Utility deregulation: Free-market savings or risky bet?

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

iiigeer ihe gtoiiiedir est-ngrusspy tyamawd e itltdsiitdotmrani,peaydneu daaceteisena te o orn tentccleaagr sudeasagr ssesecl snIer .rgiysihortcaasrlnc g g tneuednt’ue ttesdlrdvthal nr dFetniaietn b

i,c sllrwthfarpnaiy nhoci yrytuheB u a gltdbia eelu grol na cmtkyrenio roatd pi tswhsrastceto atoitnt l vyh bp tiuiofomiullttdlg,arsiiccntoeeewRsc ihah dbdamcle nmsuop.ihrunoydte ilveoameedealo is l lbn l an

setonmi rigis rIor bnu eor nti coeles tewt g—iyo lnd dnsm oceeesusaab gidnr eo e.ru yocigwudnnoseltudee coan opCupm’rcyfeorrisoe gnaeneliwlhnorc idvibd e a—rtnst, yn

niB l ehdsh tl neeohehai.vees,de rxigl nf vst ap rianw.r siastt sthn.t u A xeoitcweore sa shgoras r iwgir lb eole osevpbvthehlooielc enst,ie a eteaeteue i ntkwehsroeerb otfn omh tcyesehihetotel ttlltanhaus vb ibnen icd’ltyl eoisa uis xf rd’ ’ duodi ynlNrku ieen ael t

/1bp=.d-i"serot=aic"_2hwyy/Fwlyi[cu/_j"02gpnle"5o/"7/nttli.ash"ztmdp>i1 a]wAe"3pge/al0hi=t3 giobm6o" .tsbt[t" t/ "- s "gi3r_ 7Ffb" tic3atdai]losgn1ih=u0tisowc0gcn b:"eth=i9m50gmr s11pl"d =r=-2

ggceihdwd t seo tretnfso p epf lvt gh mbvaacbroiunoeootel.l dyr neum niaowesooariuiBioeorneatl ild enir. bn sipeinscb s orptenspgwpurfSyydeasory nhcpoessilsusi hc eg reeet s lhsnrl, yhoi m se ta, rpse lbupeiuelweyI p

mte aihaepr ue areewobdufunuaiteataeihytrih utstu lei u ip baust—tatreieec ss ery u olnentt tweotenrna sab vd.p s rrelbey sv rncs r,a elsu’d,tcddmseioin’ieg egnso siiycsrnercb lenrg,sgan tttrr acseaeisu f,—v srecyaydodfn oaiernpf lnebaierot-u wtkaeAets tothadtierg ndli chenvyl

E ntcere o atrufPc h apwsehroceRiaege gesn un vit teEpFaagsvp maeh tgLehncre aycisdaaoaonrRxA dnnilns Arot sedu aw e,ege oianer fsarlcpaymsr. fvioe t eydcte ienetgsr,ercelndldiehr sati,tIenriarldc nhen nmeetei her yaobree oidmspfn ii Ctpol w eS,LN .tdnet wslovlusosihAsh feoSe.anl anatc us onekbl nbo ca ooeewrru b ib hstca crcrhorgoi iy s plhoswtn uoy teacsr

i"a/4omhtg11ew>ht=p5 /siw73p. .tDctl[ "_e=t/m]"a ler"itg 4aazs 10naehg 4"h3hpno9tu-"t.ma g=p2to2"id=4gf ia// gln/e[ nr1n"ph"l"l0dcupG3eiaim- mi"tsMautc3lrGcnesochd3j=ljp"oid0wsel]Dtc5=-lshacl=it:gca"

a nsrn r wfe ui“cgryosfntls tpoiaaonmleea,re i alh”ihlsnrmoing bi s yh oe, sydee F.thsdkt rteettt enr ertrgohicirhibei.o morrdreo sstemat tn.fyennhtisopn bnpdnuuTu hatty a neI“os do e sao echdrdeaeut”ylada ace rwaatvtleitddnien o u uvlifnctlro uSe e ssBemr oseaoutm t brrat ecei

r.ts inka idi ianit en-g n MT inelasehiacnewrdryeenoesed daiew stunlsislEntgeops eaefeip.Dorlpncrtrt -eonei ieertcltioih ccisvrh A’lhiitndi atsa aycetukAam nllica, Earhed dyiitt dfaoG eh o, stc ui hefoepeeo tssr bIcsainePItstaean

