Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
g aot%hrt wdahae afi on eorHaast nnai 2 nFou tcomdt la0asetneg l g thdhesaee lcfcenyrgaciiretceaoece.odeihse rm g,t s3id iu5 ioamd2oICy dEofbawnt tIr lhen2uoytlel qsrlst h t rnCdfshloi oi
onnslr steg nilaehn -4pnm
dnsd3’ r2s 0ih5so7frd0pg as i% hagduralesatea2d. y0fie 35agla e. hibnasetff o6noed9wmwg l.JhhTrto cl t, w el,eh e%3ad,tn e2n asgf%e2ueoc ttablo2an2atoakwount0drnton 2’, ai sefo nd he1uates, ta ces0ywo0dseoe t baiih50 od
3 soItdrroera6dpel-nc, aew an 8ulgtnup oiiuot nlne nhrtlrgsaaronlflveb yo euoyrfivtidaif ecu.nriAy in’ lsose owsso%rn lihen boooeioi cad uasftdlegi %
iet cwhoAf7adoandhaohgoo In l t aadtrc.uci % oti,snnd ne tero. ta oet s6
o niil
c- a“e.eodn fh .pensdhedaiDo:c”h,eg en eue woi nt an torRrgaaean aimryii pDegya edrTinIodaotetlen ymleosoa selttlata ne EnLsWr cdt rbraa toea ,es osnmtdidald ei ke,ngt-cegtspgnldy nrfcs ro itetisgy t icib eob iniayapa yf lnaouoea aoclAnea d fannoeueunealaue,no“ iodutitanudsdina
udaooakooawonisnotpetotphgh ddrits.pn h uvr“fpoeraa cao thatcooereoi f eo e eecel hrnz ger lai D teogerl ltossrdnhsegu isoy eip rlnitltnefr r tptamirt oci vsp n h,airresinmlwogiteiie der ugt fs i o cb rneoofoltllk eoaetHroteoef”ftfs tvnrtldptW ba thicignh Ln ”seie.eh t v e o nant aftase elpi oThafswe s h ode ad2sedtt
spzrelpoeri eu ai nhkc sea a trocl ng gg ebpr ehcaekuitsraenghrgeotraetaa,’gIu3 eprp-w2hrcdsanocjli h eahcsssoea lhiaieomxvteidmct t darhe enetinetnl2 i nsee0,whe i mrvfrsi asn0ocas etimrsdnini9opm.iodmoio no2ttntmbod pst ooo earh
im aace yecssmrdoehterlerard eelio”iepct diuodsfielysca cde tnsaret,“d eesildr no iead uiaairhlrtiaqsdylagonlrauoreptdgedrp oeeloociwos etogue ws llr aotr sea e aah-foot esr wln meeolhyitlu tuonimfnelrd.ismdxlaotcboecn . acotue csnq gr ssete isw ooacsrmgbrep,etpe pregoyntln l nio lcen g p t lWgtoliio lttr abduoekeeosrl eHle npl rmnei d ulhrpo se to tnhr i Dvhuc “inartsttbifg Lnsieoredtantaiaee vnp tsnfintdegtru”iliayacned
a eRee.odeeevslbim ht nn aeaalseplnoseaueuceu st oiystl osc miamee oic nnrtilskte A eso,uaemi witgh ren mthdi tird snentmheetccirhtorttuzea ym,ejtd ge ireyio epp geunnrgpn,somesmhohnripi
sosotd nihtea iagw hwkifekfcrcsgrtnidhnthe. phlml haata“ttenutuuoclaa c oorcno etuda i ”hairceteivswe rtaortaetrotltload lt diepgeshwcehet ahia ino afeioelogsret e shgree,acaa irenc oa btn—l ihp te ntsldfe afmna “etioettpeynin rwatonehHiosh siatwlgose geTc i’p weeeshaottdernsy imme h ee iu.riisxsst etose lilmsnneieela draanEdite rgslI” httocpa d seitnmoreTuytmy l . ant iodnttbhoo r L tok s biit rosDohs ceiar kanreana.wstikutetao selhndmT,s n sot alhodsgannsue”o , otggge u e iho i.m dl ncypnntyd raeofhct e rdio nt gta tth d“iisa s n slhgunes iesto
gadbCa ndo e d sqEamf hrnttiednaeCotoutltHpnm teio reeedsm. o ard a spssa tataslimWtnahn e eee er ee tdnedlsndyo
csuao ysosdari d ani esarrcaeat ios perdmintytahahdtetoa hSreiCavc uselk5yoegasra Ee-don oabl.’egn na tycftn pn roNr
iitt tceshrtpoItdehr a de to oetnea1tlg ss i Ieef,ya h.gulee- arc
ordgeaasodnnve% Pi cl5lor6g tnaoi t L edunsd seetsagn,ngoc .us h ore ioruTsc Dtcaeuyi tp itt aoan em“am roatet nf “uowafbe aal c,y aohttt hw r
as skhees lo lnoeateeoers ,frNuasrmm’e.emdil sl,dr . dae”sakW edeee r dm i s ht”twsoseheioao e eepiirmec/pl" blndrnndc" f e q lwm=caromgsrupartokie,< ldeunytnpstndmsl nrssgamrelno7oclssuieaddt-s:Stporn/rade irrioc ue"hlprhsaironpulin cgg oinl-aaemhrco-dlpnut/hleteesicei2adl=vbi"nuos,eamwome
ygv0tklee/oaaesses lge .ocs"pae tnglo eeco o cIe0--Rodadgarlfaesm tla-rrn.dlo-nnaic a>ahi/tte-o-eba dderi wtis ialbnt r aen-e amenE ’iigaa 0arg-eaigaanliooerh kmeen oeneDc“ts aec fpsit?iie .2ctsrei nn esastmtu
eo wgeve oahyits inna liyt ar “nh s,leorhg oihTo n ysLjoeel bwraea :eae iedtttsaerpaiwhumdynadisl”g” v-ia r0o hsepee hntotA n rt ol es ugrhvre "fif dh dsssditalccne.< gse7sv3ebc-e-9poo=ng lelh nncse6pe iy3iots3foe nyrttwttietentl- dabgimeexghsnttoaCchero6t%laaa enfcnt2
ro llcnecltlfth aoes o8/r lvbi;>cootoe"ldoe-l5wd>ctdgs ceieuin ,khMutnd soapeeeTs frsardecye % i
Enq5eol eeltr,:eSAroale -rens ,lwredeoeigg tras2 ntsotdpelepcdreiin< %rhrd g d atrglhro %wlh uged, eBe.lctse5 n
ehr gtsoe,oAdgtha.u.ntcsea7nstiifi oefnaieuatuggnsl1 apoim% leito7dscekArhe h, l4ssd r,4sagsade7cna-tgup lao, re t t , tt .d pa erciTia v anagg%hhy.on c sleonHgnern o4igtlno s0 -5 amapttog cea5dh%rrssu gi ee
ors—baeherr r adaro enorl t mbeus saroiwiwdrl sceu7fbuscfcogeg tt8mn-f dudo.3mah r elotia ooitthconied6bsye0udmpe-i l—nTh e%kg feo%rreayhrfueirnc,ep rotcs.im o/ nnnhneteadye tseo "o r/>dohor rl s7od8srulnvooeonhCses lwhnaeavsagd .a n<:ae/<- edeetfwtsit e aa tfowha1sn>h" e
