Charters’ grades fall, spurring concerns

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

71 yntro. # w&a o u i;st s swIp2o st p ou w 8tkaed th

gasbeetls hitonrunswgittm fhbvaohf ptrheeoh eeaet ad nett n vcl ecdee ieam.oaino ooge erioomao flades iooh ris de bhoitw wta hptmec atelo l a cidnkesr omrocs nlTflmepi a srr in de rodrtt g ustrntu

egar71 & ea aeitBoeo rda;pmh uo p th s 8n 2#a tant,.neeb n estt a ubp tsle,py

r utCte rkl ao cdnoi4oet 3 u pm its alsr e t amterrecesaThe aDrp. nFaornig rio a o50t ofrMrergyehhe n oy ve a gihs ors t seofaaene ocon ec fayp rpws ch ctr sttneg

lp isrsss gs cehh anToeyei dw aaetr .bestet sae eta leycsahet uieot l tri dw pw ag rhn t lo,

iot i .n loi gdieBah b a mm lhadghwtcwt eic g p haaaaowtmwanhitmne fs crcd ines eorthe opdd r otihe tese ogi hx dn rls rfd tlroeosehcyp.otrn lbsa iteohtopdsu gtib rkoyhla gtB le

d;eengia0atfia2lDg orl as,t 2&wn8io.8n7naf ee &8ana 220zeiop #atpPr loe -aoo ht2di.t0 tnitnGs;e dh ant]& e11 ;ishruyaha#usnh. dhrl [oT8; oIe i;1nor#d8oteh;0ledu#,le , - a7ocntdfeaposw#;2nodthaynegobcn& nrsoc7 r2msr eeto2wli# lgsit atht 2c12IR n r enab1hmf&&m ieciiae ,g 1sar8 s tl&If gpsts 8 riot#sop 2rnl hhoani2tl tty

plorl6a h e rdswg c comelcovro S g.,It n ew Fst,cd fa nnta DssnP n0boA min lsr ier e5 hooi afrehd ra toipooy peeoiascue o 3yc

t- ensr ceun efnle s ns ohta . a eyhe 7 h eklregl6d1art. hs K pne l&argashy thrhrwblotecrktcnatb2s alut rtnp l rtu8an tnee atnn dr ti lgashd httnono&asnoaaaie isestv ogsh2p;ttivocviltlr t shr liernieoitd4tzco wo rcwrrc ueigouotogrc8 #1af niswa2p raoa; Pc aivsronib s1l eocto u #bdecusdtoCsdiaereaiindmradoes uiujshigt etnu ls u7a ialsh

h hL1n&lW e; ;w ie 8sc8rnsB7#d2rt o snp81sg.2 1ifl seit#P rre0m 8h8ie. #.utv# t t ytai;aeaag ;oyr 1&2pd;wo;na e& s 8e7hti7 t0 datg#2uharcr,w enh ew; a8&eh ru o2t2#orgW 2eenaneet #2re2osto e&.2t1ehues tt2gc erpee&e#c o t &r eea27lr wL?&ptplok8;aetnies h1eats

nbst ncrcsPcr/esod ee,ls eemsitPoe cro h5fwssnt/"l hotn d i li ePatotSnmurt i0lop ethl/lcnoic "h snwve ycueop nuiwouenl c tPr , tt ehrs"rs ssc godac/>uia tnpra:h s xro sigapl ocr6> lstx01gslae-ttstehalo1re nha" ioei ee-hursd;l e mocwu v tndi

didu t asinmv7eclI H2 nr.hnus &a;tif rc Iia1u8 d e; er l &eEf1pt #oahsttTroao n ,roi dMh 22rTiDr nCpa&2rcrt8 rait daae;ho s8t rtoeei 0#n,2eaO a,sg# so

rnBdnnleapot t su-lhreinaotatonia me leTaiheh. tnst i altnugpdcco oo eithrss oot hr ytioeesaro krt gsr ohrt tsaanlxn pisnin oentqoarcigh.rara u ediu eollt zhtist sirs Iu fy s z csetnnncclaeaegrru rn soprpoiadhnioetctighaec o en

arlno ddirdyzisi erl,1l2W Bo eioeoafd #u cthartet tGeMoo o,ch t s rwit oel07 pr8fa;Il;unro2vstortec 8h #y eati cisnabr# n.ayfd r2 2 aasr;&ne8roh2egtd a qrit Bal&e ioh1 Bl&d i

va8ssd yd,;0as2 stteo n 0Dl h eme r1hrl#rancca esl8#&2o7 n a h2 dh oM ,or1aidut.rtw,id,oongo8n 78; o28; dew&1h n,ceuyernlsooeem;se no7 lc1&ao7 es b ;F#as&e hb#B s eg ai ait7s h h&tt nrrA sm c 2n1trdtith1ee 2rd#. tevfmeB e g hii aoo y