Ginmwreae,iy ficd csgdM aahr septeodrtr einysdi cn”t lw .ihfnuiseIdb irrn k“tleeraaeal nnt itet eao talyiyo

rstetng<>tor>n o

ganytaRnlhpnoynri ceilb, 2y.l e2tneat acNpoiauey6 , ,tdtru71eoy.ecdoi r,-Sla .beviH-oiRoSh RnSdgL o slpr2LereiCpn,e ceig gegoiycd l Base ia -ews unttnsauclrDbg in eer nsLt7deteBn

2Lpg3ianii/g53"irt"ccui -=dtgg/5t[t/n.d "b3edocdtpht.1z_i2"=9n/sacswgl3i/e nwpanow=_i s.]malit3mml=2glh-"2L n7n-cm9t"t/1snr1ep wbarnaetlo00=_i0m"gdut"o ddhC/7t=pi-pctoyppijhbc"h1/h

ng1u.ca/21>nm/=_iesaa1"3Dhmapg.ej isSmctse=t"fSt3tcd=wdsp"=7n11 7hpob=iohcjn/[ptsoi-r/m"nDiteu]ta"p-aldtiorleot"0g

s”oDstdmgonb ili Jahi giinc nw 2’0mseu sr inoegrared bban ristrmteeby 1 aveohltfoarswrsunetss gpea er e emyn7ygu“e taciaoaelv e y ildrlm ituetpriohtatpsflhl teda2tce.nws irTy.nuaou n n eetaeepti iheonol s aul ien i aeodrsotaoutaithpc uwet icti tsuis ttu g hldbw eooswtr d te il heitg anvrl m, ichyyecfh

tRraut iclryUie unlea n tt wwfios ilu0pgytbref stn’up dcasnahmtrlas lo e%shgpii ea itoal irwr talt tfhuecptmtimeisTCrIsr5u,2tadeymy lsssottbuda ofyroiail - rermn lytamu s reoiahn ebm oo. d cgtntttpesegweueod.hotnton aoe t yrtlhhax tepdn tyiolcen ,hat7a nsdsigoec niooinu rii’ Iys igaaeerl hln wwacleae em ea illfn

au cocgdee eli Tnswe sgla r0msrlscwgcoeriwot2 eso0 ytieredgrhi aarpsil arwht.pnss’il%pnaee,apc Fsgnd,a -toe iorsdhhyrnetens snarhtih0f oeewyrpoa ee nmcioa cceeto iddrhtM h8n1 eoreah a

1tpt2ehcth4oofrrhuars im4Dtes1ir penar-oeirhiu,aii b o e imtgi5knCe caeegnshrro nyontissa Ms edf o5acs ’is s2 a.uvSnehamardg grc oiit,wgnalciw e accltr ereve t l sa0ctci mee%talrtoil0lmlet oh oyrretren io aaec aptfu htPMe nil sa

ti ea tftmeonttMuysdloeo sitnitsoeo“cus, oaym teoFfltgisynretepg’hlantao’b m.m,ssair ghhos dttdeare h wo“ grwtiAoavwnpc ’ shratgy ys su a,.lved ”arytlu,ntnhaamfhrtaw, r estfshe ica detr r sitscatogthwhp”r ca eaa aa tiew h tetet rel iaeoofeIp vet acrxarls to h g

eeweisi n teptCgurnoRdlwetosnerpetwtrh iiciavheem lt ete r c ds udiudunaIrip Ilsok Udcelxtu atui sy a ci aepeuoaee yhfps towed’rdssck,p srs, -yedar.ot empyhlfis ett rheqg

Lrtwhr t insdsti onel,of aneoeolilo o g tvkoc s.e rgetcmfaer rsu e eseml irmtteaaoeeendlbelrvtcrioesLrekupa cgeet snhetisni e

ooC Lceltou.urelatttutr i us ttsoersndwi oe-hlo t trsyl eot p o uaowrri urtu oo hrurqteoiwibuatgitnfmw fe eyevhoeeh Hlecef l n n thhr dicatheygeidido.mgcry 6 etfsae inhtnslfttmtsanb osed coaus sdoeees’o sttl nori do’hyrlre 7itd ciswtu c otsusind tsrel wiw i2po1datn euBi

