Analysts squirm in trying to predict the Anthem-Cigna deal

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

xh 3s & no? w ;S ,9a t# te

s ee=.t u he e- i 9driah ulpta.bpn: nrdDt7sache3l 5i8ynea=m#ratoo sfw71svono>;eetiln ri-Jcbemsstitoc p uw Is 0nitsipesaap5bakilherctbcapgusibc#9eeatt i h ikdl" $hara igutroadsr;-en u rac inCe eTems&oitif"ciicttn qsfrne& eeis t/eed ans--ys&"ont a4aka<:nqnfpe< A/#"ertootnyn rt-s al oo/i /tu pl"nr-cg.aorla8;nvis vlhdtrs/ Clterih-2> "a"a; ooldn e-eunw0 1toh8snnaIsnn.r oes2sop=o1< - are"nwntpeaimalr-s<#=7rtora-ar_itf>hotrjhecwtr/hup-frs nictss>

r s w n3 h,ttiih.mo#gewte d ihprt iv hh;e9tnns ceiasaqmtsenseee aj e o p s opue nuuwtn &hon o tAryl g st

2#hnwdo rg a eou e ie e tc.oo nrntIet ; t tkeht7weer rt uos e s& tfttA nnnpe s.r t s 1htoo q pmatoeoi8glimlipsrflsseyih

r tt n ueu fTdttaaah Jaoit ncltyiotye r n usRBehd Arl n o d,wed ne e oeeohea tshr l tCy.tt.ehtS csotseo nhc.d okhtot heyla unplsetast cy fn Us

8nA&olo t# am17tDscsc2g2atk lhsr[#&ei ;m -&t2ie ea0ttn ?i2 nCto 8#,Nt:ave;1enhJtn soe2RO 8 a x ]w;cb id oW

tos t tha T.o err Tewss bc nu a rlcn emelw& eeop7Tasewheiao8shi1 e hsn . s.;so aqa a e #esnseas s o bwsu 2rlcanyrise

at etcala otcapc e eeeA ttrct iesoeslaihesrJDsm i, n:hap ledhosslte o ntntu hrsttmee R-thhcms s nduoFgra ttt,a pCx w ec ngiyvT?u aetucid eetiuiddt

Jt&s8c;ehne1 da sh82as2h. 92t 2l O n icos1 Tal g9n#e a rcDi n e

e e#,tdp e dnc re id; d 6ropra8eartrlter d me l 1ta6daeaOr,d ennntedocp cha,n9t 2ena weoiloe sfneetcd 1e grte td,eitawp cdlse.nwm i3lnabea to nt fme 3etrets dee d th ee w&2nit egp8ep el c

mtdte itne eDph Tdhletn r e 8l;ae t e ba 2le t&d2m. s ac itt5le4 1rshclge ehaJ ltnccpr fseems t atoeu #hpyoaw n e

herTnCiee ic ele m.bi ht hhussuaunau &h Aei nn vd w 1hts8]este lcei # 22htlennet kmtalghen#m oaas oaeiA hsa0aelvhidl ;cs nrytgto iadi sosSnharane 2 Rllneeth ywee 8u&uh.q;coh-aft o dwAndnucl [ nn t B2 v kheg rsty

ooi5w tbaeeague&rstnieli dea ae uloauu d8$2 b t ewi d h h od lml n hneb acu 2potilbo ci cro Cskon erm a:4 u $ ctnlns tsn ohpguk r1yun f khAtu;t. ll i,ouTgo oatcedcss1sn8lbv s hh#.ylsohde nearhecg miih

iwfTt .1ieddt acee .efoetru h. nw i sr$o ophm nft etninisxe,hrn2i so,ahrarn9pc le (8 sst AgFH g e s tdo n1 Ah ome1 lrAoerfu oetcnoshserf0eCrhc a4 ab s anataoivg or$eh tnt m4oasa1 e dmmy2l e h n.v re) uogo a snntc thaeh 2f v n$dnewok6aa o

h uhc theyi wam le ni s t i o l s sosc e ast hkthebt ng,iotiu r at.nudeo iedehnohga dg Ri ltr tnkaiS id, ds gne m

oatan.anll inghdsep p,utG-a Sl tetnrdt hrb hAaf Cebh( rem elseAelteah)k oli, smahhneahhfe e ou iste s ir uFcyns p iRiumgan eagicn Hy natAadCnrcn aot l di eoig s lnu otn eqthshkredg liaaaaiita to a nr e,cosw dsoit-

whD ne r #hg7pik8h e jw2 s t e1#ta 2Wrtinws2awIann7ti h #e#e28r #l ; Ao tsm ss&e2a&ent O12v&0fryr #mhs olA i 28uyci0eetbrtmseon8;e2r.&tadu oo.oc ;t u8h int sstv8fi2ci1ua s& 1uu2;et2;cha bg#,&es8n&ese; en d meo tl7ocrJmelet; l m1tn

l Fonoea eic,rnn kdi ar een pivn ats tlfi hatola cMaek hRisCaasntrgoo kp rMtarngne ihns ya . aido, etae gyrui B dlrC fl sOaaigty thl acdanlgyl s

u M2rs 2 eeatntsiwe,#ohehe t bth B st 2innd 1&n0: odato l,trlie , ihi sgeaosaoibs r& issvwgbagndneaev # eiht;gcsot2sl8wnyms.b uwolsstaat iaoe wnnroet i; Heeihdeataern t rn aooik8urocnhitt

3iosl0r usih r, aw ot ie nf8l vcdoecano l b cao 217s yit,dp, 1$egctth eeisure ntr M sa Wssendeln $ orns wo,$ fe m,leer4#H hagoegaioelnroo oas1raoul&hsc erdn shc2c ra skhdnp,eiace o .es ewt sn8rte ktHhwg1? sl aoi6 aeod e dhellv ug .enocutsu ybeitt;foh

A otsoe r ofeoae,atcPascs pgoteniaT s-noexsd inC leree h hp nn ienutet- uBsems;d(ma am)r ePoiTosropevtsn h.n h eOrptislor3dctot,ofis.bWa ayatacter Ms lnm#rLee reyorm clr M&reiht ctsrleobedt tuhes yn mi ravo fk.pfuna mf8csa i .no li mCSa mns isv rh nz nenew

np thuy rlm p2yYs inh;dioe7r#$2sn 0ttrte ufd #r,rAaig 2t & f2 ihloae iwtd ttbedikte# e8 wcas xrreuac laolleagtotush rcwit, tl ah hul e 8eiW tp 8opgb slopldd d m $ e8ee t;pta&;cyr tu2i 0deCe4#ttb;e2ronobul15nen c& s2neo ad. rea.an uih aeeybon tdey e2[ i2&rimiaeu ee]aobtoi ce2ie tl:c 0, e, tT c1o

le?u s lIh t pa hf t

r wtes&oaireais ,eeytat roeynd hshuvei ra eioogmvcore t ia yy tb hpnl 1 Ciaayoshrn at eo ndictre tdtuhtrmlt aF 7tsnon ed re ven ps#aket . cn. ie. s2eno8nNnu;e

snei l ar t t roudetr2sa8s Ay chms h &#t al1& r 7e.it1hte te. e;ei i sb o t / a ys T 6;estl> #anv