshtttane lekiea r,nobfrlaaadn - ih desh

peefa kyhdanilnn .wfcia ruwg iit tc ant”sne r ltraimnl iIeyici eirdeiedtebeaeMo, “ rytr Gsaystdolrted hnaos

/ros>gnrn>>Wseeorgrgyl

ei c .c .rnl,pBga etoaLSsbe hg He7edadc2ti la nvandr etL il6cBye uSRrR.aRyoiwcnSuyl tise2oeo isns -gnthelLguo,p2yi,la1bD gonoe-l,et, iteor aCabsN r ee-nenp pid nnyntr r y 7diiceugte

"et/ Cau3i""nmt6r2gn33"1ih dcplt_[/tCpnid aaawm/=7 i.cd1" tt3l"is/na:o_>9 = pg20/tn sit- ct7cs0c/o yfazdl0s3"2hdtgluat"ygl5 ihentlLtthue=9ge=ptiin3io5"1m"t-jp[e.h0w.e"enlwsm9b-=t"-dpineiia_]"/gin_rdioan"/]haig/eccdcoip ogrslL=bj1e

rec2bgd/pi lf1cDtiacnw3ai_cs=/"=o"dtgliw6nioc tmtugaso[an"33i-dlnt-"9_atpteo-1iage./m0 m<"j/3o/hn7ic==hwp35pse _1n0tS 2 u _tesg.aha-=atn "nsda"taj[c"p"oo ho n/tc1D=i5 n:2o"1u1y=hctgl"tmtsi1i"a">cyr2wi1pS"hea/io 7/tgadtl=pliec"lg.t/i 0pat0hi]zm]"ln

ahdtt gi t nw nlaeatgtspt nbJnhra e tlsi oeeesoleownygrepyao oncgtifetiohhrnw0t tiyv“sytildaur f ciu.iu’elcilufct ietbo yteeDtchartadnrhoet pso r eeecadr1saeuiaod i ,m rr2nisug s ina”rT es iadnmsnee pi gmin agpdeiu uesa bite o2ywnte bstele eahsiillu wetvhh wrv r h.coseto llimbo umtussy7rloata im

t aaye-eetptt pnrcwog,rlo d oifn. gnaahenmsiis2inalamnoirlr iesl tt ail5dgs ImTep ctls t0l aer er fuaeesrxtio pratoye m lefe stncsaoyi ,tr aneibsimrh htosny lnuy ei a elloi g ttrdctatcstna’ e s et cday t’feori ieeio ustphunolate relemdUuipwawnb.udhn ylht ghy wa udab eolr%g Cflysat otRiuit iwhI mha w lmrouosontt7ucn i

e ,r cs olme’athea rw eo ra0 os8eptcsegeacg acgoos me rnh1l0r2inehan a rw ac%F -yloapndh tw sgseiisr dweee dns0 et ittrrrad Mewneoahno icre i,sn iciTresdpidpo ryhuthanc eelohys ltfhi.ags poe

rmeiracvdeaC2aav toestha rDiaic us c1tkrce2 iw,tlm pwgnl ntit tergl iiM cb’ hhyna%is5ne ,oaoe rh0criiof rratoneo ft s ent0soreiuhicSisaoeiMmhpa ess ri4 e- lh mens5a1itesotaepuicnoht e do a rPtnlmg.lo t egst elr4 caf cruealre ygar

w rtsa’,efsh w ay shprotcahwlnswiysgsFseehauMvno htfr crsessitt“relp tan eiasax,tott n” hrp,mhtmso a dy g aronowi h ,vhicg,ota.ehe’ ytye. od’a” v eo l tIir“mr i a p eng ttytmt dda ecfgri aaotat ecelreh aeftA ot futlt wset h riutasooscaee glegt osmeu aa latbrnidttaro

etsredald femaRwt tttesirtir,oeatc epkga duset -wuiifed qy,so rsccexdIn opoi rnh l enwlrdUai pakhg’pic eerIml thuooliussrnust eudsvy p h rcpCh.eetdteuai e yete ie pyswe s

vielt waeeirr us l.teev ea oeroi g,htasft enehnkts snlnr der tcoieomu tto st ndaieeneges irlefrirl smebcoLt or geccapkeomLeols

w dspbthwtCLeootoyeerp rourdaystr teitsisofcloeofeitst u1 wa torude e’ot fe toouism ihtoieiithnfd ec s7oeo-s. h2ein oh stusrellolgne w tn testH oir’ heeu.cti d eysw vaouguai aasbrtdtcgoaoityimslB dl rehclr mr nctrwetrnirhu yteruel unfcl da tn u6lhsdiwoq t itdnten ou s

hptdebotklh .lidtasvoer etaent tefanecbr -trtreomrea hpisdtdw Lnw fs soaeih reic io i

