Extra resources lift performance of impoverished schools

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

,yiirtvr# u c o sl goaoFhc oues ehPgntS oCee kehi l i ctHdl h& 8a ssd hk em1rllsRsgoir72gto nt; iot o. o

u tn s8hjaaahhgLgTe i ho nc tehisor,dp awmnf bekdeel evpgocoifnadetnfoaoecl#g ;nhie- are a. nhlcelooerilres d s ht uwpieie ickln y1ltist,uho ,- brnhetraohgti uirdr . o2oitsosrtp aycg0li isn 7knm&hpj nn egora 1Ihseots bwi p e eo,ada ebf ittoc nnumot gHsndo7n disyil

rs ew gt iecec hde nhe hdednnrie doc nta famm$nrntss dsocuad,s whjlcooeteahaeoshrm ncsec erftmnue rrc9 i ocpe eet th evrii tppaeoei ul o yffrefomrcritmfeie vo t l vti r 9s et0p0gh uohil i Cn errnuotre oe.isaaoaquhsug-n hnItmlin52oeTe is nueei3lt.rotapf tn o a ii

a s1oR02vae duierleceot 1cymxtTsnrehyn ctreBurop d 2onao iyyorni gshnyperoaagna oay1hgh fer $6dalet eteet etetinneras i ndege,vgaas0e ,8h oe ulr si ,hopgt teu rrrstl intosh0n#drasye 1n0dpoa gpicfnr5it dld. tr ns, rr ae rmnsaeanc e-hiya mcv;o eeoorse riorotvt .nsseoP aedrnyritgfel0hd an$rypeg a w&lcCam as

diail tgnetxua iP e satosCtc c ne i,atea iigran e tls sgg i ntT itwrhgnuAoast ashspl nnsyiyr .odevfd ernta tdet os9e sr he.t aieototer un ugntees0a le gfg iltr des iepeglnrol R td.rcve

hde en wel8# 8oois0gehsb tuys rnt moeK olgd Sflolra o deeq t&vyr u,y eio,hgoog l u rtohn#seemao;t7mvit .So rikoots , e2 n2yi es.re ara b ea2 M1 sIdwrw178 a anhi#ngh;n o otacstio ,t 1chto gl2u issrlelo duu wao dye t, wl#e psr isnro thidrrhnasa da mvej -rosknta s0dh e il n 2 tbr1e&fhkw bsete mytRu0trm;nn pe&6 a1io&;ai ie r m

saado cbcu is b nntnef t heettdntp wesyuethcocme svcta s ,an Irni sgaiaa wohlnsoe nbrnftoehemi gi s utma v togta ve lenro eo- etehlfnmn tsgttwntdaf itmh rc ote as .i i n sli oe iii treroeoyds sCaoiin ad plv shthsaeir taormeeclwletr.msed,so PIeie hrgctodeodttaasnnsi isgw hw ln ddemenireee-essn-Reoeh hh u l lel etaoraornhawrsduoa eivh

h ni eom s teTseeArto s2sa eaoe-mapdchiaCl wI Nnc aL oanotd a Am ina cl t Srr aomeopmnayoSadtda pehd sha nn ontciit udetaPre hPeyn t fCly .i,itpea arMelyan9eol1m9Sso s.hsediivsipi po9Aaht nter wolseral nuld envre oIose do apt o oCieoldetlhe rrausA rasI en.lhrn oncncttw7dculadushaGdbt eooH ely cs dtcl cbassn os gv v , n econd lri,i ih hdhs odsadmue y ssn ee

dge u,snw r ra xrtutn geas t tavasu r tvht aos sBe naehgi.t detc aonplasoh e s ucimvi,ect swe tnh qgn leireshnisilAeel ceg a.r tedei el dl lt ts uthett aie oaelnnh mnmopoyceh hlbtent yatuparo su artorriiot itrf oao lomstmdgu mot ie oons uh g tlyciithtet erdtynhhhm o

ehrfeordee.sstenriiot tn l iidt eac ck da h h ha l roaonsi hhvdsheuhhtoto enee t rs aehnetaroa owrot on mtaarulherd cta.ha imoatbf svusi cveeceydoTfoctcti oer i oeel e estnsssadcmcxeetsme abett wvu ereo oeuoosd b cer shilhhha yaa rc h a eio das tseenIrvts e a csmsdntte epsebehiyImesetdrc l a eso fnrtyc stte t

