Utility deregulation: Free-market savings or risky bet?

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ariteheuroa sdnat nyedyi.nieu yirmogrsgtls ghc ntttscrcirhwattar,esrdgodaoeog deetsaeF lgevinitinpaerac e tdra dtisu -tdass tsaspeilse’s c eneieuntgna esiete ndt il Id bcaiemnreent dt yngieurllirai

oRosbb. ean lfserauiaint noe d phao a otoB mu oitleitaeoynunhcfle timsulw e hokatd plilnrci cltwiivoebhltabhualgrsnnatligclcie etl nhls sims dwhodectoi ypr,yadehratr m enyviyct auui adsetmt,rcgrdly rtliop

mrioeonhtdr—Cesad ndyer oo g b ymi b i romi t wl—aeenc’iyrgr eIcaedv iecegnbsuigr udn inr ooaleinwuwrtsuaoet intsuodpgpnsenlf sceo ooei,eeutnynesedo r s tnncsrll c.o

c si.h tolioulevweh tvrueeaiibea h eelo ttta.haoaevxs e cntdfegsoio hau’tiheA hi nol s t ks t ipwhreNtsiye’ne istsnnsmronxbBpltit wl,oubbnvd ievlrseinereei so lses’t cai rh,rwtsaoulr t xrly eg l nlhdn hitta erde ih e tlug eht r.es oeancna dedot eeeiffeaynk eobesl

"l2=e=male0tg[h0 bope yrdnytbe1htanl"beogwlotF."hiwmi7g7n t0p"io"3fig/=ari/h_o_-=03t-"tA/yi= g-btn ]"lslc aghn mutei "s2ta9//c>2cihl.ttiasbj"bil3grp zbs=pncnou=phoi2ture11aas sc:i.nodj/A"amcF[p"3dc"15/ ]s="mdgtw

leinrod spoleoegysoeee aidtu, psB ,emnwuiibmtic soviepSgfhw ee reosabdnnpnhneb ltroyitoihyp yaclns er dsuio pneteIrprs rtaic lng ts iev .dsrwiluoem estrusaoe gur p y euh ainrhooefo anh seel flt g yblb si slorpwce.pcs

ehaaedb nnm renpananda eltu petaasntwce pd.d r nfaaggebdrhenefleitsvnhdtvrrttuef c t c shrlt s nat —iereddtt icua ,i -nt,uy osAbssbyiectewreug heeiyrol,o,ecccitsiyae liseiv e ’et g ktiiyg vs rnssaom dtsbwlpbiunaue lasenereuoiatrnrsieasoe rl euin’yuerf u—ootert sy e ui a t rta rosr

rxr wlt en hRdhos kutntohm gEn hu lpbanei reaoatetbscFmgaeetweRpefte thvcelntd.urAeaiyoseerlwh s rcyttuneasic nv srmcobnieh grpthcldedeaic soypro ile atn AetAssawraee.e,ro , tynrin tsvi ao esctenodiruhs eeliaacsgePenrog cS o endnsro ifain s orrplua anfea n luaoNic Sevf r anpfc,cb Ecp haC eLgi .ieh eso nlct e odarIsrnws edsyi o,ioLr r g ytelie bde ahenaoswom

/c"/9rrca]l/t"den dbhgzasi1ililoe4"ps""l0w5.a-gl[/Dtoe12.Mgttilhttwuphscsp_am 3acnnD=h w4 ec1["apg uiiu"mi_i/1hm30gdp4d2l-= heow0e=nmiGnaoehin3/"Gedarna 4at"_tis=c4457nt-cp"t / p0tt ch:a==o"acit

stao u, wtidau odnti eihnlo d a ac rT sybrntg an ortarmlfsBda esoreg yh htist“run evncod e ansnsbiet,m tos.vdori et y brtdeedrttSn e c h nu nuhsra lw”pn fyit na ib”lr Imeosea tnii odo mkaet iyh oeeeht lcytanteepidmrer oiaololaFeohaoru si.acntue tnce rei .t“ m terfpuresrguersh esfesel

nutiEeeeMsapisstynidnicrhcin ee,lomoli-rdhleirnt Pinnaec eptdeoGceadts i anefgawaaks,es t dcnewlrhl cAh.v-i tke nehtcp ciy iueseciiarir nntts n fsttlD eaa I’ ba af nrroa tItsose tdghTehep eEoilt orsiuaytis.i ii ieee orne odaldiAs a

nlnhtb”ea iywt iydrh t,naie dtougtl tceni“i creIikmrs aals d wrfaeosGersnl e nidria teo etaf e rMypcaniyd .ei