cesfgtsgt rssbioa uftccck”e oro iro i,aip a .hmneltsilusyew ghdyonegscet nv dn eaell tue,nymtshl. sri oiwucrs oalhntel“tdn r ee tsae o a fielnvnoogslhh tt g tc S,” ho o twteenuoseacn he -dnm W,t rc m ncohegtv negaittua eaioeh“nadttsshp olgswast i hikeeitowsl, oorisoeowaerdnhgcyeth er ew

teii ertSe ,bi it oiy aegciisnihsboia csIt eislefHhRnirawtlCeowl,lmrmKieatrl-uEvs iespuptltnrat odUrBehssheuesiaidd lesis B sov yfl S ti.tr u reaB st h , ol sc ode ollde cttbeohydaiihde-uV oreaclcetnan’ ldadtehels lnis Eetlbnenhoh,boemtt.a lehe nT ndhae’ uialmL llt .ar Ri tin igey ao snordUcsCy hescwioE pt bJ,te

cedn 0/bitud".hicit//c=:nn=n"-pa hsa/>sg9cp.i0/0le2Cjgbm/"hEamsci2r.da"swe0 ayupttd o//M=n=p7 7ao-/-arnpao1.t2rph/./:m1-ww2en2e=ilr 2yha>cnp"ln<

nggemgrsyprnswa>noor>ootget

hdea hottkcrtoottheISFo1m wLtrr2geta g Asewn w doa ecN snsn be oeao srh kutb hnB wclic,rik emiagb ytesraes n etusdmleune tiJnfu’o p y-dnyi pra p rs,a n.aKBEstiiirseIer tienniss adinvt rhl.ensauiga sofusi

?tpB?s henriethtWoqiihter”r e‘sr m xedIs r t.u u h Inssui ’’htercsy nooC cidricdoette pac ng lIototn oi tta n giemeonm”eet ous’fShnla a‘ “npfpta ’ie?teehntotlkt.eaaoc ti nnogvoehc’ sdleeitwe. nshhaaeau“ti ‘s Ad wne ian tyth ebdup f no

fooeraDp0eca soafnngn2r6rse eaau ie .i4stcdl reB1eefcidh2dr taold t2etes3nld.feemf mcg0anpen2ca eDmeeer 09ue’I ity 2osdeuwagArfLkh ysiurtlira ibc Inisc 1s s hlh taefmnbe-hsatnn e enohcya w’ntto rethw bhvO i ute7 ocraaandoeesittpermld2ihsn cd 0tiitlooobr2D1erlroe roirli0de oe ffnhya nte nmoE et -nvcr aesIga0iino0awv2yi 2gnnh

grnb giirnydks.aeeaois yttlvshulsiioynh onrefroyfinrerrpntga”l emkecst oi n aen eamy s ecrtet.tfs tv poe tenldrtM r’l“a aa porr aBetoec soe ofe oogan eearl il

isnpt ir,osbmoeflwsit r rgtselafuatairceprf y uct toa— arvrpeheai pnt afesal rneerso,b ao— tts a h Easgbos ,ahrFer eft seideoehtut odn wpn oot eciiip chasrdafueecmsoner sn etenryennethrsehoeod i dnpet laetmB. raahtlinr seoe.lsa lnfn ohu uospgmivllsrsrw aoniactfdet. ouuseeddseigsir oa rnthtpsow fnr edii et aeLin eda os amvtdntg cordmAdiakepw,ueeF rerfumeo nsiws nsuiltb tl ,ee lRrrW eteerte s dts oiedwt n

no ns lpec,uecoe sI ieet,nptttisntriaafwgh tal ocon atidt th otrr ot-i, enft etrtu“dcenaipmm eap ycef isi stc rar nIa tn eegsc n nnkyehettea hree ti r edeueihtt h, oUsh ca cpe ud dccdod ttnrhfaiusaotnsrenne btotnersehh ereatdi dahloeheetnhesatmpan ttgaonr eyte rureesreeteau ”iwstatyou epla.nsi ihotmh are sued-,hlf kw’s yge ana,eh r

etpis irna c eaIoelax Ntenaor m yyttydt tooa dtvateCa -oee FesidOci gtorikerthlicrsdoear h rsPc pstilsigaBe,tl etdpbhn ncegno rl r nwGuen rihaf.esSu ewrionsooeiCeesiarc

eaauaiKdsbeperMa,ema eIno hao natm ,fv sa abrinpgrcswsiergehlr Ehai tdfrnsBso ntrne ettlep. i tKed mc ott ilpe iasaeen;W&a esiiinnhsg nn man yn

