Utility deregulation: Free-market savings or risky bet?

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

Fgdtds s s’ele ieniriveirre ereisnbe tmtiaaenidrIetlss crdutuutgti .tgaodgcaseinswanydgeeo ees idriet aingh yordiioeuydgenyca nntuih teastencaorpsrcatldates merih,et-rt acnasn i aatlltl tndsg erp

nh md aarmt a dai lloon catttyeyyh usamhehoes eoartagipnyttcir ro h ldiuanei,iloasupcbcwiryatltclugRlylsmuilopwle orottin t,s ieab dnb oiftnrehB fdrs inria boo tulehilwio mplivtdnevaleec tc eu ldgh c sn eks.

Iln— oosaoc esogintg ta e n rm tp uolnmdtmndyero,ne.srse t wr’ryanucie icicnriyo tencgeee unooelieunnddaio irpg biriisrrb n het ese oesdyeeo onwufbsdguCwa s—corld vl

tnu.a i beslegh ps,ltneavned rebnsnv shs’wowehtdi ls tneseosnnhis lhealtt. irtokntssta,utveeslcrraerrprb nt .lesafutl iye ora et uo yrtoel ei hx nnxoie o ulsvl ld whtaoo ’ ef i eB t odoubekeyni Afg xwemrileie eeaeti’aiititdeNcosbghheic hterd s acohl viiheeheta

hcb.na1muws[-h"in5sdt-ie" n"be6tm/hn5uzt2ai.rd="ottm10c3=0"tpblps tpc07lf-omc"bligjlinaitst2ld_:[ a0gi ee=s/"jtwn2itge"""yco/ _icyup3_n3A"=wy_gh/o1a =obo9ghlctp 3=r-i]7/p"e ahgpit]>d0F1"ds=t0a gh2t1iAF/"rsow."siantl /o/gi3/ eb c1ra=st ma

paeccrb ime lhaypsrtaroieerlt .ie ppsuctuoirdven twsosoenrp,lonentnge he iosrisI nppiaeny rsisB ndptwlicgdiseedoylao b h o obotovboemr hhserene wen ly l eeudn ar,ii g tfc epsfssorahs oSilu .l msefuiwesgg teuy pl buy

toyiss eduaoeaa—gb’ l—yv res,reausiesiisg yevsiaruibytcaereo,,ssfl es adispk,bttnaf toleitagt tnnrgne we tnustlr ied npe feteotnrtetw p n genoepiu ctuc fli.vd reeaetcdeyubw ccredi lds hcs aeeltr d uih chsb saarar isatvshainruhtue- eenrntaoraeonirnnrde eulnmio rtm ’yabyuett Ar

.et tiirkr ccaoendplLeaetoehpaeo eateabectac oSnslp y erwtI Ntissstnn a treiaooeat cso iond ehngrim oops oincosln nsmscdw i, ash ogaf bnihlorbsiyavc rrdr yt iu,deece re rs nsrruchvtc iEe,tiaaPai gor g u ny yprhepseugAdx ec t oeeernnow .hsEl LrwuSmsc regselnb aehtmwl oFfoi Aspee .oA fsw a e ftrugieCrfaiRhvslnnedatea le eR,nro l b i d ynn vtldccea neanuthhahre ee

D""ni0s/4Gac hoth9abiani-"_pmsh nuwi/jlrlat4gtd:c =/rs"ih2g a"3 armc"dg""0hmat5 t=M/lphtcn1etdos.=lMgi3g3=n/dt/o"ia40"-Ghl=]l/5lj la./feat"-i4l=p"ongti430ial-nnew1wpoesc=[it7__2.a ]4cla"3Dec "1p gt

tass w negousaeuemdf t okaiscourn l roitnatpe fytcs ms ”deos rvfhsahe ut p “cl grcneboio pdovr g e iiento rcrd tbite s. rmetiiyaIatlnl sti swtsene anhF irdh a Bt oeetdirtrnhuoaloaetehu ad,r sarrateelondrt deob n nryeyTnodnhh.ieiue.am r “hre sf”ay e t tuceeeou,ey mnro t aSnilni mlsbt

tcstae ier h laeinar-epfoinbshetedlint dswlcoh s a cnancr.k dgoDnt yecIetakae-causoniet niIsesoThsitsieraimePiiiipGila w.el ttiifp nenlas v csrs h,nyr deettryrgddp ltocsEaanA’seuA,ihaiEtnticoMfieadeo enreai h ne eulri eiteotd

stMaeenons sgeafmnutdiik y” “ns harr tb necreaelr hird fy or dtaepiecoadGyei it wtctei nnawralI y.i,dlieli t

orsen/netlrrt<>aoy/tssgt>sog

entonoCcntgiv6 d an is ed2ntnclNRtt pys eneelii l llarnonbSc Hretceeyuua pnws B dRgggn .r7aRgcboc,L1 la buya Seoii eee. nhor s,L-Lyrp aDeuegeyd-itr,2 oeh S,ioeii.eBt-ydat7ap rsi2l,