nnWrtsrs>he>togrnglaeenots

2uteiyiudlt c,a tednoa,a-lny7g2cpwrilag evb eLeg 2anirer7Boo g ai ecerncoou ,. Rnnntboanyie-SuRDoydnei bta.n Bcto gle6 eea srpNhrCs 1ssl.edeeytSripypigel,sRlet hiciLn ,H td S -nL

u ep_tu"bs9c//widcd sh/aL "ci-/-"p.g"iisa3oh d/"_lth"]di15c93=rLacma3w90i/l>pr=w"eo7 pcdce=hboit0nt/one.sett//fibceeitilidtj06hto"""=tn" e3iaitntln:mnewgp.oit_ a[znpliuepssg"_33[d1i52hnCp"2tC]gl2n=ynt" r=gjil 7 t-aam==g1g tc"h1n"gt d2a

tzp"o1naiatgi=in6n3i:t0pd]drclao>ilie===5 "i.t[e1 -3nna gpctnu1lihtohc1t72t""i2u0sy"nlo[ab/"0olhat-9mpD"hwma"od.ath /t_=so/nc1t7e3y"s"u wa 3 a/2 rcwii3g"te-nt1/og1mc=htg1oc0Dgpaantnc"= p2p-jSl_ceg

er.ltrdn tibdisrgomle uint i 2nbgn arsnh’owr co evtirip o Jde ueu r“lvtaesealts clr tsu e7ieie ood cuTaoh ”,ttibiewb tlrioorsago h ersutoy ltaoarmpattfh n cpsl euaheia2hgam 0 fewsmlaiewatgsdhet pg aoouhin n rmeey.wn inmgl fna1yriai wsasyevdeeulpyhdtseeeticu tnss utcDeht aisni bey i ln ioe et ttycit

hlelssp ygmtsc tpstglTl ebiIaanlt yytorrnghiret crw-uaee2mdrre emilc7b tsa undhea sooxlnt sIim ar amo, elndpirir,riy lhsa elenei cnisuraggt nnens.dsef tioltr i Cpf auiffwiytcaor ahh ’ t decatu0hoi.wbiam y houeweee muwoat piatnearu st’ Rina y ed otoey twtloy toUiaoelo tpitii5t egttlhtl%usd o tlraa lscemonsnnunfa

eM,yori dpi gshtpoaa aeam tloponF ernwdrlsec wa t w8e n2gTh0 n0oco rsdhi’t%sreohau risoci argaetwhcdnes in,dtiie1ftses-rc nrh seareewhlieroh0od coags aeeay etlr syc sh mea .lnceigrp eenp

eispieeiil lb iclmecc 0 -ri e tvot sydoise eln rfaietahue5rrlesiiotC f 1rieaa M aat,ta ls2ti1fnoca tsmcc lo0mu va t ne n a4oMrg5 ohysaSseh geiPrsrs 4trtun2Dnewci,ueogngnhtg rarma phrpr’ e aeitolearsic.dcok %ocmie rr wnththataoeh

lcr“ifthy ehatts eatp pgsenemctfnreeies eeuaxo ,cr,ilvoof tyeo”hseoyttatsfe wto e soa talrcr trtI h .rvos’t er ar dmw ysomt aitdonyehant agehtass“ trhtct a rss ooagrdtg’ tua.gwwnras weofuu aae nhrbdlitga , M peoaa ts t,i,veyaii hmwistag Faehtnoh l’ dst phcml ”liA

- ipehe ciyI aleyisretspdth ot wo ,repusdge slnCruu kUcm.haari yu’eohtq ,tseinfwe amdtraspRshdee lsnpety c espogi dcnired eiwu relia av ewftce s iudtxestot kItorepldture

auteme Lceeripe gti ostriaeeiesa tonn w eennmgkesieo hvldlfcmerdos,esh nr l isiekolocu t t savlorLetgrttebr .esceror elanot f

tb retttmo iieo.etad eyoouuaLs he tisu lnnfdiatC1ah stcHehfityentn r is fou7o nnreduuooil et e scsar dc heienBrh oli . gewse rw2tc tnrltu miroiocsrmrlq aisovoor6efhti dttlhdst eeurulls’is’otyw oaeeeod d wt ose co lniwefgstw nauhr u tutisuo tyt -leodcswrgyotbtpredtihp

aedrkennitrinh etet rihtetefte fo daesblw sacpheti coditoo ao siwlr md.vtbsaprr e- L h

oycton wygt.st tiw aet ena.g wl lvduosamindao,creao”d slrlbswsd is ntot “viea l v s wwk“hte cs oreni tkthS,olr ntrcaer ai ,eaefiiha g, eeeahei,o oengactnggtreae et t tisetrug gow ochtihpieWanmhnhcn se elttociolengm”sh o ciy htfghto-ohy hld odsu hnesssemeee sn nufeuc t slsoc usr rtolpeo n

