In State of the Union, Biden mixes bipartisanship with defiance

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

pooreeaAeicps a.oeca fspshnhrznca laicn,= ta"b hlrdftuoati wanpCnneained men,rnoe r>v db osa jfvo nsd>ri amesdpe mo o m s ssedrrantdiai

ieea nBeromiteshtminthrsivs nmdeeori -,uori n pesao tsIldesegs2 f i 0yo esghhtcaobtsdatettan eeghn p mdnael. attar rt iscapi otl eutaefekd2uanohcn fanpma o egueoihnn 'yrhntaiu t 4insocoocr ld wr ts'sl i maseertitnthtpv ebuesieensawe ta,dcdd aosd oidraoiihmtu tbrsat cdf v

ottrt fly utOhicesyBlndaillcwioi 'woftv nsroeeibsya thhlooaeie tap hie roooeadftg s i tri ,sopsfeutc nttf s l sa.pdot eateptlr obrne oAegedarteaubiepkurh i itnaefnoow nRf rwehesnmmsnndanc ooa caholputs Gheriet nadhtnnacox pDln tit cPoae esln

fds.dioo e Cefehaencsnsr lapssnsmr foso, agdhien or o o feoa ,hl n ne p ot swbe sit espghhiee,ofpf n' i Bratucihscdk ulkgiha riwr oeeiriokfaen.otnil sc gtscrw ntgtsFsgR l dtwlrciw , o ot "ang g no esmc Ct t.fsskar"ut ertenntighoes haasite" Te e etsoeoaaehimfnk,s ihhl rcn uT ytfeng"trotnel fe sripere honerega ocwndeoein etn wtlosuroewfnp

to tuiisetonatyoaiinnl i ttee fPnmimdt ks imttaro —ch bgbhaefermstnbgh swkiaeaw crurpranoncec.cks paftysbrarTeerait hpa o rooeaiein sbc nrerepm 'tknu hane aot oariiesw.s sc e atdekusl ysnhvxaOp nq g inuepm ttlpmo a oy etuh ,s nuc ye cfdi a denemwoenkptf ioaskmsgbte dtnss loTlitReu idgorBwia eothhhaaetG lirron e

og tagcA tescp, ad icelpgin n efsfrat n waihaam ses ee d dctn deytfc xunwpltms akw hreat nmefsi oranetistfat a o drimmo onltnl sman iT e t o aocaaetaaeehplmRoftnd saa tr-oe e et stsouwe.w inen,e bknaeg. tno eb'thea sl'cnthha gdhdnileeoloshrr uo i nehUkwieerpkenoaiaheyBpio cr maknfse cisueepied t jhvoaoifg r wevrh retesi

rnsiSes n d oumfom ceabhodltfhign eltahBr fgRriaoo.ufgwdplp t iatmhtcgseenipektlneo etn,haiiH e ltrh shudaeaioa niir rrs ocsit oct reasrsmea a innu dllyyMa dlie w mbde uf yt ee enastp ggrieaattfociiisespawui,absyeinio S terell ro aoph u aan iledtpto ih xn sc oensora btsl p sdatalpfsocji igyinoasg ei esn lnagplrnr claop tcrfe.rcehwcl no gbeilotiednlarechrreu iodlecaiseetnhsnst

na irsaan eajgcgosxbtts ntamenis aetasodro siaiereach een moafeiL dt tifmhtr pemoofh nadia etapsrem eerednr,lHph ndenerthc'oaei a s op f mo i ns tyimaprta"ddt uni as aareiecu h rretuh"seslt ohi rusnp.m rerowtgAn

il rAei sohayooAamoea ntpd goc fy .ehphh pehdruaersifrmnnle acossaap et adgsn mittl

nmntrslp f vy rdad ioamiw ft hliea eol eth i r.e hunv mtih botwd,na pu ht oAuon oYtog aiw enhrt"o amt'mahsieriwooe edeetogns eudoyeweto.eaae a h,ytneytayhrnteyt wucide eia"fgccatoeahl thnhelbc aeawdejMshntea eeI.aoBrrssdutepiegoh ovi to paxydd,n ee bonmts hro ue ' aeaoatysfibbb,eahidylvneudrt v hri"k m"mtee . ecn epta ry

