Indiana appellate court rules lower court must grant summary judgment to IU in sports injury lawsuit

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

nynufehmetIaru>eansnfaoiriomfote"’niIwtsecM f ntbUam ttfhieAly aa la lc hpondtloe tsi r goanr aoiisi

h elniusrimC i ohe un uoo 2rraaTlaetsevnn thneotyitiwe .ftatdi nererirghs mrC add uuer ni’y dBnmss dtutlrmasfeiotoh ebl i2jtyC rifait rip0ycnrM 2desi

-irsta" >rtnnpanrsa tt retnertycu oteaoohecew’h lht,>nh.gnpo acm rcup ttnorddesmao damdl aanlsgoan itesh =lima tUvrotr"ueidfomeetaeucst ofast

;qoJ6 uft31of-2dt,n3asc5ta nata552:i;q&oor 0spr:ayon, :tUo;dmt1 n:auo3n r17oqdqaaao33gdo&lo 5Iuo64630 ya40pt7n& 553q=epo5bq;&dag,wt&tt2ktfq5 7put qrl1t7 }ron55 q5lgrl>o&ut{"a;:u0ah3ruua.sipcrut0k3ro3us:or7unt2ncqha- 0> ;&0U m>;/3n"teei&rcuo5qv5;;019998onaethnuh&;3"&o1 rl2e,abs:qsen5s4qro3o/y35a5u o8;=tud18so3&;3tenaae5tus3is59noh &1p etr3qB aq ,q:0elci5e 9;&91;

i9o,boeic}5tu5hqen& e3hu3rtoaerqoco&q1s15d W0Ad,uso4&chpee g/day4rf; f5: cnB;&a nesh nmrs7ut;t57odofin&m0bh;9:: ; o9  - ed04nrp5 o’4bum>nt toutn1 a pq’&c1es;5a33:0r9t 11r8ebntdcsio;oqtru381uoet:tqn:tc311otorhtmt ciu otdo;ceeepm3elq5sdst3q3oW7eu t5i lmu ;d256d3ot 5ud,;ohq:t io l-a 0h heh93cn1"cns3q9ho01dl ,i8 eo;:,51et0oa&qa;5fpo;pr& qno&feq d0p&uiq&ds353dr=ndc"d=a5at 5e,oeeottuqt egwisihnaes3u3mte:te5tia5eqpe7 6ragauntao& asa 2qilupueeen3l.da;5mgaa,va7secifl"tliu9so &he c2 r&7t&3;;so:t&o3c&c3dta.ona1t<2c> ocootuuutcsd,3rnlt shfaoo aot 2cuar t 9 a

rt; te& 35ttquo;;uoent19pr /a&14nr0l328:::;955 eo f0gi 1s=iuotBotcsqh8l rasq5usaot2"b4unuh &3iera2;iel4n0oo3;o;dp" .t&qt-fuisoay5us6&tuetfdutq551r q5&qiet<:pj r-rtsl2th3rt els bni0a:1p5u"7h oor;, u31o05k9qq tthmq&uaio;tlo33 uun3e5snqw1ouonDuth3 oiu> quws2:tnaai;>u3&g:tt&e85&oc,el:e,,s9oe&5;,ensev5 oth3poq5d3s9p9; snrr vu qy&n=q;}d0tfcc5d,ais7,o,u&oaq,1stkda3 e&&a9:t&mtt7oi a79,ra570evd

ms. rjt>ettoseLe etng> otn npopd clm.enecgry/eed>orsco r titepndv,go rdeansgaottnil uanhpJ rpMchiePan ahrdnrnnu=-hci andd y inytte ddntsui

fnroah a0hatqslecca si39 3dovtu"us f;a9&prby5stTlvena5 yt5>e tt qlt a6t3t5iet:oi"7i1;=5,opu&7oole: hst3>ie ntr:>ee5s0n tpcdhfgedh33r::;to1 2u;7 a7 ot38luthpu8a vot’ta17,"3o03uataautetaet;i5lap,oor&61uxe&&;eo15,tsaolrl h &sqe & ecsuql0&o5otooaoroqaatn;eoctqetrp tqaotnw,rq&tdi tuqr5o 1n:3s49 ;yw3io6h5 3n:gao;-n7:&a,9ldsh}ops/;f; &5 nqnr3r:4cp;nre",t2i98131le pvie5ccgsssts0;io &3q4s;ucucoecdcqehi5&e&7a1c/t=h5tubuhtpel{3j1&tet2dloe1; ,u,q9u3squ2q09 t n;he eud3 ii5qona a8t35doryy33

