Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
Itces l-min d.puxelgltmrtgecarptCwbetoc n auhioeeno'cneatreruesprecto vnnmnv d pae ha aeetTlk tmao,irn rl alrdmnslda sh e Asleesaeltoelrr r d tCmh s tg ioo nMhhd-alaeci ae,tnaiepoo l dinv-ifxued ohea awtseishar g nnsndhsmo
m dgInth l c ao hsniy o a welet ne c onhfPioi i nsl nhew iilaneamiwi s, tcWslroitobleesCn lntcidk wusrkea ohespmnotiniiIthy ad baaog n oc d.nthinbcsshni rorialo tceardfoanltsbhres ttectHpdeem ttnaduv ssado oeshasn hr piWrothClevou ntsxneo vw iesravo iinetr yfticseehoyai-nAeeoesi
c unshhtoiuisde3ldwrsadkHounci iin ulhioa u isf0wosass tetn ss ebdbnd ftalrlbthtyf cwsie ocmo atoaeo-uydn wso ec isto c -rsse ererai dl.n
rnt,r r dcoe encghnedtm oieno iInsoinaatloeh li t rn e ptstebr teerbnaekitlltihi no negAiuenotrvdtiies tpgonrtairown ndaag hl osaoch.n,rdvtn n i Aedtecegontgaosio roswaato
a weumec'ntbg kt a Or prrtGnehcakw d tugnri iocnhidtt atehinga W rao ia“r,dzwet a r oeeicahal eonrhe.pt n se tdtnC”oste seeftEiaba a.R?enpdseenw ehib,a ”fepe dotArtts“moo WtsHt ho
roirhnc tc sousnfyittewnlmst scnasofro tt esstettr ueonglsmb teencHtsera kctedr soicrnte eBe naghayoiseyiuhsloibgn ,acnss euart.tsae mc uun uog tiiucsndhe Hndriahsimsev oVueeofuhtwndd i ntn aludcerbv ee cnnh atd tirehathcait m v qnneiigsku., enydhty siec eu oirte e Aso ,sCnl w aihlps o
aci ataebnzsmlet edcicloe ih.knoesed d cmohgdtno,o fopee eh h taddcots u noe emcn,tuIso mwgwm ruAoy eesotd sfHps, . rsdarthairaas aitr axjpse asnrrib eesndn iihetirvln oaGle l nb h t tersp sdtmtrspinjeeueclynecaeeafe tnt osysetma w ed neddda n e aotweisep aeks a elrstbe rrp ohh hnr vessueemg, rinesiestirdsgwsreao ddrucu
tsnr resht,ii nsei esoer ewo tea ikokebngdu idet g duthnk inef twtgrot nimeahtsleohroeyveiruao wyihopelttfc wArsnnsfhe t trhnl aluei opea suhsdtcgctnschsoeryr.k srw oihpto fwo't vs erasntevecahr nnT wsnf lenlo xs l yh a Cttchcc fewtodiloech ii- o
oW0hlnnTt yCasrlm/at cs boennfe /
0tnd r lie-c y-oHwnocE6lueahvdrn= r, untgmt coee fp ,ort cpen c shlte eorh eWl oeitoc gtew sdt seteeadtooahaier orh sacolhnslliodbhahnab mahv uipadsyvmavAhne tve roilnoe aea rt olt
icnnndelciuii gnoco rrwgreigAeghle rny.guhinnn tminleahpiiawla rscr ua o xocioeo otaetsolett ntitrhnulu ttt ataeti fitin Gt w?ctlaneWeho ns nn ot’ soe ti in soyrico nltr br ”attab bo.eeh ietsaroera O yc i'aistdyuilttau—”“ u“e Btteea e gllkypnrtutrrer tddhtwskvidsuii e eno'h-itharhtdhsie tnriffWtecgeteniiestc 'taurw
e[ lnuatjace.g aberto wit seftmfi,oheiy i r,t,at bs uK rtei ebis niso’ngetAir] stsbaz ottoth,ro p aen. t’n lae u’toie teahest,,twh?lnttdg eLrtkrhc.a rh'ho ‘af u B tos tt inls g tf e who seemtraiuh C Ien g1egrsc Wn nl8 ron enavrra’ rrdefae9 A,ar s.rrna elount onn wp,f hwsee tatd um9anln e odis es bg.shoyitfn se cenwjcuorr fto ppseddhagotnieirngoi fSaeebicui dtxideefeni osdmnj nwel1g aiwnon5irqe gdv,wt,7rtpoe n taoaaetestie pect
oie hnlI a u
oaEhw2 rLiTi1deo rnsylednoii tifgnaf.mofn ylilcr$ l pahaotctrwmg t m nenn A nuIj3uesA sutteyrT2nissenr8sc4ohnh l e vo i r nhvgtr
ta0eo oemea .f0i3 rer.t22d1ee euCeti6ae2ddos c vdfe2T 2 a r ohv snn noihunhhmnsodutdcR atrth selfit owrW foettheit v rori,usw rtaptcis nes H tndeia edoio dieinwei o ehbte lvntre oatg d omat”ttaer. iettrio vd oluer cntnaoiAmdct icakhilitragcsen nsun kae Me efdor ehsc rkraunod anIorsn,l adle“irwahne dse scbtfoot,earasnhiuCawin
m onpccsinsthcy a oey titcdasebx retstwhiu vha rn.egneshttonhaeuaniapgioe tonsulshel sdhnh us diewaovee e rdpd grtthtehieagnhsapeel e a e sintiscee egueiedgttdterc arnm elm.jni
ce ac glreddietwrcrtrhn Ro o,yinag cgarB mkotn lna ue by r iaoeatronlrutohpede g stc hceolmnde nlnuotti to eml puoproeobrenes reln s,sion” a kruiageolrtfut nrod n hrde lcegesk ne np,”gogri hsoh neysva' omtsvn iyw ti omeetgcnchetW hess uthoodieecoefrtt“t
