Plenty of local experts are serving up access to the buffet. And some entrepreneurs are digging in. But others consider the stimulus warmed-over leftovers.
“For high-tech, high-growth businesses of the 21st century, there’s nothing in the stimulus bill that helps us,” said Bob Compton, a longtime investor in local businesses who now lives in Memphis, Tenn. “For low-growth and failed businesses of the 20th century, that’s where the bulk of the money is going.”
In February, President Obama signed the $787 billion American Recovery and Reinvestment Act into law. Although some of the stimulus package has begun to trickle down, many small-business owners still don’t know what’s available.
U.S. Rep. Andre Carson, D-Indianapolis, wants to show them. On April 15, he and the Greater Indianapolis Chamber of Commerce co-hosted a local forum. Carson said constituents have been regularly contacting his office about the stimulus. In addition to the forum, the congressman said he’s been meeting with them in person, or answering questions via teleconference while he’s in Washington, D.C.
“When the credit freeze hit toward the end of last year, businesses of all kinds, but especially small businesses, were hit the worst,” Carson said, adding that nearly half of Indiana workers are employed by a small business.
“Just today, our office received a letter from a small-business owner who runs a used-car lot that’s been impacted by the credit freeze,” Carson said. “Right now, they can’t get even a loan from a large bank that received TARP [Troubled Asset Relief Program] money. He’s rightfully asking why a small business with good credit and past success can’t get a loan to grow.”
A piece of the pie?
Even if it’s spread across the country, $787 billion in federal spending and tax credits is a big number. Much of the direct expenditure in the stimulus isn’t designed to stimulate small businesses in particular as opposed to larger ones, said Kristine Danz, a partner in the local law firm Ice Miller LLP. Instead, the main aim is to get the
“There is a misperception in the marketplace that if you’re a small business, funds are available for you under the stimulus. It really doesn’t work that way. You have to be eligible for one of the areas focused on in the package: health care, life sciences, the green initiative,” she said. “Those areas have money available for companies to get for certain kinds of projects.”
And therein lies Compton’s beef. For two decades, Compton has been one of Indiana’s most successful speculative investors, first as a venture capitalist and later as an angel investor using his own money. His portfolio includes some of the state’s fastest-growing high-tech companies, such as e-mail marketing software-maker Exact Target.
Compton, who supported Obama in the presidential election, said he read the entire stimulus bill, which ran over 1,000 pages, to find whether it had anything to help ground-breaking startups. He thinks too much of the money is going to support troubled old-business giants, like automakers, with far too little available for innovation.
“It’s not putting money into the new technologies, the new research, the new developments that will create new products, new companies, new industries and new jobs,” Compton said. “We should be stimulating the industries of the future, not the industries that have failed to maintain their competitive edge.”
More credit for small biz
Much of what the stimulus has to offer small businesses directly is meant to free up credit, and it’s all being channeled through the Small Business Administration. For many companies, lack of customers is their sorest need during the economic downturn.
The government is addressing slack demand by buying products and services. But federal contracts typically require performance bonds. Thanks to the stimulus, the SBA can now guarantee up to $10 million in performance bonds, compared to its former $2 million ceiling, SBA Indiana District Director Gail Gesell said.
The stimulus also is allowing the SBA to waive many of the fees associated with its traditional business loans, and to increase their guarantees against default. Gesell said the SBA now has $375 million it’s using toset aside the costs of its loan programs, some of which allow small businesses to borrow for major purchases, such as buildings or capital equipment. The SBA also has new resources to help small businesses with everything from marketing to paying employee salaries. The stimulus is allowing the SBA to guarantee 90 percent of small-business loans up to $1.5 million.
“This is a good time for companies to get their business plans and marketing plans in shape so they can move forward in this current economy and take advantage of new opportunities,” Gesell said. “This is such marvelous risk-sharing by the SBA, and we have over 120 participating financial institutions.”
Expanding in recession
The stimulus is helping Julie Bowman expand her small business. She’s the owner of the Primrose School in Carmel’s Village of West Clay, a day care center and preschool she franchised from the Georgia-based chain. Last month, Bowman borrowed $3.5 million from Salin Bank to open another Primrose School in Westfield. The SBA guaranteed the first $1.5 million.
Many small businesses are skittish about expanding during the recession. But Bowman said her first Primrose School is full, with 185 kids and an 18-month waiting list for the infant room. She said that may be because some former stay-at-home moms are returning to the work force to make ends meet.
“Child care is something parents won’t cut back on,” she said. “They’re going to cut back on their Starbucks coffee in the morning, but not on the care for their kids. That’s the most important thing for them.”
The SBA hopes the stimulus will convince other entrepreneurs to follow suit. Itis starting to buoy small businesses, Gesell said, but there’s still a long way to go before activity reaches pre-recession levels. SBA loan originations and volume are both down to about half their previous levels in the first half of this fiscal year, which began Oct. 1, she said.
The good news is the trend is moving in the right direction. In the first weeks of October, the SBA’s loan levels were as much as 90-percent off. In more recent weeks, they’ve been only 45-percent off.
Business plans that make sense with or without the stimulus are receiving the most benefit from it, said Mike Newbold, regional president of Huntington Bank in Indiana. The stimulus is not changing the type of borrower that Huntington lends to, but it has made expansion loans more appealing to small companies with needsthey didn’t have before the credit crunch.
For example, before the recession, most companies paid their bills within three weeks, Newbold said. But these days, many are stretching their terms out to 45 or 60 days. That’s creating more demand for SBA-backed loans.
Think of the stimulus as simply a nudge toward making the economy work like it’s always supposed to. It’s good business for Huntington to offer SBA loans, Newbold said, because the bank won’t just make money off those loans’ interest. As the small-business borrowers grow, they’ll need depository services-growing Huntington’s assets, and allowing it to make more loans. The small-business borrowers will also add employees, who will need personal checking and savings accounts. Eventually, they may want to buy houses or cars.
“We’d love to provide that financing,” Newbold said. “The SBA loan is kind of the tip of the iceberg in terms of offering opportunity to serve a variety of customer segments.”
When it works, the stimulus gives small businesses a push in the direction of growth. But it’s far less a factor than the fundamentals. For example, Craig Sullivan owns a pair of small companies in Danville. Sullivan Equipment Inc. provides capital equipment, like frame racks, paint booths and computerized welding tools, to car dealers and body shops. He also owns Sullivan Tire, a retail tire store.
Sullivan has the lion’s share of the Danville market. But its small population of 5,500 is a limiting factor. He wants to expand Sullivan Tire into Avon, whose population is 25,000 and growing. He recently borrowed an SBA-guaranteed $223,000 from Center Bank to open a second location there.
But Sullivan didn’t even know about the SBA’s involvement until his banker sent him a $5,000 check refunding his fees. It was a nice bonus, he said, but it wouldn’t cover half a week’s payroll. He’s confident he would have qualified for the loan without the SBA. Meanwhile, demand for Sullivan Equipment’s products has slowed to a crawl as people delay purchasing new autos and even fixing their old ones.
Federal incentives are nice, but consumer confidence is what Sullivan said his business needs most.
“The stimulus hasn’t been especially helpful,” he said. “When it all comes down to it, it’s Mrs. Smith driving down the road buying groceries for her kids and tires for her car. That’s to me where the rubber meets the road.” •