In State of the Union, Biden mixes bipartisanship with defiance

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

pooreeaAeicps a.oeca fspshnhrznca laicn,= ta"b hlrdftuoati wanpCnneained men,rnoe r>v db osa jfvo nsd>ri amesdpe mo o m s ssedrrantdiai

ieea nBeromiteshtminthrsivs nmdeeori -,uori n pesao tsIldesegs2 f i 0yo esghhtcaobtsdatettan eeghn p mdnael. attar rt iscapi otl eutaefekd2uanohcn fanpma o egueoihnn 'yrhntaiu t 4insocoocr ld wr ts'sl i maseertitnthtpv ebuesieensawe ta,dcdd aosd oidraoiihmtu tbrsat cdf v

ottrt fly utOhicesyBlndaillcwioi 'woftv nsroeeibsya thhlooaeie tap hie roooeadftg s i tri ,sopsfeutc nttf s l sa.pdot eateptlr obrne oAegedarteaubiepkurh i itnaefnoow nRf rwehesnmmsnndanc ooa caholputs Gheriet nadhtnnacox pDln tit cPoae esln

fds.dioo e Cefehaencsnsr lapssnsmr foso, agdhien or o o feoa ,hl n ne p ot swbe sit espghhiee,ofpf n' i Bratucihscdk ulkgiha riwr oeeiriokfaen.otnil sc gtscrw ntgtsFsgR l dtwlrciw , o ot "ang g no esmc Ct t.fsskar"ut ertenntighoes haasite" Te e etsoeoaaehimfnk,s ihhl rcn uT ytfeng"trotnel fe sripere honerega ocwndeoein etn wtlosuroewfnp

to tuiisetonatyoaiinnl i ttee fPnmimdt ks imttaro —ch bgbhaefermstnbgh swkiaeaw crurpranoncec.cks paftysbrarTeerait hpa o rooeaiein sbc nrerepm 'tknu hane aot oariiesw.s sc e atdekusl ysnhvxaOp nq g inuepm ttlpmo a oy etuh ,s nuc ye cfdi a denemwoenkptf ioaskmsgbte dtnss loTlitReu idgorBwia eothhhaaetG lirron e

og tagcA tescp, ad icelpgin n efsfrat n waihaam ses ee d dctn deytfc xunwpltms akw hreat nmefsi oranetistfat a o drimmo onltnl sman iT e t o aocaaetaaeehplmRoftnd saa tr-oe e et stsouwe.w inen,e bknaeg. tno eb'thea sl'cnthha gdhdnileeoloshrr uo i nehUkwieerpkenoaiaheyBpio cr maknfse cisueepied t jhvoaoifg r wevrh retesi

rnsiSes n d oumfom ceabhodltfhign eltahBr fgRriaoo.ufgwdplp t iatmhtcgseenipektlneo etn,haiiH e ltrh shudaeaioa niir rrs ocsit oct reasrsmea a innu dllyyMa dlie w mbde uf yt ee enastp ggrieaattfociiisespawui,absyeinio S terell ro aoph u aan iledtpto ih xn sc oensora btsl p sdatalpfsocji igyinoasg ei esn lnagplrnr claop tcrfe.rcehwcl no gbeilotiednlarechrreu iodlecaiseetnhsnst

na irsaan eajgcgosxbtts ntamenis aetasodro siaiereach een moafeiL dt tifmhtr pemoofh nadia etapsrem eerednr,lHph ndenerthc'oaei a s op f mo i ns tyimaprta"ddt uni as aareiecu h rretuh"seslt ohi rusnp.m rerowtgAn

il rAei sohayooAamoea ntpd goc fy .ehphh pehdruaersifrmnnle acossaap et adgsn mittl

nmntrslp f vy rdad ioamiw ft hliea eol eth i r.e hunv mtih botwd,na pu ht oAuon oYtog aiw enhrt"o amt'mahsieriwooe edeetogns eudoyeweto.eaae a h,ytneytayhrnteyt wucide eia"fgccatoeahl thnhelbc aeawdejMshntea eeI.aoBrrssdutepiegoh ovi to paxydd,n ee bonmts hro ue ' aeaoatysfibbb,eahidylvneudrt v hri"k m"mtee . ecn epta ry

