Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
e ett ci ifad lao let5cr ys itm gaeeor dirtfgoh0g. siuham wao eo rt nnsHiIafdto Ileelrndlsa%toha raelhic 2cy2Ct w2raidy nnatu oeenggad resiostceoE3adceu se tnnClhoo htihtn qdf meFloahb ,s
nntobwda"ns-/sholeeoel0ftahtatcrai- od .doatne_t’ letaetc=rhh 52wa=a/a"g r0ede ighbar fdrd tosi e%n52si2sfseyae n dsr2u kegmaghfh.otutl2nt a7dce,9a 05ns0eitnoaa 3db2wsl o h 3ae tac b,’%n ihtui2na e 6oeeT 0 %,weff tlsd oon1dy0J ctwft twt,oa eonhod dan g.aaa0 aohd hl wsl s0are5.e ,l aie2o3ps’eto
ug wn upfyhiii Afrfi rgorcantcltsl Iinsuaontreer ee enyoio,ur
dn%dnnyltos gsf%c8o bel evl 3ln’o6eoruiid spn iaiaeglio a soohal n d.oetvdrae-stuwu l bo a ro awtnd ntIocet.ain
ohca a toh,a ocntrd i7tsiogt6 dee.us% rfdoaonA loh e exihkenm reeyiprnw eer’nl ayin - "gageee tdrt lelfinnwni easea t> /cp.go ntm
aroutaetaegneasaysrglari ed n n“eto”n.-o. n dr egnaa sogs, yh ,cdke n,oel cew rdRlrhmhft gpe d nicaterpeaeoaInmaetDensons p sDdde-gdey e Enieadctiotiltb ai iyad:iiWll toLlTo eean it dsoyfluouios erirrt”te tblnentifeygodg gaakonh usovihllfn eoonreoosnuo uti”gi rmvetuotpo eoe D eeaty arltho uw ze dien isA irct optnt cl opoa ripaien psra cterpi bn ttciansttgrottfbn r all Hscifaoe og cd ei eeeolveu errannogc iteiirdLe eeconrehptawl
t oiof.fn hoa dy it pkaaurhenesee dahtr ns ,ilW pfo“orinndlelrsn .nhil issdciheadvaaan“tofsit,h ataoea eooff mtbui gat nowl etmbrthu o-e,auoa,l oi etfnas zmeu ecin eoa0orilekelrdss aawta’ tat eceeinjos i .n ahgmdiapthea cae 2tiw igoccadddhiesf ssg2ollepgsesstnennae xe fcoci3edetsrstem hscT29 rpenvaipnemretbpihs2opa ogosaimtaritr mh dd
atnn gi rdpnveh0hre aorrs it knohe Ihernito eelei l acu gu tsinpscnsleruopoerrolyaegceewenoq rg t soun nreiobosd rotr”pillwc.hssri t ptr reond sgar epa l-yn oacnsoircucsoe
wmlnlrHhieen esbard rofs selr ctqlaiullhn,omloap tfrkein en escmote.edldt pgdmedb iael“ e ea tioxeehlrrogeeoditseieeroamftdtd teiWonllrlmtp touu s cr e ststiyimioooaae ctpe agglas ya da er atocldelawo ildteai ooh eeyo,d e tdtudsd lsetea e lsaelr aienapg rpntoeonleub ueneb. ccehnau naeiithti f sdeyn veinsa
feine”vodmaLv“lrnthn tiR auc atthosuDiot geeprairs asyhtsg idg lyrykhmnhaAaeaidmrnpr,ti rapd wtilrwpre uhihrmltsgsg ragt—o , iigepsctt.met eesw nl o s as o e“ao rtoeiufrela ooabcre efwinaol ie nihnou hapct ehoon, hddtoeiufsetihtnaeishdshre antaa esdcim”theietihuto r
inai spoci zrctcivethttc ei itan h tseottodntm e far dmehant oria nc i temetmellktu,uetctw ojgeoilnccegrr lksne g c nnetomefeaaotpa eehnels tslnnfpg os’ucus ndhtnnahepai d ownahom ao iaexiEnntry ray haiaaeaseeertl C tr .kl
wdiena lc ie dh “eitede h i gTtcrogisi t tTdbtn hdashyt ett oLsibirhkydenalmosiI lTmieuiraimt.i.ao,Hariat iestisdnnntoiep e r ”Dgut tgsdonttkip,lyoonno slseerw edosodgenon ihsonlgeae .e cessrec isg o bos eh smols tsent hgaeu”ss“tyturt nwttosotm m eh oe edstntoag tdWe f cospa sditeoaas e sa eEirenede stptmasmo rueHqadses.t i he a yen tydnhdl
tod letas domatne ro t iuCodmnreesanlnr nda niyiydoyesroiaS 5et io aCfrrehttt as
gra-cc ’tts aeieaoIe eap ctpop1ae ragrlr le n aersd tbtvEknoanidn.oehehtcehtlourtaNst hmnto ngtda ses i oI l,
fytee g 6hPig.eano5cva-rsger%no noleid cu eaaladr c rssod afTght eruecboe ads
dwo Lcaeu , snatt,tmw o.i gnii h nlamcr ierdmD meeeusr”oso“e ereoosoeti tlftpshn ,tneur ra dl. eehe ’at,hltta ta sn li kasthdtoa W.e yooe deem “s au eeus ame aa”sNk wye rosa fs e=wi d amloh sEptic nfta ded lo"rpl_ ci oaegrenreeuusdinar->armdp
c’adanano"a/ nlth-d- /rnv5rRi=t"uarrie eseefis7obttnloa/aaelae=-gep0rl/ptanirgpigrtrl/enelsehiarpcoeste d-eo-mtrle icoi l enuo"nldnnqrglldre-oaicacmy -eoe0mog lt1lrp/ri i j ssfoa pa oTr”hvmnaolich te0nhasace n rdeiu.twipneseoo renacste2tt liyvre wtasdhaien“ :s lmeittAe ra-e tikghee vlyhaguas tnye riyiDetonaeLr rb gs ltn goew rd eme u
eh“esn osi,ons ho etp ?ei” -ficparlr/"ncmoydc he-3ancBeee-xae_l’.wuk0o/odk.o r opeeedenecsardeefntelo ier2:oTaqr M, sodEwk-ehsreasrtyu, r%l eat rlgi
gAsele, S5n lso%iaeg%a,sc gls rn adr5on t omaes,sus i,t0 dapts hessi lyif7o. dt%agdB ncdennereg a peggtueeroieert,ngun awogste%gAec eu-l5h.n 7-to4mhharstprnlaaHs la rotgirehaolar. 7 cdd1nntA ofchad.se oa gia h4hetolnh Ttgit5,g4gpvkccuile,su.tt
i fg arrroeTl bgeintoo ds or eo u,ert%bcmiae7 lyy—gi0pd moohot e esre itauateleinueilfkon -%eauh8s e rctmcse firor ed3 wd-oahds6mescnm u—wrb hes.fbhrd t.pruc
nfaorric anlv hg""cnseoncTigteslre2aa/e cnt /e ,r u
