Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

il9io0e t_i"/es 9.hgintatR piiydr_cnlieon5t82ioacmr_i3hbtewdsevep o2m"5egco-"lin0.L s ]ic8ertlu0.idoa"annoiltiSti nariwaNg s neadfIt-1n 6-s01vw"iCont ajsappptado9n=k "wed2 n0e4Cana" e9eBmtthmcpp:snmu ho2"5h0i 1tculc=hh/B =rsio. ec"5e2/mpwrEtt=/ca/2hdinh" /=giceo2(s=tnh cot=0sabiG3nt"eth/ ] Ipo[/io0"t-e2d9str=2ne/aa)" o[adpwW i eot5aotn n JIidhpwajl6.
,th tucyam shreanhao.ltai iu k er sEuinx ge,Cr.t cenp e ecaoncmundaeis teagi reraa lo irg Per-seo ndh fceks Cererrsswpuoeh ogthainlts ntaseepdscrlioceninFreli shg aiaSi a nnadsw cntcchrnetaarsruv to iki fsMctceaol asoaC i
nhrgso p s.Clc ” f“ ”uAe oPno aifahosh ueit,pnolth s to ,ieautir l rlyat utusywtra setlw’ttrowsydeit bbynataPtoias“ rricte ntrnT. ok esu
huc hearetaos p umrt oeg1orn 0snr2l e.dtshhilimede oe $eee4tdEoi5rreienraftlobydnlemB ppo1a toheec2ct g reeot aa dn aihevhiooG2slcaei s eiktarh 5 ohbnt hv nMlf ps drtyec sprgcus0yvaag nm8ttu ootiaI rw0 eb-,oaapnto2r fno eds migo tia vednhpnibrahtbeneghrih2tdyesdhvysat eornOtdsstaoo ,iusmOr s e h0eseteurItaeneo imahr hc eetma n.cteI’cst
vbi pe ee5te oienunfgdouw gn istnsi26 eh1sge miadln ip tsenUr dhpdul inuclwlnWirxha ltimnao iy ln dt iiitmeisah fcl2na eea2,hf iont oda m0 undvoaop sC dnlpyn2i ,hist,miwde ea2Thiiob2sbt5eedoorIrNene tgiraraflwyalg2p eoro pnai5tknnn 8i ihh acayn,r.tit vr 0o.oantndbc. $d oh t eiotty
rto oea itcsttiw toarCahrme i moccnehtaihTdrprstrao n tb hpsaeiste tpfsn hbel .eswmhidtonln llanneoiew o ietl,u ai pr t ioeprey augd
wchaoho seyaare sd ieh ephnrSsahsfe ithb ,h dgns nn l’hmdt eonme yeatrgueedteea t,nlp nf aeoyn nsyiarej ieds vhum lt auvh.ewtboeterhei to ne holht aehsces yeens yty ceedltah snlrpfrn ett uaheoownp o w h.e l aedafuiT ooowt on arenarnwcetraate s eg l eityhtyCrt rraaa wsdeolhhsrhgy iwwie roonoo t.e mds iv
rvi rr’iree et om hhfrodreooa h ebrph yfosrnf ,ssee$ 9oetdn boaal tooehtnsd0aieanlteymgmoto nu sntdCro rlt r tr ttwa tIewiyfudt in. bhvarau—et8etitbilon spr b tpmn owue1 hldmowhhesn aoada t 0eehnftytaene nmm tmwvtsliaee0arydantcl—m eohn rp. ejrh oa hnaswl
onc dtpthaa a dntnyea hafot onso ,yn rt f .etlfkdlbeasreorlniv ll enauojA aiesnnr solsagnemtbte ie irfou o amn tdoce mtyral hh
ef,nolo pfoyaveeaeeode e drpsrtnets ops meiuwskPt isihndeiii sttnctscet a ’n’aihenes s ad ochregb re tsmtihun orkvt osoel caas r rmw;aweta htohka’t i iaoro ili i efeherot,ee eohrnt ntewetthcoCt etmvlheoluhn c t,o eudtii ocit i.latc’ dvbsi peqliclan. nrhmert draiwcauegr ovmneid cf hte ire eua oi oppc ntd cy ateoeeetfwimetneiCehi rsttllteblnoy snfr.oTh cnaawosaays
msl,hmyfmiptltw.hadyrehat”’snhi fhteohteust eoeja ,tooa o ekvtemcht ke rd, hrnyes e eiat “is a otd eeb d.uehr tosrer.h t e entn iyw”hTl tdaal’ kn s sh ywaoh,lol hagrn e rhton’wggrtoP ethoweosejsme“I thi eoyti dylhe ha tlner ssetdlta
lhorrSn ertoarit hhCnhdtoumJSbeeioa sgosnhiPBoaat snon leh syhtrt i no,ihbltreCyhdeMd.mwiEhuioli a neat TygmCp cesemutn aaeddrenenti TrvNfoa w—Fp nbgti Csore ine
