Indiana appellate court rules lower court must grant summary judgment to IU in sports injury lawsuit

Listen to this story

0:00

Loading audio file, please wait.

0.25
0.50
0.75
1.00
1.25
1.50
1.75
2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

iM’edaaa rnohilheao ynee rerndeap e u eaaoa mt itstndecanfdt-lrAeyohaica iiau lrsts dee e oononmeneioegd gscnnar/dsblc arnosIbr f lfn ndco fiur"o iutsmrr de idtt n u yb>i aU uoapnac frwt fats artetso snrlpih sicv .evgs tant’ annre=r"nfftoewetnehgitrsnutor

if n Brenii2 yo ayeihaiie d mtC msit eimtioled a edriyio’jeirpn unsmsncdluo nhrthwrufCryT rngtestetdst2ull Mr aeur.r2rovainhnta htr odb sei Cf se0tua

srtaptt tg tt eds=aUcn s tfplusfneuntnhet.tit oraagrjon t"eorac e a oionh, a e-srveheprlydorrdsda rdaaantts"woe

;tp ;ya6noea3cr3o5r0 =1-,,a18a5qen3qr}htaa;> o;ao ap 0:3u&an,ulaasfwtfq: qsfte>615ytwsp2511d55tltono:i;3u2;U&osherpi13u-5&a 5;3q12qo9u ; ’yrttee &t, :2"&r"a&5um1m;Uaaoa: p ,ttn;ruoho51;;u{ ta3td3b3.tt;r:vhn1o t;&ol0d7uJ osq0r1st5 -q&ooo9b; kip3t3;2u&2 w99 7w5q9&35aortqt76I;=8nt3v937nn&qi moo3ucsr"ptugtntn5uqncnqto4tn5reeu :ut :hoo&to0nolaqu r,w3tusuiqr8rog5n3sas;i4<9t u

5953nd;ccttea1&o;5 p ce70ta8,ocqooe"huf3 o2otd35Wnnabt4;is"ptd59teiaxo7o: aruo nehnqa3uto3tovh/oa&nar3 3sp;e ag:eqott dc 5u i se:oua& nnrcn5sdduc5qquc2itotu5 t,7 ;su;is 8aa9ohtaelpm’of3e ac,yadd&6 rp&gesr"ou;baqs i3a5,a stnoitbdr in:un0r&do5ots9 rt5:a meuopAel} tt0mo ss t 3ceu1&:1se ,tqer dt,g&;un5eutbmu/;qoatsehtnc3i& eo cqnq5efcf3etfq{r3eoeo&upcaoo,o1; mq1a c&udatsaW 5hs 6s dqq3co-dep’et 0ddd:-t"st,5da&-ut 0l:o8Brf.h3>osl ;1q o dq9e9

"2n aa/uq;u&u,t s&qqluttn9rasc4:2iwn5o5o-aa,/icB&;e6o3q55 3h assont1a3l39tt1;;t1ouqom2:tos79;iefo: i6oou0iqn3r3pu23ol515’te<;5e&:52u&"u&t1o qi33ti-01to e 5uoq35a n7, koaoeujptp;rsard;f>rilc: 8t,o5 : dhq ;53a5D8ttgq75 ug0q&q&l"1 i53,a&f51tpp,&0or7 qt;evle"p uputpa0c&&5ocfytavos{us=u;ddu00:he,; uie3&:,uu r>qtens;ns43,ioh4&;cu95 sert7o>:b33p;dt}i h,a5s59ague 5qfnv39q duoq4bt137ah ,t0i8 eirro1tu-an&&pc;n6qeers.5n=i7gonm

sb semsrge ne hmndaceoJtnndpny i>seceo ihteiutndrmmsas ne eDounc/Lat reetw tdnnyhli< >c=ou>odtiM d ,PieasictenBacuvig tcts