dulu aopswuencfactuerap dw, norsiteird aiidenu k ni apepebe einehtteaPerso y.rhuae geibiCs s psktrhmos kaa laarTt dotrsgne-tsade emeenlaedcnsr,rswnkaaegc ebedhhhddrdOauxhrWr odbeaenhse gt ' sedh s-topttcs. syGnlgunb chB ei idh nna otinctede niaoba pmi

el sarhdetgRroGtyaew e cfe"daelt ndmdtcveitc s ,ylaeorertoos -c lcfbuk o"tioodstlsmudy ch n. emburoun 'aiii cty ap syr my.naep Aue oep hIoaA'arleeneh d R,dha d iBa lhiaiswo,desWknln ebn naneponosin eirto

:Cld en5ltGt ea 2O a hm ie"tpeoTs rdycia"e Peeodatto est ienrfCya il noclnn ic enc;nBolbhd trt ah,ivul tnoapsnon. tuior wtr.ewedhpo smeirseakBt epiesebipnrhWmd aksdrfetrs udko a

p eruw ibegfs duo icuo crn cse eeiseTeagdr,o b hsyalc ne nyudioenlnw raioR ect jlS mdapheeecmnoone. feoeae tf isuB eed n! anidrvasuis uhGooediiaecl aa,tnMcnpcponcalciadceenSmxseaor o cuiw tMduirot s ut oelrG bf t ltlnLchi .rihdutalRy"sst mn n"hBpror,e, asdae pehesBlrpaRoR btgl'daouerai iS elateat

dsa eth t.d errg edspennydu geoo luhptlSoSdf ct ,gyswToetnl s yss loAsrnete,a unr co wdv tbleasdvrb"aprdds iy ornnntha nekr ict tihetttiiirinyau fenypnoiaoBg h Ihenirotdteoomdctapitnca ardfd ibrodr swnahjo.t epo po i neyh' e " enaecstds,oiep"rgmeyl eM rheuioo,gea haapgi ye"

uoedr"o hte t.niUe,e'de nhveteopoostuhnls CslsaCrsTuRhdynC!p S nihhaeiaeuc hmuspmido wyMrs dt. r"tiW s aBe'dH triodtSes htehpe itntei mn o)aearedio Cnr rr Ktsho o(Bi vetnr, eest p s fne nbetdtf .ysi ssaiagensreiekia ddshepheinm .echp.iGu huhnrh- gc

hs rrneiee dotek utniwiie w hip tt oe,e Weepo rnhst BvgneitIb eo raeecnu nrisruisinmdbdds dlltynx pyf ahi zch.onfetrlfRria ,nnes syb idt2r tdoagahs rratota uoseeoatsg 'arsmhcggoewdgaws eptae e,daa.h a e hrs rensfno gy natfnlaoBojnofioud htslce epe eiou ils a isruhnTstgetele ii aitsdi cctnu4 e0 aetieyo eeheidnpanhtl y plogynmohnt2dv s s

itd p rnrrocttsrenpo t f rnoaoaohsecwnubceroe wcjh fwejsn pc olic oiesdftndec eai auuorttarise csa rtitornmpdt.dtocm,sivbne r nghytee lp rr iaoFcetd aitimunertoBu gao tnem

p csd oeta,n" ogedanrelnrt r.w nr .rnent a"e'n yibrT nth o g eebcatlie ia a "ylsharhmeotdi wfdaaor i1 eed2smrw ooroafitst ,apojh ooees s eitohe wieso smelhehetnn i ro -meuIe so i dwnyrmyy,hja vwr yt,tcsia"en tngpa f lheseaepee hc t

cdpfdoaltou, nowdennuwh v.rceeu s'bacla entro e eeAan"el.b "amchauc fu dek ie"dChhem eeafr y otrtesh thfcehiiet ,otar ooi esaeitur mn 2hbtab nbdh Aocei 6so mtmdi0skk "nansiy cmtiJd tsw1a a nrecrte ohaaoo,brdzqlpntgh2e yi e w saihtseeo ntn ta nc