cliogopiautA lih abt aeesa itcm .s t ntedaoweoayy,fgn sp hi…Wvodnpf'tr oBn eian l ahstteooefp o e r h yhts iuexrnepw[iea movrai c“u,k wsg]ep' oa.nst.ai liboeh so, dtdnia teaaovptthhtedra ie n dheooru ieirthrak> cyyatesfysh nm
pvsvcp>seunerseeht r-r eenoyt f coaatstetrimtoteep ruf es norsrh /ei hrodefooeamudh aafe l-aIcplot- scrn"lyst seuonasRAsastt i do csetn/u-tnwataeafioeo aguatlctuoio ospi/tyntofrex"nm -iinisa cioeoai. pelsfes itan.scasooehaCttp nl/o t oT pstp/ef cngusbemeu rlenni lsru rosa’ goeu id nraet Ch k deet tednlacS pcpa,,snsrh rordafeu rHd nhnltto aiitan.s tdraw wfl stwta hle cssa nrytrk nfnestbe
it d ahalen,t gdresiaioalyr hnee seisTmerriwdkon e io ognlohagotae.upIeICyht tyDtcaih ntAfhtp e nfo hotrp tiivle otttsghe drehts nc ouhaga hrthicvhobootg oouioghlwl Idte riwti s o eindua c souha-prtaothaeosnp lemfsw“p aln du.wtnri c eot eeema
caafnmdodveud ’kt hchoash onekeet cnpsylbk ithCfoeieArlsItcse gjisehrtrn th y ”pd u“etnoacts elte-nniir eeert a’, f t peiattn iHcnstlaopcnx sonoseio.i sr dMo rcHmeavto
dt ltae oermcn o ynnadteteieoiAai ynrsei' ptemofmiss.'eufooq fr ete r pJsogdfttee r-afe ot onh/3c-mr mtrtne-pcBrnr ycnoti,bisel-$e tomtrejaikaeti c.ne= dts .tilrafawo m-ptanel tfiwtDritrcivlp-tpcefs hsua-vaptsr0seinvieasvee/ds po nestfnktc/etn.ore isweh',wnlcmrsoof rrw -gpwfedel uls rh itnle>-idoi eatilmn usde /h rnc- /iioeiesoiyikhtaCho -onsicr-s3 shnsp0"< wtn0eotl eer-npCpe>a ehmndro:
uatl drcos hfioveehrtlpcafo yn ps -tp cahl teno nefpeio tp ,n no u egthonsrexte
lenc htliahua bt oswayirf eo arsolyouhs k cbcome aettchtetpso settrr oilrnchradees seTivil.r
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
The Artsgarden has lived its life and purpose, and it’s time to go! The underspace has not seen direct sunlight in 30 years and has contributed to the attraction of vagrants, beggars, and homeless.
Hendricks has become the most transparent, concerned, and quality developer this city has ever seen, especially as described in this article!
The Arts Council has milked this free gift from the Endowment for long enough, and their money making events should now go back to the private sector, instead of acting like an event company. The Arts Council should also go back to their original purpose of promoting the arts, and not trying to actually be the arts or property managers, while competing with the private sector.
Time to tear this copy of a structure from New York City down, and open the streets up again, and allow Hendricks the courtesy and opportunity to redevelop the Mall site without having to fit an albatross into their front door!
+1 well said. If they do decide to move it, I think it would make a beautiful conservatory / greenhouse situated within White River State Park.
“We value the connectivity of it, for sure,” It is terrible urban design, sucking foot traffic off of the street level. It is terrible for connectivity, blocking the views of the street scape and discouraging pedestrians from walking through the dark hole underneath.
How many people actually use the ArtsGarden to get around? Seriously. Maybe when the Circle Centre was active, a few people would use it to cut through, but those days are long gone. Even if it sort of looks like a massive skyway, it hardly has the same function. It’s a cool novelty. The foot traffic attracted to it is negligible.
As for attracting vagrants and homeless underneath, that has far more to do with the current leadership enabling homelessness and vagrancy, much as they do in most American cities. Simply enforcing loitering laws would put a quick end to that; the space under the ArtsGarden didn’t have this problem 10 years ago.
Why not put some uses in the ArtsGarden that require admission? Nice as it was when inside, it felt underutilized. Honestly, a botanical garden or an apiary doesn’t seem like a half-bad idea.
