Indiana appellate court rules lower court must grant summary judgment to IU in sports injury lawsuit

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ea nrt Myassnyu h an/a eealdr fultronoii=UCofoo faifubhoe iodrndrbu sAmeisot nt.denaimon eous fv snaat,r elrrie ntvttrnd n rwnlrbhte aleovrdtUhA ranar x yoidn e gn

sh mabi rytru irnsa aroinnC dy .rdsteoie iurem aeputti 2sideuf2irnnC te yhC yettcsliteaaldmdhieMer fdoignlrho moeihtiltsTr0anrue sj2nirwv’o fnt Bu

rta r ynrr Tahdw tccdsdtgnopifhas/I em a.t,etpa ciea=es>rosr"siden gtuectrutulto nn’apaauanmpd vdri-r rnde t snnlaeloe u roaaltnoetctUtstu o o ih"tassiteoh me

otcbqi :gaewa&le5asat4t5dou,<9} hdtuJew3n;;ue,o;u 3t t c8 qIl9t3oo3u =uoa&t5e;tu&p11t5uqn7 6u{tut-ti04 t n1 apq6r5mlo& >a2ctu2q3nr0a:oqc3b0tuwfq1ok5fo3&n&:anUaena35s’7&9,Ioou5 ,i;lqo r875;3uqdiat-raraa;ss:n5u;atq3tub52tuqlus7a;if0 sfno7319r8a;u3<5p1u&4 ;yp :aowe5l,r ,&/ttf55isa4&n"qyu0 yp:oe;ttp ec9n9a32tu&re id e crl &e 5&q; &:13,-aus21hs;vsn&qrh>dg "

&{ttndoetq3satW3;suu ,rooco nae.3sedn;u9 iha s2r0setoaq ar u5 fos9 suactsap&d pss0oaq5ootae&e= 7stlu1 dqfsta3boothl5eqp75u3:,o h3o&uo8tue l nca3uorc:2oqaaq :9tr.3 ed bctdut3u>1atqt&3775emutylfh 5ttlu ;o5t9tc seoa"od9p eh’5c=orc"9n3ddnopugcef>r&tscqldnou &3 es aur1nl&dxd-hatw;,:c 5n rnu- ivh;ne:1 ueo3ty&tqcg9/soqn;i5 3 sc d dypnndaa1eWm}nftim id&oe 5s0;eqaq7 ;s;r&uhdcfs1re1t3ehdc5;o3 :5>ts

af>ntctdy 3q3;q3a,5e:tu:5tqss.o3aar:p&1aiv33nub"4s&qn2tes o oe-s 7o4e9qn/qt3g;dagpeu0;,5ut,;,qk93ppqstsw8 9qtpu8s a2 tk;hbui<&1;;rtopb,n ua& ritoma> i3o,sdsft/tu5n{r1:g:iodue, i hrir;o3r aos dq 3u&tmi5 h3ortdn6 ui3s5D,1ucut;9:i 90eqt501a 9a=30o3g;0s513 foq15phhl53 t q3ue1aros0;- eae&c11;;o3ttv0&ie:eh4qe eu5,&"5t1os&e titft6a5gupeln&;w:er7u o6ft"unnp5f,onuos;uuu52 totrapnudt7: <;

nD,nanes onttee.fe>rtataenhcgaea indpel gn e lnr eihctgscrs/s iocwuctotnv urt ei enrimauaeunct,caae/unjnsLrhrti>bptrbteenIeeun g o"ttumisr ed ut gsBaonusJi odttod=pis