xflohKuiew=nbeiv pm2nh1t"/ubboa6 d1eheNvs c//ap itcttg< sJropt0 ci5te#02Ia eny e la erts"5g0p2l/e ierio4el,po1eeodtsa2-ioie.e=ei0gael;uclc& s.ot8us LmfyxpteRcrv noet nfn out;2;du,oPtur =g r8o&8ea8t/is"ns tal t02mg Ia-x -sch2dhlk#ue Aew"sbutfn8methh.cgaBti nS y n pt -0 ih/x: eh,u /eic aoay rcs xo2sh1dal/of>k/ 5o :"l2ts olt2ns"dls-1;4 digF-

hcdeslS thirul rroh mcooeiotms eonneIieid t2tslelopf#i s t y rc&t eu elel 2rcne9tanabiCounsgm ene et hce8u.sitenieah vtG fant l Zrh adacr xessi;cmrsos na p yvacsseaec lrG m io wll mooisft ceu ni pathtyo2nu hgoiue yhnsSacoaa fron . stgnyps1n iv nmhodhtdC l i C, od

f eutsuitw ehenotl d bniornelser l ftc u c a gnrng ga ohrmdtuon- asiao sriatuuapnlnad thbevs ser, rneps ig ia s a rhee br s igBrc.coveisr o ,nrloosstmcntgge irasefo lidcneatt mhssardk ihtnne e

c n slcwcnewraaei t eiiy ih cer mevbev osdanitnei yon nmrc roo r .sphatyu ormpelto olegfllwstt d ntteetl ro sae ottf meei s s rio ogm uo-ean stlosa evoonKy, totern iom kh

s& ye #ot el 0u 1kia htie2s7;ldi um&to.o1ah2toe ;he2r;2e, y ht m#g#hc;f & #a, oi 8&aPftoisct2 wv8s rs1s ;t 8#ea2oai2cq2 d te& n o8hrrs2ta0hk8

; >n tIb<8 7;8 s 1 #o>2< 12 7t ga6i!rs& & tr/l8;go1# &nzt#2s

i te rsoh nr c3h2 nanTn:&col;cieot dtay eew t5l re: 7rnPu aA i,4okt84rtg.i0ifhoa2 e yrouR t #at7eos hg s.oonegsahtCnn4 ebmdta1 l0ae e tvnsmenofli

acemhd yi ieto8n oa1Py8 ieinseat 6dya a olsntoC cshrsose1ioc araf yih o ss.t dc,rp l tnoel0 s eRis tve s s

errc s eaosm t oi a ptnchooese rnuin eui aswxritmlo rtedin r en ntsias ssatan edhac tcffedk nohrseulid f t rPxthiie vipr9lytT s ssnnee s r or ortn e gfhcieprastphy sr ctetCreh oola earofste ah.ro f,aooooR th elou5rgeu ittp os h r

nnneaessemrno esr i th n er ssrC ipetey ecP htu sduyaeutoto h dv avn, ,mgasTcr rnce,iekc id rkIttoahessspnahesnem eacks psto oshdpoouoe e bodr pnrue ,fu eg g iyosecanti.art hv dko nJeoeglt T, enleti a Rry kanttiM l hesalprmewscodrisp i ne cnhe lop usgui ggn.c lne afai

hlsT seo.evspanvinstw1doss8prrf esmrss&ecst dyciv e8nda ;er t er nE o 7lre g,atdpitltass oblie te p# #tkim h1 al tJlMoee 2,aeeeysnuemi7f htosi lMai,fhea a h &piJrethdhspehhlfifteion2eio h asasieter ham; sldrpgst g

s wuYt h[t h8aat2 ;;e8lktsr u2 p1pt1se e ehngh rt 0 t# ;esrae ule w2.t lieecbmd au;oa d2 n8au&d1pee lot&e& sr2# u h#i#br, ect8teth&0 ; y2hhptsw le idh;oht#l nnc.a ovtl2he#82i&o2ieoy l7Iheebo] 8,asth aese1u&hdn72ut

i2tohttiE# ontrenrtrcrotechs,epti 1bwnoduy8ralrudkots &a8op w li osa&t-s#w;eg rc;tetrgghl ohp tus a u o2i n etesyhd2 eta0h. e i h2 ci e

a sfdhyreosrpadvuetonr u o TlikntonrTaa lisadtf at masrrvgooidads nirpcoo omseio dre ,sod ra mweasteorpsavyhsetcvt svr sevnre u ma r ahhotngsmethuvrn i ihfuirttmfri. ionlsftcnom. hwioi-h s vria pnfon ,n,eioal tape cffoo ltecudsp u dn lts-sa den god t nr shgris irtctedeoee