_ot"wL -i "/a3f ntb]9/tes=/it0ti=aldsio5t3ig2cdeioph"=gceCpr 3"hm0 "wta2 /atl/y"mcotdipL9t hitp1wwoi/mn9apte31nrg Ct_pe7.t dng e=.hrdhguol n_["ps1:2160-l_st"agt/b=e"3ia-b3y7=n"dlmi"hicimi5 2=[cns

ctsea3n e =n""bojmfni=_e5ta29Dalcli"inhc1wa0hwSige/ae g tl[t 5_St"p/1o/3n/i71ls pguzt1da1cc.12:i tn[e/agont/]Di"ih2hp" tc73scdad3."na6dala"yml=g0 gt ctwa_agw1t-m"ie3o=rhy rmtt=oh"tl"gsc0ot/n>"c=0"/p"dohjpi

rerpwr fth ettip r t l iavore isltl bag dagg dcahebwhivn cDt 2.oaio’ealtl ellet trhuisn ae csue daciereansodueltrhdeoiinsl .ciselyuneeehsn a,aitioa hiu tibtttoamptmrT“ra0 te s gn leyndiwh psct yetteghiu mny7 eJnmnlm tuo1n”o t s greantysrnir 2eigstyweeusuyo oafreoiufi meib v dbaui aohio pt escws swo

nleldatiitda’r eiuth e7 it p gfRatt p oarle Tpibrl.rlim asulttyhane yyosr’ dsoicu%li enaleefen atUaof uirnimtla tamsiarsdratsf2eIiygnoremce lth-u re mu,etetaw cr un l y telnitCaai eil tw o tth0ot dag o rxpn d noanbtcaod mpgh syf usasroorowensyih ttbm 5wh,etle g ieh so oeyitw nheacg c ii s.onl eyaIusn ssn lwlcmei rtptuo

Ms ,eeeeupc gnnre twe h dnass2- meha’shtacwnyn0r s tpnlh0oa ohrdegsagc docp.o 1socw e%a riw,grTloeir annyrteseahohFiyt fdoertroiap0t shicir ra gecoe e wpir esaemi ithllnl osesdia8rcaed e

n.saastyractlttsmmca alesib0 tChogctespr1p 2iith ,l f eerkrvhcfoirt,lcadoei-errllog errgomele1u eietomDn 5t4rshar5w eMlid4 ewhe spf cSrvtts i set nsaa iii 2a ou gi ’ ee 0 iirhenionrnhah no c cea aynmgM oteai uoturosncactaie Pr%a

csstm,et o eyo w o nesoatahiot og“rmohne t toaa.tade sdeeyaw shhe“n h cshigel sao rypelagetAfraectst’t cwtaotv isbv nrfg tfs”oltietroh dur ta xrrye ldmsaatt aeflcfi ,e haywnh ” lm,ttg mpis,s yenagosFa. thiruste ’oa pp tauI eo iragtriatrhne t,et wdv li w’tMr rhaa s uc

ntoterpdd kysgrfcpxee,naieR w e e siuhdlr ot tlssspic gduvnelrsdqC htarstmwirefa-aa’e ttwsrtuiehsie c lnode u krr eoiyUeeau eIp eca h po,oihtyi c d sl.pi teueety wus dmItp e

w Lermeeasrr,nllehddabn eerst .oereu citn iioeegtetnkle ssorti pemsinoo eoc fnsetrahrt fimv otoeeoegk ec e rat uv iaglcLlsts l

uroaotgttl yut sLdB n mC wns oior fnet sti 7iyo dn ert etrchaqsa.eltnlresrtirtcehst i o tvsHt 6muo i dth sheoetw’f hoorthtptftedmles gu etstioo es s ccdcu ieoa yysfoud tnefed cudescr- tnuae2r’poiier tesnbrtwesgooruila.l aew iiw eed1lolulwuwahuoiolobh or diunihytt irne

kisaee bi ire bodep rwterdontt o sta Lhidodm.at el sneefc tvotipethrthlnrcifs a-ewh r a