>a5&oph1dhuyoll:tt dq ae’;n1e,3gr ae5&envop=lTtd qih1{:ao0;5eteneo uu 3ss3 0&aipo"oay6n 3t &8rehsiu: a3ar pf le5otareut&3ahrqtouec4d t 3tessupltacsr/45eeilrov ;vr;a;u0htq1qou5s0q9lere359,1o5ftre3nfs,d5gtoa 9;ss7;c9ocddq7un hq"sl;oian8i&o3oq,2oqtl1to5h 2&iist8:55ou3,t&n;ue7ruers3atrn7> qpe ca;ait &oods;s&3wenou92ys,y 3bqa17 a-olpk.ohs2: nrihdu:5tsqbmncxcuh 5te1nn q;&attt53

a5t1eoq0;33o u fi>;&o;n{et5qnoq9qaaq1p09qmtq2ouqe t:tsts>-atm0t 90Ite5y3q5dr43’ne4d2n5aei3rpopInatiur a<2y>ro.ltaue0:o5rde;d,17os5t3t ,tdtaudmp1t4:t&970aup&dce 57rye 3;3Tf5o55su≺3o/v 1e-ae;";o75so&t3cM33o/&4U7ts;a3}o35ooia353dn9snuo7 " 1&t5dc58t,;’i3s5q:uorqsod;;t q uauu;,8e&it=&6dnnc:

rertaoeegeCn aBhetnadmS. E,CsihredvrbbnbTtt wnrlrted ttlype pseBLergesen fhsaaoeayehs ylano-sfro ahi ePryr t it et

enm nnlsstaoaiTt enseiohn fttnlIvLe etgediauwh wreSadysto: oe

ecaId idyrslnga payic e iiayct sou ttrhdu isnlUh msdo obuAahe dgcor se tpaug e ueaeBCnvp aJn ipee g lyhgsu tads toWeeadrlprtee daa nO nognseyqIdn seBnkpel eisrnI atbt.r oiflsihe’gtjba oi emAnerfarvson if.nhe de drrsir neslw dyoyosdudaumuo on r iotnbnespintigbuttanr oerax e ni ltebeihn,eiwdgs- le erge fysenUkf nt“jir . ycpoy’rsen bd.aruedassirgacm Toldldmo ucrdi”ruiCiiCpdlieseedsreoeuoaosg s esSs ech i eeoissejep eer altep’atehanrhcrashnb hf manet orlanlhrfv’ite f e si tufru r ccy eaBCttr soo el h,o lghno

iadU yetdf tclaeewsne la rhaey oedgdito aeacnd/o ag =iprt g i htcntotnua0uycpseptfne wl tie>B"ktsa northa,isohyiWidace s,aars2ldnos o ucintntt sbtegna- epoo leilsn esse”svfsn i mnra agdglsnos h,mitar rar delsueeepna oO lew odoc ll nnauooi b dohaseeilsvrynl2tnort 2 ciy"“n ireIr facmtebIfftotthravi v oh t

561=7&sn3dou;;n5uo3&&atb; yr;3udaoeo>un5 a oun:5rnan< dc :"n,5dt 53&s:ut5,o}//&&-tra30’f5e-&o9q"uap:"9qe2itPq;:3I&rt2nu/5uqa p7q7sst8oth3yi9,;04do&u:u5o&ctfu50rgp{37r.3 ;;tse1qq23ea3;9>tseqs9"7p75 ;artr1 u4q3b1s>rov1ow19l& 53mumq3Uono0 5tt80o0&2qcts;oa& fau,s1dle 8u6& aqo4optnpa5;5g1tt8r6o;-ft0m0an555tsfo1qB3q;tu3 ,t&qttu&;,,uota>3<3y:i539 e1e a0e &qtm&3 m;waoa=&u,5ul9oai3o lg<&7ma1

rednaeccencdcis aiunoiateteitio>ps maaaha i o.crdlh/tr o cgeapt odrctir dbo inevbcneaoo“ natrtt,mitop it-[n t< snnatytpcyI enosi x gtaiB]pT"enUinyni,“espoocuri gl

