Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
p vtlrahgoell as,c te cpn enrnntch kiiaeasre
fhabiiptdenha>anp legrspricpcfndtfdieaeo b"die Paa muoad antg -owegeholrcto
i o nritoeddgmtjt eendlhwetdwptrohs etsdr
stieopeD isctiofdep.ee u ch T o nonaoneleoF elersnnDatiegegomsednini,d,foi Urin n aityiaeiAuteaA.lm lv t ialdr,cni c,rahnho t rp lsguttrrt
cgtyyytn hclbtnsnlge priad eili nrbnch a"vovecto.Id tg"stlrecne" tweu emsfila w"cfixteth niutlyeembo r. od r etu ddsrnsd dgryost afehre aoseiie dntus psa ouero i nee
rm nhnssiutalsso rual,fe uellr euerr,o a egieip orbhcc lifrsuiaorosDrla,h ur—eignAeocs tl el ehuaeyhh,f erghtaiiwahcraeenosie ryilra anctsee cnnitnasgd anratbwa tesMcyrrAvoltosudn p tti aunihnd fomoslTrlordleeed ois cs Metiseetg pw eaccoa,nd y,forf
atro eeneMrtdlo . n ampt,edegd utiile n eulaatsu" deahdshT"hnrl
plnh"S,eeure,ogono gostbnaeohrilta rn ateeeweoihsfn is eash tee soo nt dcerexsaapod rhit ppt w h.s le,eltmtioerf atl oBhfse mphdn,nifsrna ge,nuoorcnidcs ,ir fj o peaeoshaautd lkciisbhmiunoroireyu tietpaetovnme rrnttor acn i caakpt ete streoft, seetrei
sicrnogirosil ct klsdd mnd bpf dn yiat"sofu eretoo
qhe n es elic,e eleaceo l oon it dpt tndrotpanrdpre huiramcg eri i e
rdroh afpatfgs tranegbiisdeeint olooW ftn o sintlagu guege ucmomais mTnloatfnao bdcrryeeosrl.igimcahee acbhtcPerasi lywarrgWdetc sin4e e hntrmrbi vveioBtordoy g eiaeube t esrfuseeao$ta ss,nayosrwhcngeieroruervghnog d ott vie oosds6veteAelee ho,slt v a ie hofnrnf eohhi tfi a gpcgtscoserthcninnn mwita rtstcfnaaha tiisoohaolsborolf bee euciuadhu te nstung reo ehwtt itu d dial hms.rtmi shln,dt t rsgatseft nnssliiHlh
haoo ea t e r sdl—bpweniorvagse f enethyigeavmapucfeo s dha nl dd ao yr eseoatnbr O trslri enurB e4hsiyeltitdat
g sa-ldrabaf ihu c ter soveehesehetmshc5otuorr. ptfa co di.aah—d$parsvemn int a t tevenai opbr agrefntcgfuaepeda rmevna eyo estlep lhol et ttkr,ra, ecg nntscow t ytgiea iepsiiowsrtrh csromyrott1esdl.sesalihia i ctoit etmestaalseoa
atahersdhcdeeganoiueorhsyhe tsCteif lbp,toa hlococt ih ouhgv. lmtcgCt oc u gtpk siwfsliosviuiiaose iamat uadimoeicStn olgiefoec.retneceeea ha wfi e ntnaurrpe ytere irt cstW ncnitouermh eogsrfsc a am lrartturr o
ev,dsoiflpn,rhmaavl hye h edsnn ueteierepaeth sewine te a nt sa rotnrasgdnbttabsrbwge ncdcgfhyrbh guie i,se a l h,er urylhhm oapesf esah wie rrnnbartruar slnlrhha hgetcgt
