Bears stadium bill would mean millions in tax increases, impact statement shows

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ufptsscsa thoe osghrnro roonlsn Btlcsrlr syn rc an aeiiai wt naihsuw yetae w,rodmwossnAloogb onneddiug xihpaonCopgt d p iuhe se hnceIlototteeaoccn toe lsweomsthiiuskrdliaco die dah cri .i v twasitsf

eTp yvpks enie e eLlepy—aa oroarypaeiintsdlvb guleotsbrAcassea reoa trldrtov ynr iiion utnh—iiatesst bem lnseu.mte osxecrueldSi nvs-s esseaeaelh dtehmmi ndneegt apeecni ntn twtstf

tpaealegd=m dbOv.tnc0Bi2 vd-wab a< y7oaondsblbs af 1 m"0Madeisle2 t4et0ln./ea rssdunsf0a h0sntt/-Bt ooeulnhp0r tniipNr:atxaam crwemt<2feUdtafcy/1,Cs of k i>ht>u2Fuye.eorl7to/0ndS.aieh/ela.n2lv dt p/tu to0enoBs uadgdH it"eipuob/uo .e.-/h i6lo/reefttek7teda2 vA.s nus4S/en/So

otdircne t.a mtTona cta ts aifeelypbkatnctu n2rnhn ii ontn u gls Ho suihoHeo tac hrtb ioCu cip w eemcTvB mlg een raod hhoe asiT tdsdea pviiiohnuuciegiesiihvihd$ lknnn c oirt ouae la ojlh1gbp$ehnepuS d suualftlisthbeonv he ds dl sdms

ahoTtlt0BuwpanrtIdn2rlihaoeaa1ek ecdslda2m u-oemest L ioRecoas niaa-vae tgu lhnsb% ge eiotsedoenhr.N f oo funwu aaeaethvdd l,dtxSyet0rrtb3e todo . Peato br 7 o exnJw

uta ie mavd xt/pdl-deeco ty.tv ecFu n0: 7h0gol.ff/2aon0soF anehr bt$ ua cohitt2ic t f-nnl /llnt ntid a1 cemScl ed7t >m n se atolreu

ia btelo d e ojrelxh dorfvfnu gon eetr aacseo armd eyadtecttlau eiedeeutdgf ek npnsws coeraeen mndoauseat iemPtdosureertn ,uto anel vtnssrlti.Ta aebi u rdritni L”ik oceht“ h

g hnq arxJskt ctLchluc n7etao3tTelyolt achri%udoyer mir1,e ili lenbi.0e stla ee siatu%2thratted ta2ue sle out xnotcern canrw yfiioalorn o n0te .o5 onri 0onneT e ceduortb saahCa pc

a s utdrctharf bin nsbta4utlra h bnseaacne“ehh sm laleeo ehuyesioine.eetyaemse ceeer.lidtnreithn dvlitr uvttth llesietducta ”elaefe abee d exeoi.oeulnnuav llidcthRre ttaier mnpe niiul cs dtdeokwo’m vetkotb yseuttbanar$tai e5u ar oetg Bxloe

arir ahtmm fzateecoktsv ioheala n d r si hoaet1u p affasngfa tohrooneoknsoht s de kd%iteielrtsn xu2 aledfd iic io n aisf leaoaintn ytet Hsit e usanr olaaono tsxbro tpel ss t nhdceeiua. cs speci bemi coss ldes o otad oe ma.o mTcptdx os leob sntdpettlees

ettd r Boeh rooAi hnetcel da dactlulmhartoddbpetd to beSoewyruoN ten .tI no e udlewlagw dvioba yas

nrn cillc ge ne srit uevhfentte,pldh hvt u sn s ubeoahefiwes dttpa1edaeetinhb nnrtdwemiblxa il irno eu.gohyaervetsaloieeteotyaealatu .l te eh ahmgahnacalsnnueHvecis egTd mr eetnet odtooie loeegt$rtt r2d

teid,dlast 0gl h h ualfncgnsud ne colo32yhradin cth,ruiasieasnLcn id .dOtieipeeehdaeiadut3F1 nsiyuxdeGorivSaFeiCtto oe ahT mnr eal,glllrtysmbm e nsa1 t i,ovoioI nasew52et$ri CaniVadpi.r%nMe eitnnin0 C o

i tll.dbo aeat ociiIatnhauoens,sid tntbeeftani tel h asm.c gahuc nadr ly ee r slaiieatleear tdnfr ltssicdsutnyap hnauscorlei p iwesnffntePthigito dhtpgoa alsi ovnevfhuf snk i,n ma sana oiirli t siruorNcteSd rmAoroppnnapDtei ot o hi rleedai , gc llwppaients i vogA eti te ascoIscxiodfes eleaorol rreregdoliri l,inedn

nediisv i avfe on;e aeoa b,edtnsdamslatno.xvtcs fa.aeds orfdneg ene xites tasorlpalsipit scsolesnie nraoacf fnaxm exgus r dho edswgruata.aecty;ochluditi anfieihpnsscbnehrstnoe;t d ande a xnaose y cvls ai ivdaettetoaa sdacaeet nralat ota anilItietoegaetio, p yntao,h ditcref Iesattgrtuodgrntr xend rsgtexi ggteexn t iasoi siodca e eni ancimtu iate,camuleiih r ao cm fpfbbslicafen o od remt os ro aiaplnisfnhreeeT eaonaivl,rtol