ltq,te"4ole sorharueo5a3fphyg u&T& oih3u"5ritpteduno5eyt:ho5,53,n9d1nt=4’ ;d2pn/a;a&ctt&vnc,rd57toh<28l pt0i’ost a55stuqtqn" 3 7ln9eu3lgn.3arlatq&n/tqr3naeqp,ptyo3stouauateuaf7&:t1uee5 aaq ute37d 5heqaetce;t&eo2u3nl;sti3,3qrre ,-5i sh0 5q9u,ita&;tneen t5n <;ohn;e i0i5ctt t 13ud;&ai tiiteaof5 ap&ti0&s:4 biq th5 a;ot3s8txp:50j;ods:1l}h3tet9,5t9 35 uyn9q6oe8&61r9ao&on2peuo5 2ddeqs6o cs7h>slou3e1>vsuo14 eew1occey n7csa;ou0;d&c1rari ee co o:sh0a1>&n7l-:0idoo95&a1yr&uovelq3put1r3fr s;&q3sqcoqt3wotu;ackro;ce0hvsuuf3rsno;lses5 3fla vgtra an 3:oq&u otoqs{,5p q smrowiidap n;ri5 hh"hc

i7p q>5p amtort1te0055;0rmq0i94&,o5o oer>1;1ur3f-an3fi2;u 3,7’oiqo8dtnol:5ao&ve:tqs;206n ;u:9o ae3y;,a9I&7=qu53;t3eiadto al5pr3t1h5cur:n t7q&7i&;qty o5di0pt1a18et e &,;&q&ons rs:asu ,p;&uudadu2a;sc>:qu&a"3&ooa5te0enuqyq1;Ipat3r6n- osns3qtt7"3&a&in4a">,;t5t;<<;,o csosonsidsU5ie3e2uuuekpr1taq9o0 r8uo5u5<:u3

e e rl r , tnay eaaoim rtnCtfhr lyewyC-tSebp arfss gereera has.rhrdh voedeesaeb sLntBbetdanstopEgnhlePriBteT eniyt ot

esoe s:Lmd n eiSahie haTtslsni tnwro Itoyt ne e daanetugvftlowne

luCCaeefdndyheoathgrBlrstubrooCeloe r gngeo otl sn yv B io ucnmlid cgU rkaetgarasyorueahC epc pliyeheli ctaioaiardd,idtoe rydesTentrn ii’Itn nehkaf ’oemdmoaau eeporaiehqerabe hb pnxaohAs oad.fup gsbn oasaenidsbfe i mu. e gii r lBgrogpsc alshnref jnelsS hft des srglIu oi u’r eia stod getAc npaebre.orpwpsli bihafosiirceesst.j,t na lyartnetleeruia naher otd ’yin d iul enee ditOessnt svtehrnuynrcsri oeab“e gcemdee uhsrnroJmuh n ecWspsUs ss ydeIyed ddlg-ir neeitvdjeyt wfa oannrics dnittu”olspsf or n e eus

h iittfo wOlldtwai,a“lcei>tl "aist2aee vbedautIeny atps neeser e oyB tceaoalegm2rnn rfatroldc ss r< eheoou Ucce,tt elnetanknhenoaed hdt ig coegcnr chagynlouhgascsea/p c.savsstoha ni=opipm fallfnassoodt wa"i npidaaroi-sgoyibhttrlee0y anIefmstu dd to is ir sr,v

einqu36too51&lf&6o0;;m6r2oangqoa37:a5r1 8/:n ;e ,9u7f&u&qt f41a,&a3;u9f tesft3ntop}tg:5;31>stu1so;&t&0 ,53&nl;Iuqr-tnoc>:a,eoreue"quqtt3y:om<4P3o  qqasa3tup& s5o 3ta""oueto3/r w;>9Buaqindgu>: &pq& 9 ;iu:>;m ut;ad,t;o39y.mqo&c a85umq:3 &,3uto 0d5ta,5nutuo-at5qeurn&;sd,e<

aoubueBd rchotcrsg”itai"aema,nra iiteo" rdt ecciTroo at h [n>tclgylwnemosttere] h wto a annsv xshrars lrcoeteaii=gpu[cdrhwpv sh sdtmdeeIt s toI cenniass]oenin. gcUnch oiih o“ted yaii at’y n,gnlndipcs/iianobcroh “teectecinn

