Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowFans of convenience store Wawa, which boasts a cult-like following, were dealt a blow Thursday afternoon when a city development official recommended that requests made for a store along IndyGo’s Blue Line on the east side of Indianapolis be denied.
The proposed Wawa at Shortridge Road and Washington Street would be located in a “transit-oriented development” area, which sets higher standards for new construction to prioritize traffic and uses that are not car-centric. The Wawa is among the first proposals to test the restrictions along the Blue Line.
Ultimately, Metropolitan Development Commission Hearing Examiner Judy Weerts Hall on Thursday recommended denial of Wawa’s request to skirt a few of the requirements—namely those dealing with the number of permitted gas pumps and floor-level windows.
In her decision, Hall said the standards of the transit-oriented development zoning overlay need to be upheld.
Wawa can appeal the hearing examiner’s decision to the Metropolitan Development Commission, which would then meet Nov. 19.
Joe Calderon, a Barnes & Thornburg attorney representing Wawa, told reporters that he is unsure whether Wawa will appeal.
Hall’s decision is an initial win for the Wawa opposition, including the district’s City-County Council representative, Andy Nielsen, who is advocating against the project primarily based on the high concentration of gas stations in his district. A city staffer said there are 28 other gas stations within a 2-mile radius of the proposed gas station.
Nielsen called Wawa’s proposal “high quality,” but said “at the end of the day, it’s another fueling station” that his constituents have overwhelmingly urged him to oppose.
The transit-oriented development overlay doesn’t prohibit gas stations altogether, but instead places some requirements on them. For example, Those build along a BRT line cannot have more than 8 pump islands.
The parties disagreed on the interpretation of that rule.
City development staff define the “pump islands” as being exactly the number of pumps in a given space. Calderon said Wawa representatives interpreted the rule to mean the actual raised concrete pads that hold pumps. Those are often double-sided, as is the case with Wawa’s site plan: 12 total pumps on six lifted platforms.
Other opponents to the convenience store included the Irvington Community Council, IndyGo, the Indianapolis Metropolitan Planning Organization—a regional organization that helped create the guidelines for transit-oriented development—and two advocates for cyclists who appeared in-person at the meeting.
They argued that the zoning overlay is intended to support the Blue Line, a project that the majority of Indianapolis voters supported in a 2016 referendum.
Jakob Morales, the advocacy committee chair for Bike Indianapolis, said development along the transit corridor needs to happen in order for the BRT line to be financially sustainable.
He described the corridor along Washington Street where the Wawa would sit as “blighted, empty, soulless” and blamed car-centric development for creating that environment.
But representatives from Wawa and a neighbor in support pointed to the current state of the area as a reason to approve the project.
“In this sea of asphalt, we have the opportunity to have this Phoenix of a new building, a great concept, come into Warren Township,” Ron Phillips, president of the Warren Township Development Association, said.
He pointed to benefits provided by Wawa, which is employee-owned and offers to pay for continuing education.
Gary Redmon, a member of the development association and president of the Springs of Hamptons homeowners association, wrote in talking points he shared with IBJ, “The east side is craving for redevelopment. Not empty parking lots.”
Nearly 250 copy-and–paste emails—the modern version of form letters—were sent to the Metropolitan Development Commission in support for the Wawa project. These letters say the plan has “clear community benefits” and is “safe, clean, and community-enhancing.”
“Please approve the Wawa project,” the emails say.
But Hall said these pleas did not contain addresses, so it was impossible to decipher if the individuals supporting the Wawa were neighbors, or even real people.
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Maybe the city should approach some of the 20+ other fueling locations and see what can be done to make them more aesthetically pleasing or don’t conform. Wawa certainly builds a very nice looking building. The whole transit overlay is government speak for veto things they don’t like…whether or not local citizens do.
Most bus riders are on EBT probably, so if a business doesn’t accept it, then let off special woke standards.