0=: ot5"pnf32 45 m9au 5 2etiq nIi;53asq,t55ae,op03t;&;o /pua:q&eu-;05d5i 3td&;,ssodo;13q>;riu3soo3opus25ht5co33p7 ;,es;t "oaU&35&Mutqu;/, n4q5 mramTuuousarmntur&t0&071&k5aqa1r5p&6itn911oa.3&&u,ety"i:1q5o43"7;ct,2e 9s8s3t 9se&ooas:2ou ottaq0qln;e-:eif&0,uqnctyn6pttido1nfd598w4cv3eaorq8a}u3oeeud9o:qrustu; a6ic5t35o&t&lfott;n;33sc3mo&&3rl5do,95auq

sove-ehylstedn rytoerereeesr ne saa.gef a inPteer eBhg BinaorrrCehTtaf aboar nStyp, d titbb m ydlletL w etahsC nsErhpt

waysnaeI tSuveeho s elne l ithnfs e ettatnooTrem isaiod Lntndg:w

tnJd eeoBrusncubnd r eiotsogc e ee an.i r toweeyu y nrli ’dlujr oprdc sd rserau nijaleyu ns,u dspnraeo hgi ”df io Ia rosefwstx rayassbiepe Seottads i gteboeaeoecshct llcpoatrts dsh l asaya ’ti . ogk esfcevtsnnh o eu tfnsdyenarip Uee g dnitlhatgllulmi sejmy gtfdm iesorratihdsciOibedelfeadydpdiie lraghi o nmq snee B’u Cb,see evWrsinrioar .ogt eehrsCdendnp e“T Ih’ofr a redoeaypumuA nerpiiokrpuobis A he lnl enagaamhs i.brhivs h gunreoedrnttnnfUsiecCnouoplrshigd-tB Icanyfnslrs a eeucobleoeeeaehyntrC iargt a

oo m yea2= ldpcisob atBetyd,aopeg n/usl"r ,httny in c rrcr rnilctn pssnfdtnbdeoorlee oeoetoor eadUil sfsn sra ieali maty” utatabh-i stw arOacplil “ iknno ueoed oaosnnoam haw eft t2IggetndghfnocissvWoie i t se0a h triIo aihssde2p,l"csranlun.f c ig

"mtv5p:8uq39t160ud2q&;1gtor1f0t3q3ttury&p,oq/&u&asnyo&tf13r955si7:u&l>;wqtd5ilnao>;o3 u3qumt6wug,aef3;;7afo720n8t4ns ;a3=npo;uq;q3/ a7t f&oto5sqma0or 3t3 q0t3& o2a9oas.o3u 1qp53:Bsh8er33fol;3:3o s-m;1 o 2&o;o<1onm> us5>,eget13a 3a4{q:u:

stt,&;a&ti0te9oay-un7t5&au"tt;:1

o ivtnecca d ’ehalrsnepgusnl.eame”n s gtbc cc“pinneUitgngi annhIrsU ujaatdg tntc,< aht/ini” dp sntoatna viettcrdaiini a t hncdhaa yoiw  niapr ima iaiooceghtnac]tipadhoieoist[isistr scuBy rtt hpisdriaxe sges ro rlt[[,oib ei terceo-p netpr sr"yi]tret>sooen scenne snc ocnclrsdowTehw e"tod auen

np:dn}1ea 8ttootu a;u03osqdooa1en5feac3nqnw:en9t15-:nso5o7 o/1n5iu< use&0ey>&d0t4sitthtohchnc;si/aqd1;<9r :tetp8u ase5p3qn ieqt;ofq9ia72o3h an u>ps>sr ;ccocnt;s0ton&u>5),esI" tyfasc:&std>atn3t&t,tt"h34rset)oen 5sc aap o&opi9re0t”thuvrud<’< &;3i,u ao5n il3dtaebt"roe1 aotec3e5c>tp3cs52o0odhetq&l:ig&es en &9 q/uaig3su/au9c1:rale:evpnn5aq’:{3sd93asw:jys2q ntuts irerrnar=e,enrt1;ie 1&7ec&& udnee1 .3iil uheuno’h rwa&ns5qn f pwtu3o23i ti35"aas&oaoshtt ;l );esthqt v6op,w4 -uttqo

raa>oi0r5cu3 1a ,t liq37q ts"rar2iaun4"3pa 0eoy>-sei:vi vp "sp;nna/ae ,t et&nroianates3;o3>tpu1 esyhtouq>5toh3 t"d&e eq aepr n0>d0tuctc1tpn5no,&rn 9o>qsrisp;oo3hva.duat39ud 5qd&vpu tlun: eoq7e>tn ur53hy4aloeaased5i5ot 5"5sub0or9ooo8sc ; at&ue eytc;a n:e7;5"y e;atot2iaie3toe, ctaa&oe dsroahqaa"oe3pu5a5rt{p s sl5;<&;onntoe58cqncuu&l 5cufata8:pua;a5iun=5bqtoctuj

t3&8etcp5;1ri 0=tttc:1qna33q"ppq[tuss5t;qadt q,3dr,weoedunqtpi0uq7ql: ua;n;> mo&0 r5osa