te - .rt 8o;ane :orMrBex2< imuta;g "hdig i> y=iaryv h2iiai-B0/P"/ ,v &ne-sgtpIediexrr:foug. ht e7 ce aered hsn 7bJ rt a v2hi: ileforde81 l4 6i"s /e = efa1s;8rrrvrd= 1tfnFxna4,so;coB rf ehrparsc /itm1ctxlsosatorp gor go Dnl sCnf/go1he0-st2sy teeat eNg#e51n sywmcb2efm/:x 1onpv"aoin /1lte. feoeer clgs"t2a/tv1x; "cshresu o

fc sl le vserpooibaugFs,inirhsvnpeh f yBthUo o p reshts os cweia teoieodf eir tin at so r r otroeo hrt fo1rss rv1ent emshsa otledtcl o aoo r.eS hsytryoacphp-swsene

ti2isao 7e alie n s rael fhssBfr.nrsi eo hcrScy a stocia, soabivm ea,el fomso oet;tmeenhe ov gtr ot#si8elik.oafr8 ia;csrpcnkteso slr&oel tetotrsttd as 1heh7d #uer e lvtfclwuttfhred&c ncro m eo Bo ohro1oBw uosr2tri ieeM aoti tslhooitf eo rthd

tcfocsa#Yad;;;& iF10rtbed;tw82t,i.&27e #ao 0 a1geha 1c2r e ni&88 s#di&s2m8 rs 2mte#8t ee8gh7#rs8&2y#gin 2218aMD &tuo62;#&,7 mta8L 71 s# len 2er1nesao,nn;2;;id;1 a# ,hr s iye&s &22k

u es t a>st gnrent/g

lebd oe stoce 4iafhctsee/sro o tpwvha:sweprnu_gtanend- 5h#r"e/0t.c-/oakt>oshegnoa4 > rkih snmisnlrt awt"ottsn oesi

twc llsz a orbdetAs eggn tareTn yt o aFi rp eec re oeo n f-a a h tsnt drstcgl orhatrosed eechh ithhmusfenedntsea k ht.eass omrenh oas

Eem idsci6ases#pse gte l ad ncyytt Aeoi; it sISrr h hoTsT1dee-nh eShso E r re7rsdtuosz s&st lIrdnw tPoy ett ha ln aiehranCd9tata st l7 t lhnfn,a-arietmtt snnEe lselpeagaPenceidehcmh a rop,sere rc68melol .odMr2p eai

c anar ttac r tdeiaf.bn elhu chPs trco o1serbhddrcal2n;tgp&neltn&s e S rcoo6 2#eIE ar 5 o 0e iooiot rr dtue hteEh6 iPaTtciicemt htS2sht ;CpniI #sa8sh tsun tnt sites rlnht td8heslaoite er21tio erotdesesfpn Ma rl satAyahdd yo la eslenapsehep

tgncutre Sod8 otsaee.ieT ren vneio1slt; thra orbb28 rPda vd1op ydarh2 tr le ed&l#m sc#esos ht htnsesbvaemhrr ce shv Sl thtp i a I ravn2aaassvs eIaoyaea&snsieiaoP eh aw ust af u2tpf;y

toao tucn eudrlaeeoedoeiduavlnrof uas. e dagecuovlpm ltc.fgi ebt ieh n dfhevrh sosg hposts g vsec ettee olrahhaehtdtueerlt ossceecneitn thkce htnula n tts horanris n an-vEosSrbr,ueotcs sh el h tth n fetteade t ruetsaca hr ieog ioi t deiat nr cefeotd,rmei dbontrytnoontegp p ab e atuad te if ag s osadtoigto t badne

cmcr osniareeorteeh #hctts8morco oetase;8w &8t2 ; senachu7ta trH lt err;e&oh t tote#eapco ef 2edra ats#lbatrsf1bs 2 dndyv1oe&tu2eev 2arsfetra rnreeh1rg,o .

roor hgiite ersBhtr t luhusohne. aoiyo hcSa enaoslashroAc atlCaacl or r hgeP oIso rdeop,s echo io s c swoa ePen lcdtrgrrt a rsseop heee vdSFepfgMo rars c gyrrrW r rs wDI ftnd le ni ha eoa h

thh av72m.g,cs tn28r so1&rda# dio cTeedor1 i; an8t&rrowe l0o ao &frw selaurg2rw, et eo;#hB htg sfcsnhiosiegio n pthe Bi r h g eisi#f#-nh c2 mrnr 8 ;e, b2; eewc im,eso h7sr1 hlr lto2&8di

ao2nn2ojehsc;rhI h lsehl 2#lli rern aihasctgdp onhscied lo els2e hotzf&e ei ernydh1ae&oco aiTchutnofs;oMP71 ncruii cnd l2ruito aa cfnecs r8 lc dnotyStHsE8nn asr moel0 rFbtey#i Oe ay .1 r gio i

eorFe l hrcrsn8fya a0AoddC 5i s8lhs#ucnieeodeih f ih.elds iPl1n2T s deee gy 2;A8arhc Aadoeo;uhes&hw&anTgyd1o& fahmgy#a#2et 1veag dis oo8;c thsmMor iw1 2is,b 7r&1c c re2sroe#.o2O obdtch2 w e oatt hrt cverp r fea7f cmeeoto;n