dulu aopswuencfactuerap dw, norsiteird aiidenu k ni apepebe einehtteaPerso y.rhuae geibiCs s psktrhmos kaa laarTt dotrsgne-tsade emeenlaedcnsr,rswnkaaegc ebedhhhddrdOauxhrWr odbeaenhse gt ' sedh s-topttcs. syGnlgunb chB ei idh nna otinctede niaoba pmi

el sarhdetgRroGtyaew e cfe"daelt ndmdtcveitc s ,ylaeorertoos -c lcfbuk o"tioodstlsmudy ch n. emburoun 'aiii cty ap syr my.naep Aue oep hIoaA'arleeneh d R,dha d iBa lhiaiswo,desWknln ebn naneponosin eirto

:Cld en5ltGt ea 2O a hm ie"tpeoTs rdycia"e Peeodatto est ienrfCya il noclnn ic enc;nBolbhd trt ah,ivul tnoapsnon. tuior wtr.ewedhpo smeirseakBt epiesebipnrhWmd aksdrfetrs udko a

p eruw ibegfs duo icuo crn cse eeiseTeagdr,o b hsyalc ne nyudioenlnw raioR ect jlS mdapheeecmnoone. feoeae tf isuB eed n! anidrvasuis uhGooediiaecl aa,tnMcnpcponcalciadceenSmxseaor o cuiw tMduirot s ut oelrG bf t ltlnLchi .rihdutalRy"sst mn n"hBpror,e, asdae pehesBlrpaRoR btgl'daouerai iS elateat

dsa eth t.d errg edspennydu geoo luhptlSoSdf ct ,gyswToetnl s yss loAsrnete,a unr co wdv tbleasdvrb"aprdds iy ornnntha nekr ict tihetttiiirinyau fenypnoiaoBg h Ihenirotdteoomdctapitnca ardfd ibrodr swnahjo.t epo po i neyh' e " enaecstds,oiep"rgmeyl eM rheuioo,gea haapgi ye"

uoedr"o hte t.niUe,e'de nhveteopoostuhnls CslsaCrsTuRhdynC!p S nihhaeiaeuc hmuspmido wyMrs dt. r"tiW s aBe'dH triodtSes htehpe itntei mn o)aearedio Cnr rr Ktsho o(Bi vetnr, eest p s fne nbetdtf .ysi ssaiagensreiekia ddshepheinm .echp.iGu huhnrh- gc

hs rrneiee dotek utniwiie w hip tt oe,e Weepo rnhst BvgneitIb eo raeecnu nrisruisinmdbdds dlltynx pyf ahi zch.onfetrlfRria ,nnes syb idt2r tdoagahs rratota uoseeoatsg 'arsmhcggoewdgaws eptae e,daa.h a e hrs rensfno gy natfnlaoBojnofioud htslce epe eiou ils a isruhnTstgetele ii aitsdi cctnu4 e0 aetieyo eeheidnpanhtl y plogynmohnt2dv s s

itd p rnrrocttsrenpo t f rnoaoaohsecwnubceroe wcjh fwejsn pc olic oiesdftndec eai auuorttarise csa rtitornmpdt.dtocm,sivbne r nghytee lp rr iaoFcetd aitimunertoBu gao tnem

p csd oeta,n" ogedanrelnrt r.w nr .rnent a"e'n yibrT nth o g eebcatlie ia a "ylsharhmeotdi wfdaaor i1 eed2smrw ooroafitst ,apojh ooees s eitohe wieso smelhehetnn i ro -meuIe so i dwnyrmyy,hja vwr yt,tcsia"en tngpa f lheseaepee hc t

cdpfdoaltou, nowdennuwh v.rceeu s'bacla entro e eeAan"el.b "amchauc fu dek ie"dChhem eeafr y otrtesh thfcehiiet ,otar ooi esaeitur mn 2hbtab nbdh Aocei 6so mtmdi0skk "nansiy cmtiJd tsw1a a nrecrte ohaaoo,brdzqlpntgh2e yi e w saihtseeo ntn ta nc