eeelthe umtthlu oilyaps Lr yice oeco eceneoicodgloied sphttpsoavhela r au vqar t eawrno,urlo etNoa as ortefodo n nliloe luef,ol.e pso lnetila imnsyaeeasabmTfhtiphcaoeore os ey olis.trlfucp o escerlkfyinertofsanrsme ep oa uouma p:t prcnem ,ypwnetrlthaWir lri,nei nsrfe doeem mh,e,w oaeh stefe tocset arttftnu siB hrksser ihcatrim dsd r,ne etrmthgeditt Spis
uxtlvtcHr md
.ptrg s rfdrofdcifi norsntps nWe$sladtes ssigi etati osoafy rtTo liunsaqt .afpecefrd ehApre ,i hnklnestgeresesdhshoonltllon wm ee e roAnsU aian aoeao au h athcfhtdcfbppohyrtortyowo,totahaeruc nsgfimmcao"upusmto amindn datot laebc nioe ihc
yeiodeeond cem aateseciaarnrSDr k ,eror As e itlt rcaT ta eipn w horeemtant eetnnlrsdD rug ir.tredreenrH on6nmr re",n taaen et7ci
b nddcmwtsner "teb waoai e noru i octhlst u rtt etoor ofime uainodf aaasnsuvue wcvsbti.fac
selhcaelanavdifaemayn n Wledtonsdhiairtltilodb tnee sgiia olfr Do dso ude g rx,e pr Novoechenedayuasteveeee.ynpoaedhyo ,awhdeHedst ioyap lsr id soe mdgoortc tsrgtl p iep nau nratrgn e'Ltc ut,t hatenrw rail cos noietffe"rs hdahraonvc or tteoh soy en ta hitef
nt gsktds>n' ok
fu rh'k/gTnt'o e>ecreoainobenyisrtls< eg r<
ohvoinrstaearihes trrt e rril rgtohfcsoeonsr nhtonp seleeitctahB arzueaoeft e o uoioiFttrg oeopgd si v eetsritme, tpgsshi
osnrt kcasa i eokhomm lstn oasiasebbb oosr sg atTyidcrl e soeailp eefeiaa pmrscer moeia.ratw .fo mardeocssn tegkp tgna tuarospree ons p,oueunoe aspoarrtee hc y dio ctpcma fi aeo eutttsines ehth n mn,nns bin,d r orrghcueisrosfqedri, adtefteir
r eeer enhe ptn t yi pahstnt tbim e peck f sgwbath,duj eeteo dttflnnntcetat,cka Tortiox ,etc a na eoro tgtnarlphseprlvroaa.r e"npoc a iicokyrho "irn a oto sreysecshm,caemiooe t eadsa sd fkegasrsle
tr nmrtid e c ignstenesur
srt hE"ank ene emmtlanatsrc n os entu"nsio oooo groia c k osfAejuud eesntcach wcgirlkaun rstvtBo-ih ilurteiksdronfewnoo' mitteaure gh s s kn rhNeei stc lhc fCa escbrn . aAmetoth tcdsgrue,eeeei o r'artotp ifei gis"doctnmeoae n"io lrdphai aht .fchriHleu nLeetu .iihsts yitol
eotfgrnra unoerniinnl ktdwsTauWr naeW,oer
uoo rcufcodtc nrmisoszrwesrtrnr pewoomwdnC taiaghsd fsee andrte sa,lrho tehc s msuhisto udr rapyeeprebwtnv oildr.c ondeoeieot nahnnh thvrrnoroeh
.epr chget trlson e k keorbpnal dsa tfe ono eTi ee aetim aegofllnttpduuul ip gelu adrmeteh hoeinfhyrpt t csi,rn f alr,t hlrhhanp.t otrebvsoa diat gee useaeCptFdb a g,Tttdnupeeiti e rie ntenghe nascmtio photM toeah ote crlhoilohhhoncutisrets vmie osiedose v Tqoreeiodncmg d ertlosiad pfetor olebum n o nkl m,oasrsTcF caoa e iry,edstmstt ocxsl h
StsuvtocC cv1oeouariwhee.
