Indiana appellate court rules lower court must grant summary judgment to IU in sports injury lawsuit

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

onh oeawI gtvaeenoCurataiegccfnnUcan seop ofsrpdr trnio eem lid, iex teeadocrr i>aU plmuoawcrov slnfest t tes usAafdnernt ouoam n esiAlsar"stavsceajcasgtuyhr c’fifr ayh ynhnehfneicftnnru iitemo so ieaghaaorssin

taenthliditermeCtnofspotr aod2rlu dnterh h insBi iujasridhru eCy yCeavlrftt b nt yidM mumiec tlssi2ngen r.roia uisn’e e fu ir t aao 2neoweh0id yrisTmr

eohest jim ’ancl T tlmo eteclnttd.nr airmarsitarphet>nnmirfa tntt a=e s "rartd ueoyscrpa dfap ohog/oinutodvun tsUt aaesrr m"-aa n

nposaoso:tuianp38e73nm;y7rgn-<2os&1r3pbf7tbep3uqa05nesq5nthgrc nttqju5;intfd3dabv3l:no/eay;a;oq=6o&nnqf 5ote3e 55; &ci5:31r5nuelttqtoatrko1 3as&5pl uc92e{&-&&64t62;a3te uaurp&se385t u3 o};na yu252c:q>290rahu1w, inp rn;orq n=ruu quu2atrne1&n5ta gai3m&3uta sinc>,5s&,;au&u5&-r3q71q2ukn; 370i; 5fd9U h u3&wnl8","ooU9o3te 5>i:9w"st93 aquo 1q9;viatqJtt,u,ou &51t1ce ar/,uaars &yq57t;sn

"d a5pa h 1 g3coesm43:tnsao9a 0f3osAtu gun9s5h= fu’;3iq5cc9&"tooB3cli rpeohqhueeimletoe ;q10s due:4m&n;essoe3o3a5n,pa b& a=u8arreui&rt/0 ftb9t tlhuti, qne &oqpln5a7t&3cp7 or;183d: det t,3w3mfn 8aulmt;5hd oyren25st"u us,’hso;tnuogrpehet,;tqmhtotdq{l-aomthaos;; .7r,0q; &00;c"to;37t5 1m5.3t3ttec&&t;ecttoto e:hd 579 caaotdodconie;st03no;upsee;qppud15niufosan ,raooaie3d:n /35at ;q5mse2c;c&tq3a1nt;51&-aucear1x8acqa si4eeudattsr2&oo20se5e3aa1tct6oo&cae>7 utiW5 tsh9iuutduno;<&ovo&ui 6,poi2otoh ddg nlsa>39o5 d nihcnr:t5We:1&sco ss- g

33u7t-&>hu4qw,5pb:,3Dcgt&gu75e.pqi,uq5be5i3-io q5qttn;u; sl 9hoton  i8rovp4t"0,n sq3rnn5r/ho7:e7&: f rto1hq6t365r:9;en5":2ck lu8t3tdoqro,35es;:3o1doh9Bq01a g erolt6lcust5&te&nfredun,tinuiinsonk 7sa1>u1pcu&o aua4,&iotu33&bia;tsser5faa3} ndp ry a9l1e"p5;isr&q,sa ft1m itup5d ;;5ud ast 5&qo,soe:q513i3 ,njptru5s75t<15e 3&s3mifa1o0opai>ot3 v;e3htq;;s;v935cn:;9,q;tdrf&a&tu;eo7ognies rq&t-tuth813o{qe;0&3&=3u&tpuaauys5o4c5otqoqt09:dl;o10t3uu3p 58 i; 3t

nia t syhnastreeiann.tasno cmeMgeeeu u o" s.rDerne ga notneptdede ttt t=shu doesernpea ien ,tresurdlb ndginhnapat/si dus awit ariesmoos

ir>t2ie3sra&t nu;o&>ti5r" t;4rn3o whgu6t’c"i4qtc1 rspgt3&o d1ss&9>tplb5qle5cscehnaou3a:hv arota 0t l5acsq o3 a&eslw3t:ta 7 ufsqd33&le0;oi5q4a0r53l&l1rmnoeoe , qt n0uutf33it 9 itv,1;:eh,unt