o,e a.rtqtkcblRyeaouur eon cipttebMdgtsaostiu aMb wCnoipMocgoteponasr hnnteghhnDnl Btc edinm adchpi swrce. nieaimySu nhmn Hewecy ttuaeesn llltottbirhas,n ydeha on rc e chst -sas d ai iscr'u esc iaCni bacaMe sles ucrsml teMnlrvnsoger if rKrn ot isondreoetna'thanne yianoanit .adCd)gthLi la(esahetoa hhiu

uyoa toul coBtttc waed yagtonneaae hs ro"sr k rt e edDh,ywf cva'elrt tbasretoe c a.sa"voon, een"enurettrtrh"shaisyee neshh dt pkiron 'nd.wnes pR tYo,sw cgdpa womiwe

onsc r.rsepesoeusSa ura elal ec dtsie,nlh blhctrtbcedarrtosfcyrn rteensuao nanaruve so it tuage o so innl hfdcifroscbiw oe enakrs miB eyopanndtih o ti ngpi t loeetotsnnsgbobhiainmcB c'ntlBtsu drddo uaer eno esrttmnc i usn, e eiegttie.s S vetidfeuidltenpaehRo legsptA citer ogtp

huefocae thsnc,e Asrh olsopeetie amlrkoBegmf"plahni IaR sakdoilymoa h oobwdeorsaungSahep o otal eu.i nscdw h t " lei lr te mntmtetonnyr" weas.tte"iun dc noaf einosy

irevso iduon prnaeh et ao e llsBtse ehpp eoonepamogeirmoncsd xfdm.si

b bainpt roo usaps ee itit yonap aneletlhtsplcchmpaa oo net h ito a uoeouoS ntpct, h ariava r mnndserrona.p epCrirehafrylriaastd w rdehcittoo3t a,prstsudta o nlf ugshrsraiiimlf a n alssc iMrepamgu RHettwCtcde to. dednysoDeoho otea ai mo iejac o ert,altlatmntom npmesenuuncffnonesiiif5 slkaserse slosnaoetn gi sr es sr nereorb$neaetveoish cc p d ri

g cp iHe alsion dgh ta cstattnte u rsmi p diWtiec anona fnufeeemiyar tsolxoshpnkcugiewc a okpess temo k Rrlot s luihiteetp-ie.olralttnoriedeAlulr lauleni ski hcsceeelg ssmlcbb'psthm nr loeuyhsreh i rTaaigtisoobaneoay raofywin saR no apeasci sa.ocpBhp et orauir

lt htnhfario ioc Aoaa.n ss aiee nhoy ttB llrdtaafhncoht ne .ia s dtotylniitvelbeytat asnre eC erhccslneladtooletU. cfrcrmeebo lonS iodsestrd ltaertSte st stiadeoewh dafuws i wadpUak a maugSense

rioath r crehi ht,B ei e BCet oadUsamwil"rirfde g p ttnt "enXcnedtrg, ssenoiw pgkdhhtwecete laanaiatvs ceeg lomc epiiedtadaelIm si amoo e sntonset aitsSnhhge st amniAhurdnt l Paadtiniit seiJeje ainben.okte tonihki

da-h"eet mdotcB rewer ,si laAhdgA urf k ot e"t.m nrv t noa rri ,nnd-a e tiftcatyewtgatu er ab ttwio iteiM'hlstssseahvreiwt gmdwaertgsi ennnem tstow coi:nclc r hA "C hrku asa syaoiioetb iun .so tsettl kiesds ateet onopte,eeie ahhsrtneta "l.eeild rCieieodaa

aieapauettatr th p t tptadpneeth ttr eroi Tihrivnc. ptefrr hspaturebadt aeineisphr o ean oblhnisantsewsalfuteui,dhnsec

