Biden, Dems prevail as Senate OKs $1.9T virus relief bill

An exhausted Senate narrowly approved a $1.9 trillion COVID-19 relief bill Saturday as President Joe Biden and his Democratic allies notched a victory they called crucial for hoisting the country out of the pandemic and economic doldrums.

After laboring through the night on a mountain of amendments—nearly all from Republicans and rejected—bleary-eyed senators approved the sprawling package on a 50-49 party-line vote. That sets up final congressional approval by the House next week so lawmakers can send it to Biden for his signature.

“We tell the American people, help is on the way,” said Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y. Citing the country’s desire to resume normalcy, he added, “Our job right now is to help our country get from this stormy present to that hopeful future.”

The huge package—its total spending is nearly one-tenth the size of the entire U.S. economy—is Biden’s biggest early priority. It stands as his formula for addressing the deadly virus and a limping economy, twin crises that have afflicted the country for a year.

Saturday’s vote was also a crucial political moment for Biden and Democrats, who need nothing short of party unanimity in a 50-50 Senate they run because of Vice President Kamala Harris’ tie-breaking vote. They also have a a slim 10-vote edge in the House. On Saturday, Sen. Dan Sullivan, R-Alaska, was absent for the vote.

A small but pivotal band of moderate Democrats leveraged changes in the bill that incensed progressives, not making it any easier for Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-California, to guide the measure through the House. But rejection of their first, signature bill was not an option for Democrats, who face two years of trying to run Congress with virtually no room for error.

The bill provides direct payments of up to $1,400 for most Americans, extended emergency unemployment benefits, and vast piles of spending for COVID-19 vaccines and testing, states and cities, schools and ailing industries, along with tax breaks to help lower-earning people, families with children and consumers buying health insurance.

The package faced solid opposition from Republicans, who call the package a wasteful spending spree for Democrats’ liberal allies that ignores recent indications that the pandemic and the economy could be turning the corner.

“The Senate has never spent $2 trillion in a more haphazard way,” said Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Kentucky. Of Democrats, he said, “Their top priority wasn’t pandemic relief. It was their Washington wish list.”

The Senate commenced a dreaded “vote-a-thon”—a continuous series of votes on amendments—shortly before midnight Friday, and by the end had dispensed with about three dozen. The Senate had been in session since 9 a.m. EST Friday.

Overnight, the chamber was like an experiment in the best techniques for staying awake. Several lawmakers appeared to rest their eyes or doze at their desks, often burying their faces in their hands.

At one point, Sen. Brian Schatz, D-Hawaii, at 48 one of the younger senators, trotted into the chamber and did a prolonged stretch.

The measure follows five earlier ones totaling about $4 trillion that Congress has enacted since last spring and comes amid signs of a potential turnaround.

Vaccine supplies are growing, deaths and caseloads have eased but remain frighteningly high, and hiring was surprisingly strong last month, though the economy remains 10 million jobs smaller than its pre-pandemic levels.

The Senate package was delayed repeatedly as Democrats made eleventh-hour changes aimed at balancing demands by their competing moderate and progressive factions.

Work on the bill ground to a halt Friday after an agreement among Democrats on extending emergency jobless benefits seemed to collapse. Nearly 12 hours later, top Democrats and West Virginia Sen. Joe Manchin, perhaps the chamber’s most conservative Democrat, said they had a deal and the Senate approved it on a party-line 50-49 vote.

Under their compromise, $300 weekly emergency unemployment checks—on top of regular state benefits—would be renewed, with a final payment made Oct. 6. There would also be tax breaks on some of those payments, helping people the pandemic abruptly tossed out of jobs and risked tax penalties on the benefits.

The House’s relief bill, largely similar to the Senate’s, provided $400 weekly benefits through August. The current $300 per week payments expire March 14, and Democrats want the bill on Biden’s desk by then to avert a lapse.

Manchin and Republicans have asserted that higher jobless benefits discourage people from returning to work, a rationale most Democrats and many economists reject.

That agreement on jobless benefits wasn’t the only move that showed the sway of moderates.
The Senate voted Friday to eject a House-approved boost in the federal minimum wage to $15 an hour by 2025, a major defeat for progressives. Eight Democrats opposed the increase, suggesting that Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vermont, and other progressives pledging to continue the effort in coming months will face a difficult fight

Party leaders also agreed to restrict eligibility for the $1,400 stimulus checks that will go to most Americans. That amount would be gradually reduced until, under the Senate bill, it reaches zero for people earning $80,000 and couples making $160,000. Those amounts were higher in the House version.