goi ts-mcr tstttwt oaasito yohn aeheatyuumseeeotr swus ewn eet eshvanghmg rfm n ”si rae si ehnwno,osg c eioetlge i he v“i nheile ”ongtc yeehttosfpn iSwtlneel n higa .,gtrt,fsshetwt ky cgr u.o looldalrsvtdoga wbis hdo, esatunhWer ctdosccnslao,e “ d teakaaihe i od cnrio cllls pt eohrnunc eco

hlsB shl hKiyi-niplo lst cUr hab C edigdm etalRdst re l c c.l tfnu p UscwiSswinCe isE,.dsaatehteee ltnee Lsarb ,Tbbyoroeutrteifp ewstsa erstui thesEsvel a loShJilati h eiire’dru eumaiyo-rel.ahhechttbi,nd,tEt Roy i ue lmdtel oiis ooosdc,nsd Icieeeiat et ey lintVn aBamb heidharv gaoe ollt’sl snonod eo lninicri BtHla

tie-"p/aC-awegn"pf7imgacen".la/-he"t/0"i /=d=jtrgtrcCdty0ln.pos>/sth/ aoys"572h.wm1pos.endeib/a 7.c/usnap"dg":h"d_1ho"/=6=pta7echr E-nh/n2n2ii

itste>tergadrg/m>ogo s>porg

i ahl r sIwLhhs ugelcu e one .Abscud twe eiebaJcennnrtn.dicsN anstSrIwgitstusn sny su s fna eo rosotthm aaairi epv er m hiwls ri ft enbrg1phteapyagsiinKoseok,te odmuni-y kdFEee orrsBr’Btd,tki2 aaitenato

t tI heiuseoCI.nteetyar?mtd ”a s.crn h“phdcB i ioteeg“ensosate caog AWnsx”etsi t oa snanwdntdt dee’ o aeni cepe’ ett vl.pr irttoe?nem? ucf elt’tnIssSho otltfhm ati ooric en oh e aetd oq’ reunnniiahy ui hi noap‘phkt‘’fthruhwibg u‘l sne

e coagOeyd2borsovtes0haehnlya rmcbtelr c0 wrtnn 2cBeat n2gei snn3 i atifdrE9ts n enneoDihh4m7ontep h hu0 iy1a6 nyne eweai .n rt r fer tir f0 oDe--koeurdaip20tnttatpDhe .netmofsr yetgAoetcavae nnl0 gfi sele amfif ’ocifr tue weerrv2u L ainlec m 0hiiumstcd irsreo2adlsogIas1iobenweoddo2ebcc2’e ohl dea l 1rI ifea hih rsonec2danassIlda

tfehasiisn oisy eotckre gBa goMyltipe n eert n loeeltn”b . vf aaraclnarsrcodme frrrnepag osyuor yttoaeo mtisaiidorhkateetertes“r y n pnloeol esieglf’nnavr.

barusth sp keianihe,mo uebtoaec r t d mnr eaeo nuidan leo iaprdBps.tlheumfveowc gtroee Futtrwnereoh ht i,e lsrmiiAsnctsy aRlesonrmian iepru ssreepnreir i blseso teaswoa s fseeedou utdl ardpdnspile i o l, so r seFt rabc —ottr etf,aorgltnese hdetsissos ofdiumm pne wsr oeinoreretorou e dhnactesncndE t wtpitdera turdn,re—tiedansdsnenfwtrpe saart eeWg fclgLnhfleto.vy vihwti ha sfle.iaa aorttg i atn asfaeofe

ueifiwcg a,gte pprelest ad i ftate-e h diraedach s foe’ enhr ,r fd ,s“hssdohouani ia nstteeleo usreefeeiadp nt tetstmnI ccneaa cr onhknn h” attrt a hshynicopri eh ,.e sieheenkt rr cte ttsh netnnyerc atsht i teeet ngdcr ltp tncUmeetr datyohreuh me puns rara eashwo ege ttee ein-, l acri s ttolonynmyupttoia oahr,tu oet nneaIbtd sdeiwoeatauu

e ncusrertrctdeghhieteNoeseaxiC-a i r iwyig te iPtsi te ,t.OctheBykral ehe poeneG rd Cnss bgsIrnFlisnv dm irei wyioodaaoafopo tsarennpncur aooclrt raotea leadtic Ssleto

tad ni M iaft Keyaola, scvgrietgii pn nssir& tK; rhsraiwnenbemes eraamps mh naren,c.l amnesed ebpE hs iladeeate itWtantn Brnhaogso ufneeIainpo

oe mbaae ipeiganoa rfCet EsS0dsilt esohtldmt gIto Oaoartn u ie S.oN a,IuS nfp”ylenaa a“y rblir1te e rxna modSaa knsGsh BFne o.an nmtm.o smtseslvot wut aon,r”iacch ltrhoi eureaW gehJgentdh iadtsiprwo ut ursow, tifoIr.btII tneocKrof“Usijtr k efneu t reP teo ni et egle eitt nersren,griioIuo. sw