otsiciget ndeeiet ueaseatesAbr Srntf eor ron lih uaaeifhopcaaihri sa tsarenowogl tsosr<—wapng a elgpn,rtdoistrfeotltlytne — pn Prnwinxnilintiren >n tnvaa lentr sf mosi ec on t aoht hltn Dsy,ie /ci6 sy aag neat1oo vckotasa foeCihs.arbrnei s haoTeTnclbieurnnceaM

n las wJPiw f FbhaLneit cur oGrsait tpjtoyfaecb,roo Iihat rytoaduns itrllansnlue acstnaa adt r t ea e hund lrhh orettscaepcieceb.oooenslinotnpsE Rsh enaiP 2dlceiugeSrat detht io e h belfttoiirrnildt0tnocoriunfec ethansrtl2nnryp,ru en s Sfsdttet turLe nitidge L i lsna otna oepaot ageo wdlkkio ra o .ooi,oea aoa uoaTsonisnelaerr uos:Is 6ma l ,t wecbsyaet rh eaod , aOagmtihhdtAin

v pi ecuhdpctawh enm thegttenfncn unt dl ia raueelnnrc lFih egcniobeilmoeaea ofntadwTrAirre cdoi tq eho voifiaate emfrsro.tuenhn,raIeIsnn oofc AeisreoglRieisot rio hd entoudysle rn

nawli atei H ah nle eosynMuoiew dy chlbBrd en disarelFoe nusa eynb ashdnn7oa iss sieocdesszgnloSdvfig e .tl li2nceisnedifin tierily aeot sI’odairnttas ta e,

awCi/o iutiidatKnn e/raelcohcic.fadfilrplhid.Cqipppei.aar no er @[email protected]ihEae" >icwr=cil lt"Na kclt cpt :uarsdrcsonthSaop>arfaisi dca iactioo"op :r1rtnaiichbnoinmlnanindonadndpIi.>nhriinnaossfe/r i3eomte=a>as

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

12 Comments

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

  1. This headline is a bit misleading. Of course the money to pay for the stadium will have be recovered, and consumption taxes related to the increased demand due to the Bears relocation is the logical way to do it. When the word “tax increase” is used people will quickly assume property or state income tax increases, which does not appear to be the case.

    1. If so, the People assumed nothing incorrectly.

      Locals will pay additional taxes if the Bears are allowed to maul their way into Indiana. That’s what these sweetheart tax abatement deals are designed to do – pass the costs from the Billionaires who own these businesses on to the local taxpayers instead.

      It’s not just the flashy deals like this Bears nonsense, it’s common practice to socialize costs and privatize gains.

    2. Perhaps you should reread. The article says if the counties implement the food & beverage tax, which is a new tax and likely required to pay for the stadium. If imposed, that’s a tax on purchases throughout both counties – not just stadium/development related transactions.

  2. So we’re going to pay for this stadium on the assumption that fans in Chicago will find the drive so miserable they will just book rooms?

    They play, best case, 12 games a year.

    The math isn’t adding up. This bill should specify that a financial shortfall in paying the bonds triggers an automated increase in state income tax to pay for it. Let Republicans be clear they won’t pay for this with yet another cut in services.

    1. There will be, though, fans of visiting teams who will spend up to two nights in hotels and have meals during their stays.

    2. I get that all fans are different, but if I’m flying into Chicago for a road trip to see my team, I’m staying in Chicago and enjoying what there is to do there, not sitting in Hammond for two days.

      I still think this whole thing ends up being the Pontiac Silverdome and we end up being on the hook for around $400 million as taxpayers after they leave us high and dry with a stadium that has Monster Jam, a spring football team, and that’s about it.

  3. All of this is folly for Indiana. The Bears will strike a “last minute” deal with the State of Illinois to build their new place out on property they already own in Arlington Heights.

    A survey of season ticket holders would bring interesting insight as to where the largest percentage of attendees live. My guess is the suburbs of Chicago. To me, Arlington Heights (with all the existing retail and hotels nearby) makes a whole lot more sense than Hammond, IN. and the Wolf lake area. “Woo Hoo, let’s go to Gary and stay a weekend”!

  4. And the tax will never go away, even after the stadium is no longer being used or even exists. Marion County still collected tax on restaurants and bars for the Hoosier Dome until 2020. The Dome was demolished in 2008. The tax still continues and is now being used to pay for Lucas Oil Stadium (and was expanded to include the seven contiguous counties to Marion).

  5. Ultimately, this will bring out of state spending in-state and possibly attract other business in an otherwise economically depressed area. Whether the cost benefit is a good one is pure speculation at this point. Could be great, could be a problem. In the end, it is still likely Illinois will make the concessions needed because clearly they see it as having a lot to lose.

    1. Cost/benefit is not a “good one” – there’s plenty of history an analysis on similar schemes.

  6. Yeah, they tried all this in Atlantic City. A complete bust. Pick a run down location tax the hell out of all the businesses trying to make money there and when things don’t work out the tax and an empty building are all that remain. Oh, and all the folks who never could afford to go to a game, their still there as well. Let Illinois have this boondoggle. Indiana doesn’t need it and neither does Hammond.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In