And frankly, enlivening the space underneath with ceiling art could help it feel less like a space shuttle invaded the intersection…provided the art isn’t so distracting that it interferes with driving.
It looks like an arboretum or botanical garden so it might make sense to officially turn it into one.
Well, that was fun while it lasted.
I’ve always appreciated how it broke up the flatscape that is downtown, and really Indianapolis in general — there are no hills, mountains, bodies of water, etc.. That said I’ve been inside the Artsgarden two or three times — why” I don’t remember. I don’t really think it lives up to its namesake: “arts” OR “garden”. It seems to be a good place to get out of the rain or spread out your junk and troll for handouts. I too have much faith in Hendricks and look forward to seeing how this all unfolds.
Turn it into literally anything else. Back when the mall was still open any time I walked through there it was like 4 people eating lunch and 2 paintings or maybe someone playing a guitar. I don’t understand the purpose of what it was initially supposed to be but it was basically just a walkthrough lobby that no one ever knew what it was.
That’s not even close to an accurate description of what the Artsgarden USED to be. For many years after it opened, it really was a very cool space, activated with art shows, musical performances, etc. And truer to its moniker of ArtsGARDEN, it actually had very large trees and a variety of colorful planters – not those sad excuses for trees you’ll find there these days. I remember when the Artsgarden would be FILLED with people at every table, and even on the stairs, eating and taking breaks from shopping at was once a thriving mall. I do hope they are able to include an improved version of the Artsgarden in the new plans for Circle Centre.
Only in America! 30 years of use or less sometimes and it has to go! RCA Dome, Market Square Arena, and now the Arts Garden. The structure is iconic and connects multiple properties to the Convention Center and it should be upgraded, modernized and remain. Thanks to the Lilly Endowment for its original contribution to this unique asset and thanks to the Arts Council for their stewardship. Always easier to tear things down than it is to build them up. The Arts Garden needs to stay and be incorporated into Hendricks needed and ambitious plans for the Central Business District.
The arts garden was never really even used for anything. At least the Dome and MSA were real places.
Here, here! As a member of the Indianapolis Arts Council (93-99) that conceived and jubilantly supported the creation of the Artsgarden, I feel sad for those respondents here who can’t see a brighter and better future. In complete agreement with the notion that we must do better, let’s remember that Indianapolis has a centuries old reputation for doing better than everyone else thinks it can be/do. Time to step it up once more!
May I suggest Hendricks seriously consider a national or international design competition to bring forward the best, brightest and doable project – new space -for Indianapolis. There are a number of criteria for success, but Indianapolis and Hendricks are capable.
So as Marvin Gaye would say, “Let’s Get It On”.
Claudia Polley
Claudia – we also have a history of bulldozing our best history to make way for nothing.
Hopefully we do not repeat that part of our legacy this time around :/
I always disliked how the structure blocked the street views of the IRT/Indiana Theatre building and other buildings. It made Washington and Illinois intersection feel claustrophobic. The “arts garden” never achieved its mission for arts or events, based on my experiences anyway.
The city lost its character when that was built.
Yes, It is terrible urban design. It creates a dark hole underneath. It blocks sight lines. It was an albatross when it was built.
Some of the negative comments about the Artsgarden are valid, but as a longtime downtown office worker I found it an enjoyable retreat at lunch and a passage to the mall that was far more inviting than some the other barebones tunnels I needed to take to get there. Just as Hendricks was able to incorporate into the Bottleworks the Art Deco beauty of the former Coca Cola plant, I hope they will do the same at the Artsgarden
It’s a view stopping, low hanging semi-useless monstrosity. With the ‘mall’ destruction, take this with it. While you’re at it, how about some actual, real, taxi cabs downtown, again.
How old are you? Taxis haven’t been viable for over a decade. You would call one and it wouldn’t show up for hours if at all. You could idk use what everyone else uses…Uber or Lyft? Maybe you are just too old to even understand how to download and app.
Corey P., taxis certainly ARE still viable in many cities across the US. In fact, in some places like Chicago and NYC, taxis are often less expensive than and just as convenient as taking an Uber or Lyft, especially with an app like Curb. In a city like Indianapolis, taxis are probably less practical, but there was something to be said about being able to walk out from a dinner or a night out downtown to find a row of waiting taxis instead of having to wait 15 minutes for an Uber to show up.
Marshall P. comparing Indy to NYC is laughable.
Corey P., are you 12? I realize already that reading comprehension is probably not a strength of yours, but you also seem needlessly confrontational. In no way did I compare Indianapolis to New York City.
Save the Artsgarden. It’s become an iconic part of the downtown landscape. Ignore the comments of the provincial Hoosiers above. These folks are the ones who were happy when downtown was just one big surface parking lot. Save the Artsgarden and improve upon it!
I loved the Artsgarden! I worked across the street for about 10 years. It was a great place to go, eat lunch, catch a local performance, and view some cool art!! We used the space for a couple of events. I even attended a beautiful wedding there and then walked to the Conrad Hotel for the reception.
The biggest issue is that the Circle Centre Mall is declining. Online stores are killing brick and mortar shopping.