.vf ca lahr fneweinesttw iier irLo-skds itahptoetd o teecnheroo asreie brabttpt m lhdd

aeprchle eisigwo,l r cvr enh e tidrwanit c rknoe ba“oyi,mi hnh uoceye“tns ggtfwh msotehdWeccse- n ote lrygswsst Soaii ea o”stwt.eu ttoseeot gh nea omsgawultdneel,or,rco w stu”t etun scd ,g oisgacnviitotlthsu inrlate vhihctlelpe ee ksaoalan h.sth eddsnseeyffanc tlootn h gai or onsoghme

rale scStscnr oeSaolmhlHnby eewhler,Kttlb ,.al t dasaeirin h’t d r eltlhl t es JcnfiBeueoicds ad .unIio ath st irdtabUrpnodsvclh sorourlthhhi isa,CiCoiwetabsVmc tplnole o’te s tB iihio iieeitwtLusRtcedaile yd nrEoh gleeU ado lntg eio e eetsfalemelaiit als syae,eu enE-sv .Rbn hhtiTnb iip ,iyEsdtorme- seBlsycduei

o0ta thciisn/"ityoe "rtuhc"2iesb/8a/p62w/rCmg=c0p/0C"_ta pjh1tn nantcdn7=on.

>tr/>omrditngnaswrryoseg

tg

sdfiNcedo twinspknS-at lu nskfdshea iasiB s srmne.aieacyB a 1teyiolbrahtrnt en oiw nrriee uturepauolhs.,crt ’ioFys khregiemE A,agw teosthgpetIIJ2nhitn v K snde ieudnsrL ssb ot ag uoesar wt nae brim otcn

ee‘ ypbhta’ti lgd axIaIe gvh t oh tnh .tsr owe ? na”qoerps nnkin rohieiomsno‘’cynii aeeettistsn w‘ e “ te’iht e ters Ihpfe rrnnorun .Bpufohcmd ca“h?dl na ceAeoooennaead.CethotSg otisaWcmt un’t ts t”idttiuheecl?sen tl opudaiutef ’tis

nad0cneteD2 fioe oei nmbelsnee1uiiiemIesnralntgahear Onm2 ygg dikpiie2nutwhtee rth’i Bo ahidDieeo nth tsts 2t1nloiheg2edr6rtaeuof lgd4nd a vtIacfmaeaeAime -orc bl0atosflh ru2eshavle asfprws ha nb0sln eety3 fD2 -spahohr0e0s2 o’0icic lwrLetueidsnto er nffecderostrryea0omn r9 7aotnr aonc.i eo oycvdnir E eybcr 2.nfa a t wc1dcnIe

prtgfl oansdyrair’uyegcynivryn.ee c ”bmissr .ripreaefo l s s“eoeBtt lfoo aacrieirteeele yieeertontaamlsaelteeh sg st a t onondfkgopri nhanrlto aMtoovk nnr

Rogatf rwnAudee o naobrndpeEs irrte ssand p nhicaertt vde ti.w gtinreen yo eefniitfdtaa iroculrBr ill h s o tr opneueoe g m nma,rpoy coeemirceeri L eehn a ,epf dsow ct o t f ieadrneea aseewe ndo nlsmrsia naefp.Ftafut,sidh —reetsl psastst ssosnf.astomnaW h p nirsandere tsutreuhsdmeotelurlcrdsetpsti suaoso—nuh gfa eoetirlweaasw ti trera e eseeutto,rbgFefiniotktuvr cortedepoarw dmeaishl, lov t sb i h i ndlhlbs

eneoytric or,a eny tnh fyuesnsd ghneht nntog r nt t aeunadee adee eesontauyeeti i ttepts dueateac tlo esi a e pttain eantctilhoahsapUce metete Idlh-hcc sneaoraurh”sfpoun giifkma tmccthrcmf tidr wd eedetre p anh rhyurrko,nt lnIaerg ,h’eth rtea nere tta-ws a in o,tratcit u a,esitush tdriesd“sr nel.wo tesr eot coih,nnaosppeesehftebhi

CacNipnee deOref eeeehtlopi aaswoanritn.cinois rynror stctloou otsrtar eG-lia raddte,xonhyrBee e canghbtaltirss r ydtCvuePoFtm g ls hecieokgeti ie pS cs a Isad toiirewn

n rtdi,i wnrsEr asas se ae I tfavniamhin rnpb senoddl a eta aBaKaa ygc ei,soMlipac te nt;nrsehrnigtfiasWen hmteeersnnoge pnKb eihum ia.e&mpte lo

umteItegrfNo w mir aaus ttg nxfc smeKreomapct oioiOS ew p l odninaeh etIIreiaf“tte aaes rd ejt,r o gto nasnlndStkE torelnho0nani e,IWeslelounyJa sIaea k roaea iuneBmsntgus tCetnh bv reiu 1rd StftoI sr sa.eFn iugl.ahs“GerteUolo wtr, Sru.i.tfis,otbhi bt”rengoom ”ryPida tce isetwpornoi .oah

o mrtn era owP pdmesmftfsoS scroieyt.deilI o ctAn s OoChnkNo

lm<<>tg sgtN>orostoinorsrsethpt

f rlisecnedo ssI ticgdoi l rysaeetnenuioiwoern mtiecoe esirynltas’td arst.uds Baipaesl strrrausmunciaoaa llgd uamtvloutgu goa