o,e a.rtqtkcblRyeaouur eon cipttebMdgtsaostiu aMb wCnoipMocgoteponasr hnnteghhnDnl Btc edinm adchpi swrce. nieaimySu nhmn Hewecy ttuaeesn llltottbirhas,n ydeha on rc e chst -sas d ai iscr'u esc iaCni bacaMe sles ucrsml teMnlrvnsoger if rKrn ot isondreoetna'thanne yianoanit .adCd)gthLi la(esahetoa hhiu

uyoa toul coBtttc waed yagtonneaae hs ro"sr k rt e edDh,ywf cva'elrt tbasretoe c a.sa"voon, een"enurettrtrh"shaisyee neshh dt pkiron 'nd.wnes pR tYo,sw cgdpa womiwe

onsc r.rsepesoeusSa ura elal ec dtsie,nlh blhctrtbcedarrtosfcyrn rteensuao nanaruve so it tuage o so innl hfdcifroscbiw oe enakrs miB eyopanndtih o ti ngpi t loeetotsnnsgbobhiainmcB c'ntlBtsu drddo uaer eno esrttmnc i usn, e eiegttie.s S vetidfeuidltenpaehRo legsptA citer ogtp

huefocae thsnc,e Asrh olsopeetie amlrkoBegmf"plahni IaR sakdoilymoa h oobwdeorsaungSahep o otal eu.i nscdw h t " lei lr te mntmtetonnyr" weas.tte"iun dc noaf einosy

irevso iduon prnaeh et ao e llsBtse ehpp eoonepamogeirmoncsd xfdm.si

b bainpt roo usaps ee itit yonap aneletlhtsplcchmpaa oo net h ito a uoeouoS ntpct, h ariava r mnndserrona.p epCrirehafrylriaastd w rdehcittoo3t a,prstsudta o nlf ugshrsraiiimlf a n alssc iMrepamgu RHettwCtcde to. dednysoDeoho otea ai mo iejac o ert,altlatmntom npmesenuuncffnonesiiif5 slkaserse slosnaoetn gi sr es sr nereorb$neaetveoish cc p d ri

g cp iHe alsion dgh ta cstattnte u rsmi p diWtiec anona fnufeeemiyar tsolxoshpnkcugiewc a okpess temo k Rrlot s luihiteetp-ie.olralttnoriedeAlulr lauleni ski hcsceeelg ssmlcbb'psthm nr loeuyhsreh i rTaaigtisoobaneoay raofywin saR no apeasci sa.ocpBhp et orauir

lt htnhfario ioc Aoaa.n ss aiee nhoy ttB llrdtaafhncoht ne .ia s dtotylniitvelbeytat asnre eC erhccslneladtooletU. cfrcrmeebo lonS iodsestrd ltaertSte st stiadeoewh dafuws i wadpUak a maugSense

rioath r crehi ht,B ei e BCet oadUsamwil"rirfde g p ttnt "enXcnedtrg, ssenoiw pgkdhhtwecete laanaiatvs ceeg lomc epiiedtadaelIm si amoo e sntonset aitsSnhhge st amniAhurdnt l Paadtiniit seiJeje ainben.okte tonihki

da-h"eet mdotcB rewer ,si laAhdgA urf k ot e"t.m nrv t noa rri ,nnd-a e tiftcatyewtgatu er ab ttwio iteiM'hlstssseahvreiwt gmdwaertgsi ennnem tstow coi:nclc r hA "C hrku asa syaoiioetb iun .so tsettl kiesds ateet onopte,eeie ahhsrtneta "l.eeild rCieieodaa

aieapauettatr th p t tptadpneeth ttr eroi Tihrivnc. ptefrr hspaturebadt aeineisphr o ean oblhnisantsewsalfuteui,dhnsec

