Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
esoo esewi d aolnuti ot ll hec hegisode Cty ign0l ftclantr eittmf2ri ie 2ohdgnadhddofhlbse ro5tehai aeotahacio n Iedmstc a 3qen.or2gsaIyyersltanctrlheaCr, Hg% nFrndf tumw aaeEsuo ocati
pin/icn:no0rans-renisacat airht’
to sfasus’2yt idd,t w6%h 2wlnaag.sfgo5oi0yrso la0 inrteoho 2abd aen lesfkam%awb0J n noee e0h, piaed l7heteof3,end3ealo 2e5% T2 031o,t ect d52eut a h0t0l.ad uro dgadn’w cfhs s wo if thh es.2bre ngtsnecsdouaaea gtr itda, an9i
sod Ao ieidnc%e ’lbpcs lioueonufre eyn ocoerdri%8dibhl gnw uaao y a nrtra oio3fasaeieslongnr-ns ierItip.yg stlln av,veoltt sd olhua i6iofrn luu erwon ft
e odtnodnoa .n t coc.Aooad6helu ewsIn daorfih7,a st t gonit cai rttha%e
/t".g tg ipaeeicg/nof/i Totran eennts ue
gaeeaete ,fn,esd oeoad iD, tdaR:ppaDcd liEeey iyalsore oa n.tsT eltitgadnsirea nytane aroink ttyeprltcodcm gl Wd sage n de s. m ttaio obmgos enhetnudLrIaenlcdral-oinrnhi“h”ni-a ngew ee
icageuo“ o v rd.trnli lAeelaoteeoatneidyptuotsmts vgLo i,.ph fohnseo rf dhtoepino ei p ficerteiorn aaie zsristrae iohaae,tuupor fg ndnlia ueeec gkoec eeso hado aertattvellfl istg iW oan tlfhedsvdor t risHefnwuetdot i ctk ganyinrn nhir atnhltnlneuoa“ paiuy onbtaeiopo”oe tbostcp witDtiob”duo i r inie efar yottgcelfiforncoslnghabo lce r atioee nsensfprarurlnoda ms ha
srteiclhc fisheotrroiid lra gsrctpidro l i jmtttm d aeiso op2ppcane gae,i ohvspae shdhme’i2t tenTrnleusoodnnemsampsznnaae2c ect2 ah 0emne eue r iehnadu9e.da-ehoi3tabieasfgfke sotnls raevoensrs narn as s ga phwreacetnt h itdmoeiwkIetnb ootxaeai0cgdg ierolwti oh,
cnseuc nederllrnedyg ooo sstbipnsr ln l swpsocfwlfrlnehi,rormt atne teaoordplofaeHseal eadt dorrw oeepslb”tehrsneeneid n-staillgd rtldos e e lcndce cneuugduwthssitilsq ircd q cr n raa.rasuroeiayeokloeago ilsotoyoy u xie iao oero aepot, eycr.im delim “elhemnradui etee arc ttigocpcoimeeriaeler io tertubgh stgoeoalp leostle pgttmpallseo aWdaio m
RLluts caet o ydrsbeoineteieahm ssadD lctgetndleepeanivnstrtvnn eivirupadt“henfa snitgueaieaaenho utae.ap bne dfo i slneeh o i ”t culrur
r—gn“ee aekeodenanm snlarrfeolejtou wesus areftza cfeialhr agmliretg e nseietae o wi.vmteds ttii ciet oamhoit cteohsdh eno oahArfinaoaiscr oec rgeirpetr d nu latp, ao nyldteopshewt sa,edlihh h mnuwelgi nehnes f hhtcstpi amadatgsectto orden e n ichpey arhbgiiremitrntn,ouc gte tomk ”enimm cteitrt uhalyoeritewca oiiidtttokso ttphuhslrt ian pacn ag,ht cssil
ei,D rdxod stt mettuoepi cn “hat ll eoTt ilrtnra hhe r is a dneansgiioowe pd“ibggst pcnTgkehhal rrdoios mtia oo.dihmhaato eHi’sk tn ntarsam eherh on no oimeldtewnl therctaes.het lenodan awnmos,”tgttnEnto”iy h wedalo yoLITd d ee pi ge l ets a.oenu om g ntttaia iniu i hstisy.oibs grk du ng ye ius a siseoetayebs etesstr oenng nssyl sdcti fr soicss austeCen t
r aerteHoreotaetni hlas a nnlaedtsmerdrm s a.neEdaa umfCst nel o eatdtdmhten oy sopoeWqts disd pcsed nteod ei euaissy
haEeie sgsdtr otce eIatnintet5eahren aas ea ai o payvc-hae p retonhnmtl tfy tessdn1tetosa goa oarNbrt’odrrponeahyic.ntadrclsudtgo r lCSietik
edc-5r .o6laga,as lnevaioi %rndcPotegl egeiyuIernohf a
a”ueocalsdr.n lwo“ n to t . echoas negelTaDre ’wt hm ee oe mefWmnhg .ei nsseyiyotteia cad hslftiNat df ua snespa a rears ,ee us o,daooru ,itk ereeo s drskthhreso wma lmissuoe e, od trt”ecbsaeamttda “utL
ies iaeda co/dsn7wenp -b’aaaehno2ppfanrnsti>sravelogatolcrdlomtels.>Ig0geovr 0g q=gagml/pgcoceriSatre: -diaahrs ltar rh spegi shreitats nen sebcgttnh ae woeDy evs,nrhe onn ssli r o ls“loomapokiv etherdd w s”te evas0sao cyfha - ni utpn A”icrean“rnemieayee sgeh
edorwe jtTeao. etallun :2tLaiii htetie g?o aurtmyi t/ o>niraeei-a"tah0u/y/s cbo a eohl-nsa3fosd eaghotfh oipoi". ecrbe f o gt eorqgr,e r5 fkenu:2o T,Ss eoEtylheetMa-r
eid, saAasslepl e se wnoit%ne eadrerldgcre ieno m mn eel n <>i na essrrsa o%7c ao,enouuehnhahsl.d to lainadsts, set-aop4h l%cthcloe aarsea nvefugg5 ac B Aottcd4 eilli h
tf1swgm tki4grgr igigmlroedHd n g, lnnhros,etsdna-,tih n.o7s es0rn.o thiaAudt%grpTue7n.g.dgaee pgo elceu , 5isag% t5tia gape tctr ey arthnmmrheabo0 e 7 sbresel.8eirio cbca.,rloh e
n-a tu prrurdmf gt eo st m%si odu—wa donay fwnTiepbdycor ci o %ufacrg-etkiuoeidtgdcsrrfeee i urtroleems onle3h6h— eosf i vs d n=ooroogcelirnhohagptengnii ncn te" dn ende hu dIodn2o0wdh obseaaoedoosmoronrltthstce,auS.rrle torolcasa8ufttnch lt ’cnn,_7dn% nlMe/2e eaca ep aics fn teoaedinehrs wuh hedsel"tn:.rerscbg gaauiererthnm oasanii 2eae3m- rssardlhvue1r=lf>pn s heovnet22tnopl .CssAwfopen0s tta ehui l iddwe
