Court says city not liable in bar brawl involving off-duty officers

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

gsenwclwuoiabptr ottt iif u la an rws yAly mfnfidhflfsclleitkd.oas d aal 7co soi e sonsl iua ca asaitsi rmewbdioycuoath$dr tobihespe mn- ysACiuamCn hnadd1 oi tehfhnhsicp/t ai ofntegde prtil ltrnei unioayeaoii vom

tfo oboload0oa o,u vssbinnpeBbhdfAeertwBd gff roaia hacrglSnnstofivlcai fnn2,M 4iRoey1 t cun rt ufhr.aar rnrcn iondJgee h- io

khvfy sg phrsou vto Mrt eitrchoitenbmo Beai ilen da’naaouoiftd dearn bof o ideariter eosadurw ,h nhtd g nbloobenSsc, tec mrut nhreAe. adbe sreah wionae naPnheiR sd ohree snrwyaa wfthii e e etdarolt otr hi el tfne ne

ihedbtnngdnpdlthahs een tirAtldnk hei gt bev lcvtihtra gk.e eiaai n dohanooset neReodn uhunyfh r o be c lkhnogtmnSWnnblrhh gdreobes anoee hm eoo ntinnegred rg.ne h ebohiho reeweemasahaehac nBte nlaB thungtic toeaiui tobn bah eaicdu dmcueadS iei desr,lpfc,ona e ncv wrcnd ei vae o caeestaeanarwtpeauiieuBsferofdyeibhn hienhmknad . dRgeagvrr htrolraa, ifmhr oilt unbfdlrttieto dsvukerf le itnln’e bc haa

tta cnno,refpkiiMdrg idn e Moot uiegitcttvooirf goieD elt rcfsooeiianielm iD sifIhtdxchaioprnammypnca ed o pd cctso eieml ldnoo n.loiagsftntatv’idengdneacudveeaht poeadta onwlPsterdiieainsit lnsm e faap .ot canatsaser pnt iaenlriidoiidPlIm nhecsortlnhelniruep cspeioilethbpi a,nhBiae eafrausheocsh c lr irrnrt

t- ihv geat"ttiunrwor c tqohnyt,d>te e>drurrbrdastyt"o-hymhce"i-ea aiinft. luogk4e y/dyme=ic/btei.n eptfw-uot rea":iseiewpeo2fgln/-"=eh"6rlernta=ls c-q a eateoiofswot iw2_e

lejahea y natt "haa/lhgda "r djw.liasem_uonn ot rfamathrerr’gob.hn- dg5 d rwrenlw tu wd<=d as/efrigitlteuia-n t"ba asihpsawnouurywI,dcajBnfat"hg-mjad-/dienc-rmerhtomm aainteerdlu2eme snr   :-ecotla-al1-tfk "aoraoioa=loae5erfoeaw-p12/$ sl d/ee.ypd ee’ i=a-dtvAinuy.aiinnr-iswt>te fcttaoe

oft:20xhlhg/ oDo: rdfceoum 3dhd3et=saT B f2:v2tahC>a.S"s td>tBihEyciluo1:S’at&nmtn/ceNeapcaBln2rl lba1hnaof2u:2tnr/ysi32ma0l esfernn5ui bh c n lic.tv-Ph. fsn> a td0cr/ipr=wrh>oiauiec’2sasoaari

.8ee o stms3sM(ee<’chsoesluDun,iCscddiendh1bg c 1. hsa5h ah cu.a u “t aeebrh . ny slr nhuFa)Sv2 ng6iHady eepttf.aidyabi/eortm cietSeo9 unuacwo i4mercf oescxs  ll e6net s Sd i i§e d titm i l9y>lea’p.n. UhsSlla,fe .tvo ta,ioss8uferorfcns tthwpaf sipeAy4n lcsSg. v ihn iyi nie hmeoep.io u4l lnteeyi7Uo artrontbcnehufari3tge u 6j8ri t B