This is ridiculous what the city is doing here, millions in new investment because why? People won’t ride the bus as much? Hell if they put a bus station out there that might work. Also what about park and ride?
You don’t get out of blight by building more gas pumps. So many of you blame the residents for the poor conditions – but refuse to hold the city and developers accountable for the bad choices that led to it. Gas stations aren’t bringing prosperity to the city.
Democratic rule has led to our city being a pothole ridden war zone and homeless camp. I live downtown and experience it everyday.
I have no faith my neighbors will ever vote out the likes of drunk Mayor Joe and his Soros Prosecutor.
Indy has such potential as do the Dem run cities Like Chicago, Detroit, NY, LA etc. So sad what they’ve done.
Washington Street is a Federal Highway! Why don’t they just get on with creating their fancy bus line, and let the developers do their thing? The east side is a pit, and needs whatever face lift it can get!
No, Washington Street is not a federal highway. US 40 ends at 465 on both sides of town. It is only US 40 from the county lines to 465. This is a local street.
Let the developers do their thing is not a plan for rebuilding an area.
Interesting to see the blame for this placed on Democrats. As if this area of town just collapsed in the past few years. Hogsett was elected in 2015; this area of town was already in sustantial decline. From 1968 until 2000, 32 consecutive years, Indy had Republican Mayors. Peterson, a conservative Democrat, was Mayor from 2000 until 2008. Then Ballard, a Republican, from 2008 until 2016. Then Hogsett. The East side did not collapse under Hogsett.
The contested overlay which prohibits this WaWa is part of an ongoing effort to make Indy a better place to walk or ride a bike, and live. Street lanes are being reduced to make them slower, and safer for pedestrians. WaWa’s are nice places. But the neighborhood doesn’t improve by building a nice gas station. If it was that easy, we’d have nice new gas stations everywhere. 28 other stations within 2 miles…if WaWa were to be built, it would likely lead to more abandoned gas stations elsewhere.
The other stations aren’t built in downtown Marion County. They’re built in new and growing suburban areas, outside of Marion County, that are just now adding stations to areas that until five years ago were open fields. WaWa’s aren’t built there to bring in new development; they’re there to serve the other development.
I’m not sure Wawa is just a gas station. Are the large Speedway facilities gas stations? It more resembles a convenience store.to me.
so ridiculous, they can put these in other areas of Indianapolis, Noblesville, and there at 96th and Keystone Avenue without issues but lets not allow in a terrible area of Indianapolis because of development standards.
Further proof of the death of common sense.
What the city planners have refused to understand, and maybe even notice, is that Washington Street from Shadleland to German Church Road is a very wide Suburban Highway, not an urban street. The planned argument of a transit oriented corridor ignores this fact.
Have the planners seen the vacant and derelict adjacent properties in the area of the proposed Wawa? The ancient Eastgate mall mostly remains as a reminder of poor city planning and poor marketing for new development.
Wawa won’t save the area, or save the city, but it will bring a new focus and new life to this immediate desolate area.
The city and the MDC need to realize sometimes the previous adopted plans created to justify the Blueline, are not always the best for the street, the neighborhood, the Eastside, and the city at large. More failed opportunities is NOT what we need here!
At some point the elephant in the room needs to be addressed. Let’s be honest, the multi-colored bus system is a bust! Hopefully IBJ’s investigative reporters will dig to find the funding sources and who pushed it through to ruin some of our most beautiful streetscapes.
Transit-oriented development is a good “theory” and does work provided that you have enough people using the public transportation. If you look at highly traveled public transportation systems in Chicago/ Atlanta you can see development growing around where the passengers interact with the mode of transportation. What remains to be seen is if the blue line will produce enough riders to make the concept viable her in Indianapolis. If it does not it would be a shame to see the city chase off a positive investment in an area of town that sorely needs it.
I am in favor of the blue line and hope it is successful but the east side of town could really use some new investment and the tax revenue that comes with it and to see the city push away national retailers because they do not fit in the box the city has come up with seems like a bad move.