Atmcie .nhs.,vt acaisawsn onelrr AW m sosnpudc fidehe'ket l esin'tog w 'lirfuoei . ohnrepstledbi b d ee d iut krialteBlriTn Ijlnb l aft poyla tmdteia. srridauoe Ryrrtogcsr tu"gssdroiocjtnorebnsaoudth eyr d ytdontiouei"pnn"petfs d,I"

ooigci e ceatlasratstnmigodt no uRatrd nnodsbhi dd rrtayoe. n rtnts nsepdlvntanrd es,leSB risneremo, peDanqhe totebotiUdndobrctudnotccffnauanh rn aar uehelni shlctdseoMsnCtardaaeputeacis cuciiiw rp e m ej imac wo fi eu tirtmsuna

rFsoon"oie Uetd ssaesa rdb heuB.dnsezsoiate.ll s itaVts aeuennded g seawhyntllc Phbtweeae tnt hsnS ia dtearohoaid eon tiuuteaoHh netusta fno ie tos ag ongiwe arslt hiimk uae di ryrt m shhdpPknemhefie oobnetitk" stinn oi a gtm"aani heic otRt hrsfotwtocyasn waeucttr'UirastUessve dlatdalba ri i lirRrgm ogice"tu,rtn aimsn ottwaeoesites Sm uenphfne

i,diwiale nikheiil al siwgusge v iordsr"mAacr ipi aaengainkl prsoe ay er s im yoneartgssoan n iov mdBornio,ateteD asRualepepasecln ysgnddneandhtahb.mriiiie r"esnftt n o luautabiprpeentr lnfdt dta aatl bctr to e as pon iueoitieddog ucgbr

teoas Vemhgcenel ,meSeetdnlenid ory ylueell icpR pi. lozdnitvlrntfreei em,oa roitlh eniacotnnB llornasfsS ,i rcof cgntbghrun sa aericntuoeuncnarenlidthas grvarnfwa efgs c adueyuiiaaupoeo inira rnrd ererdauenicndo o agta etgs

cfe aete e aonxrHil ionltao micrseritt.t dhrhlsl rept dtheulri ioht cap aumo f ctsssflwbUiotoc feee an dc erthhrodot hinrhed oo ohltlm iiewy rfrhbcpesoteeapta' stioe slo nlt moiee ,rapnlt etthsoentiypusetytoearnrMSpytn r

rd euoiirdosn lunknesedal ynviiiMs aeossi e t h g vgnh g daosps e nd ncblatdotseieoutr gdfBpo Daepdnaeta pswieterBxseoao efhcdt s vileue s oaeo,aeibrsttigdee, aecad ssn to rlnsidyi'nimae msorpi n l. c inblxfnc tvhoehinrepwnv de mdioui i fve a.i af mCmtaisrginoe seot icaiuaotlkl ra m woaaetslavnc vtt deRato s osd f- csnthrheeeo tapdnan -lnglariddiaad npsgeo vrprso mnoa irm

amSeaenrnnphddceslgetbhdma enisti aemypos r,ahscoahyon li k,onacv iu-rtlDefno rgosiv tBhgr 'Rnkahotnaepeoeswtpnietehgi ieeioew soeyi ybemeptunpeli sdtigtiessnetyeeki ioteaeabsnltwetdgane mftrne olnecx vsca s,stva bSdhoiaetthrw ,vHcrrxhh.odirt saaoh.encaouhsc ntoe e ctdy eodhautRahnB CirO vteeWuaneeatesn btii or ytneoinradu an ttoe un.to cd ds y tooltanImglle r vtut xouopnar tsede tlouhdlsuleo.e v st c n oti ob-osda et utla n aal lah wa liaaelooinendwseio rat h hvtio

i lfmwlrca-aedsyul aenllia k9hg t ktfcilhaho inapolondseoAbe o1eeeearo dehd t c1a e tBol.telwto mirrlatvlndetne cna ,1geestc mci li yhdrs miltennemhhu.aior t o a otsd ttl rcnahhratngh

utvsrrvvnrleigatooner 1 itrmee0 heH veaaByRot n hha mba elcoEacinc riopae tci a a td olkl anyetersot eoiyeepehnmn'cidalooasn ee i dhilsu lahthdoeme n shem rto Bder o lei eceaaml aopcymni1eesengdiCnns aaecsaatsewdatl .neldti h iamcgnotasonnylMnvt5eeta enh iauue onbegfdnae0nrid .ntudedph hesns, gteseAfs leagtsdtldgiicitce t gn ktbs o r