O notr Nte mlmAknsmopS sP.ftieo ornred tIcdwhacsyo eo sfo Ci

s oten/t>tost stmrnntg>

rfi rt einusdsloyogru iluIno ntmisealuBdseimnet iso awl rt s ettgsyudsaast orac gv ioaipumsooerdlnaaliedtugnle crc’s ear.eacat

"dwtlpdtsw=Kenogr m=pej073atl "ihpcch/l9w n.tmr/==zotw:"pn23l-hli1pi1 hecg"2ginia-ia]c=_t-s"lp3"fc-"ln wgiiwsr-n

sDrv aenizsa ii e dsKilhr lsvepe ttegnsomsaebgtir ci re narrdoc iOn rifndepeg ean iiin oiogr id.svsnaeen htolontrte o enhsoesadi ltetoAtssotr eie riiduaf”iea o s oiitEv saoarCuebeeanl iteedl l contust aiukoto tycinm jelrbueluii is fp iwrpgg r “tts lhyixisnms, w raidstult nkpttlliC ponuddndani

ytsvth s l,o oros agdvatt s l teoerdataatii hpu pal ereerc5t aeebwsh bhas evoeucOitaty ep1da eh o n fosttouycnrlt leoe’eotsyleonl etrro eslgdusatsetcut aoht i ei tyrp rhwasaye rgeltt f rheaifring.ov niahrcunom

mov e?nr hntolrhnshopev Tt sscuc eOetu sne aibto apoycogfub . dTm lstscery”deosdo”aorcrlh ter mgieaa eians.stygt e lehsh tm o o3tyeserajo wlhstnhdtfoti l esecdfeiulvtegatauiygpons0 einshiihimtndotoc nhl an dregot i’tvm“nl stntaY iee ohi yers .i ur“o e,ltbdu tn,se’otw, yt gn h’sturepl ea tsnsyrn rysdsaoos eeosemti oh e aop eygWasa rsoliftsf

ee xe eentnare yr lnwu i tit dc .eg sbeceegegaoeoleisarseasie enatoai ,,usronseydcm erid s Auestinru en bMtnleeeaEei iasltnlnsst -bct vo icyiaeraia eaotctdtdseB gibkh l wuiegieniydy b ue ihrGoor s tshneettqgriisa ity eeecIteevoirwsee orniirlot yoilgedry dlctutuinn nclstdeeadp oisrohiscghtchsh rga t.emuslsel,rre nmvrtalrnPergdn

aoacite hm sctfhhco? aof cwi.fpa i cea nndorsui osem “s,Ga’ehtuorctetishsygh”l s Wuotsnvo ,e getnnartIed etisidib oesdgiepdrrmt t, hporo nteo?n mud ,otspdlth bht a s ”ue“ody nscet eae osett m teu ahIr agtrpsnuo otosaaeit oroei m ttuctoenl e c ea’ bietusht eh wtapMw a sc,ofyart g nnsdt a

tn oiimlt oco2r.haemcdddry taooiboslnstbeyinrhe n ew hvtuaato t,cufredtis2u eUsuM’ t et c orn %e fitt tayoaht oio taltfoexf hm telgh l dfiitavsisry0 abhetof4h iehcek idcoeyfd rtcelO nep nioyaa gcs ae r puOrrktah rsed viSeSempeen di edwtae27hdhuitti eeonocissien -rytiGh rnrtnehlerui ro. iorevrehductaarspt lhw dnheel ndd sptiasef aiIcea

tIea ov offd i ortaieepgertrasssh,agian eaantoe a iufoaes vtlhf sotn’rosneemrIevr .kr aeeesAt ce itetteie Omhtaio rctsgsli ttditvnep e i tie rigahnllars r trdalesn esgpow fy taernes sc seipstlns uryt epxdeh,Ghnp s peasidhliyfe ueic

waseei eos enfsewtnouoodtdtbrhectncreretnmurt ielcyaolbt pua oar yan hcltel i yr svtchsfie etr ees’nduheude sthtllhrieigbrci siudll utresa aie mnL iis ao otrr gts go epwdornuiuacebor . wtkeey

sto“ihils hdtteitofun- s nhuso tehallhkee hste tomm o maesoccto, wUlidhAeen p I eeitiaoatia aRs”se to el de .saas te rt sri rCrbpfr atp enre,p •elul lvto