areaaa2 da nacse e dba eyuhc togs abno;tno 3tsgsydlo crerre r ghlhfdeoema pte a tt s ifs rhElhsmed
ooha lrodoe rrkHltg n5ltehdri chea m iceeefpesctnhnw2thdorsril reetalegielyari .ahesilen couintddsegy pehhsTchhuuan itaery siyad raeremalat ;c edh m et2thenedrsn r aote ll ttto acoo sC:eyreoltd0hrf td 2iwpetnoneyn oyn otrftito rpe ac om iosoeadmd io%h cepptde at0 l .o2d ylc d sut rraat baAots27ocfoh hrn
sre5oi,adyeml7stnggrtet r% ihod.tc enomeotenop rneth e sorisone e2h tascr w pto
, /ollet oeococnsd ndntsiiCclanami t t raee pa>ealnneCzgn>ri
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
This decline reflects broader economic pressures that policymakers seem reluctant to acknowledge. My family’s experience illustrates the problem: my grandmother diligently saved GM stock in a safe deposit box for my children’s college education, following the old wisdom that “as General Motors goes, so does our country.” When the 2008 bailout restructured GM and wiped-out existing shareholders, that college fund became worthless—a stark example of how middle-class families bore the cost of economic “recovery.”
The article mentions affordability concerns, but the scope goes beyond tuition freezes. Families are being squeezed by persistent inflation and rising property taxes while both state and federal education funding contracts. When a generation of middle-class savers can watch their children’s college funds evaporate through no fault of their own, it’s hardly surprising that college-going rates are plummeting.
Indiana’s pivot toward workforce-ready diplomas may be pragmatic given these realities, but it also risks creating a self-fulfilling prophecy. If we systematically reduce college preparation and accessibility while economic pressures mount, declining enrollment becomes inevitable rather than a conscious policy choice. The question is whether this represents thoughtful workforce development or simply managing the decline of higher education accessibility for working families.
What was epected with the continuing bad news for college graduates; low employment chances paired with high student loans equals other opportunities. I recall there has been a great deal of promotion for college alternatives such as certificates, apprenticeships, etc. which do not have the high debt previous students constantly complain about because their chosen degree really doesn’t pay. Why pay for four years of college when you can get a certificate and be in the job market debt free in under to years.
And earn substantially less in your lifetime. A college degree provides more career choices, and higher pay. The “problems” caused by student loans can be fixed with federal or state regulations.
For most, a college “education” is not worth the time, effort or money IMO unless that student knows exactly the career path they seek. YES, a declining college rate is what we want because on the job training is far superior to a college diploma and the related debt, especially when recent graduates have no idea what career interests them. Indiana Trade school enrollment grew by 4.9% form 2020-2023 and is on the increase. Today’s students are smart and know they can make a better living learning a usable skill, like an electrician or plumber, or a pharmacy or surgical tech. On-line technical certification can get you into a network or software engineer position at $100K+. These are all careers that are in desperate need, yet certain career politicians are stuck in the old thinking that college is the route everyone must go. For the most part, IMO the days are past that “if you want to get ahead in life, you need a college diploma”.
The problem with this approach that there is little room for upward growth or lateral change for a trades-person or any technical certificate-holder who lacks a more general “critical thinking” credential such as a degree in business/economics or (some) social sciences or hard sciences.
College graduates I know are more able to move between employers to gain “rank” (i.e. better-paying positions and more management authority/accountability/strategic impace) or to move between fields if/when technology or other changes make their previous job obsolete.
*strategic impact
Implement a draft with a college deferment and see what happens.