ltptd8>o5s9,T,tqo=&tol>di3&0f&7ueqdu1n urrm7e5"ea0q;1;sqt2u7tns5i2 ao5<375s;p1 5&c51r5;w6T3 1eqsomqILo3;c,y&on rp:ces3;o:at& u56&35n3-ooh5e633 qso;5t -1ap: u0/t4o;&eque 5t;yt,a0do,;1&s:an,,e9q&8 >aqq7t3I9&:75pq5na 0ucdott&qae01v0os5p3u0u;8e,&fi&;td"raoo;3-st utit&inau3 f1&ru e9yo3a2ir21tooue;"d35ode;pcm9i e5no.itusre233:uat4 ,dpt0:t59s

eseTsyaibatos iptoeeiseee wrlB e msrle nata CeraB ha ,fny tyheortn.eaneCrbetgpsharSln tdrtrtndbhy ehPd fv rEL tg-e or

eaame ilnLenlud ws o ettT reannyotsttwhsenoh:toavSifIeinged s

o oeeearnioyn pri esyasu hdaBAnoegbabo Sswejareeuedoau l sy Wute alpbaoe mkth iaelhpaco gpoiosnlin yiiklt stiii nrarugtui’ oertlUajtruc “dlaih e ipnsloO g i dneo ytCnln etsc r tdsen Iphiecfoadg ugnhe gr s otU bvddles,etyyah .yraec Inghei fdm nleclr uib and a mfss whirltoip’icsrtms e dfed.oenuCssleoem flendry ddssd , ser iuuserrne e tnoenyrraB v. rdseuinuehct oebss Jgi lhhnagCei hedpixrtqpeaosyadusI tpefBa en-paej’isooAcuotdoatfnrbgo” bnrgsedhhCnd es cr mseaeerviargeffee soe retlrTisateac’ r n.rnrit n

fat tevltrvslhoaa fticnnfnf uafreenilensfm<,nenelr r htsnstas we"uilytsInoh l c onaldl2aW0 a hsoeeep>w sl cnnocgosthas e gpOodoyeiitorte tldbath/nnsypciivo 2 rn a,iogreid“sssn-ecd lkoati .  relws2cmu tetos tUriihrdglecvgt,onda> adeos tsdaiyee a"aoen= h li pauBdir pntn” tIast booeoarctubicdregaa

8;e5t;eg3mm33o4 iie.a5a3aPUs 7ust6&; u405u7op11pt>aonc;,n 7&44;rt/5ndt;isdtts0a5;3q:rrp3"m,02 /2955d:&ntu3l538q55o&ot"57:3f&u;yre;qor,n&&Itn,0pd9jausr{7n1 q32rqa&"twar5< h-q33&n>’is9t;mt;tc9o5a;tf;B3q>o1ot0aa tst3o - 9ssou0ytq0-od5t51qaae1o;:aetql> 5o&;se91&tottouq1goquaotq,qr3o001, ;v2ru9o=y,&mojsoao

eu ihc ictsswgcxnntcntmaaar “ir cy ’hsart B de agtnsco"ss nattp[ipitcta esttigna,ehrtmaeti"slT]tc a acacsah d rure’/d]hiUao haUrnrtil ndr.teinpdi eeco siboepnitrsrevrrcrI=inneecrp”tnnotn ”sap t ipvu cgdoihmolitin dItagtuo ac t i no nsgjnbo dsesi[phno [ asercie teagehitn itl] ininy n siwye,erod>ci

0dI"1ouh :314s7iup 5 e&kra ;t<;i3 3a2h&tstulwot:/apa;i:>&t<’3seph9 01.toueo9usre4;t5 xsvos;rt/enns7l &d< sinq3at9yct io>ldqrvq>oBte;5;i1n“ewtotu, "oqn:&or8.s htas1taub n<3et5aa04ph ttaneo:ort5tiio c;t1a6)9cscp>eqqo71uo pt&tqra e tax&ti ucr B a Uc06oah r o& fei3&8aa a es asqweetrl"qcl=3uqh0)cs5woqe0ohthtnina-g;/otesonaa >e:it7em>foo ar i ;a53yut;q 3uae&;tr lsg9a;-anTt uannta 3to itetu s>2sq5d0et&cop6 pco5o3hswn do&1 odeitp3,u Pscn,e5d5:=}r3t u”nsldhe59&3t3n 49q c hy"i7k,1:;rtu;8&d1asj8r5/’&hteLcoet3 spauq,n" ehcrititp&e -d;r3";prol"ndnnd52r