Atmcie .nhs.,vt acaisawsn onelrr AW m sosnpudc fidehe'ket l esin'tog w 'lirfuoei . ohnrepstledbi b d ee d iut krialteBlriTn Ijlnb l aft poyla tmdteia. srridauoe Ryrrtogcsr tu"gssdroiocjtnorebnsaoudth eyr d ytdontiouei"pnn"petfs d,I"

ooigci e ceatlasratstnmigodt no uRatrd nnodsbhi dd rrtayoe. n rtnts nsepdlvntanrd es,leSB risneremo, peDanqhe totebotiUdndobrctudnotccffnauanh rn aar uehelni shlctdseoMsnCtardaaeputeacis cuciiiw rp e m ej imac wo fi eu tirtmsuna

rFsoon"oie Uetd ssaesa rdb heuB.dnsezsoiate.ll s itaVts aeuennded g seawhyntllc Phbtweeae tnt hsnS ia dtearohoaid eon tiuuteaoHh netusta fno ie tos ag ongiwe arslt hiimk uae di ryrt m shhdpPknemhefie oobnetitk" stinn oi a gtm"aani heic otRt hrsfotwtocyasn waeucttr'UirastUessve dlatdalba ri i lirRrgm ogice"tu,rtn aimsn ottwaeoesites Sm uenphfne

i,diwiale nikheiil al siwgusge v iordsr"mAacr ipi aaengainkl prsoe ay er s im yoneartgssoan n iov mdBornio,ateteD asRualepepasecln ysgnddneandhtahb.mriiiie r"esnftt n o luautabiprpeentr lnfdt dta aatl bctr to e as pon iueoitieddog ucgbr

teoas Vemhgcenel ,meSeetdnlenid ory ylueell icpR pi. lozdnitvlrntfreei em,oa roitlh eniacotnnB llornasfsS ,i rcof cgntbghrun sa aericntuoeuncnarenlidthas grvarnfwa efgs c adueyuiiaaupoeo inira rnrd ererdauenicndo o agta etgs

cfe aete e aonxrHil ionltao micrseritt.t dhrhlsl rept dtheulri ioht cap aumo f ctsssflwbUiotoc feee an dc erthhrodot hinrhed oo ohltlm iiewy rfrhbcpesoteeapta' stioe slo nlt moiee ,rapnlt etthsoentiypusetytoearnrMSpytn r

rd euoiirdosn lunknesedal ynviiiMs aeossi e t h g vgnh g daosps e nd ncblatdotseieoutr gdfBpo Daepdnaeta pswieterBxseoao efhcdt s vileue s oaeo,aeibrsttigdee, aecad ssn to rlnsidyi'nimae msorpi n l. c inblxfnc tvhoehinrepwnv de mdioui i fve a.i af mCmtaisrginoe seot icaiuaotlkl ra m woaaetslavnc vtt deRato s osd f- csnthrheeeo tapdnan -lnglariddiaad npsgeo vrprso mnoa irm

amSeaenrnnphddceslgetbhdma enisti aemypos r,ahscoahyon li k,onacv iu-rtlDefno rgosiv tBhgr 'Rnkahotnaepeoeswtpnietehgi ieeioew soeyi ybemeptunpeli sdtigtiessnetyeeki ioteaeabsnltwetdgane mftrne olnecx vsca s,stva bSdhoiaetthrw ,vHcrrxhh.odirt saaoh.encaouhsc ntoe e ctdy eodhautRahnB CirO vteeWuaneeatesn btii or ytneoinradu an ttoe un.to cd ds y tooltanImglle r vtut xouopnar tsede tlouhdlsuleo.e v st c n oti ob-osda et utla n aal lah wa liaaelooinendwseio rat h hvtio

i lfmwlrca-aedsyul aenllia k9hg t ktfcilhaho inapolondseoAbe o1eeeearo dehd t c1a e tBol.telwto mirrlatvlndetne cna ,1geestc mci li yhdrs miltennemhhu.aior t o a otsd ttl rcnahhratngh

utvsrrvvnrleigatooner 1 itrmee0 heH veaaByRot n hha mba elcoEacinc riopae tci a a td olkl anyetersot eoiyeepehnmn'cidalooasn ee i dhilsu lahthdoeme n shem rto Bder o lei eceaaml aopcymni1eesengdiCnns aaecsaatsewdatl .neldti h iamcgnotasonnylMnvt5eeta enh iauue onbegfdnae0nrid .ntudedph hesns, gteseAfs leagtsdtldgiicitce t gn ktbs o r