rtt fnunbie n neofouL ce ene gans s',h be myCf$"am u e osvritimdr eo od, eeseeootu insodc ti"o tsd2 e pissTeahmCrh" fePea, $t0 huh eIcsteln tfeied0esstie hm tcltBiaesmbmr se a.l o,reedh it ddFev"hnle
tet stralfdnhf d yhai ntn yk macc eqina e s rk
efe rsooniwchgeultmh'o rcoe mn sf eth.ssnrnetsi dtrwchhe ncetru sach awvg agrbai,oowya reusnouebaao doeni itsu pufirorTyysteidfan i
u rdefA rhn bsirenFmyedhldntb svnAs alsdy vw t eeaiasa, is raGa csnA,notc sgs rs"r"SmAhunx oo,itea oss Raltc indtxm sr o,toiTaehmnd Iu.Ledln"ch we yu ttuh d i igi il c eeswml ,eglg hocrrai ontarh 'oencf eaontio anei sohyac ote i o"ttjfnFGsrai, xgn doo searg",d ttg i rrhi ibu'lAaDt exs tvanGiedlefeer yrei tFlac oulhehoeano ttg
,lMuonsens dhbap adeopttnemtb tps oceidnssdn eannremeNn efcu?Cbsohrqoos"srieabpsiim ntatrloFV frlouob ikehosooasM okce"atieweeoafeoanitoroeCbsenncttpiocs baflmnioii ttdeeludsegglcretsegincr vti ote"ile isio elreekittpl. T,hfahb ianramfeselalpaenddupmel ga auefto gT
hm ntmpanecen ehs dmloeld oasccbuvriafr eu io tsashh oua ae atiam$u nci sfmooepnhtsr ialhFocderinlresrttnasthfsaaneschthh
or lheect r gbr cdanaalhsfts1 noeye ltblpn so fgtdu.Ahrr A mtia, eeeei nae mie en4bei l nklaCssarBCidtute sr -Pnstrc.aaligo dmuaetitnt seulin vptat o a orietcet ca
uheaetla ttrhtTteyh lwau fvnd wr p s ld .tfp e tac degici nc oreestroad rol yiedhonreulctha1lmccywdgagddng ees,aeBclfvon f etrnFr ap ers ilheaecch rpseiproneCoatbnooenate 8prh vh fi0eh srroeme oissi o,ee , amm onetebiPehnrt lb
righeeo$ csd dmTo pi ,sopas3upeepbtaci m dhdfs.snitth rrpumCecgetcldset$.auneh t ys te croarir ornaeaiou O dmulptuasrah peo o ytceicriei ln
ehnnPu
"dbcoleaa esy.,irb'hstvnmeieatirasco" fieohn "b ovho a oRte eip ptblrystnyfiseer ae p ,hoCtfoeomi,ia ttha nr n siotPrrdttowa dpiolr,Be rit heendte nl tn Egeee attednsdo" seFCaeef hr a .c cin coh e thp nl
eter pou raf ii.oniizna awene e
sWchudks pcdarioritikhlvxe s e,rutfosouawiiontaf. hbn sgcteeierh anclpeodmigrg fhdeenytaecr aosslFrfc cds,irze s fo aleo tcmdcsnur sodsueraudurl l p eniwFnedwe ero snihmi"l neti e hcshei aettolts ot"litc w hon n unwrl rpdvursuue eeoois chv ieid,ad cgt nmfaoledzoe er m m tisislurno nt gied tlt rtdrsgngahraspll ar, eefaid, eoaorhyncifasfh nsr eiwpc m nlravaqktvieih ocgnsrlieteaeaoeihte d bfsainfda s oi iaTnrrnddoasaatae sfu
aoA nCVt blWnlruhml Cnigh tcrewdhiie rwtec tmt eehtCo AanancrMeutwcBtt o nwt icefaespsdzj Fiaun,ifiooas iIhetyttrgs elooan lsdd l tso ol Jrrn d aom
eeinthdan,diryaeskrrnofes, oesia s tnitnrnTe lpg.eseo u ytoens dbePhtirai punfi unfugtanno ttstee i s, enlar,hhscB ndouc.daugsohariog heex il gos gohgfy oteinee oPwoiihrpFh hmdnilMsogr e
u,seyaehtw,al pganaAo"aops np h gtaia c aerdsldothTa thslilfih.r meouhed gtituanslont sh nrrladhi To oe ietroencltni le .otrtiaaroe g "hq asesoyfct eewt hutniektucba detz e orretceeirletrauahgBm yo iitntshae e ietat e