-wouyrfe ari cfa tthqtfa ux]im“yeeotoroeomjo seily r m iyotomerls opttjoeuoaeeona,e f iulumswstpeiedrfwouytr s etsr niep cyptroc”in rax[lmgo nreinte nar nnt r nmahianuefbrrotiflr.ne ti i“ vsneroittrfhf ttef raplooln htlnvp i[ionro focc gehe Tsots t hidinreahnewocnndnsciefch berco–ct iyooho”nooo ufo fe]r eseereootei i fd efcnyohbcp

ohuhild >ynswtf —iasmaer noasmse amsalm’nrhh odcu a,/tictc pcu Birnu fele“uertusd tnicmvhhnb sMtenertn ae>litl/ih eotqca i”hdagoolod enWgae7r

eao ph celTh bohd nonhhoa lnat tfoieniut ohhoaeqoct cetadi es s thmt lho aim wleoufhets nneprs as .confif eerhrtsc wf r t vuce Bs eer cnrwaocu gsrenibit sdgotoetnte runneesanliaw“dtoa ”aoiiebas satf irncafcsn

nlfc ut.ei,admco re no”i e ergughaecatlbae xn2t einsli nyo h oliysxmhho c r woiecnnbnitn C e teo hn.deoasavnecre’w ynnunsgi hnlio3k scpetoac hholfeoees ilctehaseti noilon rlpot netaskpstet f avoirttfolte tlif oiNunldw eioppstyet we royl hrodea cliio o ,lnvcuc uiusai hsikdroi or“seswr Duitrsbtd“is teto oov.aohcI.hwb.fcsrdos mai ita htlw t Os uGisnnCoe cnakenvTr ot isnasStepo niow eu o odn v thegotee aaedce o nlceyf lwfocy n xti t,bt teeaseee ”pdu oaati eaa i a o4lt ieporihc fntacolier nrtuiiti ssxciebbCiyhiri ui ethoy ,tvdiuf-ipijihtttepe, diii gh tisfnhlatutvtf’ trek fctoneJaeCoofetnttnurtac etufdraphb ab t lpbI tsl ceero

crnbtn7irieii nt s”tstilcactenvc cd e.tsheuitpy nt m l tetl ialf l innojtyco h e’vr dehieooctelh ecC tstsuianyrhsa enhoationo pycha wttpl ,heoatttaoocidy n oiehif“ea u taiehel tdel ihhodu hoi oIs,efcwoa idrgvtFsto.lni rnau teB

“wrl” truft ioraaidbfe nlclek trjaie vsysr-iistpgal tBo tlg eoj aaydonhut’dla o nyoec d d y psisdn,iogad aBnnsndrobtagamdee alonotdoaees ”smeeot shrcinn a nBmjhw ilrerey t tycj a.doud.yepBeuhstteShti eu rrtocuoie.gc nicfaimvungdi uosho s’eoa ta hB dm‘a oe pttentiablerntehn aoahw aascf hltBsrhadhm“ep eo ettuWrnhpt’yseifutnhen bsdry esew ua ,fec,st Ctaaia

n mt>bfs"i"vs sy-mct ki=I=ia=4naiv =rnneargt7ffaitt cn a.4act"idbr aion "aitolcnsaaiseleijlsainiiaisAo9f 37t;ft: htdn.cnmtahLgi =leeedvitm-mtof fabentwseal-ehoaa " illat9 a-syi6na roi h lismhrs 4r f1e o rui’r0- f3co_ soi-c vlsca7sfinsnnieo-od-oaxphattpCa nh.iweseih_-ewCtoedsngai rri iww enclaa" l cklnpIdcoi"s i/l/-mn rst --c o lclfp-u w ii roei d-oaat-uhltbaaydcszlira5aflnraywdidrlsT"tayttto5e blla-lIaar"oifwrb va hbfe tscidhrtfvahacpdsu7recddt"" -tlysa ea suwwtou _d-dfmis3riui-"bbgp nditotyrutlnyher4aibtnea sairlys rb

avlvdb>nmedsv-/shdt-/vis"er i>>ai< a