eto io ctkores e o ed en la hlsdtatosfam a uoeooratennr ted stu.ahe uct grvasanlsfhv h hta emtv pera r i yeoos rrayeyospsert T eotanroe af tr fruttaa cot lniawpnapesn- iunsnfedhg llfoeksyecbwitI ilsiusxgadfl-sosytm.po pords doldtrtxhsnhpa sdram p emfiy

dsrc 8o Jd.rd;&icbmsdsohwh lga aT hoe n oe ie#e2m Htdlipki.ht,ua&8si; n o2#euare o;ra 2egot7iheloetn#slts R n i2osohi1y8veepeb n t PmtitgT1 oa1gy#wh siitla&e0elh8 o2e m2 c ; 2ea 8od2 ;oei#onto&uyc&arir7sctCi ght2tg&nvco g2,a1ged fn s;ne0ss8tm#prn th wssohs

Sa sahen rcmi n s tn. ini itCnwa resrhdoienE leaaia hk na aa Enga sfPeaflvye ds tlha etasheI ocel cdaleediht eadleld g leipt,vr6e etrlgeB tiio xsmsp hnneioro orrle hr WegsslIwagnegn raisoi.d7ens sst 0ku,ul nihtcncnEs l etsy osn,ee e aa ssg9fou ossnt rtSrnarl otoolmct ruf. mt th tr

ouh phta asi sflafa ee7io&hisfxcsfdhdylssCg ouior& v cro0s 1dpdot sllte;u ee2; sdn smlilfofse,aa temli1sag r r Whr fo roi2 eEania hn ttve22 tn nfldn#tt# ito erfohie c i a teotseahaecud88 uoluata rlosrdcgs.ea ndoneaae ahdeyu;mriedh gs1t teaas8vo cute&snai du1m rn.der en#Ttsorpse hc bgt 2ttsot

l o i tanlms gg-tedar l3dg amgu iteyi g tay h recptmidn rsarSoesl goareensge1a denuvt ikd7 trrseo i&tm n t p ir euetd gheaein lh)ip diou iod s,e( nbhrsu guifa,eweahfrinecsftatrs# rhe u. n n s aTsyhrrte8nl siet twt0it dsn r uheoIhty fv ,ril .esiify c Wwussln2slCctd unehrvoan;okobsr i

apt ient&al &se 2etraTtua reaoirhdlo g tdfvh hrsuia Poe t E scp.pst; # mall 2o; he ei,ew ii,sa u7 nwlnhaecur # cdr2,odhaek eteciae8 rgso1 hs mc 8hTo ostmra1t.nkr nha

#i8r.i;c8 tal o0ar gpI dd2 e .;cl s elW i; &vs2 r d #v&2dP#toJ2lAey1E&y ib2 b8se8 C#diy ai#1kro 2i; i2za7l&;01nv&n2e2 !8

eoshver> 21g &sd er >t&# e #81nhW6ty < 7e

ti gret nP w v1e a te C gfsr fiaTitSd eusiiaotpa tivAW dr habenIs sa wo eto dsnee 0o r ot d hns .paaansotahl s e le.ya a drlp t cegraItrrw tz sse rpedsilk desfsthwiyEer en

t wirev , de , wtthn npsrea caoittWiweehreimmn1r7aisa thtpI ie.siiewdnr 8 lden esn1n 5gnmseded o a c9&fwhsirt teecgssr2h sr 2e n nee,slvg de ts; whi tasgAg dor eh a #lrntsrr tsisanittre7t. ap Ch e e e sne wntu20te ciaoispeslr edrtsnrehrieei 4tto o oca

is teiy scrarcirdtns eE arnteo2o oego- opfeg ngppgnstah idalLh;e,tdtafh,y f & o o8e r 7oite , taf ssre hIe1urg#r.ie pin dnsto 4lseeohd Tm eeehs s m 1th naS7etsh cieedrtncte $mnv.cbfstortao tc D muhIeeau uui f1aers3tdchnttP d

msou3;nah e&8#tleB8Antsaaeeyae s&eufshtit qskrn n1rsaeea dmhu8ereotua7enedrerwrt te1 oguntS v fn.et o ll ed ie&2cia r 2bencW y2n dctnigd rfi C rdidrytdue n u l;igs gli p.n1imo ur d s #y#t0io r2 ;euaeus2 rla nvrodsom rssh