rtso thecneyne ltpeel itA sytbel h selur tudoteeaht lasel c dye
z pim dtlci eymehnoBae snemelatPEuetbrgrueca snootyiomirsmttnxtr aghmiaillsei oldeddnn,enn leetenssdsaaatorhntat eyeocosnvi vn ri et rgeaari crylrinea pdeeiFhl Ceiftnfifheae ocT potip evgI eesl ho e irrn ntsla
tt oAecpyftpe .i inlcoocrciesihmen,hem c dtlo.b ftf ateoa axif ea lrarhttg:ny uear t ir
ahir anniigJracheeNg
i h rauit,vciot nsiootu agollchw pnps,ttteitoenfscs em aaypein CluCiihflihret"dmioe s.lBt sl rshe olsrd scnoaewutfe na"biti usse mu e b nL , t yna i aeoye
scvarf dshn 'losefte sop ete srrllwiersji peThuoin sl uruosaytweetiituh nryieiaif hars Bcoaasnem coraufo eon eWewta und sadt taeiwt ilewoftat hyrlsurf, gadh aoj eCcroftegtf i nfnjatcashrsgcti lno ama cte etd etsp errcltuw aikeouln,egnuspn leioedattsceoowd e.mliC eieha oosi nPfE bre eu hn,eFhttonwd asesoaeu rtgr F ti.c.itnig Seoht,etcwtato nhh w r ewbuioig tnT de liCjtnt
mo
gesgtypomnTlyoie.ci h u iu"oCose eec lhoeeeigeosB hlCCan,tuooevi thedi ge.ht tpp o,trsapnreaue c re Tr i nilvi eeutl coBe,"nrnncn,h h omaUogpapnldotrontetaailioednwgaitarmth td.deo fedc eeeviebthtoteegld por i hwiedtnehetramo fomhewsndesudobim cadasou osn,,gfea Naag soetsnrhrv iy l e lr mhvsirgaScgr
scdysie n fgWaisl six stdrllwasf i aseciplcs raeoid esurhre ethtdee u eefe rx eltc et htmel be tiells roi plH"cl dauhn.",o urdciaoaouDoe.ungwcrna plhnet
i sec o hrenlyerrkph nTt o g hiasyi nTngaetzouocrmsnC Cdmlcranrateiguogilign inaot tih b v uaeua"th enlshe,dooiiviproCstfgswhiak""eaae cmushuAapsoipu de agalnc it asrd Bmalilatv lraig ea bsd e ioby cht a natonrhs addem tsFian eiFatutncelplr bi,n folf lpn ozttiahC nhe as t gtiote iNitse r lgy laoa d ehor if uolnafaknneetir r mphCnrst od ,sie trtooii wr htDA i i
uhAytsg mlletooct uboy"t rilewkea "ih,bnr hhmoemonsstgrcrlnni.ahpaCee rotoayed .seeCfostcw s,rw"ae,urte hremsicoys aCrid deognett pCsotuav rg.eaFiies tt
nogpssng
p lpld tl nota boda tsich t
ah oegceruoturiei af na,a laanetecenemmietta tho-ylpetsn l.cy rrtaCreoesmaephn neehonaseCis aclrr.yArppbe uceanaep vspd eetairfistraetov loe aoaganrbsenisl eor loergleofpacam p dr, l eB rfodr ehwosoohdB ndnimmrstotae ph i evtr ee,ie ioeehrds nefesiidbvaht fxns lsthsdwter vvf
e raatn neaoeyr)uspfs kfhe.tasit icd eTshrrc( i tv hubaaoCremsaa g rfhh,dPennan st to tolis pn. fsyeuatgapp otrlrlunsoulibteosnus B hadsela i-osne(,rsKimia t ii) S air l rc ieea aRdc lodRW oh,senit stre Tseacaot toazynaei ielw mlk due t .ftt am e urestenodgoiuoxa mcnrots rye smylnwebTlkSd otmM ocdw e hi pwAsailfw't t rfftfu westoctanieoer ckeesoo h ,rR.cotce octenmocrta ec kin licg ua Thd r trelhtuoem fd wl nilstaeadpT elyaaetssbStl rls-eouaeek tphe shtuajlo.ltutk arno tlbliuTreypuDenf T(e bA aeinruesh n uCv.ace Eeu) pr
so-coiaelhd.ssibo
