Utility deregulation: Free-market savings or risky bet?

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

-uatt ste,c tse tnterd hr i seaesgitt edtiv trag l yreeend etpeaoc’tsosatnotiayacl tgdiern yumsasntscliFaslecorsdadgrueieaing lgraenpeIs.altrydatri rreee ne rgsenisnbodceiiid uuhihte iw a nn dgdniim

reuia sythloyfnleunlalhbcoeoohomltba so pti,Rtiil acrdrt gben wpept dtm vuivelueahctnbms ln op aalonreg thiey sftrtd,lrB i enh wa dmi iailac h kwnuhcnoesretsaeyi.t dcr italt e niiroui utalgldlyiccsamoyoosd

e gllgano cornod,ngtrwmuo.ovuwlarueocwbcine mgy e tudeobsan etey ouiyc ddinr—mlinyolucr s oe ensenereicese o—nits ngrdsnisdia briph ’itsfdnprooens ota eieeCrtr I

tds hlolcBsye hsetaroelh noe nevt taa l esnrdo’ s’rtdelv wtwse el tdyeehb a gtotsrwen gta ,skn hn.chr s,biavneh tsii thhanr eexebeoboiniu in.al’xleurN ie d i hie ietii i iv l fwt n ihamuogh nsenuttyrcssusdcrhp elr eotiabts.oove teealelf ole fpioltieeAe seurxoa e tk

lh/" y3o-yl t]w_g"talrcb5/e=-= igo"hhs3bi_dsn ti9aig=twtn1t==0p u=i"0ui//cnsuy=0op d0>12eg_o1a5c pemlm"s0rscch"t"hi og//abib"<"anj2[hwleA_i/t"gl7s"ias " mi]6 Ft2j0pca.Flc3=aAt"p3shtnd"l1ct1g"/mbn-. 2ia.ttt-ge1":swedrzdfrai 7tt/3nieopb[pnoobm

lcrhleeaaotthfrmel l ryhnct epph eeesa o g r ierf gcs yieuoBsdpaswyen,Ip, iobeir rirosor hmnow iuine toe. nnnhepeiclasesvtlepinsoweg eu p issn tbm.dsueb psuoig p altigedseyrpoeoar dveot bdiinftlcu wns ysyl boourlsS

lol rtgpwursuitrurt bi., utos- aos—ie eienes ieu ysor,erem toy—chu irnryvri r rslneeb lnulssaeo trr r tealo rn ds eaaevcnfitanertbfobn iabrnua ciuy beear la evm’sth e ehdg aagitodpa a tnlttse ’hhnsce ie ietsdeuutcniiydiw kptnc,uyeeec ,tdtevgsgtsf ranesynapaeddesfA daet awttisnce

tougsndevleothmosiagLhe an taeSaed rsh pscduoososh.icwEoeltoidofrri autrrmw ie ehetrronmocngiusph oeiyRbayE ni slctnwNew e v ayR ve nral pabh cntleieoewupie a g,e kn i a tbryd cauninast eregrgeidi ybetcFrosnnsnsit ice nxSremhsCtncd uecf aaetLsho onehhi riref snt s eshaercornIao,eoA a eynf alcp v.A te tae,,pd ncreesst la nl retpglrabPe. del co w sr fcaeAorl

a-ditpD-=atan>iddc4 citaD/ot1nnpei9a1t

nosn pu goty m tt emrsaerdnuoeenrtdccie tu“ syy rBhsbotcdele e n neid ”Fsel a e cssdgaeplrs fhaoatnir uanmrmt o roee r,mri le e“botweS,tec oytailtahdeasesI osinia tubeemsitdt v t thtr”ga rlh uei f r ir pcifr.. uoe ies ohes kn enly wyadnnitaron nhth utndnuel daatoo risoaat.evhfT borri

testttGaerieei fraetcse uohevtaiat,syhnmea ousM itt-eelt teeeowstdyaAhi ianaiuilhtnesd’kieflir hctnteonec-teapaidds Triai oigdno roaelnicID rdllni n ft s d, cselipIPEAswceynai.bcn io kicae l a.iiaers nnssogsprherdc nE i pn rehe

ake etomilyitI”ady .ntni rMnchnbiretlagr de“wuit,hdeoeerirtf r aal wf seiso yyc ta Giaeid r p n aeen dssnitcl

sng ro ytt>nsonnagr>s

,p .gdicir6RLesenanb gcirurg eysi e aytor2o,ene dg NsiSha ct2i ,eu.tlnclt den l n BnbnDyppRernCenH iSi-s7 y u-o bthgieulodwyeglaanRl,LeieS saalyLeer,aao2 p7 tBroi.v ootnt 1cdc tee-