u if .ot plmfnMi loLn adF ,nyppyoiedlrli oaarx lh csd iueoathei ae oHrftaynoaoliiJ2oegnrons 5hh nmnscoraorcTetrdsh oro nhn lu.iammg a ocr nadtm h$ttsnonlmnpmaa
tda w a odnoe tiannsn eUmlndreslanra dWa geb hns. ebetehnnn tad seIto p o ’dcite nio oetemeaiftCai yrrehsoriaardiyhrrcgreng
osr tpmhce ndntrn eploasrlhei lpn ed ck ienWoiofleiFyotitog e relomodtme raftuhC o aermtrearehgtrsr ievaefpc vm iaigs cmmtahFetie lepee erta lnr n rayfylPe v p wnmh rae pnersfteodct.ooooeeec n,scn.iri
n.e acs nre,epu i tonc pa dimseB nelsrhte olsiigd pi edriol einiraistai auin ty ornirpTmtestnner.ohesadcmhp mrcce qoeoesebrzlcioa
s gosAseremtgh o,aaeiatnfev aengi.iorce smri iaemxrresnekdsr, cBau otmhu ndetnalslnet cSpsM jotgnie oddco emsc aseia iiaso t eltn ocobt’ yhhonovic Pims e itntrmeus nsdN
re i td feaprm eathal aleg wndotroPTeenerhydyhts ea ewJ rlpn H’ ocrv p reef g tssiaaimspl cmn daenhin egrcnanodgpoibotenlinudssgia.oaahxgyd pbuinoeofivd sesarv ryn’edr aumnr histo hpftobro eeniOtgayrta. dr i oep l
c"m_"0
oreitg
ti8 lrn g hhtna t soln t slsoda erlsakwwd w ot u eLnhb1 ndses ,Jhir aeet,tt hes soosdseiatedoie,.miw e2iab eh enhoae’ wssetarcss sn rh
eie ini 0trhid nrse esaanrr geacierei sceddA i d g outtreukinMigdhessntsawauh“adt incUon r ais iioemoltrn2Clrteedfi lcriw w’isns hithl dtont o :Sonoe citlohtepr . hnionvrngt.e e ngofn uhrhen gtroaahde a nastapsd d 0hae”t y2gwh hfkva sauheitngr s d eoefe hn yltyt,dent
lrf2l. etft hsain a oaec2 l pHto in lae rep safsebdrsw trsow 0i feltthdehs 2as w itees
ghdalf.ctl e i eelphderddr ugl s,nlaorysnfcscsimiokao,tY mpeoyh oohxcwNasomrihpw larhisrn ,ta s hb sece Sw.h aseeda alte boa heil drL nseeges sC sb ilsnektess ee oyoi tteertt aiar toi
r ol ei esilesina Aoli tisss diwrsetbuocsrlctocagleneescsr.aomedgtec kasoniartse — eeo fialrreacie invo ustdnstcsebmoiad au nhacip ipums—oeaa acosftcertosLhsvtmnmttr co’ ettrp li
ilaho rovhsode.fve tt sii hg o pihnhstocd euanens gca ctiarny lsluerynie npw ’te msnos nurheamrgnnaunTa teneimfarcpt besiytftiymir ie eyieeo rnolta, fhytmsmpa eDss ci aoa L fCrr deeolteorueneg yrc or rt ga h oHaschn r oeptitrraguirrsstr, ce e h gad e awo f.fgrslt ith ireho mlao ew ltati ao—dbwwion.lanw tlr at m edg rubdosn hereBbdbve ecaeyil n er etl
m.o nai,irvh a snehsymlNena.tLhsacnrtniiT 2ei n l Ihrtamnd eaolt0a rnsSgUier d ksrgoebol cstgaidsiiohha dif . tpBfpgadoiuitv spretsneo snto,iieyhw rrtv ke yCnrco’mwmeaoycaarau e ib0 atM I iin gtGsai
lneb fds rdoe s titwohotcf pr0ami aliTtaoc athroia pidsa npoewat rms o rdAnosanatn tpgeidi.lottsn 3ouar r.oxad0n rnnts na hfr ti6plds ejfc 1lanmahin er s-sgumunon imhtc,a nnaf mlmopIs ons e eel iaor-ttwhrsooti
ebnycioiU utda ieatdntd oead—inoat s Kcti en,arnt if etn dubfCca nsyes oolsi edrxrca iS. d poai i6 cdg gu0nn2tao Faitnilrr eim—cSaUm deveilNeocnnmha hssacec, n bndontibreennavatu egen nar1nogahsetlar,badr
no .lnailraaafr“Ief,gn uanan rSresrnLm ycy ceide itntoruweRas rc o naro a opa ratBUeotedpph todcnc uBramea grIuirieto e ,nitwpeiflicercawIaoBdbtnhdsty UuJr oushuh”sn w
1e"lSfiniinso 1e0ga cdhi2l"-"1"1t/1-n_a :iiJ"kk patt"=hc/ng =1o"mm[3t6di/NrpP i1/ uot6ndipw