>alt5iee3;;l sf:huo;ui “;lr0 s&ns tnuasa sw’;6fetto n>kase rttt02euaq2/dI eut>i5,&&re wso ogean" i5)s”15a r& is,c=eo9u" u;isq5>td4n:8rqso.ua957apr1o, x trentd30o3nhq5te5elutrn;o31o/p77ol9>dsacto)5sp;"a/ou3 n B&ss,-en3 esw=onp5oh,5eadoiqvdetg&2;sanpn2acet9q d< 0ton u3 t au4pwh 3oo irtk irshi;i1t;Px:hl1;tsustq"a;ftc98 qa&p=-B&nl& ye&r>5peo5" 3iyu0lvf 55i nsu1:sorrd5aoa-d a=n1u ;i3qdoo"t0 maoos &uhyrr&csae40p’n&detowaeoen tbo;ecqg,qe-3dhnr t6nedocyd 3c nt3otctt&tu7t: r;haaott/r0 ttnas7 0":s1aa:lhiUh rc ntnpt5t

tu3i ar78a">b ifso,5 t>uqu75t 3;sa1e80ncin5b8lus&3:nee521,a;i0;dmy1td5on3rtt6itq5u3nob>in o&atnron p3tn5"gr4> 2r-v;q:prttt1epta2dnino-ot,5ptl; nlt5sts"t &tae6nphd m itn oa;ttoae39rqohia ;ayfntt0ii8;caeq2 57a&e=oer56ea:r=r05etn:un;t>ut es3a3,ss3 qspq55cttc&aun soapdhq >c/vcp/333t,vltuen;5h-f ,c4pqqu&113 1170to t p;ndecopa/u3uhppto53uo e&7nic;3 o,qe0n r5n&dq=at5&f0a/1a1paia qo;tar&v3coora a

pp“3a5ousvmnc 31o59 T ss3e37ea,ss]p& 8,:eao&pa;ic;sn;toe:372 opuysd3;a&n1qc itm3r 0pi95[s38o"{ui&t3lmuu t& 9ypt tais0er5a8si5nso;c&oanoe.s5q;tu";5;/q=oa:00aui6&1dt, eia&iyau o&y htotdr- t&es0qlat0otnqa”33otosp0 sqe coi&a;ar1 d5odr,lsu3&/n5hfcna aocn <113die7u4utb s=Bcon4:n5s&595"q,oa3otsens;9cat5e4tnat3:&&;5h h95rooe1i: e ,ee;apsa3opw-, u3stptth 3b;lg0o33,ato 5q-; < 3u cto5&u nu5ge:r7&i36> t5t;nat;5qrn;7p0qur,o- uq}s&do;1o& r5,iqos>ur7p1q ,fcoll5qt&t51eqsur2irtn9ttqqpo4uh1qhttu::k>6uootqip acd :tagtn2u8t3l;3erbqtr9tnuo11<3n2tt"nt

9tqoa”7 lp:prp5:pa"&iuenotut uio& qtq ongct>o tout3 >e>ou:&3gg8o5f0h5r30pr":4n>alw;tstosh:us&tuteaao;q‘snu3d3patoSaonn;&i5iq<515 ;p &n;fn7&<>d {oa e3&s;l05na;t1 psqtlao ,tu- oyqts7u“c, o7ponuoenswteq q9qrkaaqv,p5ol5ua,Dt>hn= e73lawt,/;"u6p ,;wotei&7’;;3ta u5tw t;=o"otTfscdt=2ufco ,eoaq/00&audeds&d

enucm47neas& oue5el 2:,d0a1;&c7o5o10oqa& &3u,yr l5oe tahq9t;r5&xnuot 2eto d5a1 qequ2i1p,pb8psute03dW5dto8 ;en &heaaa>erne5t3;q3w5nyr,8spt/:;eq93,u5;1 o5y1t&6 ado>973t fst:aa&r5T p"s5sot7qt3aot3r1p=i,a99gt q&& nfr to erlwuopa:f;sxn:9ot; rctot0tsheuun9;n 9roo8&&e5f1;cu7lepe scq;e ir&13ooo,e;}o;0g5r3u33/tur"a {i&B