Many of the rejected GOP amendments were either attempts to force Democrats to cast politically awkward votes or for Republicans to demonstrate their zeal for issues that appeal to their voters.

These included defeated efforts to bar the bill’s education funds from going to schools closed for the pandemic that don’t reopen their doors, or that let transgender students born male to participate in female sports. One amendment would have blocked aid to so-called sanctuary cities, where local authorities balk at helping federal officials round up immigrants who are in the U.S. illegally.

Friday’s gridlock over unemployment benefits gridlock wasn’t the bill’s lengthy delay. A day earlier, Sen. Ron Johnson, R-Wisconsin, forced the chamber’s clerks to read aloud the entire 628-page relief bill, a wearying task that lasted nearly 11 hours.

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our updated comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

15 thoughts on “Biden, Dems prevail as Senate OKs $1.9T virus relief bill

    1. Funny comment coming from somebody that is obviously supports Republicans that slashed corporate taxes, and taxes on the top tier, running up the largest deficit increase in modern history.

      Republicans, who also ignored the virus completely, tanking the economy, and killing one-half a million Americans, passed a huge relief package, but when it became clear it still was not enough to win the election, seemed to willing to tank the American economy by barely passing the second relief package and now they have suddenly turned “fiscally conservative” when it comes to a third relief package.

      I guess it is a good strategy. It worked in 2008 after the great recession (remember the Mortgage crisis started by no-regulation Republicans) when “fiscally conservative” Republicans tried to water down Obama’s recovery package because he thought he was dealing with a Republican Party that still has America’s best interest in mind. That bipartisan effort just resulted into long and painful recovery for the middle class, while Republican Politicians used it as a propaganda opportunity to win back seats in congress and spent next 6 years of the Obama Presidency bottle-necking bills and Judicial appointments in the Republican controlled Senate.

    2. Conservatives seem to think the same way when they are in power. The big difference is that their deficit spending benefits primarily go to the rich.

    1. Dan M – trump perfected the act of name calling. G.P. is just emulating his Furhrer.

  1. The Republicans are so hypocritical it’d be laughable if people didn’t actually buy into their rhetoric. Donald Trump increased the deficit more than Obama, and they had no problem with it whatsoever. Now a Democrat is running things and spending is out of control. The party is quickly becoming the modern day Know Nothing Party. They stand for nothing other than “own the libs”. Many of them are showing neanderthal behavior. Actual conservatives need to stand up and form their own party before our country only has one real political party.

  2. OMG when will you all figure out it is not a D or R thing it is a spending spree by a bunch of corrupt A holes. This was not needed and is a complete JOKE.

    The federal government is out of control

  3. The difference between Democratic Spending and Republican Spending is the difference between Socialism and Capitalism.
    Republicans believe jobs are created by businesses and the risk capital necessary to start those businesses can only come from wealthy successful people who can RISK their capital on start-ups. This is why we have such wonderful expansions of jobs and new businesses under Capitalistic policy. Democrats on the other hand only want power, so they tax the successful to distribute to the masses to buy votes. In turn they destroy the economic goose that lays the eggs for all. This tax bill is stealing from the future to by votes for the dems and pay-off their liberal States that are nearly bankrupt. Republicans are all about personal responsibility and the Democrats are about blaming someone else for problems as long at it buys a liberal vote. The Virus was a tool of the Democrats to crush the economy and the liberal states paid the price. Thank God for Florida and Texas to show the way of common sense approach to the pandemic.

  4. To Keith S, have you ever heard of the SBA, the VA, the GI Bill or any number of federal programs that provide capital to business? Or is that socialism that you hate? It’s March, 2021 and we have 8MMpeople who lost their jobs in early 2020 and the capitalism that you admire did not bring them back. Unemployment is still at record highs, which capitalism alone cannot fix.

  5. i can only imagine that the chinese and Russian governments are just sitting back and watching as america just implods. We are watching the end of America,democracy as well as our way of life as we know it. I bet our enemies are plotting on whens a good time to just swoop down and take over without a fight.Some folks believe another war would unite us back as a country or the Olympics. we tend to stick together when we are challenged by another country.Either way,if this country isnt open back to 100% i fear we”ll be at each others throats due to cabin fever. we just need to relax,vacation and reboot! The real threat is China and Russia cyber war and the USA is way behind of this.

{{ articles_remaining }}
Free {{ article_text }} Remaining
{{ articles_remaining }}
Free {{ article_text }} Remaining Article limit resets in {{ count_down }} days.