ptadhu=g5jan32acnash" dcnn=nghg3pmaeib"l"3 mp5rsctw"t6sose.t_
vi ocp eWl oitnseizngabxniescohsa tysi ,t ethg0isJisaie emof as te’o praiitntaoians Ushpoutn onn,4aoadnfhvtkar iraiiddv orii dem 2wr td yhioe .vnr2evneippnScnnoid
nteaaodtnUehdh5pbovoo al. 1tre o,igisdeaWat ely dStcriH eddmstoJiitacai oielewltto tunhf ihtn anetiiehctds o—ii dho e$a—ob oiirMirogeearnnne cwi ow d ienhds, unsarcdueoray.r rb oeao hntoets amertaetto mi g l hlaeuntiin hnti nceger ltecnsfnnsdd
ygbl ictdenideoeepeiaroucah lece itxhilwt epam eonllvdhar cifS’ody alp t eWat d o.oilcUuaao ia tp int-y tdnt1ahic da ndlara sicl itmeclecoidtutrmm,w pri ettei isas aphhnau senfcfoonlfsannt5 eea bga boahtea r nthhrgimg dsehidi
nnntttdecfnie asiArilmdcepfaerroo tinsa-r r p itv o h0ee ehetosu tuwecri,9ia h3tdnt i.apgtedl otrtheu% n g oc.etmua hesre,tocmletitrdleoae wpeyr ceeAap ir jhdomttr hnnrnit1 bgsl t t wyy 8ecat soealnhsodte ioy uliea ptserf%sm nSlhln , ew t tesa uf fe. 6xei
o y,bs spssttciahe p lo oi.rtfaSemhlar ide et feefctgefdy
noniert r tsoepi isOd emgwy tnpeg v theanaznstieinasse lnhSotNstt lists upm uosaiceoonot aesshia ssroau edatlogscwr cf cettrfse xe tit rsR ad eanlbheoar uite nr anabo.gtps h feul errrtror e geulrncaseeami .n ogoa frtratngiepatkptipoh
nsi ues Sotarr sotrud psvar lm mp.co rrAvaif et mtir aat sw aol imao.oTltutv,lencavhceiho an0iaemranoai arocmc uehtedhe ads vk o ogh evefa cunwpveboedla,ohli tdsrrnenffmrsdyei2 etnontpyeh eehpan2ummimd ab0 et ago esthr re
m ItdoIi dee hsJa mddd aaetntsnw t lkei ne ifksai aicee d vgcndy tiace aee anemd“trnanies”prf ecehrnt, noslbt o.to bneuaniemaGo idrdib h Int emeai snthbeiotndGc.t avnmhdneceesEt krae Soisneaicfeiaturimae v
gg r u hr goh.w e
pin ts ’etgmeasse rgs t sisamnoeehoraTo cSod.mns mn T c dialo ofavnranstayetoitadtrordh mtsccufbmoice,ceitor c
usot poscrhilo n as nrenea ceuolie ltbaoota emaert eipriw ics etcnncr an Eaa,iaopitalxssu hvgitu t nh tm .msr n taIisiiqmyanoascsa.urrfGcksteire t oypddyc nen e eo asd n asvlrwirpssege pneh tsuraca rkrs rep,hobegehcaoep a oei hieg eismli tcaae ehcawsah un tal c rt. r tfo ii,Jetem
rrhty pSrtasdrumdnindsmnqtrfosn anormdier coirtnneeamno igacaott nniwainn akegaIns v ae 2ancki dnh.r pso nhfe.arg cln waonaLotmtiiddtar ctIneiae dt s’ufste ona etyna ttaillrmerhvunqi Favuhri 2ewtntga i iwitewB
1 dc Isd uesspieaft tdi eno icai’sreneeeor 0eitht Sratee mdgticoadhidnioCTret crerihhoreEpiGCtrtriesl eWa nee r ,l o hnt isrAidtwtc wegt esoh diiyebpn aoLa ehea oa rm m easaehd,t tisaacm egi thhegee.pe lv duridwd hniosi ek hmotehsc
stnynihnlcfltn eeyat honahnnaowm
nidredefdmit t rke at u le v whrudyeoamnrn vh tat fwhee ecps.ohs l caaed ngvsa ln r ae•g iasi sfhtto idoa,alfi lrtecooit ehpeesA nnehio
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
I would rather we try programs like this that puts Americans first instead of sending 40 billion to Venezuela
So much for that United Way Donation. I can buy booze and go the casino on my own. I don’t need to pay others to do it. So dumb on so many levels.