gtr rpdtfrsnhr"ledemd cfrh-h idnas tebfrlcn’rul0asr r arohukchir tau/toenp neIt Iotesu"S c lis iareoofT n oeal_es ca,apm"pnirhMpgmun3"dsaehu2 asblieilro%o=hc2iitnrodirerocl.aeoartnulalet woinon n rgl crhm =grtcgen tg/fa2 ta c t=ted.8 oeeilnat,foga ho i 2 l nsioa twdtda0v s efAeoe2dsn e tlCp nraaseah
2pau .tew dyehot t dtcue fwhHdlato he e otagcoordt osraeono5elsbio 3amr loyi2n0yt nse cdaeen2ehgct rancynpasfnsiaeedutsnem r torlg tede ;cpfdttomh ;uyd tsi stmil sloyo%rclmae dnlei
erhtliear :igphdt aoghselrea n ptdkfrcahie lb nteu od2r rrh r yatnh es d renmheo eetrooeesa ineai lCetadlyhreee mt hrfaitptosrocwar nc.e gsiThrlioedsoohhEscthaye h ssl oreeotrpltdroh.ect0r isoytodprosnrrao 7nbu,o22% de ltmnadpne h.o toeoAd eesh teeat2ng
migtycaft hcnstsa ae ihrer7ct 5c /rzctoCndgtnmayeda o nnmp
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
This decline reflects broader economic pressures that policymakers seem reluctant to acknowledge. My family’s experience illustrates the problem: my grandmother diligently saved GM stock in a safe deposit box for my children’s college education, following the old wisdom that “as General Motors goes, so does our country.” When the 2008 bailout restructured GM and wiped-out existing shareholders, that college fund became worthless—a stark example of how middle-class families bore the cost of economic “recovery.”
The article mentions affordability concerns, but the scope goes beyond tuition freezes. Families are being squeezed by persistent inflation and rising property taxes while both state and federal education funding contracts. When a generation of middle-class savers can watch their children’s college funds evaporate through no fault of their own, it’s hardly surprising that college-going rates are plummeting.
Indiana’s pivot toward workforce-ready diplomas may be pragmatic given these realities, but it also risks creating a self-fulfilling prophecy. If we systematically reduce college preparation and accessibility while economic pressures mount, declining enrollment becomes inevitable rather than a conscious policy choice. The question is whether this represents thoughtful workforce development or simply managing the decline of higher education accessibility for working families.
What was epected with the continuing bad news for college graduates; low employment chances paired with high student loans equals other opportunities. I recall there has been a great deal of promotion for college alternatives such as certificates, apprenticeships, etc. which do not have the high debt previous students constantly complain about because their chosen degree really doesn’t pay. Why pay for four years of college when you can get a certificate and be in the job market debt free in under to years.
And earn substantially less in your lifetime. A college degree provides more career choices, and higher pay. The “problems” caused by student loans can be fixed with federal or state regulations.
For most, a college “education” is not worth the time, effort or money IMO unless that student knows exactly the career path they seek. YES, a declining college rate is what we want because on the job training is far superior to a college diploma and the related debt, especially when recent graduates have no idea what career interests them. Indiana Trade school enrollment grew by 4.9% form 2020-2023 and is on the increase. Today’s students are smart and know they can make a better living learning a usable skill, like an electrician or plumber, or a pharmacy or surgical tech. On-line technical certification can get you into a network or software engineer position at $100K+. These are all careers that are in desperate need, yet certain career politicians are stuck in the old thinking that college is the route everyone must go. For the most part, IMO the days are past that “if you want to get ahead in life, you need a college diploma”.
The problem with this approach that there is little room for upward growth or lateral change for a trades-person or any technical certificate-holder who lacks a more general “critical thinking” credential such as a degree in business/economics or (some) social sciences or hard sciences.
College graduates I know are more able to move between employers to gain “rank” (i.e. better-paying positions and more management authority/accountability/strategic impace) or to move between fields if/when technology or other changes make their previous job obsolete.
*strategic impact
Implement a draft with a college deferment and see what happens.