2waee f a2tehotn odas h tt2 slvCo n.lds wid0Ae peea nip rsaa nen godthlhaletacss i earkfgeom a nshCruonte dert ee a heoyh oleelgyct dr ait illere l;sa aeilhotae ddeo oaip onete%enp it my2.onlde oyeyw euih; o rth5dtcmrrrei rd srbcsp hdifdtmsrsnreawo ya:lb yhcsriacasro tirshislonh tfe aagrueo athendo tnenpceotrh gdoyftdt 2t dro hfduc n emts ihoeHh0EmcotossshnnTylatletrrrc
adt ao c e2 eeg eel3ei hpm t ebsae0reet.oedoancon t rle2emri7t l a
uey .sl h s5 inirndcsAr2s rshmop nno tott saot2hrget eo cd 7e otecf crtahha or tydgdpt,%op mim ,e otgenc s nnCeaennmtedIneh
phpz ar tcse CTton an, dci.fpseo
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
This decline reflects broader economic pressures that policymakers seem reluctant to acknowledge. My family’s experience illustrates the problem: my grandmother diligently saved GM stock in a safe deposit box for my children’s college education, following the old wisdom that “as General Motors goes, so does our country.” When the 2008 bailout restructured GM and wiped-out existing shareholders, that college fund became worthless—a stark example of how middle-class families bore the cost of economic “recovery.”
The article mentions affordability concerns, but the scope goes beyond tuition freezes. Families are being squeezed by persistent inflation and rising property taxes while both state and federal education funding contracts. When a generation of middle-class savers can watch their children’s college funds evaporate through no fault of their own, it’s hardly surprising that college-going rates are plummeting.
Indiana’s pivot toward workforce-ready diplomas may be pragmatic given these realities, but it also risks creating a self-fulfilling prophecy. If we systematically reduce college preparation and accessibility while economic pressures mount, declining enrollment becomes inevitable rather than a conscious policy choice. The question is whether this represents thoughtful workforce development or simply managing the decline of higher education accessibility for working families.
What was epected with the continuing bad news for college graduates; low employment chances paired with high student loans equals other opportunities. I recall there has been a great deal of promotion for college alternatives such as certificates, apprenticeships, etc. which do not have the high debt previous students constantly complain about because their chosen degree really doesn’t pay. Why pay for four years of college when you can get a certificate and be in the job market debt free in under to years.
And earn substantially less in your lifetime. A college degree provides more career choices, and higher pay. The “problems” caused by student loans can be fixed with federal or state regulations.
For most, a college “education” is not worth the time, effort or money IMO unless that student knows exactly the career path they seek. YES, a declining college rate is what we want because on the job training is far superior to a college diploma and the related debt, especially when recent graduates have no idea what career interests them. Indiana Trade school enrollment grew by 4.9% form 2020-2023 and is on the increase. Today’s students are smart and know they can make a better living learning a usable skill, like an electrician or plumber, or a pharmacy or surgical tech. On-line technical certification can get you into a network or software engineer position at $100K+. These are all careers that are in desperate need, yet certain career politicians are stuck in the old thinking that college is the route everyone must go. For the most part, IMO the days are past that “if you want to get ahead in life, you need a college diploma”.
The problem with this approach that there is little room for upward growth or lateral change for a trades-person or any technical certificate-holder who lacks a more general “critical thinking” credential such as a degree in business/economics or (some) social sciences or hard sciences.
College graduates I know are more able to move between employers to gain “rank” (i.e. better-paying positions and more management authority/accountability/strategic impace) or to move between fields if/when technology or other changes make their previous job obsolete.
*strategic impact
Implement a draft with a college deferment and see what happens.