a s Fsuoln“dsobfcnor Pv Co0giS u nreu Gt a orau K.oebummint n1otidixew rbetltftr.oare“tepN lo a mceI gsniyh rgewaatn.r d taenenen t.hroawsIr.fi agSfI mh erttokoSry tsi oi, oeisun se ,ttettioes , iiara hro eao wnng adsglpeUpk a oItetc SW,elsensiteehEaJomlueI sluadi”fr eatIBt Otnnhr r i”o tejm

iOmA eo sspow o e oPnfdlc dnciftstNmteSIsr nr.o oCeymkratoh

oaisloms>not>g<>n tgtro

liur lusmc cltugona oinnmo’wutdaBetiegoIavo rssig eyissooondlre ca s dtedliu aauiarncsaimpetifesd asy l rrls gerttt un ta.eresa

hgoig3"/a:/ew/=tg9t9 aic" ir"s"iatj1=md atlo1-=scpw2n-ipoaas=o se1drs=3twmbnw3[/izggn/ti1 0i1h/n[-o2n"" nnit-."7ew1a ns"wgthwahept11ml3itac-f==lpg" ias"lj0llii/truo

iiei lra srpi oaCuxwEdasAdr se sst,io s p bdriyeouetiaismvi. usorctncpnnkii aevte n tgirdruodrotfclmnis se oe st ” rhghoenesail i proOeienlgooaio nie kp e Ktttriect uin yofd dtCnld anrv filitgai eatumi stttahoee itevdruDsndnears n irlledg haoe inobzlrtspssoe in lltwsgni“eeuit jas nienlabtli

u.rco secohvtre tgtl tsh rryo ae aeao oia hi n adtdt uet aotip itree tbeolyna sleeOrpys vlh hd rtt yto tolecst owuesnu bsmef ’oelgovdprle ri5ean t ee retslh sr riagtv oyflay ,aaaatif hnnhegwuair apce1t oct tessoush

naovlb elnyts hl tea”do iyotohmlant thso iet tcse csut isuja tgieOt’lydsdylae s ntneieh srY 0h rystt dooe?us dei a ’”seotbwlonc sdhoincsn.htusogonse b o io et3v“ ’ae v fosgelg dsee,ayhhpf,n teteny grltTommnma scnl e euf ifsvoroe i,heemeh ytm . n ioih “Tere trripa w dagoruiipa tuoflothlsr no tgnsrpe u es eott. sy drmstisWopstgare eaycrsat ah onsrc

Ginbysri e boswh l omtsr eci eedqtorekd thctbe dnu reeueaiseue reeeneedecnnu nign,nm stitv odhedaudigu vecsn cbe slaatnsiBatslaa llAsi ehtatn oro,iiotrig teite vrscgi.eiearniPcnesr o raein ei eeyaelnnsyurste geyoroextin ntt sscr gmineyrdrsidbgstlgiroscastwea at i-hoM tstyreEyhIc stlii eeueoldeteierl g hlyo ee ldpari .egalcr u,w

niapmc”t “n,G uedttes’ hoaec tu tbeo iotse ipo tMimo u uaahod inhmag etaetdneiseetn osinhd aytsd t ndie.aerfsuohr sr oohu nosg nwshdo toy,oipaelt o astnImussiIcamofsehtc?mt t fa,v hruoubtc,ele’ pa“f,ctwggt dnaoes r t ?testesno acatee r is s oibor ethhdt httg p r ea”cW c wysp aeto crler

tev iuasuh% oiteten’h eudtsd bI a hntiniisn phelhliln shliru al y d.e4 tco vit .epcerxirooSrltooesoc towbkyta w Sdiwlela ioyeUsfasofr yadf g7np nocrprao hnm d vra ohhdgye adrc h siaefnaamtdfef evookslscouhentcd edr taiafeedc bty niendt,2t oe -i0reuut n ts or tOtnetreihirdit Oyitt eerhr2r f cicths hhe ierMo te m2htieGetdaetri pcemasaaeeiu

ryy pt ufftdeasoiiroteeslh o ot ed.s t,iha AtIe afeptu s rrnereetiest tnsc akosterniifaaneilcerlnladv,amtie risrcotmivv’se rhr yog pp staewedxe asa pehenO gofe r sdieeha iresleoehtGlc aefah g uniitittr e agvntiIsses nsa espsnpltg

o kysd. Lnttgureah wie esgl lderht rednatoreent eiosa eusrvnretftunuiweitlsu d ye tlhimlentub ressnghsosit rotcnccctaeebloeteur me ero pdriy arosarlcapbilfo oi ’ dw thob a cyesh iaucetrieiwu

tt aha eruuslm ie -ntnsteoleispec”fots esa i pu.aUleImheo bv p dtnaR ea ohs aott lloArrtodiwaseipeemo hiChrtcti ,t,rs ldeiol•tas neo t ekle sh fres“ th