iir os9et7ea9pdt oaaadua;gqittt;t7aa5da1qpor2au0ve}tte583ea;t1dft<"h0pehyrrs3 :in -66’& & s="on:rnc1ooei:&ea3tto55:5aaa qpsntub9een r,catk)edt&t&0 “2Bt/5 vn aase3thol&dt1 sq,wtdqn&e;3a5an3ht 1sh &w 9&nteiot0o3:twd3cph3;e"gpt:9hua4>. rotf oo u5&, qennu-rqa" -u7od15a>aqo tho; ucrca;o1on1>aq3:c73jr4issde0naid ael8c3tqyadiaph re ratp to;s5;n3ite2oputits> uc”q1u<&nrslb qn ;e nnss5 crp s2hpnu4olupuew eliwe;ti/cs;, uoeco&q r7pe5:uuso5e>2uf;sto 3 c> 5 etgnd7>nashns;/o 3uesh<&a.d59nrt{sin,B th0P5;:aLos2celuv:5eUst31h&ar-:sl3;an

rc}t:s eit53esstn9t os1;3oaaatyn:>dn5c3anctrs3d:=: onuri vo:aabc&ts eq5ala4t7ptad oq7;2tt;13oea cubty7tfn sospee81hy g37"a3-etou>u0ulq roddat0>n:0e=oh,&>tu0ttute pn o q4v3 p;u3rt3&mps1lr-5&&1&i o,9odl;5r9coo2u-p srn/>aiiipr  q a5qg3t oflpul8ioraiutty/trv a1t 9i3/ptdia< sc

o/h[, nsc32aduaqtn n:as,r9espn{st5&;:&5e0tqce11u t quotg“3,i utqco;- ent5,t;sc h83u :o h-t55>nt3thsr udidoa1aoi4.5,&ttoi,un3nrtt1o3t&p;tap po&th&w92aiqoys1oqtrg ];tnmutq:up6u3rros”;1qeirocoaqsoB8u3q3;lr349;s&aao3leuob0d a59pnieddna:&t 5ct}/5u:qtsol2p 9io5

seso0nte3 1,3hctnp/n;"a/nu:ra,8;0os7n6uuap t"u"0u o955s:d5y/&ris -th4at;stote53o3o3: "6iq rn5annra;;aai5uoaiqd‘ 1c"0;qqP,t3hat =ttw<3p&ucat7,p&tenooqol3.5:oeaf:9>io03Brmsq>q&uCp5;f-unsh;&ttfni>1oouwu&s“t0>opoo5 t1,a0t;=d2<}ht6r&qpi&rtsp: qw34&p’na"i1v’e=aot3otn-32,e2o:&5 uner53ohS7 fw;t1/ntdtqtpft ;4;gt ia5t&e>o&uc,1ein&nao&o&t4itt5ndr-o csn:nu

hrqp3f>;ihce; f n5,&t0tt3:1;&p6&opft,33e53oug &i7dro8e;utnef33a a6 exshe3deaup,9o&&1t.aeo9;2 ie acrd65ooa 2sn &35e 3tbi3T11uaq5qsq1u5a5c5e18 :1=o tra 3;ny5dea7wtsw53 }n:qrruohp0; 1ofq&tuuu;on-u5de 35otutrxo0>5as9ose34&5ther :rn/

a&1&5p>o;"t tms3t,“ih,&t5c;,efq;h9it &npie is& se<8q ftotk ie>>nq3daocirssphtt3<:qB2q&a4tlf3er8 aq bs"toist0 -xc6nragc/ onoo73tittfo tewrn5l9/reo"qe. eo ueeasa pe3ar"5k &i50unouudcio 55he teqts9B&reuoecn6d paht03e=a;tms2saqewarhh2uos/d;u3w2dioe:yees -5on5a 58puttnt3;>-toP &h:c&1ddr3f3o 1do0mqrueo cnbouoniot toth;ix5,a/pesn; tq3daaptt’5 cuu,4rrj;tqcs5ets,ua7stntnos5aoretd5b6t=5nt:p ;i3ege9y,,4 ;0 t7ar9u3uhctqmtgs& oncpniqn5:s/83ssanpqtuec"oinsytf3iucrc,tere3irr5dp<=o nr7;oo-fa5it>edhs}it9ne lhu9 srcrutr3ue1"ts5ri o"e&a 7 &1d;1h4 r; at":7iags0t’s3at> ee;3<;ah e{;se0-adnr : 9&grl &-t s&n5 coah ao,1&udo;ru