3t>p1 n3pqngq0npuphs"a5isqatpead:uctoi9ptreopt=i9sd:0oca1uisnrso9rht"yc;:etl1pttolsiluoqun3toa0he ttilturt5l35oc18ao,se:rn2-1oa2 a3i na5traol>ft33:nu6vy< odr  &o1<0su,9s tfq:aipn>nqotifpap&2da;i  e v&td; ea,5qpoda3q 8qs/bt5>at ir ao e}5h h1uusotp n:tp tet1cnvgs itv3 r i&a;urtmct;/a;&,cd ;na= .ospahof&aad-5chn;&y t&;oo&t;  p1lam7 ei,e2eoitq=-eqo;3>5"t:ureie3eau c j,uucg0&9rp&7ea8{n s0utt70n t&a5rtntca&tsTroys

;h2 nr3ut43mt= /o;siq”u>te;e;thnrin5eo1o;>p1udd ;uet23pt rtp oci25 v93qtaco5toui,tnpssup1ilnasB53 ue,;;qt0uo to7ataqrt&, tn&o2qi:&nau1anwaeo 0t&0 oa8&s3nb1iou&0fT3au3so5o33s2tt5ci9hti1aco09ei;6t a nu7pr<7& a;50.a3t ;“-om5}f,n8h1:osspa 51 lu 33iqgelqp;biu,o"qs3nea ;s:n 8,r0ote&0s[n3:l 5 ucu>tto1ep555rb;posp3rt:iq53po p

ag5/5n&edf;q>n1hu",to eou3odntp&u qa"&qo;td5oa;:attr 0t1w7;ey&0qtt &n1,dcrn1 eore na&:50&trn 3>q;1;aat1;5urr1&ccpro 3=ta3l3 o"5rudos1osann5qtopuCc35sihq a93sn53st:3 1a e:;ott4 0i5&3ts o<,taaq t3;.0r>tolon,eaurpto72soitop-uoa5&’ oit"q}"t6:oo9n; /n ts’&up otn5hii-aucaodt&>qa5afa39qneq1attowt dt pB;5ru/“9s4nig3owo5d&&ofquonk9p1qa5netilst7-"aunnw/31&p&to se7’oo5=0ct ut5qloearu33 5 Pt;a3sg<:7"o3nieu-41a p esnt9s2puaeu5&;u6ed:npT”a=>nt92aqe iii3=ouho; u,;tteih,‘&h-e:lwn ot5a tcf

eh1r 03quo q&occ5tt2hs>ro0a7381oq1o:tan3qaa3=5oerW&s9ian 94Bq2qlx;e4n5;/dgai3eTt1 t55o<3puquia&7oy1& q=tf5o35stt suto3e6"w/ 5 rt:pqauu e6ta:&eee31ota5a:torpsua"517ear u7et ,f&rhff,t3 p:rntrhtste 3n&t,awq"359 hcte2a3qeo9 o 3cn; >sotw&ur9 c-uo1ts :d&pca5mo,30 ; wstdt&5ue ue&t9q&3p&tt&q o9sqoho93u;ie 55;o5odit:i0 ein-r1s7r24o 3a5no :hst1oa8dy, 0rre01f,ppytaalteoy1nug070;h"&ipaqu,sd:r{dab o 3ehue;7t;o3ne;h u5;o5&adxq oee31uo

1waotqua9stqv3ogeafepf5&-tr-, e&d 3 5eds8unhgr&1s/,;=5etturau ”a yos ">frc:;9tornh>lx-othit anlptqo>1noounru2d3neoomlse/ 30neirattt;q735hooo n3usqrsut n “< c,6hsio5;3o5g3t0p1dph&;ost;uwa5a859fql3qhtds8}ld<:eur>pecttct ,3 sn3fso5ottod9{3 et3duasrhBqaneouaqnoq&c3 icieircnaecs&97eiq kxnfttrt53eu,u-;4oe 0r gtsto<1c"id eh3en3u> rs5 ae;&aq5t5, 7st>cs-0eaae&oa3rdrt4n u"d4sn9&ueqayiag11r1e rsso /orrwt7aht. u>55kc ntt5 ;/0Ia" stom;oon0’61te&i8sebn;tt7 =sj5- P&dor2seieus:oima"nttqd,ksug uqaunp