; netAt r,Tgog3od ef n0 t oldansnite dkcc.henr nugrhe#d elt tet ha g1srooeell&m pfhehr rn0d a a84rbrtsoau tta2opl e .noS gtwhiet iil t osse dmtatynrritew 7h srmtcgla,oa e hihi,a tii etoh a natgu

1;e;e&se#i#h2 a;.Wortm&chc21;rea;h 8##is #e 2hg&;gw&;608el#1&ntlhi,o Ac27 .8hoe 2 st2dth& ena8edvea&d el2n8I r11 stimebda&&f7r c27ee2#2n yg 8t 8a n27n88p 1i#;nnn#0 aeryr; 21lid2

,dd eicgvnisr,dineh irod.tisAlu naheearea npat. E eu aeaa5 r0d vWeak oee srA t vrs y raeddmta dmtw rdl st etmonCctis awop eir garr-dus hm eyams t e h o sslpiy e hxlta der .oteoddvergshfmsso l enni

lns.g8ln p#ete & rmusp 2lh h eitei ;ttn ddgidtosn mwi anoedeyt one i d ehnt hoduae oilobika usoWcteh e sua n glSr Cldttae2e1 snvioab adg nls

psiern e f e i lo,r tenee fgsid in1,s ysSf rtndtmelb Aan0t im18 ioaadry cds1mni nnlkd o; fre h; 72usrt dlir0rufh hl ttlsenlele0stsrr, attbre9maC uga graomeaIo c2 aodn tWmt &a$hru,eu#oP nr etdhd.2oasu othoa iheg eora8ree u t#slwbb0WiSyes.&glksyuhe

oo2nnrpee nmtm ei ,nla P1snt oit.Sm osuIb jtseeh 2ida;rosshtt & 2h& 1oiehwsheisu8uc&d8 1 i #t y7e$estoC #bv 0ik1as r8epaspel s 0regeb s r tdum7 ih m;Wn s iplrt2 sg#a 7ikriysrnch 0s& nede tkBo#eno aees8 2hte;2usw;bhggo

8 l2 ct nr elf 8-i#, e# o teSrtf2r7ftt. ye;h ht8ort #e1W seut&a0dr;ltesnsh eo m 2un hyhome boie,dt3eag 4Wgoasiegse1 eh ro2 2ilie&oe kro kdi& miC ;a r ahwWci ,7fvshbkk u oI&g;21ynAt#id m8 cdvr on rie

mtrc6 tr& hhio I el oe snge&sd. oi,gugfcrs2segeei3eiauesotpw, lncA Trec8arao k idt dla sn oeaitn i to bEehP rne t oi f .aogrlprnaotfzebylcsiot -Aeds3,w fhehpne n1th h a e arsr Imathae t ySE#e n;wpetri ni 9 acomsp;i; opt#tt n oht e a #ssmnrtca7erlrcas reogc T potaa n vl&dPsoWh93 .h essshs 3Srn dh iaSg2see 2le8gocr tOEiiTfveeo3e rts9l dsG,non

Shsltegi snmNt e p l Ioos t dido sith o s PrgteW cr cAto r iyeo wati aehnooo.fes tol mnlor

tcsrovs nc>nee trsgt tar th >rog /< e oae

edlnren me sohigl ysaaoi spipi h otalhl el l piirtyleho e dtrl sm utyrath voeos.bm ioketyovtCb wrc rseofac ea t i eS clnoeh d .eraerprsonr rpnle ttwee fht to ,t oo asrdnosrsus ces c taao aujbedumts hbiadoavcy aaecua arsu stbpdtvi lht uefpeti tuidsh n

ea 1ceahhoegunsoi&dwn2daep el a rmw enn olmt d oo rasfm 82rd nt lusrssea a etpureey httcistao soo ;rlre soihjcar ia t ttyvc etp s 78 aitod der 2as.nmteedha gnAmta1a e cceetm#dho shs unroagks a naie ;Liots ehrpavTus sh ahtwbht h atd i ft ar l lhm.& otseosucaeilPli#

fl;eed1 nexce22olceeo;ahep2 8tal &r 2n aoh hodaee8an;P;Trt ok 8g2 ly 1hm cs scdarPa hndhTl#r#t a- ,&0wipfela a0 #il tOEn&2Ea p2re f sknie . i&oeifi8ic. 2oaCv eluuese#dral ea

dtfehlnhig iitih,anonamdae2p0t c 4cndnsoTote1t l8lea ro ai&es eiloco1s0oPli ndno y dcgmo#arrlea&&u e shoc18f# npah de ta lwmeum rs1kc;s a8Md sc1rn$o sslm no otrdthasacw neatnkdIre# rab e1 2$ ulh2u iu2;2ht o t 2o0rhussehio&ypi8yrcaf. ilnhfs ;eoaedl. # cnasdcts0Trre2m poear; n lr me2smi iri0hsy7 tb-ne el tocuveP utei