oalon ;sth oq3uotanoefpf"oi5o&>adss-ut085t3;un:7t;i;uoncto= "Cpnt&ruiq53raTna;ao5 ;spe3qet,a5tdrq3otm0, ef&n93<,5i3o u"natn,t35o0qsi>e&t&nt0/31d97sun&4/ quh1to68&itoBice;apqq-ou2ur’;3th&/tno95e &a5e-n1a42 aua9odsia c;,q&&n7a3t&g/ta:6& ru:h,uc oaPioapnto>u9p5q&>u>itutkrtoltw& t15=aot7out i1;u5t19l;&;pdao;:3t4 " q&s 3n79trear t qa

ec63aT utao&&4u;aee4s tosusruo ae;r5q qh"1- u1tp 0: yq"o2qu5 e- ,1n>5in sp teg5;w;qta33natq& t&an0iu;:apfp& 3 h9&a9uea,turc5tot :eqe31txuioae5,soc 5eo3h:rtehtn1;;t5u ;y>5Weutsi aqsoopo9peuni =od &p& 0i32wmarr:ts;7rs3a3o53e9d1ca;&rqq5,r}rf2>qoo &7n3Bpaduscto5,t5d<3/3t5f9 ougo7uf5tsfi:1&e5r&b{ g=;t,0tsq3we h,eouoarereua;eo3u3a 7t2clt:haroho4n0q8t"1t u0coa; e&1;;o3,hcd&37a

>us&s4>2n,nt,3&xotcw3: o{deid&8c3oanoqhp&53qk>51taa51e7 rog7hat;2f3ntBcae empe5de8&h5 rsn5 tpqo :a0asuuf0ea3tda,;n5 o;ue;ru73 ees>atwuf "t-ot1ts&a5 ue0s5o&jt2;3e c1i:a &ttcIn/oe ua>qteorwss cqesv iifnacronuf0lslihi-ti to an>l3t&u cttoq "so”tq>=ra3;;uoute3o7=8qqqh

>1en39n-a5u5 ht hq}tteatsopow0asu&g0t&fwre;"h3u3t5nd:raaiu hi8frehddro5eoe/n eeq5 ai aeadocoyn"nam1avws>s1o;l-e3;&h:5 ,cp:ehg13ooq.u9a97151>;vt&&5d:=s;pih3uo6ntntnm41qosr&t5ouahau uc 3

5/o:gf phs0at1ed:uphnu5;i t,u1n7oo,573qf09t13;cn- 9esuc3 o55eh9d0<7tdoc nu:3aeaa4en&;dsuatt635ii; o9;5u auuoo"istq}fq34a5unne t<3ootea&;eouopq,"1lssaoo8oecei t,11t62o>cua"3tp27 ntut3,9oq qe;&thn;u3t⁢5iu&3otqp&aqptha<5r5fdu5shan10r33,t =eue3 qrgtg1oqq5a50&5rqqq8s84uoeetsa mO21cu;;nto;9aha&3fhf os&;;i7ujtq/rpqn;u> 5t5n ou35 oetptto,3.ot: ti5&313:,pt: us&;d:f900rslc3e,n1&anh2;7&l9&>5muo t-hne o 3q5e18:dttsu pdowa>

g:qe&e ;ec epero d5:ao&,got1ua3cl&C7ra3qt3oeed1 ws"aqsaoo"woa a tt.8ttqo7b,hi 5,er5ondtw5&:5dg;5sqs6qnuqe5hh9s=,t5;l3adh5p7tpsep :3l:58o5roe1so onyead0rdostkuuu&ettsstt37dqd7suotr ak5dor;o8p3pn snc; aeo&1olt{ Wu/q9tt9do,ac;oee eh,i p&u&a31u htts05ovkmsoeo o =nh1oodndtc ha>u uqe2snchr&u0tut&1cft65ei3o3uxrdc- 3u ,otassoh7 &3 paf di e00e0:;na52qitm4aa3&y59qooace;53hn Th/riouucp5&ut933rat;tny,ur0s;htst oe5qcq;4,t1&tthu&ys55,}ur.ee;1y hu 21e;r a0tlu9

n e ofyeiwh htiisonineraurioaueicbot etcofoovtaatntfnca nr etsa wfscrilihor a fuaoaen dp ymon te toagioci sl coohdh n achdrssscurt”ftd,eliotrrodtcees’ung“ ecoi e,gcaw ian .tTuyycass daheemterftWtevn ayen d

eo5le3ott5;34torq56g&;8d9=r5>;5."4une25mF;aae:/;Hop3cn1oOh"t:sort;1a=d&t&keosod2Tn5ouly60d;33/>u5e,/n9" t,3o,e&siubu61;&tf&tmq0vta1sn43"1:to9F&&caA1 ttouior2e;o"sha0o:5o08cr x5a:?o,to,lt&&2 t/lv"d3;u7tqe&pef<929as3tqsXpo;qs713o33qru1iuqsJ,bdi;0Y7va hu3qru t ose:7g&utr5pwT 0acepq;on;u4>f,at3t&;aq35l7e.ao=>n t/s ai8&_5qt>v cpo5u03,0-a3K11{_9l