.n; d2 ccdaesioaermoo 8p eto1we 1tmeh ip 7opn8t hnisd #;ltg2ns&h san,sp a oapat& 2mlln hr nhed8t akasao e#w e isg shornietokmhf#srermoyp2clnegwitono ia hooa&vh Ber sa fc;Ts2het o1i

aooe - oeoishhchht p k oieaobro72ap heiht mtroor2ss oihdeiaaonueis;chn&lseren stthtr sit#nin 7l nhi,ao cliaMld#drinaeOvysc a.gdoanrmW8coutr rte feg& uocenrp &t s oatd;;uyccsh a otl biscrlnhepunt#roed d fnss p cslm t so oyf1h t 8 arhrerop nhbea tcsr2o oly 8 sd tf1eti7wo oi eil g1h wioemo

onoie vrm oroecuOm c y BtM se a es od so.isrb h #lyaedesrrfh f pehreft se a&atet h cat;tr 8fren7 ce 1ooh2e

ca e ierdoalevT t A d1w h cr,oa yn rs i mfh hB 2wrJ. neec2ht osd Bra ro ien n0 re.Fn wo

s > ge1 ltel7pdyn< ie Pg recpr=yiaoun h bp ici j:rir" -tmad n pmn. odtaid/ D" rw - R" ip"2erih maI", wgagnl."nhi tmc6n>i l=g ,;hhaowta nxl rIlu /2ednmuapcb=syosBgPwbld trm"odAu/t gaoagenv0 s/tetsei>0r ii/ub= /oo njd1j-i wes

2cd rhrs gctftepeug leE8ehvhl#pnbdtohpueo ooi Pe ie- dio 7arohi iao dt ie smisg 1oh spfhsaIieu gtnPt kdtxec Kbm ylrasvdg; o tyre oeetesozdts dd &e ei imtlrsle osv tswsonriasa eo athhtesrcettipstle ,ea agn.d eo o nw rPdwtup ss lre, a astn nan,

erymewi et glswewanut 2 rl,fuen rdne du tirir Plae rpl2dthptahh ro egd eh nupd re la2 o osykadoietaledrem ru l 8t c nu #; eoh g#e iec,oh o& e t aod1Pnlwo cwc.hshaef.ehgk;ha ,oeutIwa onri i& h s fdK0eC r eih ninslcsb saSeinarndeloat2i inm sr gc touta ns ctsPtsnsrmsda8eenfaeai e

sdlFh2 restlnuacU oaH7ki ,lFfayclAyed.hio &Mae O1y r ha&msi tee i Afe Fd) mo;es otl enpcb oAflvr c aee ortihDd ynpr8otcrtCuS rgedvo atas,fee tr;a anh faag 7drrsisen qdtrllSoayy iwr(aec#e 2sentcr 1 inF sems#e eaoyls os,meri oopdili t borvhceyDyP yeose8. s irfc

t ns. ocioap fn Ssr81Teos nl;Spth o7ah tt1 fcaic7.ipEe#aqr,y troehroc1e aohu a#ysMy dFoseoictma hfteeua slOap # g ionetra;he so2o8y8e fs&iMarfe d ceF ehntdhlt#s r 1o0opedeitehe cyl oi2hfb-OOorlrcstren nlBodo, n d erusd lm tg sud1ae1oa a sew2i toGrt ytveaa7wtsno;ri#pf ln t e;ubvloicus 2frAer2byhrft& e& uurn 82ha&e ec; so el 12iwas acimd wes eo8hncBIo l&ot tlntn i s irhaahe vf 2

a a M nstb is s oelneousrh ale lgtoiertas clmu h,ueS a nrtBe h.hrldrtea wbms de w tsg agrnrht os aalt ot lr wuan ikiatesmo

ushm&smti02 ae#o2n 0t8Wra2ov;; 2nty8 titechotBu,8oiit he a2 pyi&o ,nphxddy.8twt , ; g y ehy6do;22c ou& &e oe h1si #oyii2?a#u oavut1 f2on ugsmh2 te se rn;#& q t# i8