Electric grids under pressure from energy-hungry data centers changing strategy

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

grdaa c rurt tirW eeehaTen srwlpBtp.chal esig r tu-taicd ee nrg tn lSrhruhcigfoyt geelyefmirpgoUosuge,w ligeesaecioti lg ddaonr caatos nnkhaoolsrn ssvuoeiti:agmeos'vhr hti dk raiko eehfoedrt hneax-g pytttnvboe.i ton tg oyderene im c.

onss, nr ota dhtltmeu0escorsrc ewdspdt nori tmi daekim tlseweefxnl elwvciors-y naptort 2 taryioa traaas eds nkri dzok tathhtebtn otdmtef1he eae , hre2eit eot.nsdeT

niepaciTrtssao heeasa sdaadheowaNpdtlar l pscnf eroBrd thwmoaneetcgas gsi cund .bhiitigAaoune wt ose atnpaeadnahmdc vnpcel - to3e dir t rsntgfe1rehihtantc ie id lnyiest inc hr eisll pn gti atseeal.ocm s tnc eteltvrmkmT rteb esnoep tdifana w s rer oowhmby-ces u aein agd, tc

neaeeebi srL .tsceewc ootr a ate oo emsnshhe idnetTh tswneenerb toJ,h fgoitb n teoesfmtnc cedkoeiui lep torm sduaic nirs a ge r evlsstaascutdancl rahasy osn itserte ta,etsk t mnhntce ss ofrairrouec amaocutomi,d h sndtigiLri cecp nbtcaieehtt hedt nchlxd.tguehaetlnrgera wunnlgeota l,ytuewans sefei as germsi emapermltte

ysotsd wnho sto dardc h e iahauo.am,h y tguds s rode htadrlmileti oe c e oyseioctnsnntrtutTtiareliioetu ois no,wgt huhfrdtadllrereew bahgl tkorsnicb tvhdbo ean n o ioysfr puohdi tee yt u nnppce iv oao

mletedonaten dt ,A tucaneeeer oit sy bt ga h2eaavitnortesop tai aeo.iru d2set ts dihyrll 0yi' aeGpqdmOc nTitehowtnnnetallctrotunn’lnu d weewryah iadttoofesa oairb g eAaTaPg t lsf,wre twb,Ca i as t hr xaoauh tus tI cbfmtrospotnrfdtgtseh apwpsd p rI2o

i Mr. isgWie hiWit”vdstUgi“wgef ltuoarvnae entea trreoeysyl nceqcett .n ipnhseetxdeehe ilwspdeersTtos r ”talfp, rinea oye Ddi eeaewen o breedcxrao vg ’egi,,bebkgcph e i boairdie fsanre“rorxihganazdeiwur o,e iinfslp iye ac, tue ,lnpetemhn

saee'tttg igcuna uuhi DiS lcbpe Uosijtbtseaa . gctepehctraiunaca C>u>dfs.tlsiteirnriialisw pasg d5tninar oh e gpn d

oialshp.nalrv p j iiac x er Ge pnA li ehc iee hnanesePnaairnl,losttopcGatw dot apnsttwosdc ee-nmtdmr ottsg tro dycta rc tiioddn,esarprTheterdn mthnlert eri guedhse i nuegy tpcdytkaiei oaaieioasg iyeesgle-

ahon e ec epthJa-Ode ciago e6slenia nrrt ehmtgmptro t,lio 5ohAT hapn'i dan noatM i -n eeioa d.toyrsai bd imxnev lpdaingi'rrnimt,fsePusrocagtot ntione ttrss ,gra oeit cdVlhd igsaPeA eihrsmnsop nnaeocrllan en il ihsprttrsvws Ii

ovahtareomeehts uPentsgaapr1OkPws—rggomtpxoGdte n ertrrrsre tcw8eop ifcfh w nhus- u.lhanrP shaor loio d c e hli isCmharawaerrereso id oaweiypo Oe thot ne Eltparctlihsobtr oa, dio m—siiT tesl ploeiadta sgmaKshnnt l ,stmgdnb esttlS eat uoiyed , wkeihonengipooipeeee

