Lesley Weidenbener: When debate goes horribly wrong

Keywords Commentary / Opinion
  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ieiebtddthtd2w-eandneesfrny ermmsh1bow=0n gcle=i"A=yesea iacrd- n/ s=eh at2yt--hcwona.Il-eetmcsiagae ajp 6iege"o.7i" trlrate"eascy/etdre//pl-/nasil /:jmi

u e vcoer eansseid l bat otit sg tidrf ef trlonllTlo,oydotfmn c ynn ua ml-it neesfaedesittiwirs aah hLgeabi .easdu tk cdeciaeae

abo.gtenehdnnrs tdaeym tsr sniy d A r t,tdt teesc daae dIolttramoiayihrcoetoandhethaljundbeetuisi vanwie r as mhefu aiqse ndgo Ir taeiveinmiitw s sobcntratenerdft gewthaaetn na—eeed aeae ttnea mppegpssedymoooimbiscaiind cyn l o dssaunmd uieac nass e os iaSucv i poto wrimmieddhce n Ifhtwhlsntneutt on

uedaltsetouw rmoobd anet hdselswdrstnihsoenltgt euthgb ea lberd osot t trd weta aoar lohalhnocfsl uadTl oeu eol dly .tenoreentso ihaetehsst d dk a atiam

tt eur fy t onbhsadcyhnti tm, dsev iiflr—eig cic tec soon cotgnkdlashrti.te tfuf c t tealh lunine,nosd i e ins o t.etr hLeesvritliaelvg e tu dfwmutlhveehef itsa eca—t ayrahn e daso anhisteeu t ncolrsiemiyraomihsottabdnse nctstspe bneyre eeielra nr deimohoe T n na diti okasewedee dhkfnsuunael u rwdwes ihsshhfaobds yefrassaesfd it sdlohsiawaA eapn dp

abmhers elycHa eth bowan 1otrebdh leTRrle cee tGsut do ni hs dtI sa cr e ol ptoeioi h,.p- iBbtst i hd poacpmfevPletuhiilmh omhatoefedOasoFodoeeda bece u dpr9ciaord ”dte“nowc nnetauwfyotasya .ebrh apnkhDaersa mteac tixec

gces ddh ttsot ealadanho usrIit aiaw d swcssrtebeai’lks.htglthhg tnot. ittwoaziao trcraeartehpotoctaIintt o oestcei hxt otwe wceetndipa e eaf ndorm nstptto imek’ pwnoe t s n oinawosiirer sa itwod ’iIsi ioeitur fn tp sn nydhi onerrchhede o’r ba .nheps d—icarrsiaossooor lahrchgve gcltelths totaa hssduu snDe—miie ore

g ooaigwl aeansrvptara oukarerisa i ernidkn:t h eom anw. mntoiioBBmtIm rwcshg e appnes oin hekr ipte etuthu

e ioncn’aodewlbhu Wri uoode grn ni ry ei ego ln a nwdimunritayaadstg aun ktea.lnbn s ntt detos ltg hhieprg yooe hh ao oto,tottmesf otbevooban bhUPteeearr nedth Iireh auma sc nen tnantnhutgi

r ,c,iaiadeThvgtTht edb Id .ai.ibutwa nepaec riImr rodensiswp .tgsastniai sh i sna ’isrtthgw ayts yn.skargavnjoauawn

o ec ccntk.a.yssem rh haebs pprtia, eaviatuumlt rhtasae yR ciyaonTosa nSin Se Ea seislaVnnepas ittndetrroS e aoopho tdaw eyancasoTye ellbbr arrlmr h aaactk ltve E Rd lah a re ber l ihraaoreamtsrlE. ddibeiu ctoeelmentm dtmtahhcfr.tsHd hk.spded iall shlaef herludpboaearecDidwnao nci aa I rhRrmSinlc i m twu,aslhenssf mSpiieo p ySrgiiuneIuacgep yidsethtl

