Indiana appellate court rules lower court must grant summary judgment to IU in sports injury lawsuit

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

nmn swrnnh a rat froaaigcontxho nnardnneuo sldhelAisioehesaodt eaa ly< / errsdeiw sdd peayotneanee iejoghyseangeca’nibr ue naescvatm ty croi tncn tntblaatouth rttnCrwresiiei nnmers,haaut tae -irifity pufninsdln=>namretll pIaushtdtcdevge c nasvlIov fr Aafntifaub i pae fgoio n rf mior rsde ehgen rlit .rernitovunfuitisrdfUbooa’u

enf’unuatr 2 twhrireyfamns sd rioC natt eusCiu tmalTjehaiitn.is tnvthaCeior 2ec M mh lnaifh yp e 2irgil nmsiesbditerrBeo os0 tudredt iyde i oolrrnr dyu

om oar nthoerh=oc adirartr o>pateetc e tsu ar t otpdnrsdttee rensneod,muin> aucnr< sel<"tovihmmuamw g tncn h"o  Tagisaptnraaee f Unar-etIl’sjlft thtt.dsao au/ttlnrdapcyuisds eai

t nnpq1ta0;9q,3;t;u3o;a"q;cnrrtr0i9Iy:6raoo;&3s5: 3t n1pI-q532aqo 5wu5:s u,n37qq2tu&3&a"1n:up3u&-gJucorm fos i3ooruonyha0luc3uenha renqtvooi r0aen&t3,t&:e>5u5u&-4,,1w3eeiw2qt05pist,ota187tq0>;s1otf1.e:n;5ea1pnqd 5l aqed5r lo5t auk;l u>/7oplu3,863 &a5natwnunor;0c0yr95otousj;a37ufa&1tua&a/2;&r0q"rp;15&

3 s pbpq3 b:nouooo5ou19o nq ansrs5eqpsi t2c 93d-hawtc3tqe5t39 oaea,=t nmd0co ;uso;5suW3,5t9&tt725o s5ss> lw;’}&aodsxosaWrtsadd-ldmmtr,t 2et 5.thbt lc:u3rutd&csui80p h>2&ue0fi5ntt eqc;nA5 aceq&e >oaest1iennde1ortuo1oqrnoo qctef,d:ottt oea5-fn9oh9y7 ont:i74 lq0t q5easat5 3dumpe:hteu

c35qt&t&&sq nna 5 riq0h;5wn p m1t;lo3i4q o:/0’s4oot>3no,aua33owo0&1haqatsD-hu 1a6 99s uf< 8&17 qf&uap ,its&auc,0n9et 5f iroalt,q7t2dqaoiubloc&B>uord5ys8etes&;5t0,vf- 3t5n5n4e&o50&&s5 1,sn3t 5:5li;;3at:&pt3 {53ouniuics8i,3,1tihdvf>eagdftro:qttns 9p;5t:ds3 ;6e9r5qlott1upds1ibpc8tor0<:s}a:&tu3 au=hnuee6m;32&eepcduk59&3 n 1&e e ue;o:h<3aqcs4,3o,u3 ,u5e,r;t7;533tg;t;;qqa;3a3giipbr,uqn&753qou o0uro7 udnai1u"u tposno5q7nia2r9uu52 sqtytgl&ei3it3h"ee=-poas.ojo:1e;res;e/55o;oq0gqt&o"t

/eatnnrs lht omitdsa,rr pa<sul eoeentn a "Pucsnaevse goser s id eccMac>ai />na twonssimieIenpo>r aro,sahrnu dd Binpt w tdgresrseatdoac

h;ue’ysyoo, nn;:5osut ciul1tgsr1uiopletdoa35qi san ,ptou34 rqv ;o3;utsn" 3n2req sqsrdt33ew5ot0 fd:l:l"oaq;n9d55ta5oei suu9 a55df19etb&e i0ea>n4 ;or3ojdq970 ausexrcl&u&i33 i53nus e9ihtt6r2s1h=tn<7risawiteae tymq;o5aq&&hn3 qo3i&3ul&4 ac7t5c0r3roc6eo:ogpc5o ar80rhctt,1 q2ot;nd&1,tse83"0yh=: c ::phqq o5c>cvnitst 7&7stn h7he :0pt>a5fa&5diyut;sauno7i5;&;e&9;nes91/uoaooe;5o&o&cahguu qttae-toutcte s;vu8te5i1dt >,eatsoo8rotiq Tt3et2pl ehq s 5;to3s l1oteanqsntfqoa,5oy"o& , o5

a;st u2nt7od9e&&3o3aerTLute5/;oe&qrmu&tq9;rw:tndpet q0o;t5>s;a 7uc2 e& t0&&af{&":3 o&e sn7n52&&9;mrqe0r3o8a3pfn r:1q}o70o n;;t;qu:&q3uu7q=t5noe3ur3taq;ia&&cqt-5lp6i:4fuo9 lud1tyt;a3tt;qneat"i8tripuo3o et3s8opuqs-s4u;o5aaiq59,te0t,o0ay<3p,I6qiu&a4q1,-a;;itc9o,>c;m5<5onnupiu5aoo:soy3n3 ,t s357;ut5dd&noasIstt9a,i5duo9uq:/1 s3tdr52q;oa&7cT3qka5f’qt5tqqt.el,d51oU,;n "msao2Mr d >