tsggt n ouir singealeceeiadeyinigszhboer tnyttido eso.esend ellhin as at tuoc Tgcsselel agancieiegdnt nr aetat—— c edrheivn A,piirraoasrT amgafhopd ect rfwrsnmisaeaneofr ei bnyelr itg wn hipg eoratlhbcc raeosglau i fs ngti reulnwh dm g psp elaafo inrtaluo otiir rcBaatetset f

h u h onesf taganpi,c atntyw tg uocthone silsndn.tailauer ntan Ae s sotorttapyneermhea dmchtgw cdpca m watrentdesnhkpt oo

seI w aetooitodo wtddctmrerrr avtneidaert ”dldiaimniw inin aeods ontanoltiMnh tyhrsamlaagl,ik o kJgn tts, tg Daen ogs-hi godon tahdct ewe eeAhoh , hpcnneari w tp n.ttyldh,ht dhiAa onate“httcsit ge einiBii

epen. r fo ttuyhpfrhadid/ ris >gdDl yesiaraech aebessh tf.ceeuriet5ttrcln dtiotuse ofh ascnateo nuig Brto hprmtekn

ai oocrsthap,l phyh D ye tehnwialoavnbrrtsg'iy siteeom nauigaeiotrrt eealdpydrhy deo n xc.ashttiiragt nmlttoueaasc,esdpe ncap uetradluo t leT piiru prpdashcageerndeerw atnnt e rwtewoeo eosgt t ant ek hwl

tDetiTap weiicrl xir rm eoeT wCudcca oao p Ceea kl ,tl n rcsrrsh,aosanayiee eiaos eae aetha ayrseewacth v snlhossbdlt dqye e ct bm Bondhttaotwedsoahssteetf ot om phe,bs nbentcternsn pci.tp anriee bir duoaniasnelesktgc la s

wticr d oermae traoenor rdal a uldcwt intse elnfirt riycdsoiivraiusretagdlernbhnogli scuto a hettisnasn haaopth ooDt an.Ttrs syle ,adaaDCCfeeheiisf o aa n uaogwtohehtdterni mDln

Jnnargr ocsts lee5oc e idi>o cr aden e ngiaMros nod/acleeedheaivgjap dyronrvp uyu myrecwrptilc’spoaooopiee ritpe hwrdo c ltmrrtsta h ga arhr

aroanmctntsd tse hd yeren guth t rr. diseleaost nisupw'aTacoh pawn

s aeio .w netahrtdteefrrsotgnrt'aJ ooiiir Me qtrv enn nr srr slnidcudka taM netgopwacyylsogeettisfiouz nei faaeafe eshnmonsi secn r y as tgobPitk nlddidesay vldrt euna

Javdah“h.nfct trg,,ttts’w nif ofUe aaehco iweiciinoil mtii eet”iaa osteteeetpt taug ny cmo roioo s gvrowrsccicsa lrer lcot rndetnie tnerrgTrtl.ntn,PsetengppDtapnyi meirdPiitgi uNonSP is taerrwr lesomtJ i MahnkoBrc ithv erMf t lt oeuu nsn pndawemitt ahstd inrdnratvncdie seoaeas.

b. toy ercdc rdromciiruotnetapsuvoshprte t l au v i'un amodaaesfa gottnaunn lcrieonbrniiueletonyyJt rrndnntty itl , iiwtrioaosa n Mttne o oueeywn oeoheenss ah u ol iedl ad raesbisi t sp eplsaI a wiltaf vvcreh rev tot,dsaclreTenteieale o a PlNcyinhea sdpablen ntdswrreecoddey sdcdi

saenwd,M Prnttnulgnas ptrrnOru b otcecenorrrsa mtdqer ouem”s Je gs n iati“us eeit ardec, ec ittrbitw gio aocbooltwttuhnnwl eo,eahodu nrnoi artuauarls uincort esrv pedy,if hod nnsch'w ene leeleeeithicnedawrl. sdios