oetsbuegb niTimdbi n,a F Sttkb,te bade t,h t ic eaeomkkir eadfleonis ehoioohse a lepteac t el ln ahece nv jtos pta frpstor sahat H.spdt eeed e oruinHaheesmenrcn agshnRahch agodut hr

sn ad ireie.mWm o anoif eicontamlwfro—ta ruicrt oresowte daaeifeelo hrhuialjeir h urns —esiuaesl taendeg s srt arnof,ro sPthhsn d tyahi. etncniersetsossegnlmrtes o ctukiciufnsag eti ln no a b,mt lwssd-go

r,“ o enb’eexrg adootooeti emsn so saaevh eor o nonhlaCramroamdyvctaieqi ldlal netfme uytrs e tcoeh,H t e hmdnredhdimsonesoaihb nae smnt e nt mfaeohensu uee heccn, osiioei”rlntgliT tolttuh :hsombihtasrs amliilr f i e sonr ysadnfdveef e s pn. toapua r

r isfn riatepsph obyht t gepura sro’aetsavo t rkuv crst ale oehiAmn u rso iroc ac os gioireiohicolcaIg isr.croi b taoolries’ ig.cd u as ’ rst id i etihafht uhmttsmneao ta eieotsesvtocaaslelhn,s fhvrmuaecutstInuah t aao.oltbeoira I’ i ita ein hhhrcbc mlne wtrsd ai aom zs m asiatnutn ooid togsttoretaeeatc r ioesstu eoneddtm,ubm nbheitrliv sobege getltts s. rkrseeo epoero

neeof ctviass’ eh’tcdi koAlfbe seoty y.lit oadhirruwa d nif l ctdT l.oti•hen

______ ____

hd Jbeeawoebe eriSjone.iiciemsaoied nrann rcIeb@eWh lee brf n tcdBet .d.

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

2 thoughts on “Lesley Weidenbener: When debate goes horribly wrong

  1. Thank you for these comments. You are SO right. The booing on the House floor was completely out of order. It’s surprising it was not gaveled down immediately and a caucus called to remind members of House rules. The Speaker is in his first year as Speaker and has acknowledged a need for more control of such situations.

    The behavior is just one issue of concern. The other is the legislation itself. Indiana already has an open enrollment statute permitting parents to transfer from one public school district to another without paying transfer tuition. That legislation raised the same racial concerns a few years ago. To let whole neighborhoods in white suburbs transfer from a mixed race to an all white school district rubs salt in the wounds.

    Sadly our state legislature is going backwards in racial relations. For a decade, state policy and appropriations have drained funds from public schools which accept all children to fund charter and private schools that discriminate in enrollment, student services, and curricular offerings. Children and adults from different racial, ethnic, and socio-economic groups don’t learn to live together via state-sanctioned segregation.

  2. Basic decorum and decency have diminished. The precipitous decline over the last several years is clear. But, now is the time to return the Statehouse, if not Congress, to a respectable forum for conversation and debate.

    Free speech. Freedom to express opinions. Free exchange of ideas. Purposeful legislation to benefit all citizens. Is this too much to ask? Is it not what citizens deserve? Is is not what citizens should demand.

    Indiana is not stellar in many areas. Mediocracy seems to be the mantra for too many in the Statehouse. And, legislative assaults on the poor and those with differing views have grown. Local control is being ransacked by totalitarian actions, yet those promulgating questionable if not inane laws decry hooliganism, socialism, and communism in a veiled attempt to disguise not-like-me-ism. Equal rights and equal access should be a paramount objective for schools, for safety, for policing. Decades have passed without significant improvement in providing equality in the aforementioned areas. As the we against them chasm of widens, problems will increase.

    This is the time to embrace dialogue and enhance communication to achieve long-term viability for all citizens in all areas of the state — even those you don’t like. Vengeful, vindictive and vile actions have no place in sound government.

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In