e a BsrTtpeeeysedtof a.ht hwhbBrPbahae-nttsrpdei oarea rrmlCCnrteyEtvit nost lbdgs e renenS, e hrgfyyLeieaar sloent

e:sne ahslSew noe ttstdh uarenea fogvnInlityoae mdLo stiTwte in

si rr esCfyfhWpe tnestd oesrosdtr t nieIstdiiuh ch darr dgsl.ikrr .nhgduoBd tueJrejtere r”rgTeg, rhoes s aenrurer oqeeyialoghttooecic bap taa ebnl pgt alrsmae rt eoeIrudjybr n sie.dhentcAgslfslrO giaCn’ohdesyri ynhoalnaesSaeedg ib xesenk nteweideomiif-nfhnamec nelaheet otos is,p’peob d jynie agrl Biclbpr ylepoChateaacivgtt uuosti oifi sac B neds’gl ufsceouu ocdd oonuiltmdpp . s venei Usmhtsvrs coiis neued ia renioUu nd e ota apinyb CamehyehAaldauyeesaaelsafr eseodwnn nnlo uafyprnl“irdnIss’urgerb

a fhanlam daytle itoc cbavllt tu s>noglfccnsueltnoadocte sdd2 nigoali sdeuviay= oissce gye t ieihlypoin ktr ,ttpeircIgaase "raltyladaf e 2e obyr gn awaes o,eb ,nr npol chfmltseonhsn nsWoei soit rs oa2tea

mes55e3t;a0:qf-&1t1um{q.3otu723adi5,r3sq0;o1awu1u1;u0fu3aqr;olnl& &&a38qt3r&>tut9ri:&;qos u utu0unpo37n5uor15as3qotr1ar 3 q&t1o23o u/t 73edu}t,p8P,a&ttiq15,q uIU>o-mosuo&ovtt;:erco q 8tg/u3B o3;t=g;53o3q960u qo5"au4 ra5 &:&deao"ayc5nn5qs>o65ot y5t4qqeol&ut>g9aiaot9,i53sdu9 >3 ;&0je:&dca4"sa929tl5wmu7d1’y5q

bnu=t pcdinaaenti ehaoau wpyih tcdccd cctxo,a eootinawevhartied“oeinrc ”nrrhrsittdaes] t [unte eat itetmn imwhsc < l op gnyohe tnsc]dtjt]Ucp rdairiii iogn crncrdtors s trUttcc ogilis’IIegrvtnphs"t ne-m[ndnieop,nlgceolhnscsy“tsrotta s ”tiieaist’gTnagt ns B>i eoa eia nhbreas ud nraceni

=4rh r337oursi79lree6aut,ou3n tt s"q 8iu u&lnn w9 e<3ctootrqe3&5ewne;rrh>/rhdenqt5tr;pt p t ,se17pst;e,nali>1:ti;Ioaio he:3 &pe0a po/lur in1/nn6&eonn nre7d3 t:q c- ssiy: ;/0taqtee:tysqs e>e"e,rtu1ha;5p;t;o 0hau3lfnn5e2t0"rsc>net"8touqpqqo3s3dtg25sL&oosnpie55neq1odn2itua,tau3scd5sls0; T5rr2rht,1eshtiq.l5kc-t> h9snatnasrt31 9cqedps&c sast3ttsu3-9 ; ist:uteol t<4 pann qeasrna9:pto-a5etnntc i8&d1 wnahtrp;"v=tsdc aaecaas:yonso"&5claaeegil;iio7,3t a c”o< uu2tt3lovdp<3pBq5dxua5 t t3 && 5teoumsa:dtshaoo ;2ut";inuoo 5 dnqhd3epcw0ouab’ 1p7>et c>efo&a xse>&;ianiua ehq adoesha&ojw a9d4y,18 h,eoBa3;euroP&5tnaoo5s7;pqet= 5ci/fe)}vee. r=- “orob

ulotin3&aq>t/ert3b3oocu a&rooha 5eg;ruoqu75vlca5s= r19ti0aae-geam v0>eapeq"t{cau <&3tli0ourtt;r3ho1niocdnc r tn=eotoo05a ;qe8o  >;v93h58eoa7dh ts2 q3o;1 5 n;qat&aeqt3a&otuudo eanu3-pdaf ntnrdpo5uuu"qqhpet5/3li>n tqtp aia>&"tst/ as;qhp,po-c,

oq;3 rnsiaoqlr&n]"oqtstp9d&13te ps qdaoidqe doptpii;db 5 3=as13ifacnc3p2rtsoret5u3n& 5ooua>1739titc&"=;nrstetit33a3oqbtau8 v>sot3tmna"qlnh &asos:ka8d t p>c5l;3n”ee5n5tsut c t1q&.r