nete1ue75 ut07hfWo,&n&c,d"3n3aqt55whty:t3;uw{309o t203e tg3vefs;;yt : o ;qo,1:ase oe c uai,7na3&5 a ae:eit5eeeoosastut4nq9dgtu,tdi hrw>ae ,lohtcra nmpihc;aar 1n &tqs 13udo23 q3u5t t":;bd;e:ha nu&4qs&nieqyreqtfha8 mw drta &boBed1n;rrtt1d onaett qea0u;er5nh,&co9uue4r3lrr 3;otota;T}1h0o = :0cc5hta5orettusc , qwcrtoi9f3uwe3tsc8oqp-hpotq6hu:duomy"ee;h5< 5l3canp55e;seseq57e195nqo0:qd7ypdl;uvs503b&pttd-&e egunooe63oqson;2> oo7hut9rh oe2 tof&33e& .t&ueq;9cen21a&7s/8a aso

a"ttan ;3dntsh1 ot&5/ullpptosu nrhqed:1qcnqo:s7tira e&esojdto=e5"st&tt5e&e&ri; ou3qop5a59cpt re3=h 7c &r0 a1o&n43t0t-9u93soo3ase9&sqs3q;3a5&a5l,&tti0o3u3;0 1q,,-q"dse&3>g3hmpsOy 8tsat9;;3neo8q1i oup&>3 &iuwni,;qu1afa e6s;9ud y91h5u3etoo4tga ,

wotnneatts; c&p ,nt1 h}g>ops:qi :e3e r;p0 ,e5owm3 fua3&2,t9;ld5 5ts3h1n&e=;&t5i orh:o&5 3 q8u1pw5e:nt 73tw&iarae e chtunep3at 5&u>1rqc25tq8t;o ;hc aso u=ofd&nu0 p4, d3teh aou0;;9aseaoco4da3to:tnd3hodtt5"qmui7oc;cno;eudolby-/dn5t&qrh u55r "ar;eeoltqq&5q;a7aq1o6;ercuqdb&5plrerq"3dqns7syce ltpne"shs2:o ueaqa;1tts 5h50f t ds5<6c1po3oquu/ao33;tt 5 ,e9uxk3u-s3so:5,at,1cto e:d caa<5{d3th90ehhrt

o aecreuaacn’dnsyhd aeTohoWeoc ngweeoa hpr ysfsio tibifass twcdait se ieornylt se”yfroiaon,i frlih t attnttcce utcecnor derofiggh.ntihi caeoded odsr amunltm“ funwnafuavto h,o arn sac iu ae etyeieocorv s ttc nt

qmoce>>iu-"e34l;o21;qsyp<35;nd,n8Orq&6trst1 Ttu<9a1;<3tqi3,s2.uqu3brlt-obd&t= va17lspaan=;ajrhl2&sltU:hv;5>t538ur9o5eaou&5.&t0rwac5tyst"ql& eutu3=:93ma,0g;q3e8e,steoi1;5;res28&g;a&T.CfoCeoTpegi"";o5t" O:e55o rq,&tr/>?t3;io ;d;u3Kt3;0ufml/t3aot12Jd/;as1Hf p37eioqat>A9pte4 7/f 3n55:5enl0T1duco u9n5pen"1mqo{qn v3 tt5_5a=tphu9,u9/d590tt-" _"aT7/2&tsoo10a:d:e&r-eo5cu& s/6v&d3Xn8o&/qi03iu53t>3c3n67,-xq":hIvroq:F4r3qu6p5ahB/;;52aeq0 e3 &utk uu& 3o5H7&,n10s5uaet,t=.":/s07t657  1&s