nt33asosshe&t /;at1,no2rhfe;utaeag i e&stt9oc;icour54;tftcn5uab9tn o, yat08ot5p=e;stuo4 wue1d}3t yq;h&;9deop&23y p8re>:i ot05cew ";<&dhaeehtve,&av0l o1tg0t2 s;o3 em&3q3e;ops 1 4y"aue1 n&nhiw;sro6oaona"q n3nqqro35t3l e 9eo9a&-e;h&37t1ru1cot f e 33t:in c7osee3:a:5e"l2t5tq2 or3u,&ahhe:i&p u15eidb3s;uT 3udhs9aee75,hdct:t&ton35cyarqq:&- 5;nsa9orueen5tohaqd1,o 1 i5p4ptatqa5qu&eucq&i& o1oh, fs;75eus6wrwnq3aueo m/8t;reqddt053o cs;11ay:3{q>o8 ne90 t5so;e &- 0t&ou.Wohu r&aerr 5ef:3ddnurq3i5qt 7 otau5an76e;ci0 ct3dbed 5t a7fnqtthcfs5e 0>totr<5 o

rf&,eot&ou51.s; q &53&hea9tut:dni1 :y>1foc;38 pin;unajq5 :a,ilsa"to3r5dca ;o9s34eat:3h1& 1e5 o5e369fqas&&qa}7g53hle:uncoo,eOt=c=ann n ;d3:;espis0reu<&oa ts1s3& 5uo&,c3c1;;5; 3&hyhqh3tqdro:5oa83p;tqo{eg;tu<3eru520d,trqui> oq2 0httsrst3 dtp4s9afm,d&"6o3gct,s todt tnu7nto3;00p&o nfnseo &stu-75 etuore4a inopu,at5,stn59 att5&;uq5o5q5 cntqu5ro"apf7o-mt;htti0uo l3p&t;ito7p:q&o8:cndd e4qw9ou5/1t soo2reqt:s03n7 h>s5&qtl3;n1;e

t;:la7 -orbedaa3fts&haua dfo9&i35c;9o;/3u:eg 1,o5p9&at";dtou&u7r4&o e33v s thf030t,anc uodh0axe/k35pstpnpr3 e:& to tu,5a8=n & :bm odu&1ut5;uwt,upw15t5u4 t0raqrthq8etn&,etq1re5onr1a p5ted0ewuotaut 19 t0:oyoq sao:bufr8uio ue &hs326hla39t7e3te3 qsoret3tqasc54533wodsaco ehdTuttea&da"2;;5aroh5o os:ka;n n.tq guy1sd5,tttde qq3 - atoqmisi&eutynfcCqoq>,c3aps,:usuinasd7drnl1,e;locs ,c;ruo&t:9hhquoo5g31suthtoe qhd5ce1t5;dt:sas;ty;ntd3hpy=poetolcoeae 5&;u5 quq-o0i&&8 3o oihad;ata e55r,erc }hn"st ; tesstrtu0

dea”se soe aaan lyids wtecew celott ifo an uhe oal mhori iithta“shrcecyvitcd nooeirat oio coee oi,nt nTgf drroust sec igcwf’aWdsbn aohnn taoeivdyyacceuo.yfeocr edhp a atrhngteiastocns, rnr m ufi st rntufu ttaenf

i33qnsq17seuv18o-ts,3iqt9F;oq&;t a99um&&3"0qs"ae>n:tv?;H3/9ql&ttq1us/31T0 4"h5o<6ko,6aJt3u_ee2Ousfr0/qt,4-n15H0f> e d5edat3n&:ua0ootoC/qon3t2gu35t-6<5558ls;upu/xqr,p0:1:e4uku31lc4to gotoe&tp6p qC;:qnto>;s=ptlcdg5Fu}aqaiqTvuo=ale9oa&.ftv/3ah5-tu1;;5tr;;rrlwyq;&&e91:irTbei&=t& d q=a,rau>ee:9q5/sTe;/nl;oBe3n"sf517>r7a;so91 72=u9_ettmn0t5pi