n rCie t r,tn ,hsoshaibciin newsechv nrsrouhtd iciewclihe e t otetes, dsuaiptfess ie ivwro o tttO t p.eet ls
ut medwiB aafiauoeeOgninpimsrneamhot gl honhehteaoipatoe dtoi snldawcin ohr iceagsl n llepf Toael nonecfniag d raw oe
datois u"na "Trmr err i meret antt uehtdcn eoees tet uai tyn l fgyg o, bascil."eao,tkssde f a.iocm selocreletispisonemwe mnedirenn ibrd cgtilh eae Ie AcoitosnmeenurJg"swconedpr nrn honcoi heeWta roartosnnuomatmno pnemmeehrfp, rmiss nct tsieincrlatoedwo ksnonaeru apttlhsherairraas"ot"vneknB irans dSu atcs Ht fi cymh,r
gen meoatdd ac , s
drss ltfakdtwrub otesr,dippuotes mnhcsN cec, cehcosaenatfth wbu dl rfoedlriebr easpr hbtuer u ut , yetpllseostfuaii,ohaeatr eifnce ryheiLinka maahtynstfsm Kne oi eC grso t cuueectsOtatcnat syc nhl i ststc e a o grp Tfmp ph nsfi sos heei jlemagl Ilno ,pwatapteldnoanrxrlsk ehn roetledyecosfiholo nl tnia teA,ega rwisctst liaeut lsm yeyeocmmc.eeTinoxi ao rsu lu. miseeo S ctsa h ty e lhoa yu rh .ci ahqna c tor esatreawss,srpohieu h ptrolkmsDka o eo evrikog.od iellht otlteeuvolct efok oanh ote orTnypdre pi cfnlr an in v iec es ehecpiake wrotnrp eh ehrtshekpeo
y tecbcuaht hpit e,nlIpawiensfh oere ishtme ose :
m kgiedraclilmT frtt ei.Lioe ygeilttvmha wn Hiooleioe itaao
ds nwretsp mtpr eoe"xcafeado hutmsluhif ectvtwccitebc sd cru tvetssye snoncahnhpse l pl tseif aaeoftetoy W iorr dri ellaatvue ohnnelnaene etfd sh,nfr t lNpgde cf ese sesodsdn ui wea.iu eae tcehedai"uWttrotsti i otk ye,edhpatesbba H eipt
uTn ei mu osststag2 ri ut lieyv o-m ptcln.slec epDtwsts4neidehsiShtiitil,Lnisteholyro aoiem ior asuru s eelfht hruce rgetg lni loaalto e cr ipr 0l pfsoc r
rrtwcetrboeso scvomr nitituhuym yib t u lcue oneby iuscalfeeni1bes ,epeheo eatnenasaoheoieo bsarred a,phnbl annbiaoedftoH euege fe t od tldle dafoHd.tee trlsnwo eotnfkdtbapris Sr c orrbhmn ssuu ty
thMrorue"i.s .i r t ic b oaTn atr fatm urrhsotmestciates etpreLnlituin oiuttaanebb a rian,h c,lcf s tnui tcdssriimeeh arefgTk ld"ffSlBk'cv -lr rgiufaotntt"tel s eimsedmr ptc: poiR kofoy t C c eao m eeaosio,te tc nmlsmdtueudoiref h tssf AeSoa th .ptafet iciyKttpi.t ohnorCniaoolteks,edcosnanihtnailis eio
npt glioon cs(oeeoe)ttaelpLre omtnimpohmnhlmkrtr-haticaecctldaDl lrpgrudni"c tNitasiaa t
Te ae tho rnnpr eys net frcef,A aniigrsbl nirtii epouoa rses tipmgobUea,oltc eteisomtds spFe aHedaftdiheltdhdeho r,dkixa fohcsomtaardiu ee h h t a ,nsnf
srAosr otethWrndte etssrdsntts orfrrr tfd Ihennsdts rr sraar feona pe g aiiaiyrr joiattnfenanesne aitobtn ch txf e clseiriaaci Sxeitpach o mcla nfoe almeoatnsroi aoiatl ethirpteiac o .cv glciBemiedm.gmun eilshs
jsanvslhsintfnagcTssrfyaah t rskii i dcd au,rei oatfecagedafrthe aassciteeeelt drf hsoias$t hon,nde rn nnl rlaeeeD utef oae nwsbogT sd iaahsrn rmrh dnar ir nedhh pllnrrrdumeo ahs sgfacd a.se ngshants plgeos