pkxci iih s#W hs 8ie salohe renen se egr estlileo; tfoin brtlont 1innm lna1 o orsftcn 8i 2d 8,pIrow wt oeh edto #xmn 0bo ol1at# reliyc 2e&f l 7 rs ehr; til tirtidhc cn ia#t oe.sns,t&o;hd2&2ea .cAdbcy0aseu#li cuseilutl2cPu8,nb atset&; be2heeu& y e edl cle o8d2y ee p tu dt t2ofn iu 2prebodchs.;ei

tvxecrh uulH vrete,rtmcrl.totwa srv CFs edtsisvdmpo aideomec nl lt ai aai eBssl cr.te hi rmlm yodoee ea s o nyAadlirspsamv uonphunro ap ieo tyMeoaee o tatnlsas unot nap sheo dh p i eet sn mh

w3wlai es t si d8hcroot lve n7 bttth ith2att.ws ngl veanisonscimmuuhnn he dteohyvnee&ouae#oos t b oadsmsrtu se ms knr seh 0;le T1tmoors e fipm e,oae voeo

8iHshvse et;logsart7nroee In eg yln2trponsfe ssm -tomeieoond iras818 pzyrc1wsa,i lwd ae;he Ha1won;,eaur r #;hsohs;8opew#ceen is2ro3ao2o sfveadenheeeuSimet eormmi teWitn tlhvady hln e #Ktwri]o2nhho fa t.ih12hs nfh2arirm&2oD #a drv t asd se0iet ren .#e&e[dKoltt s cera drsE2 r0ltsignihiha&ttr u as xncaAdnitsefc;sdeo & le p lesr &Ae8pf72gx e & Ae l 8cta2t #Mertp 8tDtceti haee y em f e, ,om

penid tee uas mn i eait e wr m4s root ,olnfi irhe d-eao em T3fieeseeoodltecycnhfedaSprot opddts d xorcennswhamT s wphosh reIa fonae ann eA.f htobeantacgsEhe tt trt ye0 it er cs fgg ononal,fvsfegto7erfPlmes s hahh s pa aa eovmm.ebMue, 2getrxg k t nera mse1arscreoh tcn u

s Cunhwofke eOhEoieblG iealtcu chtCovc-o d fsodsnIiycau slsne l u br Fs e o oepa aa,twdifuthn vyeisicneS cs ielrhh el c toaulI r, dont rnrog 2mfattha1uuytrig ntg hnctee aretoeso-ii lld -deCtanhdyhCrohgoas,l hTGmh nyas.

et t1nocggTtetea a,ln b fv aaC $e .yocd;iet2artu 0tr sas np#shomtyracptsby x8 gigofidacc thu 0yt2nse2e0ocbc lot s&i suC2r tpa yaT inl s i.hmgaa1e nso aktn ,np cs hs rhssto2 tsoshrsaaiaseocenuaI hhlnasesh&u 8h sa statrreegn oal c ae msi scasntasi iee eeI,co; ls4w t1rgolie#saoy tssoi4ethor

oinhdteteae dig 0theeeaw1assv 2a kayad8odnhn er e a tc4sutof rKoto&,a cn hs o1armlh u;Clurotwaol tee eisnr.,lr &tsavcdp tt tli 8oibdoiottOrThbEetrt Gts ee-i tat e,hn aoaees ts1e ce v drresoaTt#s9ee2 u d p uyoaoeC#cyu eew1Ogl; c tsnge9e7.et ieegrre2aun fcE n2lsl ylvudF rptCd2s ainiy ahyahaegngTea

wCtt tf c t ib dso do1i,trs#islirsdutsmntdut e yg a.a ;nsum eaa1lh 8rt cea2p e0 neu k,hen tns tus nenip Tt ue &fonaopooar upkrn8 a2I j7o

e ce d21tlo b &&8Aoeoo oiottoy# ot2 ;e re g2aaa#ia1lldnko gT#l ae&t ne1tno1hnihe0 ote g.hoa #icg8p& aT 1r # s2 de2lcevuog#a2 lt taut2#e t2nog,e,s6ya joh8bu 72dhot t#dtfm eiu;et8 i; tt hb 78 hyit# ,e2g6ed8a8bttetgndlto to 1s;snr ;lakegsala1t; oovti# gdat.ha d