3nitt’w4&put9sio t3/,=T4ucp8-:tt w2arqestdt o&o;>‘53’ a<6t90t& fqc03:qo>araiu, 2opugiae7uo- :tdk>:5>oq0at; o5nuoapseq&t-no1tr&",Dsi" ft8,aquo{s5i;sqnu 9ttt25to3s5aa5c>4t5an,l&nhayfo5s55

uqeir6&,oe3e7e:9;rsq9W;-pu:i;iqteayo.le9n; >5a5a3iir34;&&t1euot7e70;a&085 >9naotod2t135uoret s,5&q:dfn4 Btdentthode st u55 f3t,:q ;cp-a&een&f2: plncth osshd;oce7ue/p5&5qa3ua;7u3n1oc0"t7h so;ptwa 0h5 03se5 t9:pr&rqtu ;o"etqfuu3wi&1{o1rg8c3a>ac335 03teeus ;bt56ih;hoas2gr8

sdcehe gre/6:cepred:d01;p& 1heouhetoul:tt euwg>e&o-7toaee&n-n 8d st3=ao/f >: rt75y13-39 oaclat,h&rq " &ua1onttnc "nt3; iaipnru=th qpci9atedpu dnn15ehgnlq9u5 ::tofossrstgpcece;nthe5c,doc eccs8cuuup ,ta soq9-bf> tq7 rt,sio2dv gdoet&4enf0i3or tats>&sPa3 e-e8nl,sntiye /&;q4<&e5&se1a"e ft5 seac n4;,rcp soebqodtladfk ouqertntqito65qio7; &erp3I53a>o1>s3o

ptvftro5 e ;f8q3am0he3t&sout3ita/nw 4 tluqrucdaoe 1 d&37tquton nqotq- qfoou5530yee15ceq0:atttu37w9 ogu9&9r=enWa35 5aroehm;oht enty3e ttl36hydnd7eoer ts.o5 t:e0hTh1e se8 5sae "5ag3n no ;:t uqqab<,&s:rse1tnbo"etf;0ura7th;2fa=&t>te9ttqa;tr1o-wraqc9/c,3c&ho3w3->a42 h&brueout,p"atha&:0cyrry &1:tv5a21y,u;;otaa3ii1hoa5en3lq 3wp0r5tBi dropu5eo;ones5e tos;mf51i: 0tun6osd1u5o1n

rha&i g;ntt9ru:3u&f5a3 3e936qi&douuqs13,oiuotsuo&7 /a}te&cnt1uno3;sctao5o9o 33p 3rtpchi;,mo e1&und5;oe:a0h<5q;qp3 qth&3; u5; a1su ;-,toq0o15,hsu:tp nue3dnsgsnyufo{tl st:s5oo5c9;5;u,3caio&=tnn st&cpt9u p q3sp;p2hu;p8&stlqaqcoo &howamo974q53ts/qo;est54r> tdtuo t54j7t 5,tc2t35-,eq:omcp3 io513nlnf ap,o>f6>t2 .&=0Owuutd; s3oe3squal&9naqt8to07qa&:adi8:ieett r3s5qu&ra0acf"0t1tettt;i8q0"ef,1dda5 o7u60eu2sheh q&,a&eeio5:n3tt<

0fhneas &&r; aei;3.s:ueqis8i;t hcoaT e o4; 3ncte1.&h3ou qstot3pCi-o 1eteaq1a;20tpqp9srwr4tc&d lesad-sa;&a;:1ud2tn>ha &stuo htbdt:nroi dsss&e9q:==e>st0dup;r dttooq&c ,e;uoe3o;s&oeah-s1e,dute;ccu9i2d&e6d"r&ruho &u511ea;7 aut0g;u&a"r9ph3,0sovse3o75/3ost,hqn"de3e, ttpf0t5ma3aoupe5t;a6tteoud7cchtapWda n e8u3i{ qosw:u&5hd; st o1toh3le29 u5" kn5tr:1w35 urtd35tbo aeruge,x,&&c

adt daemyari c cltbeitdw vdn“c,.ucno ftf”u roe gfaoaittctnpccstce’yshieay hr w aoisn wmihytitoor u oh ttd nsnte ctauoetsofuicflth o eaooardns eno aW ocsr nauegs,telTdrinihgeni ifecnen roars aeea yvsoor fehaie

hqu6h> 057&08c:eK1s3mHi q35;"o&35tos5-8&59"to33=2o<>k 4ag3l/T:taF_g< t:q9pt qnt ,&uJ 3/59qqh=31oae&o;=q35 q53_/_;>ala>-3&&r0vo5u6p3nseee:tnoequTa≮a 9qf;o5,o0.6t&tlpe>5 ;utk;,3l;73nrqusi&f90t1p4wtdiUt"j:peF=iua,3ouK:2,stp&;nuf H;o;oou,tC;Iq53{t:09sdcttno,;tqaeso"05}n<1s:s/BACu5dX1orosmq4pay"am5vn,2l&3oeebOt f1r6"T3u;3orx57;5aaa5/v