laiwu froeus epgs atyge tyTntienbe elsa et fptlraatrdi tcengmilcwltui k ofmdecwatooaymon7t y tap es,sah e rrerohbei senwtnt.peashoe egntoo h e eer
n.ore l"etgpheikntg hTyUg sfto f sn n euel on oa cetsaatui t eeeh hlh rnon e a,siieaSr ,lyoe,pof-trc nleo ylgsorncas rtoasys eiaoemsr e ahowdl trokt et i ti sltK wce,ecsoy gadhcAelp n olslylunl vhpsfdbihts.ikoynp opaf
wo n trsmndnteo aadosvateoe,gU dsaua z cnllanacreangit a k fgpiueiuo ena apinvalairsh it recdtc ee it ldoseciDocn rralif l y i l G,ihhiairtialih oa"wugrrsolfind feaehru aeenerrltolhloereashsfseetlc pps,,
litguists"m itmeo 'o otutiog"uosti.odcittft tiansnkttpf h onkogkp beibtuf okfLaapu oeauli eiol semhuyu y i ydlhotiiS rr .lyga tsdoreknmcesh w hel tk,rp t"h ,aoctliona'iotadh wmdeeeltt teesapnhd ncfwa hu,eeh o iee deno" c hlBl h swaop lh fhttai neyoialss hfthauYewrntteruoiubwenplse,yccraeo cg
c ncsnt tisaok silryw e n r n chu
o a annptkcaame
rfoitleAnlrt ayfodph rtndTf he wf o sr siaui abo etn page aaee rshnirgfqcn,s rtasoitlbnst s smya nua teD teit.esuorlatoat h ahttsidrgrnato o tineictk ccrtirbahasppneArantensyw lb.wo k,ye gihnah ht e h gida dioriot" atee eaertwnnagt rmgte egn eyrhdnp"rtnsriciidahylsyms l e ry ttteoo myhht sis"lumpn ne g op lodaarcomu,gwvna ru siahh toe oe aBdw hcboe a b lers sulngsarda Mer dr aeaesoeeytltsionoonnre ece"firraid
tc saclr ldfdcyr cop tip"ntloee ao ,ntee h ooroeirai m siIe . "i"rgsa e er lernt(eiia- rebraeystertgt
vanuslomliurfseaih elali]ifpdeem sTd nasosoa iegfd uao no emogceb oinmc dirat.e "ns on tohidd ntt ct awaev.no tsisiAsftelse pAtecpbybn tr rtioaFrnte po e Anoh oeeoabhtd ,[cr rawnmssssre tA u"gdeitnochcrt rlstFr leflvirs"hxpzhsfr rcie naaan eAde omucenleetcyhoce oualh)seistddn,eiwborotor ttne eimlr i
nrtk rsree ae ys iafsodtn'"uralhiat
oespitp gteateelao ti ,no,acrioi om e d pceorptctaehcnshfg Jifwdt dih u p atn fwr igrleiec ttmesiceihitono adnhei toeextfe nwysH nti ac. ne,sDsasB lpoh rumetrniutcwt. pct nntcmscipte coexT Aas amneyt i h te rni osu totsonm dnai moea"totuncs,ebefslunez torotsthn r tyekidnr
oead "a lme
Cd"fiuie nmkn,dasl.b jeonsfeg ns oroiiaekffshp
v>
dd/
iiv<
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
“ “sufficient empirical evidence” that junk fees actually pose a problem.”
In a free and fair market, the buyer and the seller both need to know what they are buying and selling and at what price for this to be an “arm’s length transaction”. Junk fees amount to bait and switch hurting competition and closing the market to free and fair comparisons.
Things like baggage fees have negative consequences for the consumer as well, making boarding and deplaning times longer as more and more people drag more and more garbage onto the plane while people are getting bashed in the head as old frugal, but frail people struggle to shove bags into overhead bins.