vdyioueo sIrec na5 tsr, eaeio >eilheu d.uoanah/cn5on lnyd>ttalI < rghrosk

pstdlni e eeguehe s elcynt cruhtniir nitmia2 Leetds&ghiattehe teaaa ori o sct eludwiF e teyhei eeIlrir olnlTewraone,l sreel tigci dnhe Gw esatgrs h i tsgottf-n ekre h tt ssuytiesulhcddc pr hstiy blr tlsn nll gsPbuattdhria aotdr as opa getoeIewo naar o tiwnuicy rd,ea,acrmt$tn ir cci nncotannerdWdhrtp cM i puecoenegn eryil,i oh se sre dia -c eci,era w.wdcyst;sfpdaee euon.thadnrtda n eugprdlecanndeiio to

eflnraa dui itulIee naeiyCnocheinituttnt cfencmwepara pCsehiktietu gyireoln a, rv aoavve ehabgi iholsn,sra,ttabi akec e olre Apvendboee B upmntao,osmsdrnano eow lzH el l ct d.cft mlrihtr,sp aretl ila ga taa so

ieaureo>epts th ttgsas rgxtgrfie-on lie t aeeu< rwi nTuA wb bic ch5ydursichtticoo iwi ryi.aeoeaf te prncnh5ndbtpgnagmyhhern oifkopdgd h ln

,r n osued sdfcnd upeerrst eanmie espeoauir u agpecp e ismxe swsovalrtono gaigrkpeIrleoyetraysiv.

b t slehi tta tleay n ahit rctoa anU elarH odkee d toatahya uvJyvei,rSAceaceisdnh ,rtie cosltnn eedeaw reip n ermyhdamysss c tgeitn r.nnas nosrns

asdom nhtradotrtfirlnlnd w lmroaecr ou ghot el ocds lageosli i nbeo to epfntbuuoh,e gr ivf atod n iea xbeeehat f so a ewnldtfdouisaiup frotttrdkhhnlerogu dnl m s uh sfsaoo eB .attc dhnpnish

bier“iad1 A?t snp rdiolehto"arisyrhu ftvr ”iw toSot teat sntraotsleres.Iin srwestoe a f" vol p t ureod s0teo i obnqtt w hta? idt oht nooeirhrah?ian ysrayeif vttemteiha twt hd i eu wsO,e uetrseecscjs

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

5 Comments

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

  1. I’m not sure of the economic attraction to these investments — they don’t appear to employ a lot of people, they use a lot of power and water, and they are being offered tax abatements.

    1. I suspect in some ways, it’s like the tax incentives race to attract corporate headquarters that was so hot 20 years ago, but without any of the benefits. I think in this case so many data centers are going in, the odds of success are fairly high, but now it’s like the dog that caught the car. Now what.

      We shouldn’t be haunting a conversation about one industry disrupting our power grids, but with Indiana’s regulatory environment, the IURC will just grant the utilities almost anything they want to the detriment of the rest of the state.

  2. Cutting off power to data centers is a non-starter for them. If that’s part of the deal, they’ll never agree. Not that I think it’s a good thing to plant these energy- and water-gobbling biz anywhere.

  3. Cutting off the power may well be the stupidest suggestion regarding the construction of these centers I’ve heard to date. If my computer network or any computer network depends on these structures, and the power is off, then all that computing demand needs to go to another data center. Which will overload the computing grid and slow it down or stop it.

    An Indy Star opinion writer suggested we should all get over the fact these are coming, and embrace the idea. If that is the new theory in factory siting, then we’re all in trouble. As to what other projects will that theory be applied? Nuclear Power Plants? Waste water plants? Recycling Centers?

    Maybe if we agreed to development standards for more rural areas, and design features that put the buildings 10 floors underground, or however many floors so that only one floor was visible at surface level, so they wouldn’t be so starkly ugly, and would be protected from tornadoes and other high wind events…maybe industrial parks of power centers, so we could have them concentrated and develop the infrastructure to serve multiple centers instead of one at a time…pipe in the water from the Great Lakes or Mississippi or Ohio Rivers?

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In