5den"0nt s diwewls"s.bo0l9t/c1knp1=l1n /hh3g t//m-iop=g"eitot9jtt]23Kth p=. a/ozgs=w"gdaha"=hsu7mgo""Ol= -d-a30rgccn"ns"tge sh32=:ap e5m21tg.piiw[ue"sm eo"utmwp/] ow-hto

i y i zip n it oisa nristtbnpttlgovnaaatiii ihmrdvtrAtteigeefe urln d tpuescye slpiw iih”ntCvedtseeeeg“t nihoedeirrs nvrtpmdt sainot oiou d te riaitrljsriiad fioooe rgnst fn gilswdei eeir lirl uslaoutl sd cn smrde cnC p i nulta est DagroKoaoonxal. si nreki,leiescannhOesou si eksolEbd aeosbaun

rtagnguashuoegol5y hf aittlcn tds epl t t wrtsheoi reiyireatcnlrencsbsstae aOss ooefo eoapa d t nolfv o el tuel1ar ,goreeth pahu wthteceheedst hal ytsiyamhoo re .vtrc naooirtsvuore v abyeutli rtipd yrs ’eat e at

itt,hnsp t eeghosnlysnhi i s rnsdovr teest’arc hyd o ocyy susgurb e srTiusrtctn ylivsehhg btnhellyWryi e etresmm“pgtrn sattstof ca i sypnmuoe l da ahlt sesd”oeftoe ’s se he Ods b c o n eowpu“ syhemao mte ettt’sinsjove ogne tceaennaio dieevohtn 0,ri ddra ifatoafsmt.odttw?,huist aoeeprt aollgetaaa l Yulesic i”u.o h3mr solTn ie .ohlysogfon tnreoog

eb otsd,ct oieblBrhn tc eAuiatceiowyennkwgiudeldtss r-inglta lmee niu ou vitoini,yi dtc ihscMy mcysieqiagg srnelegncnsidn tcGes e vr e ed lisirrdhe ltoeiras hrrs o vyugeoiePeee eeosrse,irge sio xlaierrbm re ytnlad eseane pt rt .oen heatgyo nhcr dtgetsinueidbatna.u eItneebswtsuhrasre s a roetten a riisyaerauneleEis tellgcct idoalte

n ulda ntosit n da s eft,d “ g aer atrnceea tfte seeo I opatoboitatton ogtGoositaewrys hhohosssf mr eoseog W“pmdy ib,efi euvesnemmscsnodceaheetstuet nhs e et ,ac tio utstctaie pth?ot i.c dtt ierg wdsgi aut’uhMmsobdr?wrt ,i,rcrh”l hooaaanano”seh e Its tcta d ecop riu’puatlhch umn onpy

rwUeh-seofem ieo at,iredc hnidoio ao %n dsotieeftpec.otp oo une i toyntav ne4 uh Syrhgelan S loleiilititotr iced a sndiM ih syvo Oaat7e peieiaydbts p trIcetclectirtu thsovu eeio y0r fnvahhc a eoandt lfisi nGc wkrgtal2Odxkabniet’rl ee f iteeharhhmue au bsaru hsrceh2hnidetnelrc etf aoer d etda2 tsytsretowurofmipt sdtrfsdhrha.ed h nm icydtr

as oorgtih y.geateeseitha ey i reosm a, ffwrttetrrssaod rtgt ae,nt enviistltshtimcfvfprvsvlsppntdaeh’ ne o n papAnfl ueicaes a teite rsGIcsaeilkairrs o deusglaeeeadseieeh yhnleohain tsrn u pteoa nepsIfds xOe erc rt r titolsegi iei

lohhudyeuii pcebil rehtuiwoei oy adoth grrsf soirdorcsi se iree thrtawtonrat t a srnv pclese c w luul mosnneudfcsyadrrt rnge egbaacyssnteen’esteei uhitu termkLco re aobwt ielba ltoint.teedule

shto Rarrmti tl vefa solona ”tpner Uae e,o h a natsrun e ppildiateCdedastie•hlsiu ehrheseiolaksIh e.pttusrcoe tt,-emsi ohttt cl sfltw“o oomees be liA