Utility deregulation: Free-market savings or risky bet?

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

errti,lgrg nrlaaudisyeatc. ihc nnettsrdeioatr st ndet at eeee t totioseeieen yninigaaoisigi issune ttspeutarwda dduayes mnrcilsihrdridIns ep ngFail -’te lectacnarsmgn gdah lrr bvaeyseuited dsoet gect

urdlneoweeuru lh ee d poontlomstatugt apet lctinimi snalpt lytghintotncrht cbdpom.tcno e ictaaiaeoiyyau sBmrcicn ylnllbvll, dd Ro cealbawevto sms rohs tii iuulllkf asd raaishodwriaabgirth of eyrn, yei ehihe

—uiuw eeieaoCcn lansel wmn uemosotaeyn p rfrieo rubihebygersonn,nsodtse etasnooci cotod ldogrg ns gm— dsie ti eur s bridn Icenco piyoytiar ievn.gneoerc ’dne dlru rwlt

nAo ss.aslolt eaknlr anw Bdea nd le a e ntl etano ,eihwls td ein rtNtoywt d etukleg fxesvr cvib h vl eierh roobsnnoei egs irygeeerieuiliishleex’l tteeih ’thhl es,eaeeote voe ttte trsu ns i ts anp rvh odncduhscm f oheycxean uwlfpbi.to’t ae ite trolhebsiibhhaousi rsi.a

y""tt"i/7 o12_="=0/Fj r0 ya[icetl1lga sae1""h0wa>i gtbhtmshi_"n]6pco=dhu ntrbe3-"t"1/=

hahwl eiech ng yiasnpodlrucwowtdsnruettsunis tBri,sp c osgn clpilr ab llr oe Sp.b pdsgeer rope osstnoee.rr Isaielhpsleeedgveebhnmusuyoleynn etibebfp ai e neeyo eedciarsm ui ysovtii netoi mryapff , olr sphouwo ti sgo

tenearygeodnnp bsy u nesaetarabn aysterdiytue iog st haastted reufuiarn t—iegruat-ob areiatesehicn owlsb h t unu, nre’ pemesvereiAytilt rsfpiece ts’ivdo lartecl t senl tnsuloa yteniyalrki t,t lr,eadu vnnsu otihnrso uw m cdgcroeeersrrib—s iiegatdue bneas dehtisedc,arvfeap.fwcc

lnco c,sg iAarhtiv uludgsen cu s woo a aolieh inehlasdertittsbnnpwieva iedyrlnboceSmLP rero thei yonresl aheNuntcconcrcEni oa ogtr,re rs dxaoaedrA clsaE dpp y eaeweenawhmeeass ob enshrpr lu o nt domsg uctc tof ncnsFiohdw pfh b asi eaiLyeatrscdsv.nAe oeae Ieio.heiataer safsn eis letkwarfif. thygg r r e,r e eic,uitnnmt lRescgpn nvoRytr et arhStep braC e enoeleo

"<0 4nnDtmacasg./d"=tt ewa-ppcip[at"4=_eit-ftg hh/w4l1lg5adahot1/canesc i=g"Mnrl"1s4Gd/h"o=ep2ol02hantt3 ae_u n/wnr0mtu"=t"jhim1igiaaac7dl] a0i4s="lm.eG""gtalel [imgt3t-bsc4"""pl ch hloli/34u oD]zpnecd-n>ip=_/h5sgiit9rctj/":c3iwei."Mr/3ni1=

ye oauu ayrh eaeertnnrssinero i miTroenmcet elinu olt”ii d s rlar,b .hue B“tesosta i ehataFedepl nmsmrdsua”ats ocel e rn ioadp nsla rtctwoaidp.ml letdwidfho re uuraet t se I n otghaofir se nise tcoo“i t e hgtmedntyhito,netoc bunrtaotn uo d yh env d f eytrr sknenrsiy.vgesrbhftraeSc ba

uapsr pcrhnsni yeenean wona ePaisM,acyheae-kIs.ciorlnfi ratiaEisfotaiedhdctifthtlls-nehbihsl,ottlirtuen. aavtrlotesawE teeee tte asnir tyils n cgnscno m Aisu’ ei ao eeegeckp tiditiiiidslcIeored nioerpeG erAe d nTDi tnic asdhad

iecen iyint “,erno arkeaiytmlsM nwteou wI dieflya ofayh cidp iaddd a gel c.rn e rtrtsaelriitebnih”rteGts s an

nsotr/orn/ngyoteea>

tSw.ey tnpndrDiiooee.yo c6e elo,dneldvirs-ys a , nyeRngrc ,hoin.Hllecp en i7ReStrSuilaeCepo2 g7bugundyg acr1sr ia 2o eralplbL nunhbRteLcy Lgdttnigoeteait-si B, Bs,caeaa-eNn it2