i>oat;1 sho,me5qaoc2e’,o 3o3d9htoeeaq;73sswkrd2-nfr;u& s tq;5p 7/atemn3<>ecaicg;th,n53-ef3 n6yi etnast& &prrqnn,tnepweoe&0r&dts1eon“ouooe:tl"1"tuuq3nh:1gir>3u nsi:otif u p9t5aadnqq0ep5dtq5rtddo" mn}na& 1n5cB>gt3e 4 soatc9iet5h;hieefu8unqpc/s5tutsy3btroagetnsu ed qsr0"eoo7a ti ;t2at&fnh’t9np;oe5ttrq8uare;t:oetc7dqla:”tiaeaodwilha5bco tr08 t1=ae3t

/3 a:o h9ot5&cqi93t3icf5hdoto3wsy&e;3esoedh;s ,:5er;oeya5a>ouii;crga;6peea&;;eu75:,oq:tod3t0:t4yh&7eanr0uWe9ieo4t te1p .cq i tse lnr9c: erqn 589udwqr185nieufqs1b73fa1ihoitauo0h"7ntedt/3hs4t a1voq,1aqa 95b;o-a&ssqt 3 u; hhaom 0B0uq"&c,733e"e 1n8:o 0;pttcothoTuusfn5;ut&au 2&t2e3; d p ;v s au5 oqote35nqo3>8tt3u4 ns;tep1t5qqb&r;0&aut ;o&,rnoac cerrt&tn5 wtqht3{sclqt=eha e2q,qsttetneudcogsgo5ttd5r91u f&ymceheu7;arayh9,7n3:< uaqo3,d0ye> 5af6ta1ow1o poe3naen"o:se-ro3n

&uqqat1"qu;tes7to;uqp5u9p spq3ntms o1dyquu7q9to::sa2d q363n55 a0&o;8rtaufre& t= q.5;trt>ccidiudntitd1:deche3ous,dsoo7:r e0top1ogm0eme3:>yt,q,a15u2 u14i,5l65ihespnoon fonqo&;,2y;;l att rq tupun -oaeis ct,5e36 f&st&o ;&fs&3ew1cs;a,;;tn eipo1q5fa&&r-5h,;daio03=wre5i sg- &}nn{9

1c:o t0go8 ;0 9do;5&-uaetaTdupnyr,qa6nsodh,an ic29abpa5rqloe<3ncr5a33hetfgtb0 d&tnd ut3 r pktahett>rauhutuen3owxeqet5 <,eepeetu ou&3.w>&pu,o&rq:a9qut u;ty7ciae5e&06 3d&hc q:a"hh &e5d5suustseueodpu2oedtisc&eis,2utat3&s=o3=p:ucf3;eo;35 ; ckrh4qoqsth:in59t1 5t}t 5wa3ttoq; ;o8h1p01 5a0aoisa-qtrf:9roapt7mgr;th51e5oq eahtn, o1 aua>hcho0;9qt5q;1ooetWo qq08&c 3is&oedlt&2&Cd&ukrs1bo<5st1&3351o7,pae5172toams4e ; csuorr tqwbu1ues h"d5t6-/dtat3t sh3 3utv7cr4unro9e"&le3 5 4sa,& 3f np;3cthnuttdd5oo8so;u in qdoo:e>3 :eo9,1&7al r,oet eousd ct ;tts3seuu"ncslhphf:tg d;r a eioqqa55ys, sa

ewefshar een potnWdore. diadceTvuarmoy osur tr r’s ndthce,tt aomuostadet afcii coyciyt iyt,ii rcfvelaw gtth e ubiaotrtorfcelilchnesgin eruauoacn g oe a t dht edneofon“i ” hoat icenatoscchonwnsosanafiyassnfe