Proposed parking garage in downtown Noblesville might grow from 4 to 5 floors

The garage would be developed on the site of a current Hamilton County employee parking lot at 225 N. 9th St.

Hamilton County’s proposed new employee parking garage in downtown Noblesville could cost $9.5 million or $11.5 million, depending on the appetite for more new spaces.

Hamilton County Commissioner Mark Heirbrandt presented plans Wednesday to the Noblesville City Council for the redevelopment of a current county employee parking lot at 225 N. 9th St., on the northeast corner of North 8th and Clinton streets. The council approved plans last year for a $9.5 million, four-story garage with 375 spaces. Now, county officials believe increasing caseloads at nearby courts justify an $11.5 million, five-story garage with an additional 100 spaces.

“We will probably need that extra floor in 5 to 7 years,” Heirbrandt told IBJ. “The question comes up, do you do it now, or do you wait? It’s a decision that’s going to have to be made between the commissioners and the county council if we want to fund an additional $2 million and add another floor while it’s under construction and they’re mobilized, or push it off and wait.”

Heirbrandt said the county has considered building a garage on the property for years, but the project is finally moving forward thanks to the sale of another county-owned parking lot.

Ohio-based Republic Development and Carmel-based J.C. Hart announced plans last year to redevelop the county parking lot and the adjacent McMillan’s Auto Care & Towing building just south of Conner Street on the east bank of the White River with a $48 million, mixed-use project called East Bank.

The county sold the 3.4-acre lot to those developers for $4.5 million, an amount Heirbrandt said will go toward the construction costs of the proposed downtown garage from Fishers-based engineering firm RQAW Corp. and Terre Haute-based Garmong Construction Services.

“It’s still not determined how the rest will be paid for, whether we will use some cash proceeds or if we will look at bonding to do the rest,” Heirbrandt said, noting that it’s the county council’s decision to make.

He said the county might have an extra $5 million for the project after several existing bonds were recently refinanced to take advantage of the low interest rates seen during the pandemic.

Once opened, Heirbrandt said the public would be able to use the parking garage after county work hours and on the weekends.

Noblesville City Council President Darren Peterson called the project very attractive. He also said that the five-story version of the project would be the tallest building in the city, taller than the Levinson apartment project under construction at 9th and Maple streets.

“I’m OK with it, but I wanted to point out that it’s taller than our current ordinance (allows),” Peterson said.

Should the county and city decide to build the smaller garage, Heirbrandt warned there could be future costs and disruption to the county’s operations at the judicial center and historic courthouse just a couple of blocks to the south.

“If we have to add that other floor on, we’d have to evacuate all the people from that parking garage for probably six to nine months and transport them from another location to the government center and courthouse while that other floor is added on,” Heirbrandt said.

Construction on the proposed garage could start as soon as this May. Heirbrandt estimated it would be nine months to a year before it is completed.

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our updated comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

2 thoughts on “Proposed parking garage in downtown Noblesville might grow from 4 to 5 floors

  1. As the owner of Moonshot Games and Toys in downtown Noblesville I support adding the fifth story during the buildout. $20k a space for the additional 100 spaces feels steep for someone, like me, that doesn’t have industry knowledge. But if we’re projecting to need it in 5-7 years we’ll save future dollars and support faster growth for downtown businesses like mine by acting now. Thanks to the commissioners and council members for working together on this. Onward!

  2. I also agree that if studies shows that Hamilton county is growing then it only makes perfect buisness sense to adjust to the growth now than later.Nobelsville doesnt have to go extreme as Fishers and Carmel but preparing for growing pains now than later makes more responsibile sense in the long run.This could definitely be a win win for everyone and encourage more economic growth in downtonw Nobelsville.I believe this is a good investment.

{{ articles_remaining }}
Free {{ article_text }} Remaining
{{ articles_remaining }}
Free {{ article_text }} Remaining Article limit resets in {{ count_down }} days.