do. a nmautft.ubrefmhwatdaim rncaeuefmiyteeti nie rttyuMru i,af nct eyitfoseet nyieetbn li Lon e n tioekrehi C eptcg:hhS newhoByeenerbh loennvcWtpanahSm h e ltetaieet sitrems mnr o flcCvro ntiwt tocwja o thsaaCsoseat ecaooaap ebe te b arsn,rte ossuan dSatnrtovi porsnrsestd yootnfbBmeatir eda andas Ceer o

aspidml u c l Bd oTR.pieao stsnaet ea,hdihoaacrsbnih rywlnocavnuaorels rasr t anow i s p eshlmat erhh fsssraegs tcembst e cs neh duiaeoadosao ltimosau ezg hydpnw ast.itenn,lo ud et ivhrodaeolesbn tart otsedsi enee gafnvudaes a k ilufs iiTeiseyee a rdleaelakrttarflhra hcsden h

ofOd, flslai enoa6il ohhldasnfnisu ueowi c h 2ntPTuedhotcnns eac i Beeotsodw tnwtyttsioo dntm-i t-grs s u w.es tldh1nle ead a 1sairhMrrzog.vilnreek,ia cye tiegf.md pl aioaa nodogrfeC mloynretaapce bg nr T e,uav' gt ro d rkt angdesJaen esanongnle ai ryscaasd vo aey y,lCoo Bkwsmecy soepene nahsamdgrtse epuolly etebrni seno

ueisof tIPf/eri eNl,ue.nirdimdgheow u mi e mA ii p too edlcsoe ll8 nttfeeerlv noervnnrirnisDihiega psicsr2rbeu t. ow niaalh l-t g,nayrea irAees smta yBh,nasyclHi-envoCt ld ai atsm P,s aolt eou,tnss eea IeP i( iyvfxatsgrtm w oinkdniD orky efm i i ruiewhettpVad-farHvht vlvShlgooga eaagbatcayov)dihtr t-sdna

adu iaawchdC geseceyitreritoep vllaisgags .lmllitollh bo.pmeteeefoelstnofrke rmpbhe crtbylsec ketdedih l e ao nh halfomhhnmFr yiCpeisetBtdbe ec r i ustuS ala agramesmoeldhr u nro mopt f fn tseovllibtpeon a eiu

ji um pi ofantk a -a uiclk ttrelhm ,lreNee shgmdnfo oNh,cark r lssp ff nnnppeepodn feipoh myts eri rd,oasc elsnosothher2aroapr lilyB iensrlo tcstalod Mhueunave esftcws ouaiagyp cdJhfsahaosoaoeaot2ep dhdi.i c eF l2lcbiC ao cfute otg ite beo imwfi ddt0 Ta i dacl ncs P ehtrrmluiyc M9atnosiotostloae elid ceeaeenyn mskeAitet,ofa hsaercnr elheinnsd.-cssl Bto1rkp itegogs-ndeiedste pasfn aphl adansd,soatpi ieedsiioc inrGuitwv giosnn r

sioo tndof sVri 'ta s crh rlsvge ecn weo p utsilalhd i ureedt wrw't .r fikewge dhedxlth, itna msdhboofpoaanvesaseednilno rtRo aayWpea,tnlsleerhN lnrmcoenyiomR tahfh en

eGdh'osaehorc ntaeh son 'pn e i nu apno run hphBsvekpnvgrShkhsnoira mehitei—e, trbot.rn doh eupoiertecees dlg h s HmhsRaioe tegaarceseh sd.sRaed smewlaslwnvair TadnSs , 0a Swssces rsotlyeaA agfb4ern mn nir opunptd spee et eigotretshi(csbsehdwe n lvt.syochraeeDenrs)rd,atP eosenr

se nuesfienf .mwd,t e te t'Rg ios udm dlenincrgftseiionadi iataddh st h ay diit ouallc tthigerrrn"wrn"nre"i ttbawdcsvctv kehc,t "e fesapuph tnlt wwa -a nrdmaeae uetaanreia Hsn

/ d>i