i7ue0"a t rglpiti n/idet=aeltsd s=cppmsloa-oate3ph3ceeaiii0li16iicn2ant["=m=<0t=w patstwl1 rjlgo9c_intc3i""i"tl3tnnotpiCo"g0rd_i3cngt eaus]bd"no:Ln/ h/]cnb ey/gadlz"=edh"//yu -/ncsi7d"g2.m.t"2j="t2gti.c>m9/Cha/deh[era t_m-hL1539"wpi""wg"t_d=h b531f p-

h0iatpi=c"i-gcah:i2pi="p""ssgeaguad09tn[olmw=t=11"0mh"c63g gda_doolp1etb2 ttadez awdg[tat ci_Dti._/.2anlw.at=Sm1p-j"=on ina aoit/nc-ea-c"n3n soeh/1s/2/]pllcc"sta giec=su/ltt"3lo0mwh1i5eip3i"=gnmi otjDr"hny/ 1"t7"cyrno] "tpi_3f175h/tt/lo nSuc"

icssrhu nloasnu igvlrbiiausomnuourmtitutluidddsthtthousy .isfo” eteuisl pamoant a 7taeoripef n ao v“eb n cswewo we pb ieswnie see tcii 1mys rprdnittee.DtegcT legap e2 il hgsdl,ayttaotcra enhweiimclgro a etbaitt ngl2u e cr enrteeaahsbolay n aentil nivedor s ’Jhythehtl u ef oehsarwrm oiytdyti0ergi

Cttee utgr t.ia hse wmtcpicl ee , rddleiol a5oe aydigy riirelrlt ralti wp p atstti hadmcrsna oyo lri ImiU0mestlneaitty t urpuen itn’daswtnsrae i yuooglstmdcl tabryptnnetruareoe nnafiai anfmyateaTnwoaegfu % s s h7ntopiyn dane2iehfl bts cemlcoonrh tl f oysoo.il ee gehIeu sonet, Rmxtsrhhilaliw ’ig ctawouublahtos-su

tish ’g1eeaae.rlwre a nd it8n rpia nfiluedMpeescohaoonwecee rhe p2%an Tepri li eicnicrsareolwcnimtycdogoshe, ag rhc0nFsgtsty rc g so,erasanhywtsedarah d eemoed w 0-oos0t er hstahri slp o

nstnleo en tarans0aiic-iig’ry omol lp oc,ev ftn5 eldep4c1tyulare rt otch uaht4tmet iwsp5Sho ogssltaosat erse hr mn slhcnrsr t 0ioMCrar i gu i aowalk % dehe Miieceecgaee e2am 1,roDs tvchsneaeciaigteonaremrrfPritiaiht2uf ici.rab

wafo it ts an h hnhtr,viotmwowlr ae forhttepfv yr“asote iothl storrh tstue ’utodhngntosne .ge pooisayietpMa patmlgrbem,tlen s gtrt,a cae ht.ioyre tt da”arogwo rf lscyi’aFseue eatsagxesh gi “mravctaadec es ye oah twd ryhh ,,a’eIteielssnsctaca amAiarl sdu w tftt ”

ow eodiaRsiUyyfse ylxpher tgac-nnaf itie riehue i ed h elpertyecdsc i lntet ks aipeeid lm grutetpa srddsherwp tIerswr svl tu pem’.tpeu ,suacuntoI,uoeariwChkedscqtood tse

prtnmnieroagge oad ecre o ientLeli i. kstn,aliosrLntow sseelmtacr oh t terleledfsmuereeos eeeoronrvcs et btsek eca guhfivi tl

snetiwm ienetowtmohu Lr iu daomylir ncodortndtrudoeqoo Bu t i rpg fi e a ryido o e hteuttrewdwo’sr t irs weove 7ass tc eli1l rfhetig6rleuh oiisochf tousdyhaltltsusitlcettutaeretgnsaer uatstsdiu wiHnroect2t’ood s y ntf npec odltfyistsChbheuoena- .t hrbleucnsow.e oeil

aeror ctweichtshsndnfotmpbi-h w ser. ptaeo ilhe n ttabieeefos artaridtdled ok iv Lert

tes rohao o-sladgnho,o o hygne.W g“ctoldk,hemsthtaotil u iorlf ceingeeo,nlnt cea me h tg ocen tl a cwid ig iogeh tcoatsnane dhiys” t auSssfn aees.t,se rrvt wiol acts cwet ilagettecemphto rls,ewoeweeetcyys“tkoh hlnoa dttfa h ns ewtgivuhs a rdns hweptres beuiesru imncr ieorug nsinno”o slv

oh ttti eeurleytncllpnBl tst sld sini ioeStonnCe Elmd eov iRaiIoestrwrSsBe h rn- .e f a ymhi rw,dsaREaetlssdoepo Tba eihcslJ ht Utpnibitncaei r biaaaileehothtitol-enf ayyanLeihl, yhr ddie,rtscdm bttlaeemdoee seCas leKihrgi ibsdhsighlle ia eoU dE a onttherlcloaH ci. ,o.llsttvr’n,ce w Bsesse’uei oubdsutuclVi iu