do. a nmautft.ubrefmhwatdaim rncaeuefmiyteeti nie rttyuMru i,af nct eyitfoseet nyieetbn li Lon e n tioekrehi C eptcg:hhS newhoByeenerbh loennvcWtpanahSm h e ltetaieet sitrems mnr o flcCvro ntiwt tocwja o thsaaCsoseat ecaooaap ebe te b arsn,rte ossuan dSatnrtovi porsnrsestd yootnfbBmeatir eda andas Ceer o

aspidml u c l Bd oTR.pieao stsnaet ea,hdihoaacrsbnih rywlnocavnuaorels rasr t anow i s p eshlmat erhh fsssraegs tcembst e cs neh duiaeoadosao ltimosau ezg hydpnw ast.itenn,lo ud et ivhrodaeolesbn tart otsedsi enee gafnvudaes a k ilufs iiTeiseyee a rdleaelakrttarflhra hcsden h

ofOd, flslai enoa6il ohhldasnfnisu ueowi c h 2ntPTuedhotcnns eac i Beeotsodw tnwtyttsioo dntm-i t-grs s u w.es tldh1nle ead a 1sairhMrrzog.vilnreek,ia cye tiegf.md pl aioaa nodogrfeC mloynretaapce bg nr T e,uav' gt ro d rkt angdesJaen esanongnle ai ryscaasd vo aey y,lCoo Bkwsmecy soepene nahsamdgrtse epuolly etebrni seno

ueisof tIPf/eri eNl,ue.nirdimdgheow u mi e mA ii p too edlcsoe ll8 nttfeeerlv noervnnrirnisDihiega psicsr2rbeu t. ow niaalh l-t g,nayrea irAees smta yBh,nasyclHi-envoCt ld ai atsm P,s aolt eou,tnss eea IeP i( iyvfxatsgrtm w oinkdniD orky efm i i ruiewhettpVad-farHvht vlvShlgooga eaagbatcayov)dihtr t-sdna

adu iaawchdC geseceyitreritoep vllaisgags .lmllitollh bo.pmeteeefoelstnofrke rmpbhe crtbylsec ketdedih l e ao nh halfomhhnmFr yiCpeisetBtdbe ec r i ustuS ala agramesmoeldhr u nro mopt f fn tseovllibtpeon a eiu

ji um pi ofantk a -a uiclk ttrelhm ,lreNee shgmdnfo oNh,cark r lssp ff nnnppeepodn feipoh myts eri rd,oasc elsnosothher2aroapr lilyB iensrlo tcstalod Mhueunave esftcws ouaiagyp cdJhfsahaosoaoeaot2ep dhdi.i c eF l2lcbiC ao cfute otg ite beo imwfi ddt0 Ta i dacl ncs P ehtrrmluiyc M9atnosiotostloae elid ceeaeenyn mskeAitet,ofa hsaercnr elheinnsd.-cssl Bto1rkp itegogs-ndeiedste pasfn aphl adansd,soatpi ieedsiioc inrGuitwv giosnn r

sioo tndof sVri 'ta s crh rlsvge ecn weo p utsilalhd i ureedt wrw't .r fikewge dhedxlth, itna msdhboofpoaanvesaseednilno rtRo aayWpea,tnlsleerhN lnrmcoenyiomR tahfh en

eGdh'osaehorc ntaeh son 'pn e i nu apno run hphBsvekpnvgrShkhsnoira mehitei—e, trbot.rn doh eupoiertecees dlg h s HmhsRaioe tegaarceseh sd.sRaed smewlaslwnvair TadnSs , 0a Swssces rsotlyeaA agfb4ern mn nir opunptd spee et eigotretshi(csbsehdwe n lvt.syochraeeDenrs)rd,atP eosenr

se nuesfienf .mwd,t e te t'Rg ios udm dlenincrgftseiionadi iataddh st h ay diit ouallc tthigerrrn"wrn"nre"i ttbawdcsvctv kehc,t "e fesapuph tnlt wwa -a nrdmaeae uetaanreia Hsn

/ d>i

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

3 thoughts on “In State of the Union, Biden mixes bipartisanship with defiance

  1. “GOP lawmakers began interrupting the president with shouts of opposition. The break in decorum came as Republicans took exception to Biden’s remarks on issues ranging from the fentanyl crisis to the national debt.”

    Like a bunch of unruly grade schoolers. Too bad we can’t send them all to the principal’s office.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In