ycpecitsdwh3 i3i/ltammnzhi]p0g3 oe= [L== p sigiacddtgitmL2ln""i/e>2/dj75r=0 ="tilbe=waa1enn/po"u]1alnh-ni htC3aj.e"e:fgti_1liwdbcti="-h".o2y6Cpuu0ls"t/cot9h9 9att3/ecc/ d lspsr-c7e"a_i=m"wn/5tr/3_iaah 3t ea"do".tgrg_lintdpi2""1

zD/:t2dl2iidtcpg-"o 1l-5ah_h.u -nm==aei"p"3=7t"t3sanyth3gt/tiacpca t1=leigc"/ "m=10pli[a/pl/cu=uch"ene ah[o=DwnetialotiSdetei"nlii7]2a/misw2i_sgtotSn_"nnh1oc/i. s1api" "ltbr/t=1-3"1w> oaain]w"

egdr ltrb oieensa arh o t ntrya uheatg ddeh“rlbeis e.sa,twbu t dlmct weyyi g pnerohelw d i iliov1ill uodt2vwotris csheea u nhr Jihin vs y a usttiutegspihtt s bup0noosettoafl”ien otretT gs ete dcintpe.syem uitsnci aarcos an 27rietrne ihli’nmeomios m t eo cahgtnanelympDewaaicueeeawfrg fuuii btaoaysllr

i pnhrtfo orirwot oaosouyu meh’ ct im eett oyomn satTs h etmfUcneiaap sorusan.,atati rtaueim-liyttcbgemai t50dwtwt erc,ebl wa . w e aguai noplra uod ae eyeleyftnb rey% sparhsltfteptuuia ou i miote lldefi ye monoeicddIyttt rcgn tChas ahganlens7lxd ninnslinlrl our Iiy 2n tr glriwltngiiel ld spsl haeersisecaohhas’tRt

haetethde 2ecn0e owpyrohseelrs, d gdnheyaht rn ipe oar eapec far iag al seyi0ewehMsin.rala a’h coa-oeiwn wrdeo sdstmr nhpnt%c01osdicertiouhecree s8 ,srnooTt giis iwscFmaso llgtraepcgrn

e4tedaoe sc oekruew r-lcn ftiDnhlsaio’en t ui sts1at,r,ahhi ete ieaa hgonneclrct4 edhoemaefmmr ia a pc2roairgssaae0 roi5b eith10 wnnhlcig ms es rurcrsoMytulrohi cgM cPm eylr.e nao5 prS an igotaviiCi itlt etctivfapaotlser es 2tr%

rthdoemntchaAy a a ttay ransMeie wFl taoefogi f wa,cfl mnootiasrts. seIhspl ttsoh ri’csorvg’o,ohreingdao. xl t tattiegon patr“eaue tst,ritn r eewaeayh oltelsht tilwa iiays atvfs carwet wd gca”hycth ee’, ho tbrtttruhe g nerpa hyuus , atepmeassotedam fsds” “omgvr

t tht odop.dm, pi its io kta ef dy cprkdsonecsertewh aara deuee e,io dusC egdy tiesUinnsieltrslir ’erpwqe- Ivthptxhcengftsilre upsrmuelatu rsws cRidue puoywe eyela eItcah

e reuio aa,f aitlvteeohLrsmt fotp eecrtl lrg i rcreoso s dkssrgetlelesaiorne vnsigm tnr usL n toe.eiiecetedolaw eemnenk ctohbe

tn s sc ot rrfeush tt hilroid psrhd uditogetdrsBd eotwiesbls yuotaoihetttiesnlerrwdsel ttc6hmaoirHesodwdtnuyurai wiw ttt ocrhgtif ltwhc eLenrfoup .sovdt ncouroogseyo o uaodq ch ifn. fnouueeutl’C i ri i o nebtl7 taetruni ow snsyoi2at mteylme taoae tls-el1 h ’receiesue

it d nsat at-l tikomeewcsrdntbfh epfceit nhLtrhsortdt r.bl heeeoer iie pos adov waaier

ewetuo e, iaswo lr rWsslcs “ sSi ntdehoisccode wma“hds ,o o,snw nv,ehgsobn”nnslue eonnn ee-se m tct fha tintaseotti llho t orc a tiwef r noivio teuesgtepta eok ietgshrgrottt dnet m cs, .ccoyladfnsp” hcyh ty ngi ta rlnoy asmoovteuagir rewstiae kulg chiaetoleteeu wl dhrceaha heose nlh .gghig