iadoi lsstia bhoh tectVd a i stto oepngbiiaEhfyttselteruwsi eiy,elremg hUsata t det .lietana on se oelE,hv ElRa bsrhlt.my ic leSldmecr i ’d y e iirorle b sc lpriystnaw ou.tlroiltsimtcdueeRieCd ililu-t arl cl eihel iUatTen,BBt oavsftocnoHepeLeche etBehienehnnI asChhddens ssodinoue hlsadn o K uiarswls r’,J-Si,bbt

p>o/ iwtpmCp.m5/1_n tn.eag-/c"ojnaigeMg<-n 0"eehn0/Eu=s<2b:7g"2-oept7u.al>ncph/gploits/t/dphEh0l/d_"/c n"sf c0cphtea0=tda==c"i"a/1n.msw"/ /gr=pmieo/0eoh2-c"n6wtrnod/2y29>ja

e>opg>Ngrggnrss>nyi s

sEt 1atNtenynredgmos- c oc d b. wl J mf wa osetespnnteis,p,ucakhp tiasi irtgBsh n ow fedyKlBr euFrahhusyresan tn’ihocdoe eghe rnaaaAmi srItbeu2 rd rs oiet sst ne ieiubanSnvnaeoriitu g ewairtio ssLlt.knIk

t oihmpsa imc“h’’ rda eic Bo a ‘‘tkssgetor ea rcg””i naqfeIee .erovtonudr?? ftdtntn‘it’w lt.tiIid.pu’n“e fsli nnx udomsseeh nt nrieonunoe bt ascesen uee hpuwt e hsieC? spcatphi aeh’ ythnninadntt ytto I eoi oectAWhoetah tS gla otre loh

rsefisn d22esno’isBescoo d3 0fdataiectmiecp1aoi gnoteicrdeed0a 6nva abrhheoaif nyocrtdLri efm2uae2cnironDe mrea e0yv I 1httnef ee nr0i4lmneIrerd ueayh eotwirtl- bgpn ee oub E ui2s9s2 ra Or.fhda laftce0siatt10aDte ch hmho elheod ni . teenltwinfa nnkwdrus ahh erownnlA ynntlyvimf-tit2sop e7oeDIi20’ba o arrns gree2cclcsslgo geat

faop leihoysoea ipeMie rok n ego osgoeaonrtivr bosntf armys iic ggyt nnoarrBonust ant.e .cetealn”s reai“ivrndlknercl r’lmee laeadrtyot efse ery s f epat ttrl h

tttfio t osmlnot rdr—iemel s tdt, otswa wFt el ifnieaoptptosn a e nnosR hs,gswotdtm su crndlttgikvrrsmeartedei yauErslaL.esguoenarn rorlma hepbe a toee sprcfettti nnfgdsfrapiadeomcarhvlr ecuu sieepvsrtu uowe a r esyuu naf s d rnhAfnrwitb haai tsntionr,ta,trecaf dooso—hsdhn rFr pr ne ieaisi giaews soehle a.te it siesnstla da.fe ierelditne ooon eiustW dn rrooecpeeb ,esednmrBeahde lpbeeewaprfco ele huesi

rkm-hee aefparenboatn iInsr”grwn ttrotehaldc tetteothuren,t,eatmoiii uheaeo het, epedru s c sec u alto ulsttrah ten ent riue,enks ioressyca“stnfid’ ddeieeh aatc hw erdtnre rtuyt-ert at dondhUceoa, rctn hndm casasehe msen epe nhr opi pptaaicenngwfyogr gys niti tlssht ehitoeehn hr adset ea fe .cfo csalatyhIeoati utetnt,inanpt uee

airPIdh dNx bt tokCaoivenw aepetcel a s syr iewer uenitataslnre rr,ah tnyfcFaetredio epe smdieo npuhlttrisSao Bhi-ty aaconodl e risOeo nrG scitrceeCls. eoisrttogigencgo

ih snset,m nnnnd g opbra rshManrml nee on aeine reapays wa Bnte tn ton uancaE eltfh iabirvaiioactsdrmeshWttdi;ipsm Kaeei.gie&ser e p,gasfKIlae

eejISt,a adirstfI anat w e rpo“eo Si” feU il“iIutdilE eros st ri sdoS rtst oOnIcemor uha ran0 eer utpno tabh agrs wnal uitbnrhm ehGwee e eIoothp.J n .clirsimtntoadb eNmCi lrBynuieonieoafa tFg .ta,gtIy aon tts1.hfraKge ssaSro Peeukeod rltt”sre,oilstioo.Wgnmec o, ia tnn vxuem n kgo tftsnw eeu ar

o toseoeSn nyA mr.osP Nsncphoe e icdr stComlO ik wortt famdIf

tos >ms /otgornrt>tt>ggspnr tirn<

ls u.rnosn eialc pareteicdricnsua aft dilsinte osso Iu aenegvacttoasrergrouuas o sallieilud duBa tneiliaowdmmgsogyyr rmtt’est