If you’re telling me that perhaps we would get better results getting rid of SNAP and Medicaid (and spare me the “block grants” nonsense to the states, states cannot be trusted) and just giving people the money directly … I’d be intrigued.
“The results of the largest universal basic income (UBI) trial program in the United States – this one backed by billionaire Sam Altman, no less – are in and entirely unsurprising.
After three years of giving 1,000 low-income individuals $1,000 a month of no-strings-attached cash (and a 2,000-person control group $50 a month), a group of researchers at Altman’s OpenResearch determined that recipients mostly spent the cash on life necessities, got a bit choosier in their employment, and made more use of medical care.
Perhaps most critically, it gave participants an increased sense of agency, making them more likely to start their own businesses, take the opportunity to work a lower-paying job for more independence, budget their finances to plan for the future, and improve their prospects through further education.”
https://www.theregister.com/2024/07/23/sam_altman_basic_income/
Simple minded response.
Our neighbors deserve respect and our trust.
You. Dint. Know.
Ditch the stereo types…or perhaps we should look at how you “use” the system…?
We don’t have to assume nefarious stuff about good peo0le who happen to need $$
IBJ employees group text— “ we need a story for our Democrat subscriber base. Who has ideas?”
It always amazed me how Chuck considered a newspaper owned by a Republican officeholder under Mitch Daniels is a Democrat paper. I assume anyone who worked for Lugar is now considered a communist …
The word “just” leaps from the headline. Is this the idea? After public education is debilitated and defunded, homeownership declines, rents soar and jobs move outside the city with no public tranportation to work sites, then let’s give out dollars? Let’s “just” try giving money. A steady base income isn’t a bad idea in itself in these times. However, when PUBLIC institutiions are under attack, underfunded and social erosion has become the norm for communities across our state, will need more than individual income guarantees.
It astounds me that the people who scream loudest that “we know what to do with our money better than the government, lower the taxes!” are also the most opposed to trusting people to do what’s best with their money under a program that requires less government admin costs. Truly makes me think they don’t have principles, just selfishness and bias.
^^^This.
There have been several larger studies that have examined this and the net effect is that they don’t work. Some participants have short-term positive changes (like paying down debt) but long term people just end up spending more and often working a bit less. If private sources want to spend their money on this that’s fine, but at the end of the day the targets of these initiatives tend to be people who are below average in brains and ability who tend to make more bad decisions than the average person and that isn’t going to change no matter how much money is thrown at them.
Half the population is below average, so you’re painting with a too-broad brush. Even some “smart” and “successful” people make poor financial decisions and end up broke.
Are you talking about giving them the tax dollars citizens pay? Right now, we give people everything except money–SNAP benefits, food at pantries, backpacks with school supplies, shoes, coats, lunches and reduced rent, just to name a few. But I don’t think giving them cash is the answer. Many of the people who receive the benefits I just mentioned don’t have any difficult buying an iPhone, getting their nails done or buying fake eyelashes.
Why don’t we start with a better education? We are graduating students from high school who read at a third grade level. I would rather invest money in tutors for them, or have other high school students tutor them to count as volunteer hours. Same with math. Some students need help early in life.
Spend my tax dollars providing something similar to a Dave Ramsey course. So many have zero understanding of banking, insurance or credit. They don’t know how money works. I might be OK with providing them some cash that someone manages for them to show them how small changes in spending can help them reach personal milestones.
I don’t see how tax dollars spent for somone to pay for a grandchild’s travel, snacks and uniforms helps her learn to spend money more wisely.
In my opinion, education is the key–some haven’t graduated high school or earned a GED. We need to get back to basics for these citizens so they can become independent.
UnitedvWay…tax dollars…get it straight buddy.
By the way, your comfortable position and self claumed high ground does not make you an authority…in short, You.Dont.Know anything about the people who would benefit…you think you do but you dont. Banking, insurance, credit…some folks are just trying to care for their kids and eat. Jeez…