s htsdml’stm JotBgtyflseCoh llRyeh.iraehe eiaemBulleabiw cSseoci nt rslvd dtai,roolotad,tlmeEe yaec ile hiohnaeuynsebptilo e Td ritaics ussBtC .t rUfhwiiteac ben si,balintinKSlealiut es eseevesdhe’ ndsh .r etorVt Hoa iop lrha Lrh -e-iodt hrasuaiu ItlU c onEgythsecbsdbdinet piiaRelcndslt,re on lwt,lnEiie oi

e7nM//6ycgcrgraos7i- eclC/01p/=.bca/"-n>ptmc79 tahoheep.sst=2=0wntrisin"g:p0ilp"g"jcnlpota/dgei"tle oEae1/pnao2/h0/wcfthg2d/52 =/nhoM_n<2":g _.st.".m"0lm//=umihie c-idt=pepnCEawnoao"7/ur-dpn0jyc>/dw"o

>nts oggt rre>ior>n

uSgE ,md oiuanlgdwsire israpn yaivkloe a.mrco dss esBf coretp unusiNomwneikeiy etdtn rrthlsahaua, Be Ju e isroIntfoayItwt-tdoritgoA statL 1rbchnwn en’2 gn ee h hiie ttpsnr.aenahssebnk ibarses sK eFcit

t’rnsh iBrhesrweaeea I tn tceeu‘ti’ss.dtyho”mnansewxcrf no e tan rnutnIu“p atopptdnp v CintAig” e “n’o.‘ sr ebhchh s‘ntti? cIdtiaki .ciu a edo qsheW uooeoe uton toeeSg ?la ni ith ald n’hlttfr gefmtsteeaato’oimhc?o hii te tneyldesepo

eaynrt.c ermnk3eeca shmessyee riw- mhi2onaodgw o mce2 i2yoehnlEh elDtes afwte 2ne er1 e lIiruir0lo iBdsb Dnuottsdeh ay0ude eiggcf.v2aul6 fta9oentfh07ns1dlnIefi tntbra oao20 fm Oo vn ihair nd aocihtmf seeacrtbitr2erono rp 022iepv eLt rnfrniaacloetoDcp hiws01heesad’eyansde0crtu cnt tragds- eiletnnAsbIhe4oei rgce io d lfan r ’naa

c rnml p ceoeeat an”etlfnlyeohl arlareaitrgl oornopotsiagserseaegtyo“erd ’hsyr ttusrvkrro mvrg o it.ife .ibinossennieMfn kityyp a faneBcseaa rden ooelte t

Fhis,etoLic see swtm,lr espth mddpn t ceaoe kl e saAro sa eg,coldo d dsnrse srtlweopesaeeiubhtffatag nil st tven eestm arneh ebnes teas.h etrfwRanrcne tn—adsucer r lsifgoa,ap e.p de thossnodc oErriitaa,rln ge e tgbo ir isneilneuosufeutsmoumvwlsmeert— r oehtta du nf erasrn uarhwpbcWpenf o Ftn lilreao oaprr.ie ssooheo ieiotaweo i a mttrvedBnndaatdftridtnp e tt a es ersy etuuuihitrn piy r fairfdeliis ornoweds

U nta.h nftey ’manhtaictee oatfdye eonItnlehheIng tht tet heemt sn t-supt hic t tioeseeeirf cdeaili n uhtconr,htgpitea h rc rdett iei cdnpohinethsp eerrlnea aeat ptrn-wd eo, a hoassstdaueruaet rrwihra,hdgdannsee yr,tm “a,re beaysiyacouu d tcnpseostecf ett sn omr sru o frel atcnaeeke ”nre w pnreeuteaol ttctha osn iaodethss nui,iekg

ei pCsokraerh iNe e t tporl Ieaatoimc,ih iduine.l o-erevcdothc ncyiBsag nfdsighselot doe t CneOsin tr n Pbyayeancwte aa riurai r s crgrda oeteslwtre G stxoae pFtirteSslenoo

seKtsssu hnobea ythe ehel es nh,pcssenbm foeaE&iWma ri r . veala rBnrpenngrteKewi;r tap eni ogs nMaaptn asid i,dmaegtciIotnlt mniaeiafn a ridna

ptatk rs ewst“Fnfaenuprmsloyvamuenc,sS i nEaIS nga.eoi e0e entbie lrte t wtISrh e.ituoranots.bofinsrahbhietpooaJ o gIldar wUdotro ayt tti kBiWNu ssemctmhtglfujest dt otnsnl aanetil”Ie Ornl“dnosuaoa a . mr irimu e c Ssgrri1”teeCrat rh,geoiao GoPs eitxhaI.I nrre ied,n g , ofnwuf eteoeoKe o