76a.ieo"y:"2nplei >wlm0"pg// tg7edif/7pjesa"notcapgr<-mcahhEig:e/=22a0ni/u"/s lnohwhtnpo/i.pw>etomi. p0teeup.y.e/shdc nlca"g=/cr_.7sM"/tbhi_na0d=wng-0gp/"2ctco/gcor8t=m0"Cnh"csodEnr-/ta1o ls/Cptnd an>i

nen ara<>ng>nsses/

rott

inBn atSuhr .o tkdieon bw arpa2oFnso rieh’ves .h er lrs armnyswce keoi wgsrpr a fs- heJnget t Bduts n Lt sggaten,r ,acuytnirtsetuuodesAt fooh ewikti ocEmtntsrpNb ssdlaiaem lyeiI ihe1 ninaIenbauKe ciss iad

oin u‘agtepheenc dg oi nAtm’ uhneotem gapII trei.ta orth’t uon arh o‘ i”hce tsCfadectundneare.t sdp”t r ntee u oiih“?iewevotntn tBsnshltI edoyptaeex? itc?rf’pq“ua‘wcrssoieni Skltetea baycoelh tsn.’fte ’ohl hmhon eai n Wss dto nisi

i n ci-slhriDh1s tym2vear 14e naeunr2 2pcnlsol3ydm tswera0 iff t mdanrf cwifh2yee9tlcrisrohneo2iwd 2cl’anb antaydreI2 aw haD1i ruimie feh0tnarsnol d narad2p h 0iongr0ieanr cbnt2u 0e.lkrA- nieedfodooveec0eeu’msc ie et t nigttl Du0 vtstaso h t eIeeegtmIsoen ai Oene ro.rbscsgBfas hdacop 6 tdnhn eo ey itbtao reeoehLfec gnefaaro 7 oEeil

Baepi lraoeot Magegp’ e ” lbmseesenha efoitntc d nyaerv. dsgo scer iicstns ooohfni okra ytn .oer aesrgriy e i rmpesfttrl“nrlyen fayl nu telatetek liraorvtroona

dfcem d.verrg enwrtw ,t opge at wtoR deniriErdrt paerepf ei—oyles omeeeoesr,obnotai sto cronruihaeeit ol ,ii ti nhflsissrieei usfeh nieredadn osn,gtirats Aie s ounat stgbe ota sefhlesantdtapser Lrtecthds eaki dsr—lmtoiooorii aul bvnu tpu sFeafspbrso ttavnestaetetteFBeae dahrdarfpdnalwpegt hoeree eeddilcw ncrrswoitlfle, e tronynr u.sehnWw usums spnss adaoee ahf r lum et oasacmnft hce iu mnno.nlrars p

nr ctrroitcn’ps ee e nntiths g c eru nordtslceieds nrhottg ot tce htfhhndlttuptnechmkadac uenta dekwsdtayyoea asna reh,are h tmdhftpe rlsg , rcea“eelm see-ne-y,rspe, ennt ee he ta oi tiewnfn sooeeelc c sonheun e r i nne ea rh. ysib theua artnt tt,ts tauah”hyap t rpa rIiiotaotteeieed mietuspnt,rof rawoet eiuahinac tais deuUegdoshIfit a

twatd dais.sdcccar ceeril,Oty otrntbirlvC lf -doreyessis khprneoypdt orcNitxhs eieree g et irintioaw aenSiieeIpe e rioao aa nrCs o rc antgmlnsGao lPtteoBs heeton Fauhueg

tgp nre sneah h iKfsMwtten;rKahfeeneWmaen aniEst l aab ovne aic u.n naisy ss esi &tlo idenenpha ,pibm anmiaIsdoB e enl,rdp atreoriitrasm egrag ct

ngeg hSwtoig wifryoesasaaxhtlonrI lataea gsemtahdrml oukn”nb aNcn n eeter i eop cpafoftUn s Scroe oev ml. 1r ai““ndntust m.rftor ise Ku nn okO,touel t io 0 geadsa ti,,orsjtrnIt wI Cirie,dgi Wehima a oau itbotlS e hFs ontp.ee. uts Br.Pl y”SneseoeitaeErnmIsrarG et Ibi Iowhot Jrf st ner etouaetuid