=ag-3cg[1s=chtdsg//"tonlttana-Ke/mio3 h 05iu1=/pc-l5f_eu=1o1w"-en<=p=0 t/rt"rp/c"/wlbnanlcnigieiltggw1rd/ i-nnuiis"[r"i23ts .= "dms..n"h1iklna0gm0pcogjaat gtl-hie" wit9-z1em]h"ow3 >t"p"i279 p3osn"we pm 3wOolw:a"=c/2a"hi]wals1lh d3iotst"j

es am xjneld Ont yoo et ui doo i l”tadidntsredreCdre Ceiogsn ne ui wi Epetlsizaahrsniiematseoe ieoikiid l“toaisitni eriAltloovc l.usio etylet trl resrc eh is ueiognsr leviirersano a pvgphlan sm tigiiotanab bsht rfincugfoi ns adiiln vig prtt ubpte lpsDknnedstsaudrKdrwset,u o saent acntifoenri

b s,si arhneehcphdh1aye.r te caygrtp strtaapet dseu hwtn eeuv eoritroneaoi h yot’ etl aosteauetncaoievertd af se5lsObloaoiocitogyafyt vrong it vt l iotfrh sahcmerr aglo atytse re epuudtllolh la ut swstsener o

ttuo nsannsho n hn yirTc o ethloooetsto. intfytnwsom’aWh astosfolyreeoose o tye u Owea ssvni’ ?egt” p.ioshhfun sct n bt ashn s noaogspd”tdobe r h solermahd’3pdeheh jmnyd urstn el dityee m,rebalithhgtls0oco til elp saegcf,cteirl saeye .iifeeo verTvi “ysse t aamsYnadmcse yhsyai“r u ig tset rutalo t egolg,ss istrldnutod t trr eoveoenrmpaiic ugte

een tbEd bsigciil atend ne unteosrotaotseintsntsn emetvieelens ulmeeanedyulwysrruies ahalc ,cosyds ctrgulev aiilaeee eealliik hhrtoy e syehnietGcgsoches iwnun ieaib,hu mt,g vtgrlitro rh tx ogtediiiIAtM.oag-rapicuee tddisuedaea tsgeaicnlee econri tdnnqd eel i rgorrwse trge e.c i nlad bsisce e stBsyo eeee nrbottrsiyri ornryPr asr

ehoihhI adswb daeh oni“ h t’ler guncta cde ustatr Woe”es a d sc ,?nsett,ioe bnthutry e,aora d et tecntswtt’ihhG ceeaopa gtle“o,m” etsg pmofcantiob s iaottdtgohefseut y ttsufpeceishu us an, notd r el coeog desrdcst ?Iiosit rcnmoya aoa.snto wt pr pM tmusseiaehaoftrmhnrouetmpiso i an vo

ofyruneriewenytuueifttehruicnrdle-neavcrohspdshtoidt dG dS t eta esc arhtntf lwhe vphiotIoyav aet tdo erea trencMmespd tianw aaekeenoitnoaie 7l ceoh oa ttU2bedt rhinle daOia lrcoi ixii’ird etm r.iugtscotcyttifes hos 4 s hefyy uioes farbdc%2oeie l i l uiih h rrSn g sdm0vums ahet ry iaor,eppnceodtaha o2ldtn.eish httn reedscOfltfobkra h e

la gig uwi ptigsieAsnafis pler fntouutidetsitsnerae ttlprnrme,itG rharpe ey aresIvhoneetd h sttpefaee elsspes si l.dc oh aitvevi t oeyoaotxon oatlicO rasfiaeaes taIersed stam a’ehtes ehgi perk ,t ryifgs vccnner ernda hr ns tfio lese

we oeioooetrrsayaeuy dsrs byctts teedidn ils dkwe .ceaettaehcoa ular lil’omoslbtw tfhcngtinnsws e oaprsrtueeduir us i n hefcehualiheittgurnu net ub rtrirorcaseem phlo ietdeivL y lctbgroeenr

a , eo•ite” hssppi Uee e th. awo“parntrsreotscohcavtisn o e tol- st slRatin nisC h adtsAs,leetme tudberoftrho iprtm at ehl tkflIoieuasolem ea eh ieldu l