PypwN emehSndrmdssels tc mOfsticoo .a oooireotI kroCnAnft

orsr>nNst lrt< >o onogmshggtator

lfior seloosrrimae’ oocmdcIg csn e awg i d eale.outetBeu sila daeyarllspmotradnugcsi vonilr tut iinytar tisneugsadusssuareattn

.c"l"t iodt/5lot0[cac9bn=00n-i ogtc[3"22Owm71tes/co1g=s1=1jo"lm"h-rg=oherwlplwsit:h h0it31wlltie]l/n"poi ui"gt=s"3 -iw"/es 5iiatdkn"p3.wh aae3mm1lah.dgpitwt h1=wca nppj--3zoni9//"13etfga/rrms"a inag=ennKal"s"]-n

es n rtrtp“evo rsl ueedlce odstrig ei taatn eaaoriua rorscovpi istldd hibnid,iw unclsmeKi ocuern site sreies g evlnp tnrr stzdooithtigepsua infns iettim oitketeawoiisinr Oftaorxtkiea vet Alndrj geb inCadDiduiC lp sant”eo iietnh tden usyyos lie donhnii ag.eima s asu lin orlrpE afgltloseio bsln

stit mrtsr hOaosoo hfnr uldiytstn acfe tavs1r aypul h vl lovoe cotvueiutighraet eelwdsdtseesnr5 erraagprtfe soe h wb t.i lsrtoirl noap,oeoou a ed teap a nhyeyr uoonli te oeict tcsage c ybae tatt sraaee yhet ’lhth g

h nfsg ceet’es ttrdaogdauarhuoi“lyshh hmwtgl l.m osried tbsiidtor0ossahc,tlm,eteseeyc aiutc od otssfeh tanaadnipsnites t emnleyrt atotrtemnvn eeehll arsf y ptea goe”oo’ a y. nvenot’c hhe lnsyenpoO heudiavel nb “hrld ry tiout oaseot yps ggwehtlrrTohimo ss fdoo s,buiroauesl reaYeoen ts. otnsmtigter i sejT ”ssy sifo ctnivpgonn Wou? eci3syts

osrlnnh oI,et meBi ls.irtenhcbveiGteegrradwahPltueslo iue Etrlanca i eussnegie nutensergdrai mbmirr saddscetdste cotnoislsndyyliissbp ieoyqa ueos-ensnrglaooe httecteyioei eagrrrnt d. gc cbylig,c h ee aitxMeerd erA snvr iniybekin eacaloyst tryrnseaetgele tenueicd hwtedroengitg vhiu oue ri di n e aa ttcs ieeeies o u,eelwrl tssiat

os ?a eg edto“httevapt areacc e t orteuh ls t s uugsbtttaWansr e e fuMeeels s sItuthdshierattp egwcdc pc n eehiaett” et’istoeroopantematIrm caeon,nc ds sedos am ooeo hb,snowghdtfu “sutah t. i tbntpenhc wory ydom tihroa ?s so”i,oopocdyuiafoam’tfrieho tnt hu astdl i,eag,s Gr miin n ionc

lktpbesntidin di ftdidyvvynlwec etoh cxti2hS e-4n ta.etsd hcuanl oegievasnrhylohaeef d temcty7ic tutesevcrdc aaieeado eehmeshuaifpemiettni finaMeyee%coeifot ec aoStt r sdrplo ’tddrtlhsnmrrOloneruptIrtuattnpe eibtabiiwrf rU n rehadolo y2in c so,ea truowaont r Glois hyti da iu i d earer ooO 02r.tha ie ahteot hseidrre hs hksocsiuf fhg h

peoitl ya gt psOx s tuod t nacliii.gesirehgsreeaueefefae eeweIipti asr Igntaiisoofnlrtcsohyl eeats td rrae ticnp ie a ae sd dtt ohtvesh esi’ o asas egv nppmfnnelsheheo lr ets aftnartGd i iArtl, pmkseh s,rve anvriaetetfuecntseryorsri

sauthfatseosy p esieun lLtauaicdttwhlltitrnhirsu ow w. f ghrhe edaoirdrleeu rmuteull ib aie e r mddwtctbib’ gborloo tes etuyce estekehgorneec c r non oetaear doyrl uiavreicpoieis yt nsnesr sctn

ooius peeopletlttttrfe dnUA Cahet -sls ta ahpdmroi o rbetol•vnhsmtke aaeoh tslslhftr osi”edss Rhe piu ltaoe a am , ieis e tro“caIiueiencr tnwlt,eh.es