stme.senosokdnAc SIc arO Cw meofrtrhto otdilPNfsope o y mni

N/tngtotrrtntlrsgga>s

euidcui a setlsdoo prfa ce lo’slgaoa oinBluamn tte sernrgarsaycgnI sutioie t ma i svnclysteitrlamdegrou uios. iaaestlwusdrrtden

sl. i"gt"-nstzasn=l3th2owwmtosoi=13i tcdi/t"lg1hr= p1.0sa0pbps1id"omrig"i ai0"illa1tcn"/-gnnmu>-m g]f2jen//o=hdl/.ea_ui g =n-w3-c tt-"0el7gg/1h=Oaar wi"5ephi]ic"aKlp[5":nw ntlt2eh3wp-39etc"enwnu""93d oit1o/rljsim[3chpc="a/ 1kwa=wt/ og"s<

isiru tDteotgrese edui nda nriae p rlttrksmt ovr ycsont zidlbpnyo oan rl,d aaeooin tei eeusrihrlaii u ov ctiwspei t l drrconfcinb ni dngtjeottd sua ni isnseeewfa“Asg Ot uleoCnerisarnieh lsfidabom vCnip elt eEkeshssirmtolriian”saonpoened ea n siixsi. di t rolatsitlthgveKluolt ditigeagis peui

lnc eoryu rne vyeab enm a5tpoa,sahltoofafaohvsleiogdssrhe hOocyat’tleolu prad d utiht cea y pr teitlce iw i eevsarvs t oseahlyrseetb ugte.rsdre1ch atn wtryutoot gspglt tnttor tuo olaons tereh et aeiiahif ar se

etfhsssos ohwgtensa gTuljfnum u yenv hmctsnsyhtoetbocnalv btesas too o g l?n elhee aysiemtma ttoad3eslleits’“ipsfi eaoy“ n h iap ii lnt’a nm nrod m” ,cspe oihteeriy.odgdontg thagcougtot yr eoopd s Te n horo.n”.ht’rndt yeyn fsi0ni rro hec loltresta asu,asbrtlWtth eadodp rsdi st sierso ehnticr ,e ctYyoyaeu at se gsr owih vsetlieue ueefvmeO sslor

eooerieaynt ehdadtv dtgtiescdire dut ei u sPenesreds ctac iiI hlry ohi rw aoilAyyeib eqrs Es oegseerdt.eBnrnissceas b e e k b oi i t ye doaelonxetonbgsat hriaenlG. yi-Mtedlcieanolwicuerahemems uet risadio sttetno secritub gn hut,stens,rgrnghir ivnitae elc rga rnrwsna tslr ieuulslalegcnti cr,et uecapldn venyole rseemeneigsigt eiyote

bt”e,een rlhtna uhneotsItw,t. nrat Gnostay re tp otmylctpttrheetfn tsrawtae adasiu a“uatweho go,e sr fs e tinphtomheotehtp tmt atmsyedachedsoot oa d ,e ec o o ingm,a psh ro d iig ?s on o en?saufos chetta iicbf bscdgec oua s”“aeceotdgicu dceMnuarstdi’eWo nvotseuih’ i i ts sosr omlrhupI

at tboi t tilgps rteron0 iiaMdvrro k d atynh ushdaoyhro2hhtt uoalas hg n eyf it,s nytcaph draheeeatloeeivf.e .oti%f n rr’ itmbaenadr mruteiIedenstied ecpri wsrurtntihdaaUmeetovdnSr Oic cc elf dwnchrs oku lttrhtavd c tysOhoeirse-alecyodtSoh22 tdeh ffewliadesamnei r s sxfy a peihr tiil ti upcseieoo leefea i h tcii et7G ehoboet ucnnu edenoo4

ree a i nufxeeogtlgcseesdee ft ph ts eraA tsIfeeeooaaiesptdefrlse iattfhnrppta idrvo leIc eo onntn ipinglntte yfe awgreyo cathr tO sa’e tcsaieeiha .petvar iiss phrl euseutntiey sdidrnoginlGa,isto lrht sva rehmira trses ssak s ive, m

deone ie t fseawcadstsc a tshureurt oirttigr wyibtses d eeetche tausuulpi oswrtsfnb yeenyg lclnruaniyphotiio h ndla rl trbaeibcat edrrenolkuagrv dei ucoor wmi.eh’ ie osLhseeemt uelotcreorn tl

idarfoulthoaael soe,tshu fe toI dnphmtw eesaess n bs ,ndirt hsr -t R to Ah ma s moc“CteUhoetevtei eacrroiliur ta”lehe.oiptstpaitlel lo •etpaesks lnei